StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
COLUMBUS Few men have proven to be as historically controversial as the Spaniard Christopher Columbus. Columbus made his name by discovering the New World in 1492. What followed after this discovery was a concerted effort by the Spanish and eventually other European power to colonize the Americas…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not"

Download file to see previous pages Elsewhere in the Americas, living standards are high and are improving. Nevertheless, these successes, which can be traced directly from Columbus' first voyage, were also dearly bought. Millions of native lives were lost, through disease and intentional mistreatment. Several civilizations were effectively destroyed so that a new civilization based on settlers' stock could grow. As such, Columbus clearly has a mixed reputation. These two views of Christopher Columbus are both espoused by different historical schools. The argument in a sense boils down to one of politics. Those who are more inclined to be anti-establishment and romantic would suggest that Columbus' legacy is one of bloodshed and misery. Those who are more realist suggest that civilizations with better technology and organization will always supersede those who lack these qualities. In a sense it was the destiny of the advanced European nations to take over the Americas and build their own colonies there. The other civilizations such as the Aztecs and the various tribes of North America were simply unable to compete. There are two main historians who support each of these views. The former view is espoused by Kirkpatrick Sale; the latter by Felipe Fernandez-Armesto. The latter view is more sensible. Kirkpatrick Sale makes a powerful argument about Columbus, but it is all too political and too based on hyperbole. Motives are ascribed to Columbus which he simply never held. The years of colonization were years of “subjugation and violence” according to Sale (Sale, 152). Nothing good ever came of them. The Spanish were rapacious and built nothing and simply destroyed the environment. This is too simplistic a view of the world. According to Sale, the natives were vastly superior to the Europeans who came to the Americas. He describes how their technology was much better, but sounds quite foolish doing so: “'Indian societies had a variety of technologies, some quite sophisticated and many well beyond anything comparable in Europe at the time . . . and certainly could have developed others if they felt any need to do so, particularly in regard to food supply. If they did not, there was likely to be a good reason: if they did not anywhere use the plow, for instance, that may have been because their methods of breaking the soil with a planting stick worked just as well with a tenth of the effort, or because they had learned that opening up and turning over whole fields would only decrease nutrients and increase erosion, or because their thought-world would not have allowed such disregardful violence” (Sale, 322). This is an incredibly idealized view and one that is not unlike those who believe in the noble savage. A critic of the book rightly points out that “Mr. Sale treats the varied ways of life that actually prevailed in the Americas as if all Indians were the same, and confuses time as well by quoting late-20th-century Indian spokesmen as though their words applied universally to every tribe and people” (McNeil). Fernandez-Armesto's perspective is more sensible. He looks to historical context. He also sees contemporary political correctness for what it is: In the opinion of one self-styled Native American spokesman, 'he makes Hitler look like a juvenile delinquent'. This sort of hype is doubly unhelpful: demonstrably false, it makes the horrors of the holocaust seem precedented and gives comfort to Nazi apologists by making ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422285-should-christopher-columbus-be-celebrated-for
(Should Christopher Columbus Be Celebrated for Western Civilization or Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422285-should-christopher-columbus-be-celebrated-for.
“Should Christopher Columbus Be Celebrated for Western Civilization or Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422285-should-christopher-columbus-be-celebrated-for.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not

How the River Nile Informed Every Aspect of Egyptian Civilization

...Discuss how the River Nile informed every aspect of Egyptian Civilization Introduction The Nile, (called “Bahr an-Nil” or “”Nahr an-Nil” in Arabic) is the father of the African rivers and the longest river in the world. It rises south of the equator and flows northward through northeastern Africa to drain into the Mediterranean Sea. It has a length of about 4,132 miles (6,650 kilometers) and drains an area of about 1,293,000 square meters (3,349,000 square kilometers).8 It is the only river that flows directly northward, and has the distinction of being the most intensely studied and most fabled river in our planet. Despite flowing through one of the harshest deserts on earth and traveling its last 1,500 miles without a single tributary...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Western Policies have Lead to Islamic Fundamentalism

It was used to producing a generation of colonialists’ tutored primarily to take over the lands that they were being taught about. The purpose of their academics was to make them familiar with the land and the people, and in turn, bring about their conquest.

Second, Edward Said discusses how by defining ‘Orientalism’ the Western scholars were actually defining themselves. By constantly pointing out the differences between the ‘East’ and the ‘West’, Orientalists themselves produced a divide. The West being liberated, open, and innovative; while the East is portrayed as backward, confined, and superstitious. This continuous brainwashing gave the future ‘liberators’ of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Book Report/Review

Western Influence on Hedge Fund Investments in Russia

To "hedge" a bet is to protect against loss by betting a counterbalancing amount against the original bet. Similarly, a "hedge" in the financial world is a transaction that reduces the risk of an investment. So why are high-risk partnerships that use speculative techniques called "hedge" funds?

