Nobody downloaded yet

The Constitution creates a system that was designed to fail AND the existence of a set of fundamental American values - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name: Institution: Tutor: Course: Date: The Constitution Creates a System That Was Designed To Fail The statement “The Constitution creates a system that was designed to fail” means in the context of constitutionalism means that there are fundamental structural and institutional flaws, as created by the constitution…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
The Constitution creates a system that was designed to fail AND the existence of a set of fundamental American values
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Constitution creates a system that was designed to fail AND the existence of a set of fundamental American values"

Download file to see previous pages It also guaranteed a stronger horizontal separation of power amongst the executive, the legislature and the judiciary, thus improves institutional checks and balances while at the same time granting some autonomy to various government organs (Ellis 49). It also established the Supreme Court that would be the final arbiter in matters of law, therefore improving access to justice and resolving interstate, state-federal as well as well as conflict between the said entities and individuals. To this extent, the constitution was designed to achieve success. Even though the constitution had such praiseworthy aspects, the US creates enormously stronger federal government, with highly nationalized values. Therefore, resources get to be majorly centralized; as such the states become extremely subservient to the federal government (Wood 28).Basically all the prime sectors and taxes are in control of the federal governments. This is a weakness, since it is the states that are closer to the people and therefore stand a better chance to respond faster to the need of the people, in comparison to the federal government (Ellis 49). The congress has on some occasions exercised its legislative power to pass laws that interfere with the processes already running in the states. For instance, in United States v. Morrison, pursuant to its powers under the Commerce Clause and the Fourth Amendment (Section 5), the Congress had enacted a statute, Violence against Women Act (VAWA) which provided civil remedies to gender –based violence victims against their assailants. This was based on argument that such injustices against women hindered their free participation in interstate commerce and thus a remedy was essential. The court struck down a part of this law since the law was not dealing with cases that were economic in nature. The congress had over stretched its powers under the constitution to interfere with state court, by offering a federal filing for such cases. VAWA dealt with a social issue (gender violence) and its economic impact on interstate Commerce was indirect and marginal. Similar scenario arose in United States v. Lopez, where the court pointed out that Commercial Clause could only be applied in cases that are directly economic in nature. United States v. Morrison defines the sensitive question of the relationship between the Congressional powers and the State powers, and in particular, the extent to which the congress may limit areas that are traditionally defined as being within the scope of the state. These decisions reveal judicial activisms in favor of state sovereignty at the expense of federalism and to strengthen the state power. The Existence of a Set of Fundamental American Values Values refer to the standards that have consciously or unconsciously set by members of a particular culture or society upon which the desirable and undesirable are distinguished behaviors (Dahrendorf 14). Values therefore form a basis for judging the people and their actions, from a cultural approach, in order to determine whether they are good or bad, valuable or worthless, beautiful or ugly or whether they are prized or shunned. The values have a great role in shaping our actions and behaviour. For quite long, Americans have been known for their set of values, mostly the value of freedom and independence. This is reflected in a number of Constitutional Amendments that puts ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Constitution creates a system that was designed to fail AND the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421750-the-constitution-creates-a-system-that-was
(The Constitution Creates a System That Was Designed to Fail AND the Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421750-the-constitution-creates-a-system-that-was.
“The Constitution Creates a System That Was Designed to Fail AND the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1421750-the-constitution-creates-a-system-that-was.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Constitution creates a system that was designed to fail AND the existence of a set of fundamental American values

The American Constitution

...peasants who prevailed along the rural American belt. The main dominant social trait of the Anti Federalists as a clan was their formidable strength in the established western peripheries of the US peninsula (Anti Federalists, 2011). Despite their staunch disapproval the constitution, the Anti Federalists formed the crux of the core political thought of the American polity. They believed that the structural deformation of the newly created constitution would ultimately lead to a tyrannical regime far from the cries & pathos of its own citizens. They genuinely predicted that the gravest...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

American Government and Constitution

... the powerful people in the society. The Founding Fathers that formed the constitution fell short of important requirement, which would later, have impacts on the afterward generations. The first shortcoming was slavery; they never included any comment that forbade slavery, instead; they created rules for slavery (Schultz, p 208). For example, any absconder had to be taken back to the slaveholder once they were found. The government secondly failed to guarantee the right of voting during political elections. Constitutionally, this is referred to as suffrage (Edwards, Wattenberg and Lineberry, p 34). It excluded half of the population including women, native and African Americans, it took a long time for women and African Americans... not...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Designed House Cooling System

