Free

Peer review form - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
What do think is the thesis for this paper and what does it tell you about the paper? Is it a strong, effective statement, why or why not? Does the paper follow the direction of the thesis, why or why not?
In this paper, the thesis statement is that Sir Arthur Conan…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Peer review form
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Peer review form"

Peer Review What do think is the thesis for this paper and what does it tell you about the paper? Is it a strong, effective statement, why or why not? Does the paper follow the direction of the thesis, why or why not?
In this paper, the thesis statement is that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s decision to portray animals as per their appearance serves the purpose of connecting the readers with the story in The Adventure of the Speckled Band. This thesis explains that the paper focuses on the impact of the using animals in the story. However, the thesis statement is not strong because it lacks clarity especially on the last sentence of the introduction part. Nonetheless, the paper does follow the direction of the thesis because the following paragraphs are related to the thesis.

2. Comment on the introduction. What strategies is the writer using to hook the reader and set up the paper? Are they effective? What suggestions do you have?
The first part of the introduction is well crafted because it starts by introducing the paper. The writer uses suspense to hook the reader up, and this is effective. For instance, in the introduction, the writer avoids availing all the information about the story which compels the reader to read the other parts. Thus, they are effective, and almost require no suggestion.
3. How does the writer use textual evidence and analysis to back up his or her claim? Comment on several examples and offer any suggestions that you have. Do you think that the writer “digs deeply” into the text (vertical thinking)? Why or why not? What are some of the implications that the writer draws from the examples?
In a bid to back up claims, the writer quotes from the story. For instance, to show the relationship between animals and danger, the writer states that the doctor kept two animals: a cheetah and a baboon. Another entails the snake which is portrayed as sharing similar traits with one Roylott because of the ruthlessness demonstrated. The suggestion is that author ought to have indicated the page numbers where direct quotations were used. The writer had dug deeply and this is confirmed by the implications such as humans resembling humans in terms of characteristics.
4. Comment on the organization of the paper. Is it logical and clear, why or why not? Is each paragraph unified around one main idea, indicated by a topic sentence? Note any issues that you see concerning paragraph unity, general organization or awkward transitions? Offer suggestion where appropriate.
Notwithstanding the use of examples, the paper’s organization is poor. Whereas the overall message is clear and logical paragraphs are poorly arranged. For instance, there is no indication of a topical sentence. Besides, there is also a lack of proper transition as evidenced on the second and the last paragraphs. Each sentence ought to revolve around one idea coupled with evidence for the topic. Also, there has to be a connection between the paragraphs.
5. Discuss the style of the paper – is there any unevenness in the writer’s prose. For example, does the paper become too conversational for an academic analysis paper? Provide examples.
Clearly, the paper lacks evenness in the prose as it sounds ore conversational than academic. This is confirmed by the choice of words as well as the tendency to lack analytical evidence on the paper.
6. Do you have any other suggestions for the writer?
It is vitally important for every paper to show the source of information. That is to say, citation is needed whenever using another person’s idea or work. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Peer review form Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1696155-peer-review-form
(Peer Review Form Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1696155-peer-review-form.
“Peer Review Form Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1696155-peer-review-form.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Peer review form

Peer Assessment

...?Peer Assessment Peer Assessment Peer assessment is an assessment done by on works of other In this kind of assessment, summative grading is conducted to offer results while formative review is conducted to offer feedback on what the students have learned. Peer assessment is quite important as it encourages critical thinking and innovation among students, thus, it aims to enhance the quality of learning and encourages learners (Brown & Knight, 1994). It includes student’s involvement in the prior setting of goals or criteria, final grading, and judgment, and the choice of evidence of academic success. Student assessment of work of other...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

PEER REVIEW

...PEER REVIEW Leadership and management can be differentiated when one of the two aspects is done without the involvement of the other. Leadership can be described as the setting of a new bearing or a vision for a grouping and must be followed (Kellerman, 2001). Contrary, management is the body that controls or directs individuals and/or property in a set according to doctrines or principles that are already established. In the interrelationship of these two aspects, leadership without management offers a vision without a direction on how success can be achieved (Peters, 2000). For this reason, management is an essential combination for any successful leadership. A leader has to ensure that they are able to...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Peer Review Form 2

