StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This report seeks to discuss the phenomenon of off shoring business to third world counties, the business reasons for such policy decisions, the salaries and work conditions in these countries and ultimately the ethics of such practices. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap"

? Businesses that move to third world countries pay cheap-Morality and business ethics or plain business sense Business relocating to third world countries pay cheap Introduction Over the past decade there have been several instances of businesses relocating their factories to third world countries. With costs of manufacturing and labour going up significantly in the developed countries of US, Germany and France, companies are looking to offshore their factories to lower cost nations in order to capture newer markets and also to manage their balance sheets since most of these third world countries provide cheap labour. Data also suggest that there is no truth to the fact that cheaper countries would inevitably mean poor quality of products. This report seeks to discuss the phenomenon of off shoring business to third world counties, the business reasons for such policy decisions, the salaries and work conditions in these countries and ultimately the ethics of such practices. Trends There have been several instances of how businesses have been able to consolidate themselves by moving to low cost countries. Emerson Electric had devised this strategy way back in the 70’s when it moved its operations to countries in North America and Western Europe. These countries now account for 44% of manufacturing labour expenses and has seen profits shore up for the company with it being able to provide a 19.8% dividend for a shareholder. (Vestring Till, Rouse Ted, Reinert Uwe & Varma Suvir, 2005) General Electric has seen significant relocation to China in early 2000 and its sourcing costs grew to four billion USD by 2005. General Motors also has significant operations in China with auto parts being sourced to the tune of 10 billion US dollars. (Vestring Till et al, 2005) White Goods Co which had about 85% of its manufacturing taking place in first world countries had to face stiff competition from their Korean rivals who were not only making rapid progress in the knowledge field but also had access to cheap labour. With these factors in mind, White Goods started manufacturing specific parts of its product in third world countries. Data shows that this off shoring has lead to it being able to compete with its Asian counterparts like Haier, LG and Samsung. (Vestring Till et al, 2005) Source: Bain & Company, 2005. Reasons There are several reasons attributing to this shift of both the service sector and the manufacturing factories to third world countries. Apart from cheap labour that is available, people in these countries have become a highly educated workforce in terms of manufacturing, R&D and engineering. Countries like India and China have succeeded in providing cheap labour while at the same time maintaining quality. Data shows that 77 global companies have set shop in India. (Vestring Till et al, 2005) Cost of manufacturing in countries like Taiwan and Singapore is one fourth of the cost of manufacturing the same component in countries like Germany. Other reasons why some of these third world countries attract off shoring of factories is that it enables these MNC’s to expand market base. Having a manufacturing hub in Asia or Latin America helps them to cut transportation costs and engage in expanding business operations in these countries. Emerson for example has put up shop in Asia and Mexico with its engineering and manufacturing being done at China, India and Philippines. Source: Bain & Company, 2005 Another major factor is the wide disparity in wages paid in the West and those in third world countries. A job that would require 20-30 dollars/ hour to be paid in the West could be completed in about 1 dollar/hour in China. (Vestring Till et al, 2005) Human right laws and adherence to such practices are also questionable in these countries. Severe lack of job opportunities, inflation and rising poverty indexes make employees work under harsh conditions without questioning authority. These have prompted civil society to question whether this kind of manipulation and exploitation of the third world is fair or whether companies are justified in doing so to keep their business alive and sustainable. Working conditions and payments The working conditions, access to basic amenities for the employed, minimum wages and questionable labour laws regarding work schedule means the people are forced to work under demanding conditions. A case study of the garment industry from around the world is carried out to ascertain the working conditions of those employed in this industry. The industrial term for such factories are ‘sweatshops’ which employ workers at low wages and force them to work in unhygienic conditions for a long period of time. (VIDEA, 2000) It is said that the garment industry in Central America employs 80% women between the age group of 14-26. At Doall, a Korean company operating in El Salvador that makes the famous LizWear and Liz Claiborne fashions; women are made to work from 6.50 am to 10.30 pm with two half hour breaks, one for lunch and the other for dinner. In the rush hour months they have to work for 7 days week clocking roughly 90 hours. Source: Sweatshop at El-Salvador, VIDEA, 2000 To prevent them from sleeping, the company also encourages them to take a ‘No Doze’ pill which is a highly unethical practice. For the first eight hours these workers are paid 60 cents an hour and 1.20 dollars per hour as overtime. (VIDEA), 2000) To sum up a worker would be paid 8.40 dollars for an arduous 11 hour shift which is considered far below the minimum wage requirement. The Liz Claiborne collection is however marketed as very modern, fashionable and sophisticated dress around the world. However if indications are to show the working conditions at the Doall factory in El Salvador is anything but sophisticated. Apart from low wages, the working conditions are pathetic. Air that is full of dust and lint cause breathing problems, skin rashes and other kind of allergies. Bathroom breaks are limited and workers are obligated to work overtime. Failure to adhere to these norms results in suspension or withholding of ‘attendance’ bonuses. Apart from these excesses, new workers are forced to take blood and pregnancy tests to prevent employing pregnant women. Women in the ironing and cleaning sections are forced to stand all day causing inflammation in the feet and working ambience is especially unpleasant with supervisors yelling at them for not being able to meet targets. Employers know that