StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The recent proposal to involve prisoners in the American correctional centers in medical trials is reminiscent of the infamous Tuskegee Syphilis medical experiment that remains one of the most embarrassing events in American medical history. Using human beings for medical experiments does not only elicit safety issues, but moral and ethical concerns as well…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research"

Download file to see previous pages Using prisoners for medical trials to develop cure for HIV and hepatitis virus is not humane considering the fact they live in an environment that restricts freedom including liberty of movement and expression in addition to poor medical care access. For a person to be engaged in a medical trial, the individual must make voluntary consent that is well informed about the implications of the experiment on his health. In addition medical practitioners and other stakeholders should make adequate compensation schemes to take care of the patient should the experiment go wrong and result to life threatening medical conditions on the person (Benedek, 1978). Lack of adequate information and poor social economic status of people used in Tuskegee syphilis studies and Holmesburg prison experiments exposed them to life limiting disorders and death. In typical correctional centers, prisoners do not have any source of income because of limitation of movement. In addition, they live in a repressive environment where they could be easily coerced by prison officers to make uninformed decisions. In case of Tuskegee syphilis study, poor peasants with low literacy levels were subjected to syphilis infection, without their informed consent (CDC, 2009). According to Benedek (1978, p47), the peasants were falsely made to believe that they were being treated of “bad blood” only to be infected and later denied treatment of syphilis in spite of the availability of curative medicine. In a period of forty years, 28 of the subjects had died of syphilis, 100 succumbed to syphilis related complications and over forty women infected with the sexually transmitted disease. In addition, many children were infected with the infection during birth causing life-limiting disabilities. Due to poverty and ignorance, the little amount of money that medical experts gave to Tuskegee residents enticed them to participate in the lethal experiment (CDC, 2009). At Holmesburg prison, the prisoners were enticed with several hundred dollars to try uncertified skin medications and potentially harmful dermatological procedures (Albarelli, 2002). The procedure inflicted the prisoners with severe physical and psychological disorders, consequences that they had not been well informed about (Allen 1999). Both Tuskegee and Holmesburg medical trials involved poor and minority black Americans. This demonstrates that using meager financial inducements pharmaceutical companies can exploit ignorance and repressive prison conditions to win the consent of the prisoners for medical trials. Prisoners enjoy lower protection from the government than other citizens and even animals used for medical experiments (BES, 2007). Therefore, using them for medical trials is tantamount to exploitation, rendering the entire experimental process unethical. Following events of Tuskegee and Holmesburg experiments, the government passed legislations to safeguard the wellbeing of people used in medical trial. However, in spite of the reforms, the present conditions in prison deny the prisoners with an opportunity of making voluntary consent to medical experiments (Albarelli, 2002). As long as the research is directed by wealthy and influential pharmaceutical companies to poor, vulnerable populations, the trials will continue ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1431637-medical-experimentation-another-tuskegee-study-or
(Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research Essay)
https://studentshare.org/education/1431637-medical-experimentation-another-tuskegee-study-or.
“Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1431637-medical-experimentation-another-tuskegee-study-or.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research

Medical Physiology

D. Smooth muscle cells: Though smooth muscle cells are recruited by day 3 or 4 of the wound along with fibroblasts, myofibroblasts, pericytes, and smooth muscle cells, their main role is fibroplasia, synthesis of connective tissue matrix, tissue remodeling, wound contraction, and wound strength. They do not produce cytokines and chemoattractants (Sephel, 72). Hence this is not the correct answer.
A 68-year-old man with prostate cancer and bone metastases presents with shaking chills and fever. The peripheral WBC count is 1,000/uL (normal = 4,000-11,000/uL). Which of the following terms best describes this hematologic finding?
A. Leukocytosis: This is not the correct answer because leukocytosis means an increase in WBC co...
14 Pages(3500 words)Case Study

Research Methodologies and Their Application to Counseling

Data must be subjected to the thinking process in terms of ordered reasoning.

Descriptive Research describes and interprets what it is. It is concerned with conditions of relationships that exist; practices that prevail; beliefs, processes that are going on; effects that are being felt, or trends that are developing.

The process of descriptive research goes beyond mere gathering and tabulation of data. It involves the elements or interpretation of the meaning or significance of what is described. Thus description is often combined with comparison and contrast involving measurements, classifications, interpretation, and evaluation.

