StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Derivatives Are Not Dangerous - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study "Derivatives Are Not Dangerous" concludes derivatives are not dangerous if they are handled well, they are only dangerous if they are mishandled. In other words, derivatives are not dangerous by themselves, the traders and risk managers are. Managers need to avoid highly…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Derivatives Are Not Dangerous"

Derivatives “Guns don’t kill people. People kill people unofficial slogan of the National Rifle Association. Engaging in derivatives can be highly rewarding if effective risk measures are taken, but they may also pose serious problems to its traders if they effective risk management strategies are not taken into consideration. The collapse of two companies – Barings Bank and MG Refining and Marketing (MGRM), is attributed to the mishandling of derivative decisions. In both cases, the companies failed because the managers did not manage risks well. In the case of MGRM, the managers of the company engaged in hedging and did not reduce risk, but rather increased it. In the case of Barings Bank, the manager used options but did not use the right risk management approaches to determine the most risky derivative businesses to engage in. In order to understand the danger of risk managers and traders in derivatives market, it is important to understand the backgrounds of the two collapsed cases. Barings Bank collapsed due to millions of losses registered by Barings Futures Singapore (BFS) in 1994 and 1995. Within that period, BFS made losses of £927 million. This loss led to the collapse of the company. The losses were caused by unauthorized activities of Nick Leeson, the head of BFS. The only activities that Leeson was allowed to undertake outside Singapore was switching (arbitrage operation) between Singaporean and Osaka futures exchanges (Reserve Bank of Australia, 1995). These operations were considered by the bank’s executive management as non-risky. However, Leeson engaged in other derivative businesses including long positions (purchase option) in Nikkei futures, short position (sell option) in Japanese Government Bond (JGB), and short volatility position in Nikkei exchange. Over January and February of 1995, the sequence of profits and losses from various positions of the derivatives fluctuated. Losses in one market were upset by profits from other markets at some point. At the end of February, all the markets in which Leeson held positions made losses. MGRM established large energy derivatives positions by engaging in hedging through forward-supply contract of delivering gasoline heating oil, and diesel fuel over a ten-year-period at fixed prices (Edwards and Canter, 1995). The company was then exposed to the risk of rising energy prices. MGRM sought to insulate its forward delivery contracts using energy futures contracts of maturity periods of two to three months. However, energy prices declined sharply in 1993. This caused the company losses and margin losses of $900 million. The company’s management rescued the company from plunging into bankruptcy by replacing top management of MG, liquidating all its derivative positions, and receiving $1.9 billion rescue operation from 150 banks from Germany and overseas. From these two cases, it is clear that speculative deals and risky derivative positions taken by managers lead the company into crisis. In this case, the derivative itself is not the dangerous thing because in any derivative contract there is a winner and a loser. The person who did not manage his risks well ends up losing while the person who calculated his risks and protected himself well from the risks ends up gaining. In order to engage in arbitration requires a high level of skills in the use of futures markets, especially in a highly risky products with highly fluctuating prices like energy. This is where the management of MGRM failed in its arbitration move when it engaged in forward delivery to arbitrate between spot oil market and long-term contract market. There are three risks that affect forwards and futures are: rollover risks, credit risk, and funding risk. Managers of MGRT did not put these risks into consideration. For instance, the company did not consider whether it would sustain gains or losses in the process of rolling its derivative position forward. The result is that the company was exposed to rollover risk. Generally, MGRM hedging strategy represented a mismatch of maturity between the hedge and delivery contracts of the company. Therefore, the derivative debacle of the company occurred not because the derivative was dangerous but because the managers did not manage risks effectively, and they failed to match the maturity of different derivative elements. The company engaged in highly speculative trade in an area where prices of the commodities traded is highly volatile. In such a case the trader is to blame for his actions, not the tool he/she uses to carry out such actions. In the case of Barings Bank, Leeson engaged in derivative activities without authority. From the decisions that he made concerning the options, it is clear that Leeson did not understand his business fully in the first place. When it is about derivatives, managers always have to predict, measure, and manage risks. One of the ways of managing risks is to avoid them. That is the position of the management when they authorized Leeson to carry out only one activity concerning risk – arbitrage between Singaporean and Osaka futures exchanges. The company understood that this derivative trade was not risky, but Leeson decided to carry out unauthorized derivative trades which turned out to be highly speculative. In order to enjoy profits from an arbitrage through options, futures, or forwards a derivative trader needs to understand the probability of making profits given their position and the maturity dates of their derivatives (Pasha, 2013). For the three positions that Leeson held, he should have considered at least one that has small risks so that it may offset any losses made by other positions. Regarding the authority given to the manager, it is clear that Leeson was given responsibilities in both back and front offices. As a result, he was able to conduct unauthorized trading and conceal them through fake accounts. Such secrets accounts parked losses until the company collapsed. From this account, it is clear that the actions of the manager led to the collapse of the business. In the case of MGRM, the activities of the management were not concealed, so it was able to rescue the company through liquidation of the derivative positions of the company. However, Leeson’s activities were concealed, and the company could not liquidate its derivative position. Oversight of activities by internal control or external auditors is always necessary to determine the position of the company in terms derivatives, so that it becomes easier to monitor and manage potential risks (Pasha, 2013). Leeson was not monitored or given sufficient oversight. Unlike in the case of MGRM where management realized its losses before the company could go into bankruptcy, Barings did not question Leeson or suspect anything about his activities until it was too late. This shows why Barings Bank collapsed while MGRM was rescued. From the above analysis of the two cases, it is plausible to conclude that derivatives are not dangerous. On the contrary, people who carry out trading activities on derivatives are dangerous. This is clear from the fact that MGRM was rescued from bankruptcy because its losses were discovered early while Barings Bank was not rescued because its losses were not discovered. Derivatives are not dangerous if they are handled well, they are only dangerous if they are mishandled. In other words, derivatives are not dangerous by themselves, the traders and risk managers are. Managers need to avoid highly speculative risks and manage their risks well while allowing for good oversight of their activities. References risk Edwards, F.R. and Canter, M.S. 1995. “The Collapse of Metallgesellschaft: Unhedgeable Risks, Poor Hedging Strategy, or Just Bad Luck?” Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, Spring. Pasha, S.A.M. 2013. “Retail Investors’ Perception on Financial Derivatives in India.” European Scientific Journal, 9(22), pp. 366-383. Reserve Bank of Australia 1995. Implications of the Barings Collapse for Bank Supervisors. Reserve Bank of Australia Bulletin. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Guns dont kill people. People kill people: unofficial slogan of the Essay - 1”, n.d.)
Guns dont kill people. People kill people: unofficial slogan of the Essay - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1636130-guns-dont-kill-people-people-kill-people-unofficial-slogan-of-the-national-rifle-association-with-particular-reference-to-barings-bank-and-mgrm-argue-whether-derivatives-by-themselves-are-dangerous-or-it-is-traders-and-risk-managers-that-ar
(Guns Dont Kill People. People Kill People: Unofficial Slogan of the Essay - 1)
Guns Dont Kill People. People Kill People: Unofficial Slogan of the Essay - 1. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1636130-guns-dont-kill-people-people-kill-people-unofficial-slogan-of-the-national-rifle-association-with-particular-reference-to-barings-bank-and-mgrm-argue-whether-derivatives-by-themselves-are-dangerous-or-it-is-traders-and-risk-managers-that-ar.
“Guns Dont Kill People. People Kill People: Unofficial Slogan of the Essay - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1636130-guns-dont-kill-people-people-kill-people-unofficial-slogan-of-the-national-rifle-association-with-particular-reference-to-barings-bank-and-mgrm-argue-whether-derivatives-by-themselves-are-dangerous-or-it-is-traders-and-risk-managers-that-ar.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Derivatives Are Not Dangerous