Hedge Funds are usually designed as partnerships with the general partner typically being the hedge fund’s manager. (Hedco.net, 2006) The general partner usually invests a large part of his wealth and money into the hedge funds. Hedge funds are different from mutual funds with respect to the type of investors and also with regards to the regulations generally imposed on them. The objective of this dissertation is to analyze...
57 Pages(14250 words)Term Paper

Has Western Popular Culture Become Thoroughly Americanized

Today, the use of the word Americanization denotes the process and the extent to which other countries begin to substitute American values, customs and culture in place of their own. ‘The spread of American media including TV, film and American music …has been the main component of Americanization of other countries’ 

America, as the richest and most powerful state on the planet, is at the forefront of industrial and technological progress. As such, it is no surprise that other industrially developed countries in the West, but also including English-speaking modern states like Australia and New Zealand, have close commercial and cultural ties with the USA. Western Europe, specifically after the S...
12 Pages(3000 words)Term Paper

Differences in the Accounts of the Iran Contra Affair between Christopher Andrew and Tim Weiner

... was unable to reign in the rampant and unyielding intelligence agency. Surely, it should not have been so difficult to keep in check a disorganized and inept government agency that was the CIA. In light of this implausible explanation of Tim Weiner, it has to be inferred that Christopher Andrew’s text carries more merit as a result of being more factual, logical and comprehensiveness of research. Added to this is the very scope of the two books. Andrew’s book spans the entire length of American democracy since the days of George Washington and it deals with Secret Intelligence in general not restricting itself to the operations of the CIA. Weiner’s work on the other hand is exclusively concerned with the history of the CIA...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Great Works of Western Philosophy

...Great Works of Western Philosophy 2 Introduction: Seeking evidences for the existence of a superpower called God has been the epicenter for so many debates and argumentations till date. Arguments for and against the existence of God have been proposed by numerous seekers from various genres including scientists, philosophers, theologians and many others. The concept of God bears ontological argumentations too. This paper addresses the key viewpoints of two great philosophers on the aspect of the existence of God - a) the ontological argument for the existence of God proposed by Anselm of Canterbury, an Italian medieval philosopher, and b) its rejection and criticism by Thomas Aquinas, another Italian philosopher and theologian. The paper...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

In What Ways Did 20th Century Conflicts Change the Nature of Western Introspection

The 20th century period was marked by several conflicts: World War I, the Holocaust, World War II, the exploitation of Latin American countries, Racial Segregation and the Negro Revolution which spawned the Civil Rights Movement in America and the Feminist Movement.

The Holocaust is admittedly one of the most horrific events in the history of mankind and the impact of the horrors it brought changed the way Ellie Wiesel sees his faith. While Jews are known for their orthodox and unquestioning faith in God, Wiesel’s experiences in the concentration camps of Auschwitz compelled her to question God’s existence. In Night, Wiesel tells of the unspeakable hanging of a young boy who was left dangling for thirty min...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment

Discuss the relationship between law and outlawry in the Hollywood Western and you should focus upon: Pale Rider (Clint Eastwood, 1985) and Unforgiven (Clint Eastwood, 1992)

... in Hollywood movies are dependent on the situation and the genre existent at said particular time. This movie epitomizes the life in the American frontier where the formation of societies teetered between the civilization and the wilderness – between the untamed lands, and the creeping power of civilization. The Western genre often presents rugged and beautifully untamed landscapes which sweep through miles of land and, occasionally dotting these landscapes, are frontier houses and families. These movies portray the daily battles of these people in wanting to survive as farmers and as labourers. Hollywood western movies often portray the “conquest of the wilderness and the subordination of nature, in the name of civilization...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Chinese Architecture Influence upon Western Architecture

...Running head: Chinese Architecture Influence upon Western Architecture Chinese Architecture Influence upon Western Architecture [The of the writer appears here] [The name of institution appears here] Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Table of Figures 3 Introduction 4 Historical Development 4 Japanese Architecture 5 Western Architectural Influence 7 Modern Architectural Approach 9 1.Wooden Single-Storey Structure 13 2.Horizontal Axis 13 3.Cantilever Principle 14 4.Gardens 17 i.Flat Gardens 18 ii.Hill Gardens 18 iii.Tea Gardens 19 Conclusion 20 Bibliography 21 Table of Figures Figure 1: Castle in Kyoto, Japan 12 Figure 2: Sendai Mediatheque 13 Figure 3: Ituskushima Shrine 14 Figure 4: Tatamai Mats and Paper Doors...
17 Pages(4250 words)Term Paper

Western Masculinity Beliefs

... The idea of masculinity in the film 3:10 to Yuma James Mangolds 3:10 to Yuma is an impenitent morality film and a study of character that digs deeply into Western masculinity beliefs (Canavese Para. 1). The film instantaneously creates remarkable characters and moral quandaries through behavior in trying circumstances that the audience can also enjoy as action sequences that are superb. The fundamental concept of the film is about what it means to be a man, precisely a man of the old west. The film is set during the expansion of the post-civil War. The film sizes up the lawless, Darwinist Wade code and the principled Evans stance. In the late 1800s in Arizona, the notorious criminal Wade and his malicious gang of criminals and killers...
8 Pages(2000 words)Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not for FREE!

Contact Us