Free

Summary/Strong Response - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Kline declares that his love for children, and his awareness of the contribution made by advances in medical science to child health, made him take up research. Kline…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Summary/Strong Response
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Summary/Strong Response"

Ron Kline: “A Scientist: I Am The Enemy.” Summary. In his essay, “A Scientist: I am the Enemy,” Ron Kline defends the use of animal research in medicine. Kline declares that his love for children, and his awareness of the contribution made by advances in medical science to child health, made him take up research. Kline regrets the apathy of the general public to this issue and the tendency of politicians to pander to the demands of activists in order to gain publicity. Kline also criticizes the scientists’ tendency to remain silent in the face of the accusations made by animal-rights activists, in the “belief that a knowledgeable public would sense the importance of animal research to the public health” (Kline, 3).
Kline cites the arguments of those who oppose animal research: researchers “inflict torture on animals for the sole purpose of career advancement” (Kline, 2); animal experiments have no relevance to medicine; animal research can be easily replaced by computer simulation. Kline asserts that physicians who attempt to alleviate human pain and suffering have only three alternatives: create an animal model to test new remedies for injuries and diseases, experiment on humans or just stop all innovative research. Animal-rights activists claim that computer models can simulate animal experiments. Kline discounts these claims, saying that computer models cannot simulate complex biological systems. Kline warns that restricting animal research would close the door to new medical discoveries. He points out that most of the advances in medical science, including vaccines, antibiotics, organ transplantation and gene therapy, have their roots in animal testing. Kline condemns animal-rights activists as a “vocal but misdirected minority” (9), which gives precedence to animals over humans. He approves of the attempts to find alternatives to animal research and appreciates the need to avoid unnecessary cruelty towards animals. However, he categorically warns that restricting animal research will have dire consequences for human health and life.
Response.
Ron Kline’s passionate defense of animal research gains credibility because of his obvious dedication to children’s’ health and Kline’s own position as a medical researcher. He makes a convincing case in support of his position that restricting animal research will be “a tragedy that will cost many lives” (Kline, 9). This is in line with the general consensus in the medical world. Animal research is essential, as its utility in the discovery of new techniques and remedies in the fight against injury and disease is indisputable. It is clear that alternatives, such as in vitro experiments, microdosing, computer simulations and fMRI, can only be used as complementary methods to animal research. Animal testing is the only means of “providing direct information from the actual neural elements that underlie all our cognitive capacities” (Max Planck Institute). Kline is right in his contention that animal testing is the only way to replicate the complex human biological system.
However, Kline seems to ignore the point that animal research can be drastically reduced and refined. Over time, this strategy would successfully result in viable replacements to animal testing. One example of the successful replacement of animal testing with an in vitro method is in the case of pregnancy tests. Earlier, pregnancy testing involved killing a rabbit. These days, a woman can buy an over-the-counter kit that tests her urine for a certain hormone (Howard). This proves that persistent scientific search for alternatives will yield dividends and reduce the need for animal research.
Kline is justified in his criticism of politicians who give in to vocal animal-rights activists in order to gain political mileage. If the public is to adopt an informed position on the issue of animal research, the medical community needs to become proactive in the dissemination of accurate information to counter the emotional propaganda of the activists. Kline is right in his stand that, regardless of the pain inflicted on animals, the alleviation of human suffering and pain is more important.
Works Cited.
“Alternative Methods.” Max Planck Institute for Biological Cybernetics. 2014. Web. 15 April,
2014.
http://hirnforschung.kyb.mpg.de/en/methods/alternative-methods.html
Howard, Carol. “Yes, Dad, There are Alternatives.” John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public
Health. 2014. Web. 15 April, 2014.
http://caat.jhsph.edu/publications/Articles/aavs.html
Kline, Ron. “A Scientist: I am the Enemy.” Title of Collection. Ed. Editors Name(s). City of
Publication: Publisher, Year. Page range of essay. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Summary/Strong Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1639311-summarystrong-response
(Summary/Strong Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1639311-summarystrong-response.
“Summary/Strong Response Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1639311-summarystrong-response.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Summary/Strong Response

