Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Written Evaluation of the Research Articles - Article Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
During the last several decades, electronic sources have managed to develop their functions playing not only the role of entertainment, but also ensuring education and social interaction among users. The article of Janice Waldron aims to research and define the effect of…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.1% of users find it useful
Written Evaluation of the Research Articles
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Written Evaluation of the Research Articles"

Waldron, J. . User-generated content, YouTube and participatory culture on the Web: music learning and teaching in two contrasting online communities. Music Education Research, 15(3), 257-274.
During the last several decades, electronic sources have managed to develop their functions playing not only the role of entertainment, but also ensuring education and social interaction among users. The article of Janice Waldron aims to research and define the effect of specialized web content along with blogs, platforms and chats on music learning and teaching process. The author tries to explain how exactly Web 2.0 increases users participation in discussions and interactions with each other bringing communities together (Waldron, 2013). The mentioned study covers the following questions:
What is peoples attitude to user-generated content and such sites like YouTube?
What are the reasons for uploading "homemade" videos and sharing personal files with other users?
What are the meanings of such definitions as "user-generated content", "participatory culture", "Web 2.0"?
What is the influence of these categories on music learning and teaching process?
What are practical examples of user-generated contents positive effect on musical education of communities?
In order to address all listed points, the author uses qualitative research. In the first part of the paper, Waldron implements such research method as literature review for the representation of existed studies regarding the main statement. During the second part of the study, the author uses data analysis and triangulation for showing research results to the readers. Waldron interviews twenty six participants via Skype, phone and e-mail offering carefully elaborated questionnaires. In addition, the author conducts face-to-face interviews with four teachers and analyzes online data through forum posts, digital videos and discussion platforms.
The main subjects of descriptive analysis are two online music communities such as the Online Academy of Irish Traditional Music (OAIM) and the Banjo Hangout. The author represents detailed characteristics of both sites. Juxtaposing chosen subjects with each other, it has been found out that despite the fact that they have different ideological approaches of the work, the influence of user-generated content and Web 2.0 on both of them is practically the same.
The research provided in the article is relevant and makes sense in the conditions of quickly developing technologies that currently we live in. The author chooses appropriate research methods and offers available for comprehension interpretations of study results so that it is easy to conclude that the statement and the purposes of research have been achieved. The article provides valuable findings asserting that participatory culture and such tools like YouTube do not substitute traditional music learning classes but mostly are used to supplement the study activities (Waldron, 2013). There are examples of teachers testimonials and tips that can be very useful for other tutors. Hence, all interviewed teachers stated that they had to modify their teaching approaches because of digital video usage. Their sharing of experience may encourage other teachers to make "homemade" video lessons in order to improve own teaching techniques and achieve higher productivity.
The innovative aspect of the article is that for the first time, the term "syncretism" is referred to music learning and teaching process. The usefulness of study results can be proved by those learners, who under the influence of different forums, discussion platforms and digital videos, share own experience, provide assistance to each other and broaden individual skills. Therefore, all these interactions among users strengthen community and contribute to the spreading of knowledge and improvement of musical skills.
Reference List
Waldron, J. (2013). User-generated content, YouTube and participatory culture on the Web: music learning and teaching in two contrasting online communities. Music Education Research, 15(3), 257-274. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Written Evaluation of the Research Articles Article”, n.d.)
Written Evaluation of the Research Articles Article. Retrieved from
(Written Evaluation of the Research Articles Article)
Written Evaluation of the Research Articles Article.
“Written Evaluation of the Research Articles Article”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Written Evaluation of the Research Articles

Research methodology articles Critique

Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting surgery (CABG), while being careful that none of them had compromised ventricular function, the latter condition speculated by the authors’ as an interfering factor, which might have affected correct interpretation of the data aimed to be gathered during the study. Although the sex ratio was skewered due to predominantly male patient selection, it did not matter as end point measurements included standard cardiac parameters unlikely to be biased by sex of the patient. On all 35 patients, measurements were manually obtained by independent investigators, blinded to each other for avoiding bias due to consultation, and the numerous parameters calculated to measure the cardiac output (CO). Similar data...
16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Scholarly Research Articles

...? Scholarly Research Articles Childhood Obesity By Jennifer Miller, Arlan Rosenbloom and Janet Silverstein The article, written by Miller, Rosenbloom and Silverstein (2004) was published in the The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism and proffered issues pertaining to obesity in children where the authors initially indicated the alarming statistics categorizing obesity as a pandemic with more than a billion people afflicted with the chronic illness globally. The theoretical framework of the study made references to the theory of nature versus nurture with methodologies focusing on neuroendocrine control of weight. Metabolic consequences were likewise discussed prior to delving into treatment and interventions for childhood...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The written buyout research report

