Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This quantitative article review analyzes the article "The Technical Adequacy of Curriculum-Based Measurement Passage Copying With Secondary School English Language Learners" by Heather Campbell regarding the testing of the students writing abilities…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities"

Quantitative Article Review Quantitative analysis includes designs, techniques and measures that offer discrete numerical or quantifiable data. This research design uses probability sampling to ensure representativeness of the sample. Some of the research designs which may be categorized as quantitative research are experimental designs, casual comparative research and correlation research among others. If a research study, yields quantifiable data then is a quantitative study (Best and Khan p. 78).
Heather (p.289) conducted a study, on the Technical Adequacy of Curriculum-Based Measurement Passage Copying With Secondary School English Language Learners. From the literature review, it reveals that passage copying measures can be used to test the student writing abilities. The main purpose of this study was, to investigate the validity and reliability of a passage copying measures that could be used to assess writing proficiency among secondary school English language learners. The target population was midwestern urban high school that has an enrollment of 1,276 students in Grades 9 through 12. The whole population were from culturally or linguistically diverse backgrounds. The study participants were 57 students in 3 high school English as a second language classes taught by the same teacher (Heather p.209).
The study participants copied four passages in total, two constructed, and two curriculum based. This design adapted from a larger study constructed to examine the validity and reliability of writing measures for English-fluent students. The constructed passages consisted of basic instructions. Passages constructed at a 4.3 grade level. On the other hand, curriculum based passages consisted of complex sentences with Flesch-Kincaid readability levels ranging from a 5.8 to 6.0 grade level. The curriculum based passages picked from a third-grade text used in the district (Heather p.293).
The copying task was completed after two days. The researcher compared the work to the original passage for; words written, words spelled correctly, and correct minus incorrect words. The criterion variables in the study were the teachers’ ratings, the Test of Emerging Academic English and the Minnesota Basic Skills Test. The study used criterion –related validity to assess the subjects behaviour in copying comprehensions (Heather p.294).
Heather (p.297) Conducted descriptive analysis for each scoring procedure. The researcher examined the Scoring procedures to determine which had sufficient alternate-form reliability. After which the researcher calculated the Pearson’s r or Spearman’s rho coefficients using the criterion measures (teacher ratings, MBST, TEAE, and TOWL–3) for sufficiently reliable procedures so as to determine their criterion validity. Maturation is one of the internal validity that might affect the results of the findings. The students may become intellectually enlightened or motivated within a short time and influence the research findings. In other circumstances, they may get irritated or discouraged, and this will affect the study findings (Best and Khan p. 54).
The findings of the study may not be reliable, because the study maily used Somali participants yet bilingual students are heterogeneous. These somali students used in the study did not have background knowledge in English; therefore could have copied the passage differently compared to those that have background knowledge in English. Lastly Type II error could occur because of the restricted range of scores in the analysis leading to the rejection of some scoring procedures used by the researcher (Heather p.298).
The implications of the findings are; it will be easy for teachers to use passage copying task to test the students comprehension ability this is because it is not time consuming. Teachers can also apply the technique because the task of passage copying can be applied to all levels of ELL. Lastly when critically observed some of the scoring procedures for the passages CWS and CW, CWS, CIWS seem to be adequate enough for comprehension testing (Heather p.211).
Heather (p.299) noted that the use of measures over time to monitor writing development among the bilingual students is questionable. Frequent monitoring, may help teachers modify their instructional methods, and this in turn, will help students develop writing skills. However, passage copying does not provide evidence of the students writing abilities, and it is mainly useful as a, grouping, screening or progress monitoring tool. Therefore, more research still needs to be conducted in order to determine that these results are valid for testing students writing abilities.
Works cited
Best, John and Khan, Vincent. Research Methods Qualitative and Quantitative. New York:Approaches African Century foR Techonology Studies. 2008.
Heather, Campbell. The Technical Adequacy of Curriculum-Based Measurement
Passagem Copying With Secondary School English Language Learners. LLC, St. Olaf Avenue, Northfield: Taylor & Francis Group.2010 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities Research Paper)
“Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities

Analysis of Articles about the Poverty Issue the development of plans and engaging non-governmental organizations. Importance The article is beneficial because it offers official poverty data as released by the government, which includes the approach of the government in addressing the issues associated with poverty eradication and analysis. The article covers the basic issues of governance in relation to the success of programs and poverty levels in the society. In fact, the whole article deals with the evaluation of the various levels and rates of poverty in history and the role of economic development in shaping the behavior of the citizens. Poverty index and rates is a measure of the welfare of the citizens and involves coming up with new programs with an...
4 Pages(1000 words)Article