In other words, descriptive research may be defined as the purposive...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper

Country Study: Mali

The territory of Mali has had a great history. We have been centers of the Ghana Empire, the Mali Empire, and the Songhai Empire for about six centuries. Thereafter, during the 17th and 18th centuries, several small states developed along the Niger basin, but they fell during the holy war waged by Muslim leader Al-Hajj Umar, whose kingdom extended from Timbuktu to headwaters of Niger and Senegal. His successor, Ahmadu was defeated by the French in 1860. (http://us-africa.tripod.com /mali.html)

As is well-known, we have had a turbulent past. We were a French colony for 80 years until we achieved independence. Now we are a multi-party democracy with Presidential form of Government. While the executive power rests with the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Medical Radiographic Technique for Dealing with the Pediatric Patients

This poses a challenge in pediatric radiographic investigations. Obtaining quality radiographs on pediatric patients can be a challenge. Minimizing radiation dose in pediatric imaging is a crucial issue that has been emphasized and reemphasized in recent years1.
Diagnostic radiation overexposure can cause radiation skin reactions and acute radiation sickness. It can also lead to systemic reactions that may lead to disturbances of normal functional processes, such as, radiation pneumonitis. It is known to have carcinogenic effects and genetic effects2. However, it is also to be considered that the dose required to produce genetic or carcinogenic effects are virtually precluded by modern radiographic apparatus and special techn...
13 Pages(3250 words)Assignment

Marketing Research Plan: Old Navy

Gap’s credit ratings thereby limiting access to the capital market, international trade matters which may be disruptive of the supply chain, changes to its IT systems disruptive of operations, changes in the IT services agreement with IBM that can disrupt operations and produce adverse effects on financial results, international expansion through franchising and other arrangements may impair the value of its brands if unsuccessful, products are subject to risks associated with overseas outsourcing and manufacturing, and failure of vendors to adhere to Gap’s code of vendor conduct could harm the business. From available data in the 2007 Annual Report, both the Gap and Old Navy brands have exhibited declining net sales....
11 Pages(2750 words)Business Plan

Research Methods in Linguistics

 The writer of content tries to preserve his/her culture and also wants his/her culture to get attached to his/her recent living due to which, he/she makes use of the bilingual aspect to write a narrative.

Because of this writing, the English reader faces some problem in decoding the meaning but he/she realizes the presence of another culture by means of this writing. Many writers provide a glossary at the end so that the readers face no problem in decoding the words given in another language such as Soueif has done but many take it for granted that readers know the other language as well.

The article contains a detailed evaluation of the novel by Soueif which can be categorized as the strength of the re...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Developing a Research Base for Intravenous Peripheral Cannula Resites

... for this study. This was very much appropriate for this type of study. According to Pildal, et al (2005), Randomized Controlled Trial or RCT is best for medical or health related studies. It ensures efficiency and accuracy as long as the number of subjects are enough to represent the population. In addition, confounding may be prevented by using this type of research method. The control group followed the protocol of transferring the peripheral venous catheter to a different site every 3 days, or as clinically indicated. On the other hand, the intervention group only transferred the peripheral catheter when clinically indicated. The independent variable for this research is relocation of the peripheral venous catheter. Treatment...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Conflict Between Researh and Ethics on the Tuskegee Syphilis Study

The Declaration of Helsinki by the WHO clearly states that in clinical trials involving humans the wellbeing of the subject should be of prime importance than the interest of science or society. This has been stated because at times in order to achieve the objectives of a study the investigators might overlook the welfare of the trial subjects thus jeopardizing their health in the process. According to ethical rules while comparing two treatment options the control group of the study must receive the best-known treatment available while the study subjects are given a potential newer treatment. Only when there is no effective treatment available a placebo-controlled group can be used for the study. There have been several trials th...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

A Framework for Critiquing Quantitative Research Papers

Relevant information of methods used from the Multifactorial Attitudes Questionnaire, Kruskal- Wallis test to ordinal regression have been elaborated.  The results, conclusions, and recommendations are clarified in the research work. Potential benefit is that it makes participants recognize that old need to be given care and inspire attitude change. The harm is that the participants may demand more from their employees relating to the topic. Approval of the Ethics Committee is noted. The findings are categorically explained. The themes include ageism, resources, professional esteem, and working environment. The findings have been explained under each sub-heading. The data have been presented with regard to each question an...

13 Pages(3250 words)Assignment

The Legalization of Medical Cannabis

The federal government, through the 2009’s Controlled Substances Act, makes the use of marijuana a criminal offense. However, various states, such as Arizona, Colorado, and California, have legalized the use of cannabis for therapeutic purposes. This paper presents an argument that marijuana should be made legal for its therapeutic uses.
The legalization of medical cannabis is justified because of the positive therapeutic effects of the drug. Proponents of the legalization of medical cannabis argue that if marijuana is made illegal, patients will not be able to access and use it for the relief of their symptoms (Gwynne 29). Marijuana has been reported to be a safe drug for the treatment of various conditions. The drug a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Medical Experimentation: Another Tuskegee Study or Beneficial Research for FREE!

Contact Us