StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

International and comparative criminal justice - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The Exclusion of Evidence Comparative Criminal Law Name Date Prof One of the most important principles in the criminal justice system is the reputation of the system. Nothing should be done that would put the administration of justice into disrepute. One of the key battlegrounds relating to this issue is the admission of evidence obtained in criminal investigations…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
International and comparative criminal justice
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "International and comparative criminal justice"

Download file to see previous pages This is the way things should be. It is unacceptable for the police to contaminate evidence or obtain it through duress. However, its actual exclusion should rest at the discretion of a judge. This is the correct law and is followed in many common law jurisdictions, while it is less prevalent in civil law jurisdictions. In the course of this essay the rationale for this rule will be examined as will a number of cases and statutes relating to it. It is first important to discuss context. Crime has been an unfortunate aspect of human existence from the beginning of time. Each civilization and country has had to determine a method for dealing with it within their own moral vision. Different approaches to dealing with crime come from different values systems. Everyone is different and believes in different things. For people that believe a criminal is a product of his environment and is not personally responsible for committing of crime, it is likely that resources will be used on rehabilitation and treatment. Imprisonment will play a less important role. But for those who believe individuals are responsible for the things that they do and that if they intend to commit crimes they should be punished, the emphasis is likely to be on punishing or detaining the criminal. These different values play a role in determining how evidence is excluded. These two ways of dealing with crime can be broken up into two models. One will be likely to exclude contaminated evidence in order to preserve the human rights of the criminal, the second model would be much less likely to exclude evidence1. The first is the famous due process model present in most developed countries. The main idea of this model is that an individual should not be deprived of their human rights, even if it is clear that he or she has committed a terrible crime. To put someone in prison is to take away the criminal’s right to liberty. That is a very serious thing. The process must be scrutinized to ensure that everything is done by the book. At its heart the due process model is the idea that the system would rather see ten guilty people go free than one innocent person in prison. The result of this model is many hours of painstaking work checking evidence and a long time-line of the court case moving slowly through the system. Because, historically, the legal system railroaded individuals by planting false evidence and by abusing human rights, we must be very careful when examining evidence. Permitting contaminated evidence into the legal system would encourage law enforcement officers to commit illicit acts. The due process model would strongly argue to exclude evidence obtained in the course of an abuse of human rights. The second way of looking at criminal justice regarding evidence is the crime control model. This model puts a high value on locking up guilty people. Its aim is to protect society and it tries to do this by detaining as many people as it can as quickly as it can. Typically, in this model more money is spent on policing and deterring and prosecuting criminals as quickly as possible so that the police and prosecutors can start again quickly on the next group of criminals. If it happens that an innocent person is ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“International and comparative criminal justice Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1404838-international-and-comparative-criminal-justice
(International and Comparative Criminal Justice Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1404838-international-and-comparative-criminal-justice.
“International and Comparative Criminal Justice Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1404838-international-and-comparative-criminal-justice.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF International and comparative criminal justice

International Criminal Justice

...a new low for international criminal justice to say the least.If it wasn't the direct state intervention through concepts like the Monroe doctrine by the Americans ,the Soviets got away with the Bloody invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968.The Cold War had a large role to play in the temporary halt of the accountability culture put forward by the Nuremburg trials .Historically when the conception of crimes against humanity was evolving with in the Post Nazi Germany the victims and survivors argued for the punishment of atrocities and other criminal acts which were committed in both the course as well as the anticipation of war.The aim was to include the atrocities against...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

International Criminal Justice, Foundations of International and Comparative Criminal Justice

...International Criminal Justice, Foundations of International and Comparative Criminal Justice Discuss the role of victims in international criminal trials and suggest possible areas of reform. 'The world has become a smaller place for all of us. Today, the voices of millions of women, men and children from all over the globe whose basic human rights and freedom have been violated, even those in remote areas, travel fast over national boundaries, making their concerns our concerns also. No one is immune from serious human rights violations. Just as some innocent people are today's victims, we may be tomorrow's victims. Just as their basic universal human rights have been violated today, our same basic, universal human rights may... some...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEMS (COMPARATIVE)

