StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Anderson Reading on Chinatown - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Anderson Reading on Chinatown" highlights that Anderson starts out his article by talking about the traditional explanation for Chinatown as a response to racist attitudes from the white people who lived in big cities.  However, he says this is not the only way to study Chinatowns…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Anderson Reading on Chinatown
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Anderson Reading on Chinatown"

Two of these stereotypes are the idea that Chinatown and Chinese people are somehow immoral and dirty.
A lot of the background of these and other racial ideas has to do with a shift in the thinking of the nineteenth century "from ethnocentrism to a radical biological determinism," where people tried to come up with scientific proof that one race was somehow better than another (Anderson 585). These resulted in stereotyping of other races and also, such as in the case of Chinatown, the splitting apart from the mainstream society of other races so that their lesser qualities would not "contaminate" white society (Anderson 585).

Anderson quotes a secretary of state from 1885 in Canada who says that Chinatown is "attended with evils" and that "because of their habits of lodging crowded quarters and accumulating filth, is offensive if not likely to breed disease" (Anderson 586). This idea continues to grow in the period from then until the 1920s. Darwin's ideas and other scientific advances were used to argue that the Chinese were inferior, dirtier and that the areas they lived in were bad because of this. It was the council of Vancouver who officially labeled the area "Chinatown" in the 1890s and then actually destroyed some of the buildings because of supposed health complaints.

The other idea which grew at the same time period was the idea of Chinese immorality. Anderson says the area was seen as "non-Christian, uncivilized, and immoral" and that because of this perception, Chinatown was supposed to be a lawless opium-addicted area with "wickedness unmentionable" (589). At the same time, he disagrees that this perception came about purely because Chinese people were not white. He says that instead, the government was motivated by "economic competition" and racial myths which were thoroughly embedded in the government's employees (Anderson 590).

2) In the Aitken reading on school shootings, how is the media depicting these tragic events? And, what is the importance of place in the varying reactions to the murders?
Aitken talks about several school shootings which took place near San Diego in 2001 and compare these to the Columbine shooting that was so shocking when it happened. Several other authors have claimed that the Columbine shooting was inspired by Neo-nazi movements and that it is disturbing that the media did not report on this information (Aitken 594). Although Aitken does not think the San Diego shootings were inspired in the same way, he says there is still an element of racism in how the media represented them in news. Specifically, this has to do with where the murders took place.

Aitken argues that both the place of the school shootings and the way the media reported on them after they happened to point towards what he calls "a normalizing and mythic geography of fear" (595). What he means by this seems to be the combination of the old idea everybody has that it can never happen where a person lives because where that person lives, at least in America, is always normal, middle-class, and safe. The fear and horror take place in other parts of the world, or in non-white communities, in places other than the "mythic place of white middle-class America—suburbs, small towns, edge communities, country villages" (Aitken 597).

Aitken mentions that both of these shootings, like Columbine, took place in communities that were exactly like this. For this reason, the media shows these shootings as incredibly horrific compared to other kinds of gun violence in America, or violence in other parts of the world. The reason the high school shootings are shown so badly is exactly that it is carried out by young white males who are supposed to be, according to the American Dream, ideal. Aitken creates typical questions that might be asked by middle-class white society to represent this horror: "How can something so horrifying happen to communities that so resemble middle America? How can the perpetrator be so as my son?" (Aitken 599).

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Racism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1413630-racism
(Racism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1413630-racism.
“Racism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1413630-racism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Anderson Reading on Chinatown

The case of Chinese food retailers

The Case of Chinese Food Retailers Name of Instructor Name of Institution Date The Case of Chinese Food Retailers Introduction In China, food is not eaten for merely to satisfy hunger but for promoting health, treating diseases and strengthening relationships between people and families.... ... ... ...
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Cross-cultural Communication

Gordon Cook in 1975 in chinatown.... Kate, a 43-year-old nurse in London and Cook's wife was the first member of staff at the hospital beside her husband and they relocated from Manchester in Britain and settled in chinatown during the spring of 1975 with their three-year-old son....
18 Pages (4500 words) Research Paper

Ethnic enclave: Vancouver Chinatown

While there are numerous ethnic enclaves across the United States of America and Canada, this paper will focus on Vancouver's chinatown as a case study.... Vancouver's chinatown is known to be among the largest chinatown in Canada.... The chinatown has its center on Pender Street and unofficially extends into Downtown Eastside.... Like many other Chinese enclaves in Canada, the Vancouver chinatown started as a residential cluster in which Chinese immigrants were temporarily sheltered by their employers as they worked in the mines8....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Planning and Future of Chinatown

Date due: chinatown: planning and urban environmental related concerns The movie chinatown was situated in Los Angeles city, California.... chinatown movie written by Roman Polanski depicts the planning which sets strict conditions before housing can be demolished.... This report will be based on two major aspects of planning in chinatown namely politics in planning and urban growth and suburbanization.... The planning and future of chinatown is based upon how these many chinatown roles on politics in planning are weighed....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Post Confederation Canadian History

The Cnadian welfare state, like welfare states elsewhere, has undergone significant reform and restructuring.... Reformers were concerned first and foremost with promoting healthy and efficient living to ensure national affluence.... Peter Bryce, the chief dominion health officer, defined public health as 'the maintenance of the largest possible number of effective citizens, viewed from the standpoint of their economic value to the state....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Media, Stereotypes & the Perpetuation of Racism in Canada

the stages in which you are required to complete and furnish the completed documents.... I am however, willing to include a prototype of the model for you, which you may fill.... ... ... This is a qualitative research hence no numbers or graphs are included.... It is an exploratory research which is based on the analysis and observations of published literature (i....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Relationships Between Festivals and Tourism

This literature review "The Relationships Between Festivals and Tourism" focuses on festivals that can provide a major boost for tourism in a country.... By improving attention to neighborhood society, festivals likewise help the nearby economy and give amusement to general society.... ... ... ... Cultural events can be a great resource of economic, social and cultural development of a region....
11 Pages (2750 words) Literature review

Space and Place as Cultural Phenomena, as Sites Where Meaning and Identities are Produced or Maintained

The essay "Space and Place as Cultural Phenomena, as Sites Where Meaning and Identities, are Produced or Maintained" focuses on that culture is a product of the human hand and includes both intangible and tangible aspects of human creation.... It changes according to time, place, and even generations....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us