Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Arbitration Opinion & Award - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
In this particular case a employee of Nittany Regional Medical Centre, Kevin who is a nurse was given a five day suspension According to Davis who is the attorney for the hospital, Kevin Hyer the grievant refused to take orders from her supervisor Olivia Martinez to the patient…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Arbitration Opinion & Award
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Arbitration Opinion & Award"

ARBITRATION OPINION & AWARD Introduction In this particular case a employee of Nittany Regional Medical Centre, Kevin who is a nurse was given a five day suspension According to Davis who is the attorney for the hospital, Kevin Hyer the grievant refused to take orders from her supervisor Olivia Martinez to the patient from the gurney to the bed and that he neglected this person who was writhing in pain. Kevin being union steward saw that it was unfair and sought to seek justice from the arbitrator.
Hospital case
According to to the hospital Kevin had done an offense and was supposed to receive the termination but was given a five day suspension. Davis claims that Kevin refused to follow the orders that were given to her by her supervisor. At the same time he neglected the patient who was uncomfortable on the ground. He chose to go at home violating the mission of the hospital of proving care.
Union case
The union claimed that Kevin suffered from back pain and that he could not carry the patient. His representative Whitehead claimed that the patient was obese that he could jeopardize Kevin’s health. According to the labor Agreement employees are not supposed to perform unsafe work. The union claims that Kevin was given an ultimatum by her supervisor. This made Kevin to choose to go home rather than causing the problem to himself and to the patient .His problem was know by the supervisors and some co workers.
According to the witness Martinez and Barber who Kevin’s co worker claims that Kevin usually has a problem with her back. This is emphasized by Him of whom he claims to have gotten injured through an accident during skiing 9 years ago. However this remains in question because of the following reasons;
I. There was no documentation of the alleged back pain according to Martinez. Though Kevin was known by Martinez and Barber and other workers to be having a back pain, this claim could not be proved. He oftenly had some informal request for assistance of which the manager was not aware of. It is therefore normal for any human being to assume that this was a lie since there was no any documentation to prove the illness.
II. Richard claims that there is a department in the hospital for employees to report their health problems so that they can be accommodated with their problem. Kevin was aware of the department yet he did not seek help. This shows some elements of being fishy.
III. According to Richard, Kevin did not notify the HR of his condition and that he did not provide any documentation and therefore did not follow the appropriate process.Ordinrily, any man with a disability will be the first to seek help for accommodation sake. This is controversial to Kevin
IV. According to Employer Exhibit 2 presented by Davis, the question of disability was answered that Kevin was fine yet he had the condition for 9years of which he was employed 3 years ago. This implies some sort of cunning moments presented.
V. During witnessing Kevin tries to present records of Chiropractor to be cross examined. The question still remains, why he not presented them to the HR for approval so as to be accommodated.
According to Martinez and also as witnessed by Kevin, she does not like unions. Kevin alleges that she does not like him and that she is against him. There is no record of mistreatment and therefore this cannot be legally binding.
Kevin claims that his back was in pain and that lifting an obese patient could jeopardize his health conditions. He says that he would have put his health and that of the patient at a risk since the patient could have fallen. He claims to have forgotten the training yet he had a refresher training three months ago. This patient could have enabled him lift the patient without using his back.
Kevin was counseled twice. Though he did not receive any written warning from the hospital. He claims that he did not receive any disciplinary actions instead received mere conversation. Although he should have received written warning, he should have helped the patient because he knew how to do it without injuring the back.
According to witness Richard, the assistant HR, Kevin had undergone through refresher training apart from the one that he underwent previously on how to lift heavy patients without using the back. The claims that he could not lift the patient were baseless.
I therefore rule in favor of the hospital because Kevin refused to take orders from the supervisor. He claimed to have a back pain though this claim was baseless. Even if he had pains he would have lifted the patient using the technique and file grievance as Richard puts it. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Arbitration Opinion & Award Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Arbitration Opinion & Award Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“Arbitration Opinion & Award Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Arbitration Opinion & Award

International Arbitration

...International Arbitration The multifarious problems relating to interim measures with reference to international arbitration being addressed in the dissertation makes it an indispensable prerequisite to inquire into the broader aspects of research methodology, which are of diverse proportion. Many law dissertations rely mainly upon cases, statutes and academic commentary. However, to inquire, to arrive at the ultimate result and to redress the problem being addressed, certain pre-existing research philosophy in addition to adoption of the correct research strategy and research methodology was taken the aid of, for successful completion of the research. The answer to the problems in this research would be best found, on the implementation...
6 Pages(1500 words)Dissertation


...?Arbitration The arbitration clause in a contract which is a common feature in all international contracts is an agreement separate from the underlying contract and hence known as the “bedrock” of international arbitration.1 The arbitration agreement must be carefully drafted so as to provide for the rights of the parties and their duties to submit to arbitration proceedings and competence of arbitral tribunal to resolve disputes. National courts (appointing authority) also have a role to play in referring the parties to arbitration. Parties to the dispute have rights to seek enforcement of arbitral awards as envisaged by the New York Convention, any other international treaties or national laws as may be provided for in arbitration...
10 Pages(2500 words)Coursework