...Appendix A: Peer Review Feedback Form 2 Reviewer’s _________________________________________ _____________ Assigned _______________________________________ Course:_________________________________________________ Section: ___________ Assignment 4: Persuasive Paper Part 2: Solution and Advantages Peer reviews should provide feedback to a peer on the criteria expected in the paper. Follow these instructions: 1) Receive a classmate’s paper from your professor (in class if on-ground; by e-mail if online). 2) Copy the Peer Review Feedback Form from the Appendix. 3)...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Peer Review

...PEER REVIEW DRAFT 1 Are there any additional details that could be included to help you better understand the essay? What is missing or unclear? Details needed for a first time reader to gain deeper understanding of how far the story has come was missing. This detail was very important especially against the backdrop that the writer basis on the previous component of the story to pass a very arguable judgment that the Indians are still not treated well in society today. 2 What part of the essay is most memorable? Why? The most memorable part of the essay is the portion where revelation is made that up to today, not much effort has been made to better the sovereignty of lesser groups by refusing to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Peer review

...use more plausible and better media to record and use in the study. The fizzy photographs were inadequate and failed to arouse any significant emotion from the scene. ANOVA test was appropriate but it failed to validate the hypothesis. The study is also not scientifically presented and lacks essential imperatives of research like literature review, efficacy of variables was not explained and data analysis was merged with results. In all, while the results of the study give important insight into the eyewitness account of the scene of crime, the authenticity of the same cannot be scientifically validated. I would, as such, not cite the study. Recommendations (for publication) Hypothesis should be well defined. Sampling...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Review of Silvia Federici: Caliban and the Witch

2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Peer Review

...Book Report Review Article Article I is a well laid out argument that centers around the ‘Disconnectedness’ between the consumer and the producer. It deftly argues that the 20th century has seen a major revolution of the food industry in more ways than one. The days of purchasing the locally grown farm fresh food, cooking at home and maintaining a healthy diet are all a thing of the past because giant corporations have forced themselves into the food markets and presently dominate the whole food industry. The sources are well knitted together, with each idea being explained in a new paragraph without being in anyways redundant. The information or data collected for this write up comprises of both scholarly as well as web...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Business peer review

...Business peer review Project 5 Peer Review Sheet Please answer the following questions when reviewing your peers’ work, and post your completed review to the Final Report Workshop discussion forum. Before posting, save your file using the format SmithrevJones.doc, substituting your own last name for Smith and the name of the peer you’re reviewing for Jones. Name of student whose work you’re reviewing: Michael Connolly Can the reader quickly see the general scope and arrangement of the material covered? Yes Can particular parts be found quickly and easily? Yes, the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Peer Review

.... Maintainability The employees of the CCC will maintain and clean the room making sure it’s safe for the baby and the mother before it opens. However, it will be the nursing mothers’ duty to clean and keep the room tidy after she is done utilizing it. Convenience Since CCC already takes care of children, it should already have some supplies such as diapers, wipes, snacks, and other materials useful to nursing mothers. Conclusion and Recommendations: Additional Comments: Paper needs proper APA style of formatting. There should be in-text citations along with the reference sources, so that literature review can be supported with the help of research. In my views, body section does not support the basic purpose of the...
2 Pages(500 words)Book Report/Review

Peer review

...Peer Review al Affiliation Peer Review The research touches on a weighty and timely theme that has continued to affect the society particularly in a metropolitan state such as United States. Discrimination in the provision of health services can be fatal to any individuals as it may have a long-lasting impact. Arguably, the topic of the research can be rated as excellent. However, the mode of presentation has clouded out the main item of research and key findings. As a piece of research, it should have clear headlines and subtopic and fluency to enable the learner identify the topic quickly. In this case, the research paper lacks coherence as points are jumbled all over the work without a clear consistency of the flow of thoughts... . The...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Peer review form for FREE!

Contact Us