Article writing about corrlational stuies

...and writing are ‘less predictive value than the math scores.’ Writing, which is the most problematic type of test, is the least predictive. As the researcher himself has suggested, a comparative analysis with the scores of native speakers would have yielded a more interesting and relative result to this study. Since it was confounded to the 271 ESL students, it was impossible to know the difference as there is no vantage point to compare it with. Obtaining another set of non-ESL students would have predicted whether the problem really does benchmark itself on the language barrier or rather it is a common or mean testing score regardless of the primary...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Article Writing about FingerID systems. Federated access management systems [40] can be defined as the access management systems that provide unified access to multiple web services and organizations rather than a single web service. Single login credentials are needed to access multiple web accounts. The federated access management systems claim to provide unified access to all access management systems but in reality, they fail to cater to this requirement. Federated access management systems only provide access to a limited number of web services- a set of web services that would be associated with a certain organization. Therefore, federated access management systems will also bring about the need of remembering multiple login details....
4 Pages(1000 words)Article

Writing Deficiencies

...students develop better writing skills through the method of modified sentence combining technique. In this technique errors figured out in specific sentences are informed to the students and then the teachers provide information regarding how these errors can be eliminated and reduced. Researchers even assert that if teachers start giving importance to sentences while grading students, sentence structuring will become better as students will learn about the errors they have made. Researchers even assert that teachers have to act as grammar police and the only way students can learn how to write in an...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Writing Assignment

...Disaster Personality A sound disaster personality would help save a lot of lives. Despite the dynamic horrors of disaster situations, this personality can be exercised to make it make it strong. Looking at the three cases that Amanda Ripley presents, one trait stands out in all the heroic survivors of these tragedies. This is the belief that one’s safety and survival is a responsibility of one’s self and not entirely other people’s (Lee 17). Amanda reckons that we experience disasters in unique ways alongside our identical basic reactions we all harbor. It is important to live in circumspection. Disaster experts have developed better ways of detecting disasters and disseminating information about impending disasters...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Writing activities

... Assignment Writing Activities 2 In a brief essay, compare the quality of your off-line friendships with the quality of social media friendships. What is special or attractive about each kind of friendship? Life has changed over the years and globalization has totally connected and tied the world together. Gone are the days when people had to wait for days to receive each other’s mails and communicate with one another. The world has become a small place and communication has become very effective. A person can convey his message with just one click. Social networking websites are also another tool which have aided in this process. Though these innovations have brought with them many positive effects, negativities have also been... are...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Writing activities

..., such as when companies stop these harmful practices and change them to regain consumer trust. Aside from forcing corporations to be environmentally-conscious, consumers are also compelling companies to care for what the former care about. Consumers are now using their purchasing power to change unethical corporate practices. For instance, when Americans knew about the sweatshops of Nike in Indonesia and China, consumers forced Nike to change their contractors’ workplace conditions and wages when they boycotted the company’s products (Nisen). These are only some of the many examples how consumer power is social and political power too. Furthermore, consumer spending is a significant component in...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

Writing assignment

...A Fitness Center of A fitness center Fitness center entails erecting a premise that caters for training purposes. The aspect is for all people whether they are seeking to be fit, or they are maintaining their fitness. The most probable place, to position the center, would be around an urban center. An urban center hosts a population that has passive life due to the nature of the daily work. The population would thus be an ideal market. How to make it a success The fitness center popularity would be through marketing procedures. The instance would include price cuts for consistent participants, adverts through local channels and the organization of events that would focus on the establishment of the business. Why it can be popular... Fitness...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Writing assignment

...about the importance of learning and reciting. Spitzer also did a similar test that proved that Gates’ reciting was a form of a self-test that ensured good results. A further experiment on the importance of pretests was done by Bjork who suggested that the test force some kind of thinking into the brain that would not have been easy to get without the test at first. With a test, the fluency of the mind is improved and one tends to get the right answers. A biological explanation has been given that tries to distinguish remembering and learning. The latter is harder as there are various sets of information that need to be associated. Pretesting assists in bringing about the associations. Pretesting,...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Writing assignment

...Writing Assignment Summary Challenge success seeks to provide with research based s that prepare the students for the future by offering them essential skills to handle the unforeseen challenges in the future. The programme seeks to change the focus of education training on passing exam to provision of life skills (Challenge Success, 2013). This programme seeks to avail college level courses at high school level. This will be able to give students advantage in college, narrow the achievement gaps, enrich students’ high school experiences, and make the schools with the programme better. Although the betterment of the students undergoing through the...
1 Pages(250 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Analysis of the Article About The Students Writing Abilities for FREE!

Contact Us