The advantage of arbitration is that parties can manipulate it to suit their specific requirements. In the present world, majority of lawyers and business people frequently encounter the concept of arbitration. When a dispute first arises, none of the parties may think about resorting to arbitration in the initial stages. However, any one of the disputing parties may propose that instead of the going through the usual legal procedure, the dispute can be resolved by the method of arbitration under the mutual agreement. Again, there are certain cases of dispute, where arbitration clauses are included in the standard agreement. In such cases, the parties involved in the dispute are needed to go through the arbitration process irresp...
10 Pages(2500 words)Coursework


...). Since the article does not give the company's side of the dispute it is difficult to gauge the veracity of the claimant's account. However, clearly they feel there is a case to be answered since they are prepared to go to arbitration. 2. if you were the manager, what could you have done to avoid this stage of the proceedings. The greatest difficulty the manager has in this situation is obtaining a truthful account of what happened. The claimant did not seek his line manager's advice at the time that he alleges he saw his name crossed out. Nor would it appear that until matters had reached a head did the claimant make any allegations of discrimination or unfair treatment from his colleagues. Assuming that I was aware of the tensions...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Arbitration Law

With the rapid strides made by the world financial and business communities, it has become imperative for businesses to have a proven method of resolving business disputes promptly, expeditiously and constructively. When businesses grow and expand it is natural that disputes will arise. In wake of this, parties often favor a private and informal settlement of disputes, in a businesslike fashion that enable them to further their business interests without strangling their business relationship. It is for such occasions that arbitration is designed—for prompt, pragmatic and efficient resolution of disputes. Arbitration is essentially a process of dispute resolution inspired by ones free will where a neutral third party renders a fin...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay


...Arbitration is just like an ordinary court proceeding, except that it is not judicial in nature but administrative. In an arbitration proceeding, thecase is made known to a specific government agency that will provide administrative services to parties, the complainant and the respondent, before and during the arbitration. There are numerous arbitration and mediation agencies, some established or connected with the national government. These agencies are devoted to settle disputes between two conflicting parties without the need of going through judicial proceeding or litigation. Arbitration is the submission of a complainant to an intended respondent for a settlement of a dispute. The result of the settlement will be final, binding...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


...Arbitration Arbitration is an alternative form of dispute resolution. This approach provides parties to a conflict with an alternative to resolve the dispute without litigating. The two parties to a dispute elect an impartial third party to hear them and then make an award based on the evidence and testimony of the parties. Although the process is conducted out of court, the parties are both given an opportunity to participate in a hearing and they are allowed to give evidence. The arbitrators award in arbitration cases is often final and courts rarely reexamine such awards. Additionally, other characteristics of arbitration are that it is a confidential process. The confidentiality of the existence of the process as well as any other...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


... to continue with the process about the same issue (National Paralegal. 2005). The issue was whether the lead arbitrator in the subsequent arbitration was under compulsion to apply the res judicata doctrine in the circumstance. Connecticut court observed that awards of arbitration are for the presentation of similar effects as court decisions in further civil actions. Therefore, the second arbitration’s arbitrator need not engage res judicata to initial arbitration award. In Conn. Super LEXIS 3409 (2004) for Gordon v. Amica Mutual Insurance Company, 2004 the use of “party arbitrator” system resulted in procedural impropriety where the court vacated the arbitration award. The plaintiffs’ home in Glastonbury, which created the financial...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Scholarship award

...Scholarship Award I guess I would have to say that I did not come to choose my major by accident. Even as a child I had already shown a keen interest the way that the human body functioned and moved. This was an interest that drew further attention from me as I began to engage in activities that begged me to learn more about the biology of man. Injuries that I sustained led me to a better understanding of my body and how it is affected by illness. Seeing my mother deteriorate from the effects of cancer only served to further interest me in the study of human biology. That is the short version of how I eventually ended up studying a four year course majoring in Biology. My previous career choice was that of a personal trainer... Award I...
1 Pages(250 words)Scholarship Essay


...Separability in Arbitration affiliation Separability used in Arbitration The doctrine of separability has been acceptable in the USA and Europe for a long time now. In England, the clause of arbitration legislation has been separate, and it is enshrined in the 1698 Arbitration Act. The Act had been established to allow arbitration clauses to be part of the rules in the court when the involved parties agree to it. However, in a case in England of Kill Verse Hollister a ruling (1746) was made that the arbitration clause was not in spirit with the 1698 Act, rendering it incapable of being enforced through the judicial process. When a law doctrine does not adequately serve the purpose of complementing the intended Act and the law keepers...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Arbitration Opinion & Award for FREE!

Contact Us