Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Persuasive argument should vaccination be mandatory or voluntary - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The higher the number of vaccinated individuals from infection is the lower the probability of disease among unimmunized and debilitated people is. Generally, making vaccination, we…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Persuasive argument should vaccination be mandatory or voluntary
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Persuasive argument should vaccination be mandatory or voluntary"

Running head: VACCINATION Vaccination: mandatory or voluntary VACCINATION Vaccination: mandatory or voluntary Scientific researches suggest that vaccination in general brings rather good results than harm. The higher the number of vaccinated individuals from infection is the lower the probability of disease among unimmunized and debilitated people is. Generally, making vaccination, we not only care about our health and the health of our children, but also contribute to the common struggle of humanity against infections. However, it is believed that mass immunization is more often considered as “evil” than the benefit of mankind and I am really ready to join to this group of people. It should be noted that according to the laws of many countries, vaccination is entirely voluntary preventive measure, so the rejection of vaccination is the completely personal choice. It is how it looks “on paper”. Do not forget that the vaccine is a foreign protein, so its introduction into the human body, especially for a small child, causes the “over-voltage” of the immune system (Buchwald 117). As a result, vaccination without the analysis of the initial state of immunity may play a decisive role in the appearing of immunological and immune diseases in the future. Simply said, if the organism is weakened for some reasons, and we add more “problems” - that would not lead to good results. In addition, I would like to remind that the man who had endured an infectious disease receives “lifetime” insurance from her in the future, while most vaccines provide only temporary immunity.
Ideally, the vaccination requires to conduct immunodiagnostic before it, but public institutions, received the order “from above” – make mass vaccination of children - do not only carry out a preliminary survey, but can use vaccine without the parental permission. Such a formal approach to immunization reduces all the gains of preventive medicine in this area.
According to human rights defenders, mandatory compulsory vaccination process is contrary to the freedom of choice. The fact that doctors are forced to do something with the child is already causing the internal protest. Opponents of the voluntary vaccination oppose this for favour of mandatory vaccinations: unvaccinated person presents a danger to the health of others, thereby already infringing their rights. It turns out that the problem of compulsory vaccinations is a particular case of a large ethical problem: how much we can restrict the freedom of the individual for the purpose to make a person not to threat to society. The essence of problem is that children (of the younger and the older school age) are not yet able to take full responsibility for the decision and, suppressed the authority of teachers or adults, simply can not defend their right to refuse from vaccinations. At the same time, even if the adult conscious person writes a disclaimer of vaccination (for himself or his child); he is often hindered by many barriers established by the state, which limits an unvaccinated person in certain activities, and sometimes displacements. Everything seems to be so logical and correct. There is only one problem: for medical staff one death of a child is even not awesome tragedy – it also has to be proved that vaccination was the cause of this trouble. And what about the parents of a child who would refuse vaccination, but did not overpower state’s reason - “you must”?
I can not consider vaccination as a contribution to the overall health of mankind. Who will give a guarantee that you or your child will not be “lucky” after banal vaccination, who would be responsible for the quality of the drug and, finally, how can you replace somehow a loved one? I personally know a couple who practically lost a child in such situation. In addition, hardly anyone of us fully realizes
the possibilities of our organism and can hardly anticipate the same allergic reaction to a new drug. I support the idea that the vaccination needs to be only voluntary.
Gerhard Buchwald (2003). Vaccination: A Business Based on Fear. BoD – Books on Demand. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Persuasive argument should vaccination be mandatory or voluntary Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Persuasive Argument Should Vaccination Be Mandatory or Voluntary Assignment)
“Persuasive Argument Should Vaccination Be Mandatory or Voluntary Assignment”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Persuasive argument should vaccination be mandatory or voluntary

Persuasive argument

... Persuasive Argument In the writings of Rawls, he holds that in the free society people within that particular society have different views with regard to religion, different conception of what is wrong or right as well as other forms in which people relate personally. In view of this, and in the democratic society, people mentioned above would have contradicting commitments while there exists only one law to guide the diverse nature of the society. Rawls therefore tends to believe that enforcing a universal law within this diverse nature of the society is unworkable and hence raises two main fundamental issues: legitimacy and stability. In his view therefore democracy is based on justice in a liberal society since it promotes and provides...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Should HPV Vaccination Be Mandatory

... practicing mandatory vaccination against several other diseases. Here, it must be noted that the HPV is not airborne and sexual contact is the major cause of cervical cancer. The government has a potential motive to protect its people from a deadly airborne virus because such a virus may spread diseases by casual contact. As Beam strongly claims, the government does not have the moral authority to enforce mandatory vaccination against a disease that can be prevented by promoting the Bible’s plan for sex. Likewise, supporters of this proposal refer to the situation where women abstain from premarital sex and marry a person who has been carrying the virus. Beam cuts this argument by stating that “peace of mind should be obtained by personal...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Vaccination Controversy

