StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Production of Wealth and Environmental Issues - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Production of Wealth and Environmental Issues" states that environmental scientists, as interdisciplinary specialists in physical and biological sciences, and environmental science, are concerned with the study of the environment and the solution to environmental problems…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
The Production of Wealth and Environmental Issues
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Production of Wealth and Environmental Issues"

Text 1. Economists, as specialists in economics, are mainly concerned with the production, consumption and transfer of wealth. 2. Environmental scientists, as interdisciplinary specialists in physical and biological sciences, and environmental science, are concerned with the study of the environment and the solution to environmental problems. 3. The production of wealth is mainly based on the exploitation of the earth’s natural resources. Unchecked exploitation of these finite resources is an off-shoot of the need to engender wealth, and leads to imbalances in the ecosystem. Conversion of these natural resources into manufactured consumer goods often uses technology which causes pollution and global warming. In this context, economists tend to ignore the environmental problems which accompany economic growth. This puts them in direct confrontation with environmental scientists who are concerned with the protection of the environment. 4. (a) Environmental issues, such as clean air, conservation of wildlife, and green energy, cannot be judged in purely monetary terms. While clean air cuts medical costs due to lung disorders, and green energy, such as more efficient refrigeration techniques, can reduce wastage and energy bills, it is more difficult to define the benefits of wildlife conservation in financial terms. Love of wildlife involves social and emotional aspects which cannot be quantified. (b) I would be prepared to pay about five percent of my income towards environmental issues. 5. The question in the title is, “Why do economists and environmental scientists have such a hard time communicating?” The writer concludes that economists and environmental scientists cannot overcome the barrier to communication because environmentalists cannot accept the allocation of monetary values to environmental goods or agree to the fixing of a limit to spending on environmental protection. 6. Professor Graves puts forward the theory that environmental goods are substantially undervalued by economists using standard methods. He argues that it is difficult to estimate what people would spend on environmental goods, as the availability of environmental goods could encourage people to work harder and increase their incomes. 7. (a) The problem defined in the essay is the irreconcilable difference in attitude between economists and environmental scientists in assigning monetary values to environmental goods. (b) The proposed solution is to assign monetary values to environmental goods, so that there can be trade-offs between the competing needs of wealth generation and environmental protection. (c) The writer doubts that an agreement can be reached between economists and environmentalists, as the latter will not accept the assignment of a cash equivalent, however large, to environmental goods or agree to a cap on environmental spending. 8. Summary of Article 1. The article, “Never the Twain Shall Meet: Why do economists and environmental scientists have such a hard time communicating?” deals with the wide gap in the perspectives of economists and environmentalists. While economists firmly believe that environmental goods can be reduced to cash equivalents, this idea is anathema to environmentalists. Economists argue that by assigning monetary values to environmental goods, such as clean air and biological diversity, compromises can be made to achieve a balance between the consumption of these goods and environmental protection. The writer declares that it is inevitable that monetary values be assigned to environmental goods, so that a policy can be formulated and choices can be made regarding the consumption of such goods. Philip Graves, an economist, states that environmental goods are substantially undervalued by economists using standard methods of measurement. He contends that there will be a significant difference in the amount consumers would spend on environmental goods if they were actually available on the market, and the amount they give as a theoretical estimate. He asserts that environmental goods may be undervalued by as much as ten percent. Graves’ argument calls for a substantial increase in expenditure for environmental protection and improvement. On the surface, it appears that environmentalists would approve of Graves’ stand. However, we go back to the sticking point in the perspective of economists and environmentalists: the assignment of monetary values to environmental goods. Environmentalist will not accept cash equivalents for environmental goods as a method to calculate a limit to environmental spending. 9. After reading the article, “Never the Twain Shall Meet:--” it is difficult to conceive of economists and environmental scientists reaching a rapprochement regarding environmental protection. 10. There is definitely a fundamental conflict between Economics and Environmentalism: Economics mandates assigning a monetary value to environmental goods, while Environmentalism vehemently opposes such a policy. Text 2 1. The title “Save the Planet (and prosper)” indicates that the author intends to link environmental protection with economic prosperity. 2. In view of the rampant exploitation of the earth’s natural resources over the ages, and especially in the recent past, the adoption of protective measures to safeguard the environment will definitely cost money. At the same time, I believe that any money spent will yield rich dividends in the future. Investing in green energy will reduce pollution: this will bring down health costs from lung diseases. The cost of petroleum-based fuel will be reduced and the monopoly of oil-rich states will be broken. 3. Costa Rica plans to shift to entirely renewable energy by 2025. 4. China has lowered fertility rates. Denmark has banned power plants fuelled by coal. South Korea has successfully implemented a reforestation program. 5. (a) The problem identified by the author is the fact that the global economy is in direct confrontation with the earth’s eco-system. (b) The proposed solution is to modify the economy so that it takes into consideration the concepts of environmentally sustainable development. (c) The three main areas of the economy to be affected by the proposed solution are energy, materials and food. 6. Summary of Article 2. Lester Brown regrets that the contemporary global economy is exclusively based on market values and ignores the earth’s ecosystem, thus destroying the environment. He categorically asserts the need for an economic system which recognizes the need for sustainable yields, and environmental conservation, in order to protect the welfare of future generations. The adoption of this ‘eco-economy’ which will reconcile present consumption needs with the needs of the future. Brown concedes the difficulty of converting a market-based economy into one which is based on ecological principles. While no country has evolved a definite plan to move to an eco-economy, significant measures have been adopted by several nations such as Europe, Japan, Denmark, South Korea, Costa Rica and Iceland in the areas of population stabilization, green energy, reforestation programs, banning of fossil-fuels, and sustainable transport. Brown declares that an eco-economy must tax environmentally destructive activities instead of income. An eco-economy will influence every aspect of our lives, from food to leisure, and will make us live in unity with nature. The restructuring of the economy, bringing it in harmony with nature, will largely impact the sectors of energy, food and materials. Energy will shift from fossil-based fuels to renewable sources, such as water and wind. Agricultural techniques will emphasize water conservation, top-soil preservation, and the avoidance of deforestation. The focus in materials will shift from extraction to recycling. The entire global economy will be transformed by this ‘Environmental Revolution.’ Those companies with the foresight to accept this inevitable change will emerge as the winners in the new eco-economy. 7. Text 1 attempts to reconcile the difference in perspectives between economists and environmental scientists regarding the assigning of cash equivalents to environmental goods. It seeks to find a common ground so that a balance can be achieved between economic and environmental gains. On the other hand, Text 2 argues for a complete transformation of the present economy into an ‘eco-economy, which incorporates ecological principles into its market-based structure. 8. I find Text 2 to be more persuasive as it makes a very convincing argument in favor of the abolition of the present economy which is causing rampant environmental degradation. It makes a firm case for the argument that environmental protection will lead to concrete, long-term economical gains. Text 1 fails to identify any strong solutions and falls short of the positive note on which Lester Brown concludes his piece. 9. Lester Brown’s article has definitely added a new dimension to my views on environmental conservation. The suggested merging of economics and environmentalism into the inter-disciplinary field of ‘eco-economy’ is a brilliant solution to the economics/environmentalism schism which now prevails. This new field, focused on ensuring that environmental protection and economic gains go hand in hand, is definitely the need of the hour. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Critical Thinking Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1430204-critical-thinking-task
(Critical Thinking Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1430204-critical-thinking-task.
“Critical Thinking Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1430204-critical-thinking-task.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Production of Wealth and Environmental Issues