any kind of trade unionism with the nature of work involved would cause severe problems for the company. Hence any kind of activity to that effect either by way of organization or by distributing trade union literature is considered subversive. Studies carried out by National Interfaith Committee for Worker Justice Workers in factories of Lavapant, Vaqueros and Cantabria indicate that workers were not paid overtime even though they had worked over 60 hours. (VIDEA, 2000) This is in violation to the Mexican labour law which clearly states that maximum eight hours during the day, seven hours during night and that the first nine hours of overtime are to be paid at double the standard rates. Reports also show that child labour with pathetic wages was being employed in these factories. Statically tabulating the wages, it showed that while a worker in the third world country was paid 60 cents an hour, the same work fetched a person in Canada 9.77 dollars an hour and 10.06 dollars an hour for someone employed in the US. For a Claiborne jacket that was sold around the world at 178 dollars, a worker in the Doall factory at El Salvador was paid 74 cents for the stitching the same. (VIDEA, 2000) The ethics of such practices The ethics of companies off shoring factories to third world countries and managing their business by paying meagre salaries and violating several labour laws regarding minimum wages and working hours are being debated constantly. It is true that to an extent the developed countries do not promote the growth of indigenous industries as it would severely impact their business. Import duties in rich countries on a variety of goods are high which discourages third world countries in developing their own industry. (Birdsall Nancy, Rodrik Dani and Subramanian, 2005) Some multinational companies on the other hand, through questionable deals are able to start shop in these economies and employ cheap labour while at the same time market the finished product to the outside world at exorbitant prices. It was quoted that the money paid to Michael Jordan for promoting its products was more than the total salaries paid to 30,000 Indonesian workers who had toiled to stitch the sport shoes of this global brand. (Meyers Chris, 2004) Apart from meagre salaries the other accusation that has been made against these companies is that expansion of their factories has been made with scant respect to environment. Green house emission gas, water pollution and decreasing agricultural productivity in these host nations are some of the other issues that developing countries need to focus on. The other side of the argument that is made by these multinationals is that in the present context access to cheap labour is the only way forward for sustainability. They argue that the wages paid in these third world companies must not be compared with the wages paid in US, UK or Germany because of their higher standards of living. (Starak Yaro, 2010) The money paid in these poorer countries is well above the average salary being paid in the native country. Higher wages would mean lesser number of people employed and fewer opportunities for companies to expand their business. The argument made is also that none of the people have been forcibly employed and the only reason why they work there is because of the lack of job opportunities elsewhere. They point out the economies of South Korea and Taiwan that have benefited from sweatshop labour. Other examples to prove that such employment have benefited countries are Philippines and Zimbabwe. Manila in Philippines was once considered as the garbage dump of the world and lot of people were employed in waste scavenging and recycling scrap parts. (Krugman, March 1997) The growth story of Philippines is remarkable since such off shoring of such jobs have boosted their economy making Philippines one of the principal providers of labour in the world. Zimbabwe which was also relegated to the bottom has witnessed a boost in economy. Tie ups with the UK vegetable market, employing cheap labour that uses handpicking fresh vegetables, transporting these using old Boeing aircrafts from Harare airport and imposing less duties on entry to UK have meant a win-win situation for both Zimbabwe and UK. (Krugman, March 1997) Conclusion Several multinational companies over the last decade have relocated their factories and businesses to third world countries. This to an extent has managed to open up the economy of these countries by generating employment and also creating foreign exchange. In the face of stiff competition from emerging economies like China the concern of the business houses to look for cheaper avenues of manufacturing is true and needs to be considered. There are several examples of factories in third world countries running as per the stated labour laws of the particular nation but the number of companies doing it otherwise far exceeds those doing it ethically. It is therefore imperative that a fine balance needs to be struck between these extremes since it ultimately boils down to the question of human dignity, basic rights of fair wages, ethical business practices and whether you as a company or a consumer would want to be associated with a product that has been manufactured at the cost of another’s misery. References 1. Vestring Till, Rouse Ted, Reinert Uwe & Varma Suvir, 2005, Making the move to low-cost countries, Bain & Company, p.p 1-12 2. Birdsall Nancy, Rodrik Dani and Subramanian, August 2005, How to help poor countries, Foreign Affairs Volume 84 No4, p.p. 136-152. 3. Krugman, March 1997, In praise of cheap labour: bad Jobs at bad wages are better than no jobs at all, Slate, p.p. 80-84. 4. Meyers Chris, 2004, Wrongful beneficence: exploitation and third world sweatshops, Journal of Social Philosophy Vol 35, No 3, p.p. 319-333. 5. Victoria International Development Education Association (VIDEA), 2000, Sweatshops: clothes-the real cost of the clothes you buy, Global Citizens for a Global Era Vol 1,Issue 1, p.p. 1-10. 6. Starak Yaro, May 2010, Is Outsourcing Exploitation, Retrieved 12nd November, 2012 from www.entrepreneurs-journey.com/.../is-outsourcing-exploitation Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap Essay”, n.d.)
Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1461250-business-relocating-to-third-world-countries-pay-cheap
(Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap Essay)
Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap Essay. https://studentshare.org/business/1461250-business-relocating-to-third-world-countries-pay-cheap.
“Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1461250-business-relocating-to-third-world-countries-pay-cheap.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Business Relocating to Third World Countries Pay Cheap

