Nobody downloaded yet

Compare & contrast 4 countries using the majority and proportional system including their advantages and disadvantages - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The Majority System and Proportional System Name: Institutional affiliation: Comparing and Contrasting the Majority System and the Proportional System All democracies are said to have legislatures elected in at least free and fair elections. Electoral systems have many consequences concerning what form of government a nation will have…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Compare & contrast 4 countries using the majority and proportional system including their advantages and disadvantages
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Compare & contrast 4 countries using the majority and proportional system including their advantages and disadvantages"

Download file to see previous pages Next is the proportional system this involves matching the share of seats which have been won with the share of votes won with an exemption of few parties according to LeDuc, Niemi, and Norris (2010). In comparing the majority system for both United Kingdom and United States of America, for one, they both apply single-member plurality. To win a certain seat a candidate should have more votes compared to others. The main idea here is plurality of votes. In both countries as far as the system is concerned, there is particular share of the vote needed to win under single-member district. The election is usually a series of personal races no matter how many districts there are. In the proportional electoral system in both United Kingdom and United States, there is matching of the share of seats that have been won. In both countries proportional system rewards diverse preferences. Also groups of different opinions are able to combine forces to get the pluralism required for victory. In the United Kingdom the legislature which is elected through the majority system is unicameral with the House of Lords having little power while in United States it is bicameral. In the United Kingdom, the constitution can be amended by a simple majority who are in the House of Commons while in United States of America amendments are done by majority in the legislature. In the United Kingdom there are no judicial reviews while in the USA, there is a judicial review which separates the court from the president and the congress. In UK there is concentration of power in the upper house while in the US, there is power separation with the executive being independent from the legislature. As noted by LeDuc, Niemi, and Norris (2010), majority systems are highly used in Australia and France. In both cases, the electoral system uses the majority electoral formula. In both countries the system is based on the single member districts, hereby the successful candidate is one with the majority number of votes. The two countries also use the dual ballot which is a used for presidential elections. There are two main types of majority electoral system that is, runoff system and as well the alternative vote. Australia usually uses the alternative vote option. The alternative vote requires voters to rank all the candidates who were running in the election and then the one with highest average score wins. The system requires a lot of thinking on the part of the voters as they have to develop an opinion about each and every candidate. In contrast, France employs the runoff-plurality system which allows more than two candidates in the second round during the dual balloting. In proportional representation, there is an attempt to convert parties’ share of vote to almost a proportional share of the seats in the legislature. Both Australia and France use the party list system whereby political parties prepare a list of candidates well ranked with as many of the candidates as there are seats in the legislature. The advantages of the majority system One advantage of the majority system is that small parties do not get chance to win unless some constituencies have population with different views from the rest of the country. The advantage here is that those with different views are represented. Furthermore, the majority system leads to parties forming blocks until there remain two major players in the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Compare & contrast 4 countries using the majority and proportional Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Compare & Contrast 4 Countries Using the Majority and Proportional Essay)
“Compare & Contrast 4 Countries Using the Majority and Proportional Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare & contrast 4 countries using the majority and proportional system including their advantages and disadvantages

Proportional representative system in U.K

..., this referendum was continually delayed and dropped off the labor party agenda. Additionally, the amount of choice that the voter would be given could also be limited. This is because there is an argument that the Labor Party and the Tories stand to lose the most if any changes are effected to the pluralist electoral system, which explains their reluctance to pursue the issue (Amy 25). Had proportional representation been used during the elections of 1997, it is possible that the big Labor majority would have seen a reduction with major gains by the Liberal Democrats (Connolly 31). This would have seen a gain from the forty six seats they attained to as...
6 Pages(1500 words)Term Paper

Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Emissions Permit System

... Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Emissions Permit System Introduction The once hostile sphere of environmental policy has turned full cycle over the past two decades to a remarkable adoption of economic principles hitherto pushed to the periphery and lamped together in a long academic wish list. First proposed by Dales in 1968, Emissions trading (commonly known as cap and trade) has gained considerable ground as a presumptive scheme for curbing global carbon pollution. Free emissions of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere are recognizably the main cause of global warming. Behind the overwhelming support for marketable permits for atmospheric greenhouse...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Compare and contrast 4 poems

