Nobody downloaded yet

Rogerian Argument on The Chinese in all of Us - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Rogerian Argument on ‘The Chinese in all of Us’ By Richard Rodriguez The Chinese in all of Us by Richard Rodriguez is an article about the author’s perspective on multiculturalism…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Rogerian Argument on The Chinese in all of Us
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Rogerian Argument on The Chinese in all of Us"

Download file to see previous pages He thinks that there is no such thing as multiculturalism, there is only a melting pot and all the cultures go in and a different culture(s) emerges. The theme is relevant to all, as everyone supposedly belongs to some culture or race. If the only constant is change then what is a culture anyway? If certain tradition, style of speaking, food and dress remains specific to a place for a certain amount of time, does it mean it will always stay that way, if this is not true then what happened to the Stone Age culture and hunting with spears made of bone and wood? Shouldn’t we all hold on to our ‘true culture’? Rodriguez is right in his reasoning because he grew up in America, born to a Mexican family. He lived through all of the cultural amalgamation in the US. There are no hard and fast rules to cultures anymore. Probably there is no culture after all, but the culture of change and evolution. Rodriguez is right in arguing that there is no multiculturalism, it is just a haze. He astoundingly explains this to an interviewer who asks him if he considers himself as Hispanic or American, and he replies, Chinese. That is what he grew up with; a little bit of this and a little bit of that. He is born to Mexican parents and goes to an American school (where he’s shown to speak ‘proper’ English) and has Chinese neighbors. The ‘proper’ English even teaches him how to say his own name as the school teacher writes his name on the board and reads it out loud and asks him to follow along, so that the whole class gets familiar with his name and he gets to say his name in a certain accent; the ‘proper’ accent, this is what the culture (or multiculture) is all about. However, certain things remain specific to certain cultures, for instance Asian culture is very different from the Western culture; “Many Asian cultures have distinct conceptions of individuality that insist on the fundamental relatedness of individuals to each other. The emphasis is on attending to others, fitting in, and harmonious interdependence with them.” (Markus and Kitayama, 1991) But there is something in the world that brings together different cultures, the melting pot. The author frequently uses the term melting pot and prefers it over common culture or multiculture. The term melting pot represents the trend in culture in a better way. The author has introduced two different views about the ‘melting pot theory’, one is positive while the other has some negativity attached to it. The author says that the melting pot has changes people. When someone goes into it, their identity is lost. An African will not remain African after the melting pot treatment. The loss of identity or separation from the origin is what he refers to as something which he doesn’t look forward to. He accepts it only because of its inevitability. The inevitable side of the ‘identity loss’ makes sense. This world belongs to everyone; it would be ridiculous to think that certain race will remain in a certain piece of land for all eternity; an impossibility. They will eventually travel to some other part of this world. And when they live with the other ‘cultures’ they will take some part of it and will give some of theirs; “Even while America changes the immigrants, the immigrants are changing us” (Rodriguez) The other way Rodriguez sees the melting pot is somewhat of a miracle pot. A person goes in it and comes out as something different. The pot has magical powers, but he question is; does it bring people closer or pushes them away? Clearly it brings them closer at the cost of the so called ‘identity’. The only thing wrong with this approach is when people are forced to adapt to certain norms. They have their own culture and lifestyle, why would the dominant culture suppress it ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Rogerian Argument on The Chinese in all of Us Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/english/1457569-rogerian-argument-on-the-chinese-in-all-of-us
(Rogerian Argument on The Chinese in All of Us Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1457569-rogerian-argument-on-the-chinese-in-all-of-us.
