“Don’t Shut the Golden Door”: Supported Claims, But Poor Transition and Conclusion In “Don’t Shut the Golden Door,” John M. MacDonald and Robert J. Sampson argue that a cross-sectional study showed that immigration is generally good for society…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
Download file to see previous pages
The article is well-supported with evidence, although it lacks further discussion on other possible interpretations of the study and it needs clear transition sentences and persuasive concluding arguments for its last two paragraphs. The article provides good supporting claims for its main argument that immigration does not produce greater social problems for society. The study they used offered concrete evidence that in several communities across the United States, migrants are not lazy, social-welfare guzzlers. MacDonald and Sampson stress that even if migrants are generally poorer than the rest of the population, they have positive effects on communities with weak economies. They give examples from Hazleton, Pennsylvania and St. James, Minnesota, where migrants decreased hostility against minorities and turned around both the decreasing population and economic rates. MacDonald and Sampson also offer evidence that migrants diminished crime rates through decreasing homicide rates for the main racial groups and improving attitudes toward the police and laws. Despite these backed-up claims, the article no longer explores other alternative interpretations of the study. ...
The study must be concentrated in certain areas only, where migration actually improved economic conditions, thereby not including communities, where immigration worsened socio-economic indicators. The article also lacks clear transition sentences and convincing concluding arguments for its last two paragraphs. For example, a better transition sentence for the thirteenth paragraph is: “Because of the positive contributions of migrants to American society, the winner of the election in November should carefully consider the consequences of fully closing the golden gate.” The last paragraph can also be rewritten into: “A comprehensive immigration reform should protect the human rights of migrants, while providing opportunities for guest-workers. We should be aware of the importance of controlling illegal immigration flow, without directly affronting the human rights of hard-working and law-abiding migrants.” These paragraphs support immigration, without alienating potentially valid claims regarding illegal immigration. The article provides evidence for its central argument that immigration does not harm the society and benefits it instead. Nevertheless, it does not present exhaustive explanation for the direct relationship between immigration and social and economic developments in selected communities. MacDonald and Sampson can also rewrite the last two paragraphs by creating clearer transition sentences and improving the closing ideas for their arguments. This way, they can convince their readers that immigration provides important benefits for American society. Unclear Argument and Bold Claims in “Smokeless in Seattle” In “Smokeless in Seattle,” Holden argues that the medical marijuana industry is against Initiative 502,
...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
(“Critical Essays for Two Separate Articles: Don't Shut the Golden Door Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1453810-critical-essays-for-two-separate-articles
(Critical Essays for Two Separate Articles: Don'T Shut the Golden Door Essay)
“Critical Essays for Two Separate Articles: Don'T Shut the Golden Door Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1453810-critical-essays-for-two-separate-articles.
Consistent with founding texts of Christianity, there is a pronounced tenor of Godly retribution in Edwards’ work. For example, the following passage from the opening of the sermon indicates the scale of fear and inhibition which Edwards sought to place in the hearts of the congregated audience.
Piaget’s cognitive theory of play categorizes play into four types; sensory-motor play, symbolic play, games of construction, and games with rules (uwgb.edu, n.d.). Sensory-motor play is also called physical play. In this play, children are asked to repeat a physical activity that they enjoy.
According to the research findings, borderline personality disorder is a disease condition in which the victims experience a long-term pattern of turbulent or unstable emotions on self and others. An individual suffering from borderline personality disorder experiences low self-esteem, unstable relationships, and impulsive behavior which begins at an early stage of adulthood.
Churchill discusses that the problem with the issue of multiple paths is that they consist of “equally likely selective agents behind a given trait” (Churchill, 2008, p. 114). Through scientific analysis of the issue of the large chest cavity in Neanderthals, the question of how best to assess theories on equafinality of agents is discussed.
"Each project management [step] has been designed to build on the previous level and thus providea clearpath [for project management]."2 Not only this, but it has also come to light the fact that bringing on staff that would be casual was a factor. Additionally, the processing problems had to be sorted out which occurred in the two workplaces with the new regime.
This essay compares the two researchers, that focused their attention on the issue of cases undetected dementia and delirium in the care homes. The most critical questions explored are what can be done to avoid such scenarios and what is being currently done to address the problem in the modern society.
The article also denotes that it is highly important to change this negative and potentially detrimental trend. This is because; Australia’s indigenous populace has occupied, managed and cared for the entire country for
Throughout the journey, readers appreciate livelier atmosphere in the saint’s party, the brutal conflict in Albania, the political celebrations in Athens, discourses on the history of Greek and the challenges facing modern combatants. The storyline takes different approaches including the first person and third person; this style breaks boredom in readers.
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
GOT A TRICKY QUESTION? RECEIVE AN ANSWER FROM STUDENTS LIKE YOU!
Save Your Time for More Important Things
Let us write or edit the essay on your topic
"Critical Essays for Two Separate Articles: Don't Shut the Golden Door and Smokeless in Seattle"
with a personal 20% discount.