StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Major Arguments for and against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Development - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
A review of the available data strongly suggests that the answer to both of these questions is no. In this paper, it is going to the major arguments for and against tax cuts and incentives as far as the promotion of economic development is concerned.
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
The Major Arguments for and against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Development
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Major Arguments for and against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Development"

Assignment The Major Arguments for and against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Development Introduction In his elaborate work Rethinking Growth Strategies published by Economic Policy Institute, Robert Lynch has taken a definite stand on the issue of cutting taxes in the context of the U.S. economy, which have got world wide implications as well. Theoretically cutting taxes is regarded as a way to attain greater economic development. However, Lynch appears to be in disagreement with this view.

Contextually, he states, “But do tax cuts and incentives create jobs in a cost-effective manner? Conversely, do state and local public services undermine growth? A review of the available data strongly suggests that the answer to both of these questions is no. And while state and local tax cuts may in theory stimulate economic activity, in practice they are unlikely to do so.” (2) In this paper, therefore, we are going to the major arguments for and against tax cuts and incentives as far as the promotion of economic development are concerned.

Analysis According to theory, tax cuts stimulate the economy of a country. Hence, in theory, arguments in favor of tax exemptions are available. Particularly in the framework of neo-liberal economic policies, strong theoretical arguments defend tax cuts in an organized way. However, Lynch has chosen to set up counter-arguments in this context by evaluating each favoring theoretical argument critically and analytically. Lynch states, “The pressure to cut state and local spending is likely to persist as long as these jurisdictions continue to face budget deficits, demands for additional tax cuts, and calls for a smaller role for government.” (1) Hence, tax cuts directly confront government’s expenditure for the social sector.

In theory, following arguments are furnished in favour of cutting taxes: 1. Tax Burden Argument: Higher rates of business taxes increase the cost of doing business. Hence, exempting business houses from taxes “encourage existing firms to invest, expand, or remain in a state; stimulate new firm start-up; and convince out-of-state firms to relocate to the incentive-offering state”. (Lynch, 4) Eventually, this process creates jobs. 2. Supply-Side Argument: Tax cuts for businesses and individuals provide benefits for work; thereby increasing investment, savings, and economic activity. 3. Demand-Side Argument: Tax cuts help individuals and businesses to accumulate more money.

Hence, they can consume more even at the limited money supply and markets flourish. This helps the market economy as a whole. 4. Business-Climate Argument: “Proponents of the business-climate argument claim that lower taxes and more incentives improve the business climate, while higher taxes and fewer incentives damage it.” (Lynch, 11) Investment decisions are based on the receptive dimensions of a business destination. 5. Competitiveness Argument: If a holistic approach is adopted to grant tax cuts, more investors, consumers, businesses, etc.

will be attracted to a business destination. Hence, a competitive advantage is obtained in the market economy. General tax incentives, area-specific tax incentives, firm-specific tax cuts, etc. are advocated by competitiveness argument. Following arguments are presented against cutting taxes. 1. With respect to the business, “taxes are not just burdens” (Lynch, 4). Business taxes eventually minimize the cost of doing business by infrastructure development, social integration, consumer support, etc. 2. Tax cuts might lead to small deposits in individual savings accounts, but that does not lower the interest rates.

Moreover, too much stress on consumer oriented market may slow job creation. Hence, both Supply-Side and Demand-Side Arguments present only half of the truth. 3. Business climate cannot be improved exclusively by tax cuts. In fact, serious investors are not “persuaded by ‘perceptions’ rather than facts of business costs and benefits” (Lynch, 11). 4. Tax cuts and incentives, which the local and state governments offer, may adversely affect their capability of retaining businesses and creating jobs. 5. The roughly universal validation for tax cuts and related business tax inducements is that these are the very best ways to generate jobs and encourage growth.

This declaration is made even though local and state governments are required to curtail public services as an unpleasant end result of the tax reductions. Conclusion “Left unchallenged, the tax-burden, supply-side, demand-side, business climate and competitiveness arguments are convincing. But, when evaluated critically, they are unimpressive and unpersuasive.” (Lynch, 18) However, in such a scenario, a balanced approach can be assumed as much better an alternative. If tax cuts and tax incentives (which roughly constitute the whole tax expenditure) are granted in a controlled manner, the economy may be benefited from a much wider perspective.

