Nobody downloaded yet

Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Name Institution Course Instructor Date Does Adult Crime Translate to Adult Trial and Punishment? There has been a salient controversy surrounding juvenile justice. Young people below the legal adult age of 18 years have faced the consequences of crime when found guilty by the courts…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults"

Download file to see previous pages The cause of the dilemma was whether adolescents were to be tried in the existing adult courts and face punitive measures as applied to adult criminals. The issue of whether they would face trial in adult courts led to a critical question of whether they were 100% responsible for the crime they committed. Even when the assumption was that the adolescents were culpable of the crimes committed, an ardent concern would arise on whether they the competence required to handle the trial process. This paper will highlight that trying juvenile delinquents in adult courts is inappropriate. The onset of the 20th century saw the emergence of the initial literature on the means of resolving juvenile crimes. The institution of juvenile courts would soon follow, a factor shaped by the assumption that adolescents were more likely to adopt new attitudes because of their assumed malleability in comparison to adults. Such assumed malleability evident in adolescents motivated the adoption of rehabilitation as the most effective strategy in juvenile courts. However, the approach of rehabilitation changed, getting more inclined to the punitive approach that was evident in the adult courts (Ash 146). In the 1960s, the rehabilitative approach was classified as unsuccessful in addressing juvenile crime, and with most of the courts proving highly punitive to juvenile offenders. In the 1970s, increased prophecies of a potential surge of juvenile crimes emerged. This perception served to alter the approach towards juvenile justice. In the following years, many juvenile delinquents received transfer to adult crimes to undergo trial. Many people believed that the prophecies would come true, and that an increase in hardened juvenile criminals would require stringent punitive measures. The perception that determined justice ideologies at that time were shaped by the thinking that adolescents who committed crimes needed to face similar consequences with adults committing similar offenses. However, contrary to the predictions, juvenile was only higher in the late 1980s and early 1990s, but subsided immensely in the years that followed. Although the predictions were falsified by the passage of time reduction of crime, they initiated the issue of adolescent culpability to crime, in the punitive system. This issue had been neglected because juvenile courts had adopted a rehabilitative approach. In the punitive system, it was critical for prosecutors to prove that the adolescent had made an informed choice to commit crime (Ash 145). Many people believed that youths above 15 years are able to make informed choice cognitively. However, in cases where evidence indicating the incapacity of an adolescent to carry out mature judgment, then that translated to a minimized culpability. According to Ash, it is critical for courts to realize that adolescence is a period where an individual is subject to increased peer influence, a factor that makes many of them perpetrate group crime. Evidently, this period of growth is defined by many mistakes in many individuals, before the young adolescents can discern individual goals and pursue them. Most of the adolescents only exhibit a crime record during this period of rigorous growth and confusion, but transform into responsible citizens after adolescence. Therefore, trying adolescents in adult courts and labeling them as hardened criminals was unfair, as this was an aspect limited to the adolescence stage, and they ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent Crimes Be Tried and Jailed As Essay)
“Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent Crimes Be Tried and Jailed As Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults

Juvenliles Committing Violent Crimes

...? Juveniles Committing Violent Crimes Juveniles Committing Violent Crimes Any crime committed by a person under the age of 18 is considered to be a juvenile crime. This is so according to law enforcement agencies. According to some research carried out in different countries, most reported cases of juvenile crimes are against other juvenile delinquents. This means that the most violent crimes are against people in their own age bracket while the rest are carried out against adults. It is assumed that in a month the most number of cases recorded of teens committing...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Violent Crimes

...?Running Head: VIOLENT CRIMES ID Lecturer Crime-switching and specialization patterns are common in sexual offenders. Public perception and scientific studies have documented how this population has attracted the attention and of various scholars and experts in law enforcement. What are some of the ramifications that can impact the psychic of the community and public perception on the acts in which these criminals conduct their predatory actions? The perceptions of the public can be largely shaped up by how sexual offenders make use of crime-switching and specialization tactics. This is because they believe they should not be caught and brought to...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Juveniles being adjudicated (tried) as adults

