Does Quarantine violate constitutional rights - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Although a quarantine is not directly mentioned in the U.S. Constitution, challenges in order to have a quarantine broken have been denied by the Supreme Court. It has been…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
Does Quarantine violate constitutional rights
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Does Quarantine violate constitutional rights"

Quarantine due to health concerns do not violate the 14th Amendment of the United s Constitution. Although a quarantine is not directly mentioned in the U.S. Constitution, challenges in order to have a quarantine broken have been denied by the Supreme Court. It has been ruled that quarantines are constitutional. The Supreme Court and laws have deemed the greater good of the American Public need to be decided by health experts in the United States v. Shinnick.
Recently an Ebola outbreak in a few African countries has become deadly for thousands. Americans have gone to the region as healthcare workers. Kaci Hickox, a nurse, returned to the United States to be quarantined. She believes that under the 14th Amendment quarantine is unconstitutional. Hickox was released before filing her lawsuit. Hickox was upset by how she was treated by officials at the airport before being quarantined at her home.
Hickox’s lawsuit stating quarantine violates her 14th Amendment due process rights would have been dismissed for two reasons. The first is the precedent ruling of United States v. Shinnick. Expert healthcare workers would have testified that Ebola has a three week incubation period. During those three weeks, if the nurse had Ebola she could pass it before recognizing the symptoms. Thus the case would have been decided by Ebola experts’ testimony. Hickox, as a health worker, would have testified, but she is only one person with a tainted reason to lie.
The second reason Hickox’s petition would have been dismissed is the 14th Amendment deals with due process. Due process pertains to criminals. Since Hickox was not charged with a crime, due process was not being violated. Due process limits the time a citizen can be detained by police until charges are brought. No charges would have been brought toward Hickox. This means the case had nothing to do with due process. These two reasons show that quarantine is constitutional under the 14th Amendment. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Does Quarantine violate constitutional rights Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Does Quarantine Violate Constitutional Rights Essay)
“Does Quarantine Violate Constitutional Rights Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Does Quarantine violate constitutional rights

Constitutional Rights

...arrested for two years without trial or probation if caught with an unlicensed gun (Subcommittee on the Constitution, 1982). The history of this right dates back to 872 A.D., when Alfred the Great established that to bear arms was not only a right, but an obligation of every able individual (Subcommittee on the Constitution, 1982). An important point to be noted here is that the term Militia as used in the amendment had very different connotations then as it does today; instead of referring to just a select group of soldiers like the army or the National Guard ...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Does Blowing the Whistle Violate Company Loyalty

...? Does Blowing the Whistle Violate Company Loyalty? Whistle blower signifies a person who exposes anyone who is involved into wrong doing or any corruption within the organization. But historical data reveals that whistle blowers have been penalized by having stress, bad health, financially ruined, loss of career, family and friend. The present study deals in whether whistle blowing signifies loyalty of the employee towards his organization or not. Author Sissela Bok has connected blowing of whistle with professional responsibility and author Robert A. Larmer has connected whistle blowing with employee loyalty. Ideas of the two authors Philosopher Sissela Bok does not supports the act of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Does google violate the antitrust law

... Does Google Violate The Anti-Trust Law? The antitrust law is setup in the US to preserve the rights of businesses of having a chance to compete equally in market. The antitrust law is violated if an activity exists that brings one company ahead of its competitors in a way that monopolies pitch in. Google was charged with antitrust and anti-competition statutes as they were thought to arrange their search results in a way that brings their own products and links above others. Since more than 70% of search on internet is carried out on Google and many businesses depend on online advertising, several giant companies feared they will not show up in search results because Google tends to advertise its own products and hence is giving... an...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Data mining does not violate the constitution

...Data Mining does not violate the Constitution Introduction Data mining is a powerful technology, which has the potential to help organizations put much focus on the fundamental and very important information in the data already collected. In particular, the information in the data is essentially about behavior of customers as well as prospective customers. Data mining particularly discovers crucial information available within the data that the reports as well as queries may not reveal effectively (Boghosian 24). They fall under different industry categories such as health care, finance, retail, aerospace, and manufacturing have began using data mining techniques as well as tools in a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay


...Amendment of the US Constitution which provides for equal protection and treatment of similarly situated persons.12 However in the context of the work environment, Kudler’s policy is reasonable and the American Civil Liberties Union submits that: “Employers have the right to expect workers not to be high or drunk on the job. But they shouldnt have the right to require employees to prove their innocence by taking a drug test.”13 ACLU of Virginia,  Executive Director, Kent Willis maintains that random drug testing in the workplace is unlawful and involves an intrusive procedure which is clearly an invasion of privacy. He notes that: “Our courts have consistently held that random drug...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Constitutional Rights and Discrimination

...CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND DISCRIMINATION A CASE STUDY ON LABOR AND ISSUES OF DISCRIMINATION AT WORK CAUSING PHYSICAL DAMAGE Case Background Abdul isan Arab-American who, like the other minorities in the society, is finding it hard to look for a job in New York. When he finally lands a decent job within the State Department of Transportation as a flagger among the road crews, he was faced with the challenge of dealing with massive discrimination not only from his co-workers but also directly from his boss. It was unnerving to see how he was treated by his boss Clyde who was an American patriotic. Abdul , being a devoted Muslim, completes his responsibility to pray at least five times a day. He...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Constitutional Rights the riddle is to demur to the charge, and it would sound something like this: “How do you plead to the charge”? “Non-Assumpsit by way of Confession and Avoidance, your Honor.” That plea will provoke snorts of protest from the bench, most judges today never having heard of such a plea. This is to the advantage of the defendant, because every mistake the judge makes becomes appealable error. Appeals can be made based on a properly protested violation of rights. The issues involved are complex, but the “not guilty” plea is the first step in waiving the rights guaranteed by the constitution. Perhaps you are a member of a special class of persons to whom the laws...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Quarantine and Societal Fears

...and there need be no fear of isolation or death from this disease, although there does appear to be one infected individual left. This leads to queries about the level of negativity associated with the disease and questions about how bad the impact of it could be on society. The final section of the stasis argument is known as the proposal argument. This includes looking at what actions should be taken regarding the thing in question. In this case, it is necessary to form an argument about the different steps that could be taken by the protagonists in the film Quarantine to best change the situation. The most obvious thing to the audience would be that it would be sensible to hide from the infected so...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Violation of Constitutional Rights

...Violation of Constitutional Rights and citation The case is about the violation of constitutional rights Debbie Ricci was denied to express her political views in her place of work despite them having some rules which restrict the workers from engaging themselves in politics. Kerry Cowart fired her immediately, and the board denied her grievance, the political endorsement turned into a first Amendment case. Facts and case Debbie claims that her constitutional rights have been violated after expression her political views in her work place. She states that her first, fourth and...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Americans Constitutional Rights for Privacy it held that when government officials infringe an individual’s rational anticipation of privacy, there occurs a violation (Carmen 2012). It is to be noted that some states in USA have explicitly forbid through law for carrying over wiretapping or eavesdropping even if permission is given by one of the parties. In (Lee v. United States 1952), it was held that the proof gathered is legally valid as one party has given his permission for the same. The above view was reflected in (United States v White 1971), as it was held by the court that the US constitution does not bar a government agent from employing an electronic tool to record a telephonic talk if one party has given his...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Does Quarantine violate constitutional rights for FREE!

Contact Us