Moreover, the government’s role in process must not be considered as something that is completely redundant or undesirable. Work Cited Lynch, Robert G. Rethinking Growth Strategies. Washington D.C.: Economic Policy Institute, 2004. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Major Arguments for and against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Essay”, n.d.)
The Major Arguments for and against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1439104-the-major-arguments-for-and-against-cutting-taxes-to-promote-economic-development
(The Major Arguments for and Against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Essay)
The Major Arguments for and Against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Essay. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1439104-the-major-arguments-for-and-against-cutting-taxes-to-promote-economic-development.
“The Major Arguments for and Against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1439104-the-major-arguments-for-and-against-cutting-taxes-to-promote-economic-development.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Major Arguments for and against Cutting Taxes to Promote Economic Development

The Nature of International Competitiveness

Perhaps there is no alternative for such prosperity for a few, but what about a more equitable and sustainable development for all?... Yet, in practice, cutting trade barriers and opening markets do not necessarily generate development.... Yes to trade - no to free trade; Exogenous development; Reform the WTO.... Abolish the WTO; Endogenous development.... ositions 4 and 5 should be taken into consideration with great emphasis as they represent solid positions that can help in the economic and human development of poor countries....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

In Defense of Globalization - International Trade and Free Markets

However, the booming trade and the discovery of new lands prompted these nations to promote trade overseas, which did not go according to what Free market theory had professed.... To understand this, one has to understand that neoliberalism is an ideology that has provided solutions to modify economic policies.... he trend in this direction continued to persist until the Second World War, whose culmination witnessed a reduction in the economic might of the empires....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

Influence of Global Economics at Micro and Macro Levels

According to Dunkey, free trade economists often describe the goal of globalization as deep integration or the convergence of nations' fundamental economic structures and policy systems, extending far beyond trade or strictly economic criteria.... In the 1770s, Smith wrote the wealth of nations in the widespread of mercantilism and his advocacy of free trade was supported by the comparative cost theory and the cloth/wine arguments served as the foundation for what later came to be called the pure theory of trade....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Putting a price on carbon is the best solution for climate change

Though carbon pricing is being focused on as the solution to climate change, critiques believe that this is an ambiguous decision by the developed countries to escape the responsibility of being the major pollutants and share the costs with other countries that emit fewer greenhouse gasses (Jenkins, 2014).... On the other hand, most of the economic activities rely on cheaper and reliable sources of energy like the fossil fuels....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Tackling the Issue of Nuclear Weapon on Iran

This included cutting them off from world trade and convincing other countries to action them, developing a covert war against the Iranian nuclear facilities with Israel's help.... American is now amassing the support of the world nation against Iran through the increase of sanctions against it and is also encouraging domestic opposition against Ahmadinejad's rule in Iran....
11 Pages (2750 words) Report

Possible Trade Restrictions For Improving Environmental Conditions

It is also argued that where labor standards are higher, firms have an incentive to improve employee development toward production and thus human capital development is improved.... n particular, it is argued that where trade restrictions are imposed, competition is more balanced as states are required to implement and enforce international standards of labor wages and working conditions and thus will not become a source of “unfair economic advantages”....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Proposal

Multinational Corporations That Operate in the UK Should Pay More Taxes in the UK

% (United Nations Conference on Trade and development (UNCTD), 2008 p.... The author of this essay "Multinational Corporations That Operate in the UK Should Pay More taxes in the UK" describes the concept of taxation for multinational corporations in the United Kingdom.... nbsp;There have been debates on whether or not the multinationals that operate in the United Kingdom should pay more taxes.... Throughout the paper, arguments will be put forward to support the idea that these MNCs should not pay more taxes as this would hurt the UK economy....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Conceptual Frame of Adam Smith and John Maynard Keynes to Competition

Various economists have covered the topic making arguments for and against the competition.... Keynes argues that in order to improve the societies and empowerment, there is a need to promote the capitalist's elites due to their power and economic forces.... The paper under the headline "Conceptual Frame of Adam Smith and John Maynard Keynes to Competition" focuses on competition is apparent in any economic environment.... nbsp;… Adam Smith who is the founder of modern economics laid his emphasis on the role of cooperation, rule of law, and trust as ideal prerequisite to enhance economic and trading activities....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us