Nobody downloaded yet

Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
COLUMBUS Few men have proven to be as historically controversial as the Spaniard Christopher Columbus. Columbus made his name by discovering the New World in 1492. What followed after this discovery was a concerted effort by the Spanish and eventually other European power to colonize the Americas…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not"

Download file to see previous pages Elsewhere in the Americas, living standards are high and are improving. Nevertheless, these successes, which can be traced directly from Columbus' first voyage, were also dearly bought. Millions of native lives were lost, through disease and intentional mistreatment. Several civilizations were effectively destroyed so that a new civilization based on settlers' stock could grow. As such, Columbus clearly has a mixed reputation. These two views of Christopher Columbus are both espoused by different historical schools. The argument in a sense boils down to one of politics. Those who are more inclined to be anti-establishment and romantic would suggest that Columbus' legacy is one of bloodshed and misery. Those who are more realist suggest that civilizations with better technology and organization will always supersede those who lack these qualities. In a sense it was the destiny of the advanced European nations to take over the Americas and build their own colonies there. The other civilizations such as the Aztecs and the various tribes of North America were simply unable to compete. There are two main historians who support each of these views. The former view is espoused by Kirkpatrick Sale; the latter by Felipe Fernandez-Armesto. The latter view is more sensible. Kirkpatrick Sale makes a powerful argument about Columbus, but it is all too political and too based on hyperbole. Motives are ascribed to Columbus which he simply never held. The years of colonization were years of “subjugation and violence” according to Sale (Sale, 152). Nothing good ever came of them. The Spanish were rapacious and built nothing and simply destroyed the environment. This is too simplistic a view of the world. According to Sale, the natives were vastly superior to the Europeans who came to the Americas. He describes how their technology was much better, but sounds quite foolish doing so: “'Indian societies had a variety of technologies, some quite sophisticated and many well beyond anything comparable in Europe at the time . . . and certainly could have developed others if they felt any need to do so, particularly in regard to food supply. If they did not, there was likely to be a good reason: if they did not anywhere use the plow, for instance, that may have been because their methods of breaking the soil with a planting stick worked just as well with a tenth of the effort, or because they had learned that opening up and turning over whole fields would only decrease nutrients and increase erosion, or because their thought-world would not have allowed such disregardful violence” (Sale, 322). This is an incredibly idealized view and one that is not unlike those who believe in the noble savage. A critic of the book rightly points out that “Mr. Sale treats the varied ways of life that actually prevailed in the Americas as if all Indians were the same, and confuses time as well by quoting late-20th-century Indian spokesmen as though their words applied universally to every tribe and people” (McNeil). Fernandez-Armesto's perspective is more sensible. He looks to historical context. He also sees contemporary political correctness for what it is: In the opinion of one self-styled Native American spokesman, 'he makes Hitler look like a juvenile delinquent'. This sort of hype is doubly unhelpful: demonstrably false, it makes the horrors of the holocaust seem precedented and gives comfort to Nazi apologists by making ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422285-should-christopher-columbus-be-celebrated-for
(Should Christopher Columbus Be Celebrated for Western Civilization or Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422285-should-christopher-columbus-be-celebrated-for.
“Should Christopher Columbus Be Celebrated for Western Civilization or Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422285-should-christopher-columbus-be-celebrated-for.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not

Christopher Columbus

...?Section A: 2. Discovery of America by Christopher Columbus is held to be in appropriate and false as some historical evidence reflect the fact that America was discovered by Scandinavians in the early tenth century. It is believed that in the Viking era a group of Scandinavians who were sailors and warriors actually discovered America. According to a chart of the library of congress in Washington, it is however claimed that the West coast of America was discovered by Marco Polo two centuries before it was done by Christopher Columbus. Several theories have been reported from the chart of the library which includes the possibility of the discovery of the Northern coast of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The History Of Christopher Columbus

...? 14 August The history of Christopher Columbus: It would not be a hyperbolic ment if it is said that virtually all the Americans considered Christopher Columbus to be a classic hero and a respect worthy traveler with whose phenomenal efforts America got discovered and a revolutionary journey to modernism began, until Bill Bigelow erupted on the scene with his revisionist history. Prior to hardcore revelations made by Bigelow regarding the extraordinarily respectful public hero Columbus, the American nation strongly believed that Columbus was the courageous navigator who took great pains to travel around the world and discover the land of...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Western Civilization