Are the Risks of Derivatives Manageable

Bass, who considers that the risks of derivatives are manageable are compared and evaluated with the ideas presented by Justin Welby who argues that the risks of derivatives are not manageable.... derivatives are financial instruments (contracts / agreements) which become exercisable on the happening or non happening of any specific event.... derivatives are financial instruments (contracts / agreements) which become exercisable on the happening or non happening of any specific event....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Derivatives Are Toxic Weapons of Financial Mass Destruction

Credit derivatives are an especially sought after instrument due to the legal exemptions afforded it.... On the flip side, the inherent To what extent, if at all, is it true to say that “derivatives are toxic weapons of financial mass destruction” derivatives are an integral part of modern financial markets.... Credit derivatives are an especially sought after instrument due to the legal exemptions afforded it.... In the context of financial market booms and busts, derivatives are often criticized for artificially (yet inevitably) creating these cycles....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Risk of Derivatives

Bass, who considers that the risks of derivatives are manageable are compared and evaluated with the ideas presented by Justin Welby who argues that the risks of derivatives are not controllable.... While Bass argues that the risks associated with financial derivatives are not manageable, Welby argues that these risks are manageable.... This is true because the risks involved with derivatives are not unique from those in other financial tools....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The United Kingdom Derivative Markets

erivatives have been around for almost over 300 years, however, there are very few people who know and are a part of the derivatives.... The paper "The United Kingdom Derivative Markets" discusses that research of works from different authors like Davies, Give, Gorham, Thomas, Shah, Kanter, Kaur, Meier, Remolona, Tett, Westrup etc....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Proposal

Credit Default Swaps

This paper "Credit Default Swaps" discusses the origins of the global financial crisis of 2008, and its roots in the credit derivatives markets.... Operational risk refers to the possibility of a breakdown in the operations of the derivatives program or risk management system....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Proposal

Derivative Securities: Risk Management Strategies for Equities and Interest Rate

As discussed above that the financial derivatives are highly leveraged in nature therefore smaller changes in the value of the underlying asset can create significantly larger changes in the value of the derivatives.... derivatives are in use since last many years however their regular use started during the 1970s during the oil embargo.... Since derivative securities are highly leveraged in nature and can be dangerous if investment managers do not take into consideration the relevant factors that are considered as essential for controlling and managing the risk through financial derivatives....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

How to Lose a Billion

The author states that financial derivatives are considered as ideal instruments for hedging against the risk however, their imprudent use may result in significant losses for the firms too.... hough the derivatives are in use since last many years, however, their more regular use emerged after the oil embargo of the 1970s when oil prices started to soar due to oil embargo placed against major developed countries including the US.... Common types of financial derivatives include forwards, futures, options, and swaps whereas most of the other types of financial derivatives are merely the variations of the above types of financial derivatives....
11 Pages (2750 words) Article

Derivative Markets in the UAE

The new millennium has brought with it new opportunities and much change in societies in general and their derivatives and securities market in particular.... derivatives get traded in two types of markets; OTC markets and exchanges.... The paper "Derivative Markets in the UAE" discusses that the derivative markets in the UAE are in their infancy but the potential for growth is enormous....
8 Pages (2000 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us