Vaccination Controversy

In most health settings, vaccination constitutes one of the most controversial medical procedures. Keeping in view the fact that most vaccines are ineffective in providing absolute immunity and pose the danger of promoting the development of disorders like Autism, parents should be granted the right to delay or omit one or more of the mandated vaccines. Risks The history of medical profession is littered with numerous examples of vaccines which have been recalled either because they were extremely toxic or simply ineffective. The Rotavirus and lyme disease are examples of vaccines that have been recently recalled and discontinued. Attenuated vaccines are produced from living weak pathogenic microo...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Mandatory Vs. Voluntary Vaccincations

... pertaining to the benefits of mandatory and voluntary vaccinations. It is therefore important for those concerned to understand the pros and cons of both sides of the issue. There are always a number of factors to consider in both cases and these factors must be presented in the most authoritative and methodical manner for their decision making benefit. Perisic and Bauch (2009) have advocated the point of view of certain theorists when it comes to voluntary vaccination. It is their belief that “it should be difficult or impossible to eradicate a vaccine-preventable disease under voluntary vaccination: Herd immunity implies that the individual incentive to vaccinate disappears at high coverage levels. “ Therefore they believe that mandatory...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Smallpox Vaccination

...Should smallpox vaccination be used Introduction Smallpox is a highly contagious disease unique to humans which is caused by either of two virus variants named Variola major and Variola minor. V. major. Among the two the second one is the deadlier form and has a mortality rate of 3-35%, while V. minor causes a milder form of disease called alastrim and kills only about 1% of its victims (Ryan and Ray 525-7; Behbehani 455-509). With the help of vaccines, this disease is completely eridicated and there is no outbreaks that occurred after the last occurrence in 1977 in Somania. However, after the 9/11 attacks it is feared that smallpox viruses could be used as biological weapons if it reaches the hands of anti-social elements. Since...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


Even people who proclaim abstinence have at least had one drink in their lifetime and would do so again should the occasion call for it. Addiction to alcohol or alcoholism is also an acknowledged psychological ailment termed as disabling addictive disorder. Addiction in itself is not the issue, in my opinion. However, the behavior resulting from consuming prodigious quantities of alcohol, usually above an individual’s tolerance threshold is what causes problems. People should try to drink sensibly and stay within their tolerance limit, avoiding over-consumption.
Alcohol consumption is one of the main causes of cancer. According to a global research, more than 3.6 % of cancer cases have been caused due to the consumption of Alc...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Vaccination debate

... in the past. As a result, Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has come up with a video that is meant to dispel the notion that is becoming common especially among mothers. The controversy has no basis in science. It has been established through various research done in the past that there is no linkage between childhood vaccination and development of autism. In fact, as Jeanne Santoli from CDC notes, a number of studies have been done since 2002, and none proved that there is a link between vaccines and autism (CDC 2009). I think parents should not have the option to choose whether to vaccinate the children. This is because giving option to the mother will ultimately affect other children and society. For example, failure...
1 Pages(250 words)Admission/Application Essay

Persuasive argument

... College: Fad Diets: The Atkins Diet may not be the perfect Solution America is a nation primarily founded upon innovation and is, for this reason, filled with women and men who strive to make daily tasks easier and faster. As a result, many tasks are constantly being reinvented especially in the realm of fitness, health, and, most notably, weight-loss. America, considered by numerous people to be the homeland of fad diet, has seen hundreds of fast weight loss programs in the past: the grapefruit diet, the tuna diet, the low sugar diet, the salmon diet and the low-fat diet, just to name a few. While each of these weight loss programs enjoyed a short popularity period, none has rivaled the cult status of the Atkins diet. Dr. Atkins...
4 Pages(1000 words)Admission/Application Essay


...Ethical Dilemma in Vaccination and Autism s In human history, in order to prevent the severity of disease infection vaccines were developed. Lombard, Pastoret, and Moulin (2007) argue that vaccination entails the giving of an antigenic material with an aim of stimulating a person’s immune system so that the body develops adaptive immunity to pathogen. The Centers for Disease Control suggest that children 0 to 6 months of age should receive 28 doses of vaccines. However, there are no federal regulations in the United States that mandate vaccination. Contrarily, most of the states have a requirement of particular vaccination for kids who are entering public learning institutions. On the contrary, in West Virginia and Mississippi...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Voluntary and Non-Voluntary Euthanasia

... or her though not directly. Conversely, passive euthanasia involves the physician’s move to withhold medication, which eventually results to patient’s death. The debate on euthanasia being moral or not has been in existence for a long period. A number of people claim that active euthanasia in immoral compared to passive, whereas others hold onto the opposite. Based on Rachels’s argument, active euthanasia is better. This is because, whereas passive is painful and takes long, active euthanasia is usually quick and painless; hence the only thing required is the injection of a lethal medication or drug. Euthanasia can be voluntary or involuntary. Voluntary euthanasia is when the patient is in agreement with the doctor to end his or her life...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Persuasive argument should vaccination be mandatory or voluntary for FREE!

Contact Us