...Module: Western Civilization The world has come a long way from early civilization which led to the development of well organized structures geared at enhancing the way of life. This has so far impacted greatly on continents and was the reason behind the rapid development across the globe. Despite it being the case conflict kept emerging but was taken a notch high during the medieval. At the time the world witnessed a conquest among nations while striving at dominance. Most lives were lost before peace realization. It latter emerged that they were unlikely to achieve much while fighting. During the struggle nations were ruled by monarchs, the kings prided themselves in strong armies made...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Christopher Columbus- The Discovery (1992)

...Christopher Columbus- The Discovery Introduction Christopher Columbus-The discovery is a film that is based actual events that took place in the 1940s that led to the discovery of the new world by Christopher Columbus, which contributed to the exploration and eventual colonization of the American continents. These are events that happened in Europe and the American continent at a time when European nations were competing in the discovery of other worlds. This is a time where the church, specifically the Roman Catholic had immense control of politics and ruling of the then known world. Christopher...
5 Pages(1250 words)Movie Review

Explorer Description: Christopher Columbus

...Christopher Columbus Christopher Columbus was considered to be one greatest explorer's in the Age of Discovery. Christopher Columbus was given the title of "Admiral of the Ocean Sea", to his explorations. Christopher Columbus's actual name was Cirstoforo Colombo. He was born in Genoa, Italy in 1451 to a Christian household and died in 1506 in Valladolid, Spain at the age of 55 years. He was the oldest son of Domenico Colombo (wool worker and merchant) and Susanna Fontanarossa. He had received very little formal education was mostly self-taught; in the late years he learned how to read Latin and write...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Christopher Columbus

...Thesis Out of all the numerous great explorers nearly all people assume of Christopher Columbus as the greatest. People would think of him as the greatest for the reason that he was the first traveler to reach the Americas. He happens to be one of the few early believers that the world was round. All through Columbus's great existence as an voyager he went on about four vast voyages and made numerous great discoveries. Columbus had a grand life and many appealing things occurred to him during his lifetime. Columbus forever transformed the world by his various discoveries and it is remarkable how many findings were he managed to return to the same location each time even though he had no thought where he really was and he made lots... of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Christopher Columbus

...and Section # of Christopher Columbus Christopher Columbus was born in 1451, he is known as a great navigator and colonizer. The word that best explains him is explorer because he explored the Americas and traveled far off to discover it. Columbus was the second one to discover Americas after Vikings. Many people have reached Americas before Columbus but his discovery is important that he did not only discover it but had introduced the European culture in America and provided the basis for the establishment of European rule in the continent. Columbus started his voyage across the Atlantic Ocean in order to explore the...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

Christopher Columbus, journal excerpts and letter

...Topic: Christopher Columbus, journal excerpts and letter (1492-93) Christophe Columbus is a learned man of cosmology and hailed from Cugureo within the city and lordship of Genoa (Cohen, 1992 p. 27). He was described as intelligent, charming and great in Latin. He was a traveler in greater of Mediterranean and becomes educated in navigation. Later he stayed in Portugal. Columbus sailed in four voyages, found many people in large populations and made some proclamations in a royal standard in taking “possession of these people for their Highnesses.” (Cohen, 1992, p. 115). Having persuaded the King of this voyage, he departed Spain in 1492 and commanded...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Christopher Columbus, Mariner

...Number and Section) (Word Count: 1443) Samuel Eliot Morison. Christopher Columbus, Mariner. (Little Brown: Boston, 1955), 160 pgs. Background information about the author Samuel Eliot Morison a product of Brahmin tradition was born in Boston, Massachusetts on 9th July 1887. He received the Pulitzer Prize award in 1943 for his exemplary work in writing about the biographies of Christopher Columbus and John Paul Jones. Morison was made a lieutenant commander in the US Navy due to his excellent rich historical prowess. This was during the World War II and wrote about 15 volumes of books from 1947 to 1962 about the US naval operations I the war (Morison,...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Christopher Columbus, Hero and Villain

...Topic: Christopher Columbus Like every nation, every country has a fatherly figure to look up to, The United s of America has Christopher Columbus. Describing the importance of Christopher Columbus in the history of United States in mere words is almost impossible. America would not have been there if it was not for Christopher Columbus to go on a voyage and discover the lands of native Indians and make a colony of some people there which grew into the United States of America. After Columbus’s first visit to the lands and getting to know about what those lands could bring to his people,...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Should Christopher Columbus be celebrated for Western Civilization or not for FREE!

Contact Us