This paper "Communication and Language - Mother Tongue " focuses on the fact that communication is essential for almost all living things; it lets us warn others of danger, share experiences, express feelings, and opinions. Human beings are innate communicators, they rely on it to teach, to learn. …
Download file to see previous pages...
Here in the United States when someone does not speak English well or speaks a broken version of the language many tend to think less, enforce stereotypes, and not take them as seriously. The two essays “Mother Tongue, by Amy Tan, and “Talk about Editing,” by David Shipley do not have very much in common. They are both relevant and important but approach communication from two completely different sides. Tan’s work is a serious discussion about the way people perceived her as a young Asian American and how her mother is treated for her broken English. She gives multiple examples at how differently her mother’s business would be handled when she pretended to be her mother on the telephone as opposed to how they, generally, treated her mother. She mentions being discouraged by teachers not to pursue writing; it was suggested she enter the math or sciences. She understood that this was a stereotype in action; people of Asian descent are naturally good at math and science, but seldom good at English or writing. (Tan 270-?) However, of course she became a writer despite their views. However, one can appreciate the hardship that her mother went through. Also, she touches on the important subject of how people speak differently within different environments. There is some truth to this. There are actually a number of English dialects, slang, and regional terms being used that mean little outside of that region. That said, the language used and words chosen differ when we talk to friends, teachers, parents, and employers. These language issues should not be allowed to ever overshadow the value of a person or of the information they hope to share. The Amy Tan essay speaks to the perception a woman watching her mother struggle with this issue and the ways that the outside world reacts to it. Her desire to defy the stereotypes that were presented and continue to pursue her goal is inspiring. In her situation she is asking for the poor words her mother uses, as with all immigrants working to learn a new and difficult language, do not mean more the intention, wisdom, or meaning behind each of them, perfectly spoken or not The second essay, “Talking about Editing” is a much more structured essay explaining the point, purpose, and function of an editor. Apparently people have an impression that editors make harsh and often uncomplimentary choices in a writer’s work and have overall say in the perception or vision of the actual work (Shipley 303-?). In fact, the author of any work has the final say in the final work that they will put their name one. According to experts good editors, should always be able to pick up on the grammatical errors, typos, and spelling mistakes, but never to make an overall judgment of the artistic or scholarly work. Their responses to the writer’s work should always be suggestions and never demands (Rafter). However as we move into the ever-changing and technological futures the value of writing and reading may be slipping away. In discussing these two essays there is an interesting irony present. If Amy Tan did not speak or write in fine and proper English, would a publisher consider her work, would an editor even bother? If it is the errors in the writing that makes the writing unique then correcting it would eliminate that quality. Editors are trained and bound to make certain that all of the rules of the English language are followed, punctuation, and grammar, as well.
...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
(“Communication and Language - Mother Tongue Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1491836-communication-and-language
(Communication and Language - Mother Tongue Essay)
“Communication and Language - Mother Tongue Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1491836-communication-and-language.
Both writers acknowledge the contributions of their roots and family ties in the process of learning to find remarkable essence in English and love of communicating effectively especially with their parents who occur to be the primary concern in their attempt to simplify approach in writing.
Answer 1 Amy Tan in her novel, ‘Mother Tongue’ asserts that English has many variations and she has used ‘all the Englishes’ that she has grown up with. The myriad ways the English language has been used by different people, especially immigrant population has been ingenious because it helps them to adjust within their new environment.
Since Tan is giving her opinion, her experience gives us confidence that she knows what she is talking about on the subject as each person is believed to be entitled to his or her own opinion. This opening statement gives the reader confidence in the author because the essay is presented from a layperson’s personal point of view which is rarely questioned for hard fact.
The author explains that Amy’s childhood was hard because of the untimely death of her father, and her brother, who too died when she was very young, yet she continued with her studies. The lack of language skills in the mother caused problems for the young girl in school, for she was pushed towards science subjects.
The first part of the essay focused on the different versions of English that the author learned and used throughout her life. The second part of the essay concentrated on the difficulties that she experienced through her school life because English was not her strong point (Tan 3).
Amy Tan’s essay, “Mother Tongue,” is an exposition on the use of the English language. The essay is particularly relevant in today’s world, in which the internet ensures that rigid geographical boundaries no longer form an impenetrable barrier to communication. Societies are increasingly multicultural and multi-lingual.
res and words which render her thoughts precisely but this language is out of use in her family as her mother uses English just to meet her basic communicative needs. This story shows that the use of any language heavily depends on the situation where it takes place because
For instance, she note that her mother was never taken seriously in numerous situations she should have been taken serious prompting to her receiving poor services. For instance, the writer notes that at the age of 15, her mother used her to get right quality or desired services from both the hospital and stockbroker among other places.
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Let us find you another Essay on topic Communication and Language - Mother Tongue for FREE!