...Running Head: CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEMS Comparison of Criminal Justice Systems By __________________ Criminal justice system is greatly affected by two concerns, the degree to which an offender is actually regarded as the weaker party in need of protection against the power of the state, and the way in which an offender is approached and treated by representatives of the state. Very important is the so-called 'large cities initiative' in places like Amsterdam and the USA in local government in which the rich are moving out of the cities and are creating ghettos for themselves, ghettos for the rich. Back in town are the ghettos for the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Comparative criminal justice

...Escobar, the late narcotic billionaire. Escobar was just a petty thief who started a drug distribution business which later evolved into an international drug smuggling empire. He became very rich and he owned fleets of boats and planes, various residences in Medellin. Violence is his main strategy and trademark so he made many enemies in Colombia and the United States. His vicious acts included murdering a popular politician and, planting a bomb on a plane which killed 110 people including two Americans. After that incident, the U.S. government decided to act decisively and put a public manhunt for Pablo. US military resources spanning from a massive electronic-surveillance effort to the cooperation of U.S. agencies...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Comparative criminal justice

...Comparative Criminal Justice Corruption continues to be a serious crime that affects several countries in the world. However, since Transparency International started ranking countries using corruption perception index, the rate of crimes has decreased considerably. However, countries facing persistent poverty, political volatility, as well as high crime rates continue to portray high rates of corruption. The Transparency International uses Corruption Perception Index, which communicates the rate of corruption as perceived by businesspersons as well analysts in a country. In the 2007, Denmark, Bolivia, and Myanmar the countries whose crime rates will be compared in this paper were ranked at position 1, 105, and 179 respectively... . The...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Comparative criminal justice

...Sur Lecturer Comparative criminal justice The stages of becoming a barrister or "training for the bar" In order to become a barrister, the following stages are involved: academic stage, vocational stage or bar professional training, and pupilage stage Academic stage and its requirements for its successful completion The academic stage is the initial stage of training for a barrister. It is composed of a degree in Qualifying Law or an approved Graduate Diploma Course or a degree in a related subject supplemented by Common Professional Examination (CPE) The standard requirements for a successful completion of the course at an Academic stage are a 2:2 UK honors degree or its equivalent. This...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Comparative criminal justice

...Comparative Criminal Justice My impression of the prison websites that I visited is that they are very detailed and informative. After looking through each webpage, I fully understand the procedures, events, and what the overall life of the prisoners while incarcerated consists of. The three most interesting things that I learned by visiting these sites are the educational opportunities available to inmates, the options of healthy foods or foods catered to diets in lieu of typical prison meals, and the amount of concern that is provided should a prisoner have a complaint while they are in prison. I found these three aspects interesting because they aim at making a prison stay comfortable. While prisoners should not live in squalid...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Comparative criminal justice

...Comparative Criminal Justice In Germany law has been codified and is mostly federal. The German penal is influenced by the concepts of Prussian law. It Criminal justice system is derived from the civil war, not common law such as the one used in the U.S. and Britain. According to German civil law, the concepts behind its criminal justice system are not aimed at simply isolating criminals from the society, but rehabilitating them (Fairchild and Dammer 67). This is done through measures and programs such as work-release, and non-confinement punishments. The initial hearing of criminal...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Comparative criminal justice paper

.... a synchronization of criminal justice in the nations of the EU (Pakes, 2010). The institutions acknowledge that international efforts like reform practices rooted in a global human rights discourse have made easy this France assimilation trend, even if the court systems of France is rooted in distinct ideologies compared to other European nations. However, it should be noted that, as Deflem & Swygart (2001) discussed, America and Malaysia adapted some of the elements of its criminal justice system from France’s criminal justice system. Beyond the distinctions among criminal...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

International Criminal Justice, Comparative Sentencing and Penology

...1. Discuss the impact of plea bargaining on trial justice from a comparative perspective In order to be able to discuss the impact of plea bargainingon trial justice it is necessary to look briefly at what plea bargaining is all about and when it is likely to be used. From the perspective of the offender plea bargaining can result in shorter sentences and lesser charges for the crimes they have committed. On the criminal justice side plea bargaining can increase detection rates on crimes and make the court procedure shorter. Many offenders are prepared to admit to several other offences if they are guaranteed a lesser charge then would normally be...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic International and comparative criminal justice for FREE!

Contact Us