Economy in relation to environmental protection. Environment and Sustainable Development

To quote the Center for International Environmental Law, “Whereas Stockholm brought to light transboundary and global environmental issues, Rio and Johannesburg incorporated a development dimension that required analysis not only of environmental issues but also of economic and social issues.... ? At the same time, the international agenda that emerged in relation to sustainable development appears to have prioritized the economic aspects over the social and environmental dimensions....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Environmental Impacts of Fortification Process

Or in other words, it is the amount of water that is used in the production of food is known as virtual water or embedded water (Hoekstra, & Chapagain, 2008).... However, considering the risks related to physical health sustainability of functional foods have various issues involved in it.... The paper "environmental Impacts of Fortification Process" states that sustainable food supply has to play an important role in contributing to public health....
13 Pages (3250 words) Dissertation

The Link between Health and Poverty

ince the health sector has minimal authority over most powerful influences on health, such as education, food, shelter, environmental risks, and work conditions, it meets the practical difficulties of recognizing how it can successfully work to disrupt the brutal cycle of poverty to access to health care (Pieratt-Seeley, 2002, p....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Environmental Degradation

Citing the situation in El Salvador, the book environmental issues and Responses specified how inequality can cause much damage to the environment.... This paper ''environmental Degradation'' tells us that the Issue of global warming has solicited much attention from the international community.... The book, A Warming World identifies two types of causes of environmental degradation: the direct and the underlying causes.... The latter represents people's participation in environmental changes....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Global Health Issues

Insecurity is another factor that results in inequality, causes poverty and environmental degradation, exposing people to health risks.... From the paper "Global Health issues" it is clear that insecurity has profound effects on the environment because they cause environmental degradation and expose people to health risks....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

A Comparison of Environmental Issues from Taking Sides

The author of the paper titled "A Comparison of environmental issues from Taking Sides" answers such questions as "Can sustainable agriculture feed the world?... There are serious issues in the world on environmental degradation, climate change, and food shortages.... n order to embrace sustainable agriculture, there is a need to create awareness on issues of global warming, air pollution, soil pollution, and water pollution (Wall, 2013).... Well-implemented policies and suitable facilitation agricultural agendas are achievable, 'With policy support and adequate funding, sustainable agricultural could be intensified over large production areas in a relatively short period' (Taylor, 2012)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Sustainability and Environmental Issues

"Sustainability and environmental issues" paper exmines the general principles of sustainable development that include environmental and economic integration: maintenance of biological diversity and conservation of natural resources: precaution, prevention, and evaluation, and participation.... Governments plan functions on four main principles that include living within environmental limits, ensuring a strong, healthy, and just society, achieving a sustainable economy, and promoting good governance....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Production Issues: Soil Fertility

"Production issues: Soil Fertility" paper explains why organic farming should play by the rules that ensure that there is fairness with regard to the environment.... background issues United states department of Agriculture define organic farming as 'organic farming is a system which avoids or largely excludes the use of synthetic inputs (such as fertilizers, pesticides, hormones, feed additives, etc) and to the maximum extent, feasible rely upon crop rotations, crop residues, animal manures, off-farm organic waste, mineral grade rock additives and biological system of nutrient mobilization and plant protection' (Stephan, Haring, Raffaele, 2004)....
13 Pages (3250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us