“Rogerian Argument on The Chinese in All of Us Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1457569-rogerian-argument-on-the-chinese-in-all-of-us.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Homo Sexual- Rogerian Argument
...? 22 March Adoption of children by homosexual couples: Introduction: Homosexuality is a wrongful and unnatural way of living. It causes a lot of troubles in the society. It does not only ruin the life style of those who practice it, but also, peace in the life of those who are related to them is at stake. Like all other matters of life, homosexuals should not be allowed to adopt children. Adoption of children is a very complicated matter, which requires consideration of several aspects. Adoption of children by homosexual couples is extremely harmful for their psychological and physiological development. Critic’s view: In the paper written by (Smith), child adoption by homosexual couples has been favored. (Smith) has made...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Welfare Reform Affects Us All
...? Welfare Reform Affects Us All Welfare programs, no matter how one looks at the situation, adversely affect us all. Throughout modern history there have been many social programs aimed at helping poor people, especially in difficult times. After the Great Depression in 1935, President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed into law the Social Security Act. This provided for many social programs aimed at helping people recover and get back on their feet. Within this legislation was provision for the unemployed, affordable housing, medical insurance, food assistance, as well as Aid to Families with Dependent Children. There were also many management agencies created to monitor the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Abortion and the Rogerian Argument
...? Abortion and the Rogerian Argument Kimberly Fulmerhouser English 351 Dianne Bogdan 4/2/12 The essay aims to address a two-fold objective: (1) to choose an issue in nursing; and (2) to write a Rogerian argument on an issue in the field of nursing. Abortion and the Rogerian Argument Introduction Debates about abortion is interminable not only in the United States but to most countries in the world. Countries such as Iran, Ireland, Nicaragua, South Africa, and some regions of Latin America and Caribbean contested abortion and developed pro-natalist policies due to religious and cultural beliefs; whereas China, Cuba, and India supports...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Chinese Yuan vs. US Dollar
...conducted using the Chinese Yuan quickly replacing the use of the US dollar. These changes in the Asian markets form a better foundation for the appreciation of the Yuan against many other major currencies in the markets. For instance, the “Asian Economic Integration” Monitor and the Head of the Asian Development Bank asserted that majority of the countries conducting bilateral trade with China uses the Yuan in settling all transactions (Zhang & Chan 2011). Its extensive use across Asia and other countries such as Japan and Singapore makes the Yuan a good currency in conducting businesses. This is because its stability...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Chinese and US Negotiation Styles
...of all the nifty gritty details facing their government and their leaders. This implies that US negotiators are answerable to other indirect parties and must therefore exercise caution in their actions. However, this also means that there is greater accountability amongst them. Morality in Chinese and American systems The Chinese culture is such that most of the members of the population have a deep sense of morality. This is derived from instructions given by one of their most influential leaders some 2000 years ago. He was called Confucius. This leader gave guidelines on how relationships within society can be conducted so as to maintain harmony and enhance peace. He...
17 Pages(4250 words)Essay
The Chinese Room Argument
...that the physical performance of their brains are basically the same: and the same common kinds of physical effects occur in their brains as yours, therefore, the same emergent properties can be expected. My opinion is totally in contrast with Searle’s view that seems to divide things into two perspectives, that is the physical objects and abstraction of a physical system that also appears to be different in all. According to my understanding, the distinction between different kinds of properties is inconsistent. In human beings and other living things, emergent properties are caused by the processes within them as it is in the artificially made objects. The only difference here is artificial, but in real sense the...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper
Rogerian Essay
...to war and the perpetrators of war guise it as patriotism. I agree with this analysis in that if states were more conscious, there is always a way out. War is used as means of protecting one’s interests that is not just at all. Like the author, my view is that a war is in no instance just. The notion that war is justified if it is authorized by a legitimate authority is a dangerous notion. The reason this is so is because, even the said authority could be biased and also protect the interests of the members that comprise it. The United Nations Charter makes the option of resulting to war almost impossible. The Security Council may authorize a state to go to war. The problem is that states now...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Rogerian Essay
...immigrants work permits would increase the rate of unemployment in the country. The situation will hurt the American job seekers who with skills. The government asserts that recognizing immigrants is a good step in curbing crime from undocumented people in the US. However, it is imperative to mitigate the entry of immigrants to the country than to support them. The rationale for this argument bases on the premises that if the country shows support and recognition for immigrants, then it will be a wrong precedent and immigrants will seize the opportunity to enter the country. As noted above, social problems are likely to arise because of integration of immigrant into the society. Immigrants are often...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Multiculturalism in America and Its Impact on the American Identity
...Number] Rogerian Argument In “The Chinese in All of Us”, Richard Rodriguez explores Multiculturalism. Rodriguez talks about the effects that multiculturalism of the American society had on his life. Being the son of Spanish speaking Mexican immigrant parents, he narrates the constant encounters he experienced while growing up in America. In defense of all the labelling and accusations he faced as a reaction to his book, which highlighted issues such as bilingual education and affirmative action, he wrote his understanding of the issue of Multiculturalism while maintaining one’s own ethnic identity. He further elaborates, that though...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
Rogerian Essay
...experience of people addicted to drugs. As for the prisoner populations, it appears to be extremely inventive in seeking ways and methods of cheating results of drug testing. “… self-reporting by prisoners suggests that for some cannabis users (25% of all prisoners) MDT is a direct deterrent whilst they are in custody” (Singleton et al., 2005) or that mandatory drug testing may help a significant number of inmates to give up drug consumption at all. Although, they may underline paramount importance of such tests for improvement of the situation with drug abuse, there are evident facts that prisoners just change use of cannabis for heroin or other opiates in order to mislead results of...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Rogerian Argument on The Chinese in all of Us for FREE!
Contact Us