StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference between the Literature and the Trivial - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In a broad context, literature could mean anything that a person could consider a written text to be. In that context, one of the definitions of literature furnished by The Free Online Dictionary is, “imaginative or creative writing, especially of recognized artistic value…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful
Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference between the Literature and the Trivial
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference between the Literature and the Trivial"

of the English of the Concerned 13 January Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference between the Literature and the Trivial In abroad context, literature could mean anything that a person could consider a written text to be. In that context, one of the definitions of literature furnished by The Free Online Dictionary is, “imaginative or creative writing, especially of recognized artistic value (The Free Online Dictionary 1).” However, to grasp the true meaning of literature as per this or any other such definition will be utterly naive and simplistic.

This realization eventually opens us up to the question as to what is literariness, or what makes a body of literature to be characterized as literature? Although, this is not the alpha and omega of the concept called literariness, I believe that for a written body of work to be called a literary text, it is imperative that, that work has the capacity to engage human consciousness in all its multiple dimensions, it should have the capacity to make the human perception proceed with the possible and the reasonable to the extent to which it can and than making it take a leap of faith beyond the conscious and the perceptible, to bring out the novel meanings, insights, ideas and perceptions inherent within that text.

In that context, Jaws and Moby-Dick are two apt examples to be considered. Whereas, Jaws is a thriller of impulsive importance that engages the human perception with the unpredictability, raciness and variety of its scope, Moby-Dick does qualify to be labeled as a timeless work of literature that engrossingly and emphatically allures the human consciousness with its multiple facets that are plot, characterization, language and symbolism. So far as the plot of Jaws is concerned, its appeal is superficial, shallow and time bound.

Though the plots in Moby-Dick and Jaws revolve around a mammoth white fish and the obsession of a character with the actual hunting down of that fish, the similarity in these two works of literature is limited only to that. In Jaws, Peter Benchley arranges the events and sequences within the plot to achieve a plausible target effect that are awe, intimidation and curiosity. The intended impact of the plot is impulsive and simplistic in its approach, as the characters in the story utterly fail to engage in actions and thought that could bring the reader to consider dispositional and moral concepts, which are of timeless relevance and import.

In contrast, Moby-Dick is a work of literature in which the actual plot is characterized by multiple layers of sequences and events, which are ordered and arranged with artful dexterity towards the attainment of multifaceted, pithy and universal, artistic and emotional effects (Sten 38). Unlike Jaws, Moby-Dick does not rely on run of the mill contemporary issues like the vehemence of nature, extramarital affairs, crony capitalism, personality clashes and suspense in a way that is too obvious, facile, narrowly stimulating and shallow.

No wonder, a male engaged in a midlife crisis, a woman resorting to an extramarital affair, a quirky shark hunter, a humane biologist and to top it all a white shark bent on targeting the human existence at a sea side tourist destination do make enough of a baggage for a contemporary best seller. However, to emerge as a work of literature requires much more depth and suction. Whereas Jaws relies on a temporal sequence of issues and incidents to commercially engage the reader’s attention, Moby-Dick amply exhibits the capacity of the writer to order motivations and causes in both a methodical order and manner with a tremendous capacity to delve on the ephemeral aspects of human concern, touching on the deep seated human lack of certainty and the evil side of human consciousness.

The appeal of Moby-Dick is something which though graspable by words, leaves ample that could only be felt in the deeper recesses of human mind and heart. The other literary aspect that makes Jaws a contemporary work of commercial and entertainment related relevance, with scarce ability to emerge as a timeless work of literature is the characterization (Sten 27). The characters in Jaws are more or less flat and two dimensional, scarcely capable of conveying things that touch beyond the temporal layers of human understanding.

In comparison, the characters in Moby-Dick are multifaceted, full bodied and round, capable of carrying the weight of ideas and concepts that the writer intends to convey, besides being engaged in the issues and actions imminent on them. The varied characters in Jaws like Martin Brody, Larry Vaughan, Matt Hooper and Quint are essentially flat and two dimensional, brewing in the juice of the immediate issues and challenges facing them, so immersed in the temporary aspects of a racy and suspense laden plot, to be unable to metamorphose into something that is universal and far important than their individual existence.