Besides resorting to increase the operational efficiency and cost cutting measures as a way to enhance the profitability, one another way to attain corporate growth is through acquisition. In 2005, Proctor & Gamble made a major acquisition when it bought out The Gillette Company Inc., so as to expand its reach in the consumer products' industry. The recent big successful mergers are Blizzard, which is acquired by Vivendi, eBay acquisition of PayPal, Disney’s acquisition of Pixar, yahoo’s acquisition of Overture, which turned to be Yahoo’s ad system now.( Goodman 2008:67). As regards to the recent acquisition , PayPal can be regarded as the most successful buy-out in the consumer Internet space , as it had the deep effect on the t...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Understanding Research Articles

...? Understanding Research Articles Question General Information a) The of the article is ‘odor recognition Familiarity, Identifiability, and Encoding Consistency. b) The authors of the article are Michael D. Rabin and William S. Cain. c) The name of the journal is Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition. Its year of publication is 1984 with volume number 10, issue number 2 and page numbers are from 316 to 325. Question 2: Introduction a) The purpose of the research study is to recognise relation between the aim of the measure of identification of verbal encoding and subsequent learning of performance of odorants from one interval to another. The main purpose is to find a significant relationship between codability...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Evaluation Research

...Running Head: EVALUATION RESEARCH Evaluation Research 349123 Evaluation Research Graphic Displays Graphic displays like maps, diagrams and maps are used to provide models, support memory, attract attention, discovery and facilitate inference. They usually utilize space in conveying meaning in several approaches which are naturally cognitive. Icons, typically are employed in portraying elements with likenesses while depiction figures are for portraying other relations which are based on proximity. Darrell (1993) holds that statistics obtained from these graphical displays can be used to lie or be misleading. Poor use of statistics can be found any where; in polls, magazines, TV and even in some research papers. Maps, graphs or charts...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Research Articles

...Research Report: Gance-Cleveland (SECTION A Describe the process used to obtain the sample. Were inclusion or exclusion criteria used? If so, what were they? The qualitative evaluation was performed to find out the group processes and related outcomes of SBSG for COA with a conceptual framework that was interpretative and naturalistic. The naturalistic approach enabled the investigator to understand complex cases thoroughly and assess the problem in a natural environment without manipulation from a cofacilitators and participants perspective (Gance-Cleveland 2004 p.380). 2. What type of sampling design is this? Is the sampling design a probability or non-probability technique? Theoretical sampling was employed to find out the problems...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Critique epidemiologic research articles

...Critique epidemiologic research articles Affiliation: I. Objective or Hypothesis A.What are the objectives of the study, or what hypotheses are to be tested? The main hypothesis being tested in this research is that intake of a diet high in animal fat and especially fat from the red meat and which is lower in fiber is associated with increased risk of colorectal adenoma and precursors of cancer (Giovannucci, et al, 1994). B. To what population does the investigator intend to generalize these findings? The study population is the US male health professionals including dentists, podiatrists, pharmacists, optometrists, osteopaths and veterinarians. II. Design of the Study A. Is the study descriptive, analytical (cross-sectional, case control...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Critically analyse qualitative research articles

...Critical Analysis of Two Qualitative Research Articles Critical Analysis of Two Qualitative ResearchArticles Introduction Researchers who work in the social sciences such as psychology, sociology and anthropology are interested in exploring the behavior of human beings and their social interactions. For a long time, these researchers encountered rising difficulty in attempting to explain human behavior in quantitative terms(Hancock, et al., 2009). This difficulty gave rise to qualitative research methods. In addition to explaining human behavior, qualitative research attempts to explain social phenomena. This paper attempts to analyze, in a critical way, two articles that report qualitative research, paying special attention...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Research Articles

... perceived loving mother attitude and perceived loving father attitude. The correlation reports was that there was a positive and highly significant relationship between the two variables (r= 0.472, p=.001). The research question; is perceived loving mother attitude and perceived loving father attitude correlated 4. The alpha level for the article is 0.5 5. T-test The degree of freedom () is 278, the value of the test is  Using, the critical t-value is 3.09. Since the t-value is less than the critical t-value, this test was not significant. One way ANOVA The degree of freedom () is 279, the value of the test is  The p-value is 0.010. Since this value is lower than the critical p-value, this test was significant hence the null...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Article on topic Written Evaluation of the Research Articles for FREE!

Contact Us