...crimes that would warrant the death penalty for adult offenders, juvenile offenders must be differentiated from adult offenders of heinous crimes and they must be placed beyond the reach of the death penalty. The court reiterated that juveniles by virtue of their age and immaturity have less culpability than adult offenders of the same crime and their punishment should be mitigated by this diminished culpability. This notion of diminished culpability and immaturity which gave rise to the court's decision in the above case echoes the very rationale behind the juvenile justice system in the country. In most cases of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Why Juveniles should be tried as adults and Why shouldn't Juveniles be tried as adults

...Why Juveniles should be tried as adults and why shouldnt Juveniles be tried as adults? The juvenile court was introduced a hundred years ago and was made for the sole purpose being to not convict juvenile offenders in the same way as adult offenders. The punishment they get is less compared to that of adults, although they may commit the same crime. Today we have a debate on this topic, that is should juveniles be treated as adults or shouldn’t they be treated as adults. Those who say that they should be treated as...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Mentall illness and violent crimes

...Mental illness and violent crimes The findings from the research conducted in the indicate that cases of mental illness have been on the increase between the years 2003 and 2007. This is evident from the statistics shown where the number of students with mental illness increased from around 19,000 to around 24,000 by 2007. The statistics also indicate that more females than male have the psychological distress. The provided research findings also indicate an increase in the total number of people seeking mental health counseling and treatment and also how such needs are increasingly being unmet. The research findings indicated above and which are also the ones from the research by the university do not present research findings... of the...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper

Should minors who commit violent crimes be tried as adults

...A Cowardly Act A Cowardly Act Should minors who commit violent crimes be tried as adults? Minors today are more urbane at a younger age. A severe sentencing should be considered for juveniles that commit violent crimes. No one has the right to take another life, regardless of his or her age. If prosecutors do not take a stance and charged a minor for the crime and not their age our communities could be in danger. With an increase in the crimes by minors, the question that comes to mind is, is the juvenile system so punishment really working? Is it creating deterrence...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Should Juveniles be tried as adults

... resulted to call to charge the youth as adults (Khan 1). Those in support argue that harsh sentence will lead to a reduced rate of crime by the group. There is an argument that youth has been taking advantage of court focus on small crime to commit violent crime (Estudillo 1). The argument is that an exceptional should apply in bigger crimes. Therefore, punishment of minor crimes may provide a way of preventing the youth from committing other crimes in the future. There is also an argument that today’s kids are smart. This makes them more aware than before of what is good and bad especially with the rise in technology. Therefore, trying such kids as adults whenever they commit a crime will not be a problem. Conclusion It is clear... ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Should minors who commit violent crimes be tried as adults

...was crucial in the reputation of a nation and the adults did not reach a decision to give them weapons? This is a clear line drawn between the adults and minors, why then should we conclude that this case is different and this minor deserves equal treatment as adults and be locked away in prisons with the grownups (Bernard, 2010). For years now, history has come to the defense of the minors, nations that have attempted to recruit children in warfare have had the leaders tried or sanctioned. This case has also cut across decades where children have had to face the juvenile system. Why then change this after having proven productive for ages. Currently,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Violent Crimes And Major Thefts

...for illegal businesses. This paper outlines why street gangs are dangerous sections in any society and therefore, state, federal and local government should not hesitate in curbing them. As a result of the increase in the number of street gangs, the Federal Bureau of Investigations continues to play a major role in combating violent crimes and thefts in all cities and towns in US. The FBI works in conjunction with other agents such as the state and local partners, who are involved in the investigation as well as a joint task force. This ensures that the fight against gangs is made possible since one organ cannot fight the crimes by itself (Curry, Ball, & Fox, 2014)....
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

Should Juveniles Be Treated as Adults in Violent Crimes

...they are engaged in. The opposing side states that it is unfair for the criminal justice system to try and punish juveniles without regarding their developmental immaturity. The controversy and validity of trying juveniles as adults in criminal courts is analyzed critically through the history of juvenile justice system, the changing attitudes towards juvenile crime and present research and studies on juvenile justice. Eventually, I conclude that juvenile offenders should not be tried as adults. History of juvenile justice system Origination of Juvenile Justice System The Juvenile Court was established in the United States in the early 20th...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Should Jouveniles Accused of Violent crimes be Tried and Jailed as Adults for FREE!

Contact Us