In comparison, most of the characters in Moby-Dick are it Captain Ahab, Fedallah, or even Moby Dick tend to be very complex and are affiliated to varied motivations, and the writer goes and extra mile to construct these characters with apt subtlety and plurality. The net result is that characters in Moby-Dick not only act and speak for merely themselves, luckily accruing reader’s interest through shallow violence and suspense, but rather emerge to be characters signifying universal human issues like evil and goodness, imbued with immense symbolic significance.

Thereby, to put it in a few words, it is not a must that good story could also turn out to be a literary work. In other words, the mere capacity of a text to engage human interest and rake in profits does not necessarily make it a literary masterpiece. Yet, it also does not mean that an avid reader should not engage with texts that are not literary. Eventually it is the perusal of both the literary and non literary works that allow a student of literature to develop a sense of context, so as to be able to identify works whose appeal is universal and everlasting.

Works Cited Sten, Christopher. Sounding the Whale: Moby-Dick as Epic Novel. Kent: Kent State University Press, 1996. Print. The Free Online Dictionary. Literature. 2012. Web. 13 January 2013.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference between the Literature and the Trivial Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1466346-jaws-moby-dick-difference-between-the-literature-and-the-trivial
(Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference Between the Literature and the Trivial Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1466346-jaws-moby-dick-difference-between-the-literature-and-the-trivial.
“Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference Between the Literature and the Trivial Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1466346-jaws-moby-dick-difference-between-the-literature-and-the-trivial.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Jaws & Moby Dick- Difference between the Literature and the Trivial

Friendship and Companionship in Moby Dick by Herman Melville

Friendship, love, and this feeling of oneness between ourselves and the greater whole - this is the truth.... The paper "Friendship and Companionship in moby Dick by Herman Melville" states that if our civilization has to become viable we have to reshape it on this new kind of creativity based on a friendly attitude to the existence, and not the kind of creativity that issues from the madness of the ego.... moby Dick is the story of the mammoth ego of a relatively much smaller man!...
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Obesity Articles Television Viewing and Hypertension in Obese Children and The HIKCUPS Trial

The most important feature of the literature review has been that twenty 23 out 39 reviews have been from studies published in the last 10 years thus giving credence to the contemporary trend of obese behavior and its implications.... he study has reviewed 39 kinds of literature, related to the topic, spanning twenty-one years from 1985 to 2006.... The study and literature review has remained focused on the issue of obesity and factors correlated with it....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

The Difference between Forensic and Security Evidence

The paper "The difference between Forensic and Security Evidence" concluded all mechanisms required for designing protection are included in security while forensic prompt after an accident.... Due to increasing security incidents, there will be more demand for forensic computing professionals....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

The Difference Between Women and Men in the Management Styles

There are a number of important models to consider when reviewing the literature on this subject.... For example, some believe that gender is the main variable and that there are simply a number of biological differences between men and women.... Loden was able to identify five main areas that differed between men and women....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

Cultural Differences and Similarities Between United States and Saudi Arabia

This review elucidates the cultural similarities and differences between the United States and Saudi Arabia while focusing on the important aspects of attachment to gas, the way people lived in these two societies, the role of women, and the role of the youths in the two societies.... Nevertheless, while too many people think that there is nothing common about the cultures between United States and Saudi Arabia, there are similarities and differences between them....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

Differences between Sociological and Lay Ideas about Illness from the Biomedicine Ideas

… The paper "Differences between Sociological and Lay Ideas about Illness from the Biomedicine Ideas" is an excellent example of a literature review on sociology.... The paper "Differences between Sociological and Lay Ideas about Illness from the Biomedicine Ideas" is an excellent example of a literature review on sociology.... For example, Hansen & Easthope, (2007) highlight the fact that the boundaries between medical and lay ideas with regards to lifestyle health explanations are blurred....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

Understanding the Difference Between Leadership and Management

Still, it could as well be reasoned that making a distinction between the two terms is crucial; otherwise, organizations would be set for failure.... … The paper "Understanding the difference between Leadership and Management" is a wonderful example of a literature review on management.... The paper "Understanding the difference between Leadership and Management" is a wonderful example of a literature review on management.... It is based on this reasoning that this paper describes the difference between leadership and management before commenting on the manner in which leadership and management are practiced at a given school....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

International Public Institutions and International Non-governmental Organizations

The paper "Differences between International Public Institutions and International Non-Governmental Organizations" employs two international organizations, one from the international public organizations' category, and the other one from the international NGO in order to bring out the issue....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us