...? Comparing and contrasting four poems The First World War was a universal wore centered in Europe that started in 1924 and lasted until 1918. It engaged all the world’s great powers, which were consolidated in two opposing pacts: the Allies and the Central Powers. For the first, a considerable number of vital English poets were soldiers, chronicling about their experience of war. A number of them were killed in the battlefield, of noteworthy being Rupert Brooke, Wilfred Owen and Edward Thomas, amid others. However, most of the poems by English poets were published in newspapers and then combined into an omnibus. Unrivaled for its variety and strength, the poetry of the First World War persists to have a powerful impact on readers... lines...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Compare and contrast two European countries

...College: COMPARE AND CONTRAST ANY TWO EUROPEAN COUNTRIES In most cities and countries in the world, the issue of social exclusion rests at the centre of controversy and concern. Though it can be argued that its existence is fading out of the modern society, there are traces of it in many countries. The European countries also fall victim of this. Before going further into the cause of disagreement of this issue, let us look at the meaning of social exclusion. The term is closely related to marginalization. There exists a thin line between the two terms. Social exclusion relates to alienation of some people within a...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

The advantages and disadvantages of using antibiotics

...Advantages and disadvantages of using antibiotics Antibiotics are medicines that fight bacteria and viruses, either by killing the invading bacteria or by weakening them so that the immune system can fight and kill them more rapidly. Most of antibiotics are bacteria fighters; although there are millions of viruses, there are only half-a-dozen or so antibiotics available. Bacteria, on the other hand, are more complex (while viruses must "live" in a "host" (us), bacteria can live independently) and so are easier to kill (Reddy, 2005). The history of antibiotics began seventy-six years ago with the discovery of penicillin by Alexander Fleming....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Advantages and disadvantages of using mail surveys

...RUNNING HEAD: ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF USING MAIL SURVEYS Advantages and Disadvantages of using Mail Surveys School Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Mail Surveys A survey is mode of data collection from identified or pre-selected respondents for specific purposes. One of the survey methods available is mail survey. Mail survey uses a printed questionnaire where questions may be open- or close-ended. A close ended question can be answerable by simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’. This type of survey is structured wherein the same questions, grouped or categorized according to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

BPMN advantages, disadvantages within system integration

...BPMN Within A System Integration Context: Advantages And Disadvantages Business Process Modeling Notation is a representation used to specify business processes in graphical form in the business process model. There are several advantages of using the Business Process Modeling Notation in the business environment and also technically Advantages There are numerous advantages that are associated with Business Process Model and Notation. Business Process Modeling Notation offers a standard notation that is easy to understand for many individuals giving it that universal aspect in its...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The education system compare and contrast 2 countries(USA&UK)

...learning of a particular discipline. This is especially useful for a student wishing to specialise in a particular field especially at the university. Another advantage is that education is relatively cheap since it is state funded. A disadvantage, though, is the number of subjects taught to children at the primary stage, which is seen to be too much for such young brains to handle. In the United States, the structure of the education system incorporates; primary, secondary and higher successively. Entry into formal primary education begins at approximately six years of age, where learners enter first grade. Primary education is split into two phases; elementary...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Advantages & Disadvantages of JavaScript

... Advantages & Disadvantages of JavaScript Introduction: JavaScript is a dynamic form of computer language which is used in the purpose of programming. JavaScript has emerged as a leading language that has been used frequently because of its feasibility to target audience. JavaScript had reached a new level of popularity after its adoption from Microsoft as a diverse language for scripting on client side. Due to increment in programming presently, deeper effects of JavaScript has been highlighted regarding its advantages and disadvantages (Quigley, 2004, p. 1). Advantages & Disadvantages of...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Advantages & Disadvantages of Monsters

... humans to suffer. Their disadvantages in people’s lives are reputations preceding them. For example, the article asserts that these monsters cause insanity among other forms of misery. An evaluation of the abovementioned opinions that are considered as representative of several other positions, one might observe that most individuals do not still understand this kind of monster. Actually, several atheists might not perceive the actuality that spiritual monsters, also known as demons, are real. Thus, the perfect evaluation for the disadvantages and advantages of this kind of monsters can merely be advanced through the religious prism. Christianity indicates that there is no good thing that demons are able to bring into the life... is the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Compare & contrast 4 countries using the majority and proportional system including their advantages and disadvantages for FREE!

Contact Us