StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Evaluation of Janet Holmess - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article by Holmes is rhetorical, expansive and carefully researched with all issues being supported by evidence. Gender discrimination in language and communication has poorly in the article. The presentation of ideas is persuasive, but the evidence presented is not conclusive. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.9% of users find it useful
Evaluation of Janet Holmess
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Evaluation of Janet Holmess"

Evaluation of Janet Holmes’s Essay The difference in communication between sexes has been a major talking point in society. Women have been labeled as “talking too much” while men have been seen or viewed as potential or good listeners. However, the article by Janet Holmes discusses the issue in detail while offering an understanding of the various issues associated with ‘talking too much’. Across the world, women have been believed to talk too much even in situations that do not require communication.

In view of the developed ideology, Holmes evaluates and conducts analysis on the issues and gives a clearer view of the problem than initially presented (Holmes). She addresses the diverse situations and the contribution of women in the whole process making clear the nature and countering the argument presented in the society. From the essay, there is a fallacy of thought on communication that must be revisited and addressed. In order to address the problem, the essay offers several examples and quotes research conducted by the authors to disapprove the view.

Therefore, “talking too much” is a constituent of many factors such as communication, dominance, knowledge and the type of meeting. The argument of Holmes is using rhetoric. She uses statement such as; “women’s tongues are like lamb’s tails-they are never still.” However, the key idea is in ironic form, which is an evaluation of the statement. The image of the lamb is easy to envision and creates emotional feelings. The irony of the statement is by the admission that women do not speak too much in all situations.

The proverbs around the world compare women talk illustrating the belief of ‘too much talk.’ The Scottish proverb indicates that nothing is so unnatural like a talkative man or a quite woman. These proverbs create rhetoric to the essay because the finding of the essay is different. Depending on the situation women will talk much or less. Women tend to speak more in informal meeting and less in a formal meeting. The addition of the proverbs across the world illustrates the irony associated with “too much talk.

” Some proverbs illustrate that women talk is not, but Holmes presents a new meaning to the proverbs. Women talk much or less depending on the situation and the position of the woman. In fact, under informal talks women were found to contribute more compared to formal talks such as in formal meetings. Social confidence is a factor that affects the willingness to contribute to a discussion. Therefore, the use of rhetoric in the essay puts emphasis on the points presented by Holmes by presenting the overall view of humanity in relation to the matter.

The role of communication is to offer understanding of an idea or an opinion to the listeners. However, Holmes argues that communication between sexes is about dominance and control. The sex wielding the power will try to develop the control or limit, which is acceptable and the limits that are as ‘too much’. The essay’s level of persuasiveness is evident by the presentation of the idea. First, the locus of control or power is to the males. For instance, women and men behave differently in a formal meeting and seminar which gives an indication of the failure of the argument.

Therefore, by referring to the evidence collected by British, American, and New Zealand researchers, Holmes counters the argument of too much talk. She illustrates the relationship between domination and period of time offered to speak. Women are little time compared to the allocation given to men. The credibility of the Holmes argument of male dominance is questionable because of the diverse factors. The argument may not be substantive because it is with gender bias and creation of women discrimination view, which is minimal in the contemporary society.

Stereotyping and generalization as witnessed in the article illustrate failure to analyze and conceptualize the events or occurrence. Therefore, creation of an article based on illustrative evidence to justify occurrence, or personal opinion illustrates the bias in reasoning. Women must participate actively in the society to claim the positions they want. They must fight male domination in the board meeting; as such it should not be used as a measure of ‘talking too much’. In conclusion, the article by Holmes is rhetorical, expansive and carefully researched with all issues being supported by evidence.

Gender discrimination in language and communication has poorly in the article. The presentation of ideas is persuasive, but the evidence presented is not conclusive. The failure to address the gender bias presented shows the existence of personal opinion. Stereotyping is a major factor discussed by Holmes by presenting male dominance as a factor influencing women's involvement in the communication. The stereotyping and gender discrimination presented is not the major cause of ‘talking too much’.

Therefore, the argument presented by Holmes is not correct because of the evidence provided are not conclusive. Works Cited Holmes, Janet. "Women Talk Too Much." August 2013. Language Myth # 6. Online. 24 September 2013. . Leiter, Sharon. Critical Companion to Emily Dickinson: A Literary Reference to Her Life and Work. New York: Infobase Publishing, 2007. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evaluation of Janet Holmess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1496835-evaluation-of-janet-holmess
(Evaluation of Janet Holmess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1496835-evaluation-of-janet-holmess.
“Evaluation of Janet Holmess Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1496835-evaluation-of-janet-holmess.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evaluation of Janet Holmess

Problem Solution: InterClean, Inc

Tom wants to pursue global expansion, Sally is interested in further mergers, janet wants to retain the status quo in terms of HR policy and Garcia and the others want to take over an important role in Sales and Marketing.... janet does not want to let the old employees go, while the executive team wants to include employees of Enviro tech....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Blue Rhinos Business Strategy and Information Systems

This paper “Blue Rhino's Business Strategy and Information Systems” presents strategies & methodologies for planning, implementing Business Information Systems and their impact on the overall Organizational Change in the case study of Blue Rhino.... hellip; The author states that in fast-growing complex businesses, the uncertainties in employee productivity levels, customer satisfaction levels, operating costs, duplication of work, operations performance, actual revenues, ability to grow, forecasting & hypothecations, etc....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Evaluating a Specific Labor Market Concern in Australia

The second part of the report pertains to (1) succession planning and workforce plan evaluation, and (2) developing a succession plan which addresses internal labor needs in the medium to long term requirements, utilizing succession planning principles with an incorporated retention plan....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Why People Name Themselves

The author of this essay under the title "Why People Name Themselves" examines the significance of first names from various perspectives.... It is stated that proper names, particularly the act of naming, is a well-established research topic in disciplines as diverse as anthropology, history, law, etc....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

BSBOHS503B Assist in the design and devlopment of OHS participative arrangements

Team building and workplace cohesiveness reduces workplace bullying incidences which are impact negatively on workplace health and safety (Chan-Mok, janet, Carlo and Chris 3; Keashly and Branda 423).... An evaluation procedure will be available in order to determine if the goals are being met in a timely manner....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Tag Question in Womens Speech

This essay “Tag Question in Women's Speech” was intended to determine whether men and women have differences in their language use.... The study will also mention Lakoff's ideas concerning linguistic differences between male and female groups of our population.... hellip; This research shows that gender patterns for variable pronominal usage are strikingly stable over time....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Exploring A Communication Event In Saudi Lingua Culture

This paper "Exploring A Communication Event In Saudi Lingua Culture" discusses communication as a key thing in any society.... In teaching, culture, cultural replica and speech acts are necessary.... The student's level of cultural knowledge and acceptability of one's culture are essential in teaching....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Corporate Social Responsibility

This paper “Corporate Social Responsibility” seeks to objectively reflect on theories, models, and concepts relating to human behavior.... It will shed light on how such theories suggest how people relate to an organization as managers and employees.... hellip; The paper will explore and identify the role that a Human Resource Manager has in the execution of duties as dictated by policy and practice....
14 Pages (3500 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us