... A Designed House Cooling Method Project’s requirements specifications The problem of uncomfortable rooms has been brought about by high temperatures, high humidity and lack of fresh air. The designing of houses in areas with such weather conditions calls for measures to ensure comfort in a house unit to be constructed. An Minh lies in a hot, humid climate all year with alternating dry and wet six months seasons each. The climate of An Minh calls for the construction of a housing system that will enhance a natural cooling process and reduce moisture in the house (humidity). Bhattacharjee states that temperature, humidity and air movement are primary climatic elements affecting the comfort of human beings. Therefore, the design... to be...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

American Constitution

...for governing any state running under the democratic system. The United States government is divided into three branches: legislative, executive and judicial. This prevents any one branch from becoming too supreme and allows the branches to balance each other's powers and to cooperate. Among the statements made by Judge Taylor were ones that said: the President of the United States who is such a vital member of the constitution and also responsible for giving us three amendments is undisputedly responsible for failing to produce any judicial orders as is required by FISA. The work concluded with Judge Taylor stating that the power of the Office of the Chief Executive has been...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

American history-us constitution

...: Timeline in US History 25-04-2008 < http://www.google.com/searchclient=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Afr%3Aofficial&channel=s&hl=fr&q=timeline+in+US+history&lr=&btnG=Recherche+Google> Reference Michael Les Benedict: Expanding the Scope of American Constitutional History. Retrieved on the 24th of April 2008-04-25 http://www.h-net.org/law/teaching_legal_history/benedict.htm US constitution 1. Running Head: US Constitution US Constitution Your name Name of your institution Course title or Work Instructor's name if any 25.04.2008 US Constitution 2 Abstract The Fundamental...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

American Constitution

...that had produced the 13 Articles of Confederation, which were incorporated into the Constitution, representing the Declaration of Independence. There is no other country that, since its birth, has been guided by the same document that was created at the time of the country’s birth. Fourth, we know that the Constitution is vague enough in its guarantees as to be flexible and applicable with changing times, to the present modernity often referred to as the New Age. Thus, the United States Constitution is a living document; a finely crafted living document. It is not the product of happenstance or chaos, but is the product of collaborative philosophies that guided the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

American constitution

...Full Define politics and discuss 4 roles of government (enforce and create laws, provide social infrastructure, protects human rights, provide public safety). The term politics generally relates to the event of governing and running the affairs of a particular state. It also encompasses the method of power by the ruling entity (Jowett 6). Modern politics however delves on the relation of the people and the discourse and relationship it has over its governing body. The responsibilities of the government are critical to the success and well-being of the population and state wherein it governs. Firstly, it is in charge of enforcing and creating laws for the benefit and protection of its citizens. This is...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Fundamental of management information system

...Fundamental of Management Information System Snyders of Hannover which is a multinational company has proved to be using an old-school form of financial tracking which is not up to its standard. For a company that sell eighty million of its products, the use of spreadsheets is not advisable totally. The financial department at the head office is straining to collect data from all the fifty branches and analyze them before consolidating them into one document that is then used as a profit and loss statement. This move already shows that the company is not in a position to clearly come up with clear cut financial statements that can be audited and be accountable for. This kind of situation lowers the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Fundamental of Management Information System

...or program which will allow to record by the scanner what products buyers actually buy (scanner data) in the Macy’s stores, click-through sequences, or automated customer counts (Chapter 2: Information Systems and Knowledge Management, n.d.). Based on point-of-sale data recordings there can be retrieved data which will enable Macy’s to answer the question: What types of trends exist in customer purchases, and whether there are any regional differences? (Chapter 2: Information Systems and Knowledge Management, n.d.). By organizing all these data into database and comparing information among all 800 locations management will know whether there is a need of adjusting its items to local...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

American Constitution Law 1.1

...American constitutional law American constitutional law Mapp v. Ohio, 367 U.S. 643 (1961) Decided in 1961 Cleveland Law enforcers arrived in the appellant home in search of information that a certain individual was hiding in the appellants home who was needed for questioning and interrogation in association with bombing, and that there were certain things being concealed in that residence. Mapp and he daughter lived in that home and when the police officers arrived, they knocked the door and demanded to enter but Miss Mapp upon conducting her lawyer; she declined to allow the police officers in her house without a valid search warrant. The police officers were permitted to conduct a surveillance of the resident. Three hours later... ...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Constitution creates a system that was designed to fail AND the existence of a set of fundamental American values for FREE!

Contact Us