Several Examples of Factories in Third World Countries

Rising production costs have also played its part in these companies moving their factories to other third world countries where cheap labor is available.... Statically tabulating the wages, it showed that while a worker in the third world country was paid 60 cents an hour, the same work fetched a person in Canada 9.... One case study of the garment industry from around the world is carried out to ascertain the working conditions of those employed in this industry....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Business Strategy for a Clothing Retail Store

third world countries are winning the battles on the basis of their cheap cost.... All major companies have production units outside of the country and they are able to exploit the cheap labor of the third world countries.... This will mainly be achieved through outsourcing the production to third world developing countries.... The paper "business Strategy for a Clothing Retail Store " will begin with the statement that the demand for clothing has always been high in the United Kingdom....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Moving a business to Nigeria. Political and Legal, Demographics, Culture And Human Development Index

Although the high population may indicate availability of cheap labor, lack of sufficient funds from the government towards education leads to lack of quality human resource.... This gives USA an upper hand while using these figures to compare quality of workforce between the two countries.... This shows that Nigerians are hardworking and creative relative to many countries in Africa but certainly not the USA which has the biggest and most developed movie industry in the world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Internationalization of Chinese Companies

Phenomenal growth of Chinese economy over years significantly affects the world economy due to its sheer size and wider domestic market.... “As a member of the world Trade Organization, China benefits from access to foreign markets.... Introduction In the past 30 years, Chinese economic growth has become the world's third largest economy.... This project analyzes the economic situation in China, its relationship to the development of global brands by Chinese companies and its impact on world markets....
43 Pages (10750 words) Dissertation

Contemporary Issues in Business in Primark

In addition, it has been evaluated that the company may face certain deep impacts if it sources its products from developing countries/third world countries.... Additionally, the paper also aims to highlight various reasons for which the company focuses upon developing and third world countries in relation to the sourcing of its products.... It focuses upon delivering quality products at cheap prices and at the same time retaining the customers by way of creating value for the goods which are manufactured....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

The Benefits of Outsourcing

ost multinational companies especially from developed countries have in the recent time relocating to developing countries where labour is cheap in order to maximize on production and save on the cost of production.... This is made possible by the mobility characteristic of capital where a firm can move it to new location where labour is cheap and available. ... The act of locating a business in a region where there is availability of cheap labour so as to reduce the cost of production is what is called outsourcing....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Globalization at General Electric

Moreover, GE has presence in 160 countries of the world and total number of employed people at GE on December 2009 was 304,000.... Currently, GE is offering products and services related to Appliances, Aviation, Consumer Products, Electrical Distribution, Energy Products, Finance and business Products, Health Care, Lighting, Media and Entertainment, Oil & Gas, Rail, Software & Services and Water (General Electric, 2010).... After pursuing international expansion strategy, the second aim was to make GE a truly global company because it was still very much an American company doing business abroad....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Why Canadians Cannot Compete with Lower Labour Cost Countries such as India and China

On the other hand, China has been the globe's manufacturing hub, leveraging its cheap labor in order to dominate global trade, especially the nation's exports (Sang, 2013).... The ever increasing global business environment has made several countries adopt strategies that would enable them survive the cut-throat global competition.... Besides, the telecommunication industry in India is the world's fastest growing.... After the quarter of 2013, India became the third largest market for smartphones globally after China and the United States of America (Drèze & Amartya (2013)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us