Tesco

10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Summary & Strong Response

...? Children need to play not to compete Jessica Statsky in her essay ‘Children need to play not to compete’ argues against the involvement of childrenin the organized competitive sports. Statsky strongly opposes the high spirited competitions set for the children mentioning three reasons. The first point she presents is that the organized competitive sports may cause both physical and mental impairment to the children. She says that competitive sports influence in a way to do more severe physical activities which will harmfully affect the children of the age between 6 and 12. Whenever the children practice, they have a fear in their mind whether they get injured or not. She stresses this point by taking the example of a boy who... Children...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

History of the Middle East

12 Pages(3000 words)Research Paper

Analysis of the Show 24

2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Summary Strong Response to Damation of a canyon article

...-forgotten water-skiers. But to those who find the prospect too appalling, I say give nature a little time. In five years, at most in ten, the sun and wind and storms will cleanse and sterilize the repellent mess” (148). The article thus ends on a note of hope that his children or grandchildren would again be able to enjoy the canyon in much the same way he had so many years ago. Edward Abbey makes a strong case for the removal of dams in the country by using this one case as a vivid example. He claims credibility through his knowledge of the area both before and after the dam was built and thus can act as eye-witness to direct changes in the environment. He then points to verifiable changes that have taken place...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Summary/ strong response

...W131 Writing Project #2 Draft Aye Nu Duerksen October 16, 2009 Facebook Revisited: A Summary/Strong Response Essay IntroductionThe development of the World Wide Web changed the course of communication and computer technology spanning a diversity of people and cultures. The benefits given are so enormous and innovative that the generation today could not imagine a world without it. There are numerous sites which support social or electronic gathering depending on the purpose of the user. One of the most phenomenally successful social sites is Facebook. Facebook, MySpace and Bebo are known as the three most famous social networking websites from more than 140 notable, well known sites....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Summary and strong respnes

...are unable to cut a niche for they should be allowed to suffer (Hardin). It is my opinion that Hardin is incorrect in his pessimistic assumption that we cannot reverse the negative effects that our actions have brought upon the environment. We have it within our power to ensure that our environment is kept safe and all the resources within it are open for use for everyone in the world. All that all human beings have to do is to take social responsibility, to develop a consciousness or awareness towards the environment so that the environment can be maintained at a perfect state while it benefits the entire human population. We have the power to end all poverty in the world if only we care about one another, if the rich...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Summary and Strong Response

...Summary and Response Paper SUMMARY AND RESPONSE PAPER Eugene Robinson in “You Have the Right to Remain a Target of Racial Profiling” begins with a report from the Federal Bureau of Justice, in which statistics show that Hispanic, black, and white drivers are equally as likely to be stopped for traffic offences (Robinson, 2007). Accordingly, it is easy to think that equal protection afforded by the constitution has been achieved on American roads. However, the writer disputes this using the report, which shows that Hispanics and blacks are twice as likely to be searched when compared to white drivers. The author disputes the report’s contention that these statistics do not...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Sports Managers' Tasks

4 Pages(1000 words)Coursework

Summary and strong respond

... Instruction: Task: Death penalty Death penalty is practiced in several s. Generally, the death penalty is reserved for certain severe crimes, or capital crimes. Death penalty is sometimes referred to as capital punishment. At some point, execution was used as a method of punishment. Though most of the crimes leading to execution involved murder, some nations have used the death penalty to punish crimes such as rape treason, trafficking of humans or drugs, and even for renouncing one’s religion. This essay will examine the death penalty in details and its disadvantages. There has been a worldwide trend towards abolishing the death penalty. Several states have been on the move to completely do away with the use of the death... Instruction:...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Summary/Strong Response for FREE!

Contact Us