Nobody downloaded yet

The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs Name Subject Professor Date The diversity of cultural norms and practices necessarily indicate the differences in what are morally acceptable with one group and how this may be different with another…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs"

Download file to see previous pages But ultimately there are conduct and actions that are acceptable or at the very least inoffensive and which holds in it a universal truth of applicability. In a directly inverse rationalization of the same concept, there are things that are inherently wrong no matter which corner of the world the same is committed. Lenn Goodman in “Some Moral Minima” exemplified on the assumption that there are inherently wrong things that would never pass any test of appropriateness. This assertion was based on four instances Goodman relates as ‘Deserts’ or expressions which distinguish human beings. His discourse on the verity of this proposition revolved around 1. genocide and induced famine, 2. terrorism and other acts such as hostage taking, 3. slavery, incest and polygamy and 4. rape and clitoridectomy or the removal of a female’s pleasure organ. The author recognizes the commonality among the enlisted illustration of wrongful acts because “All the wrongs my proposed norms speak against drag with them some violation of the truth. Not that truth is somehow the arch-imperative from which all others rise, as if by deduction. But the linkage does suggest a way of looking at (or looking for) key moral norms” (Goodman, 2010, p.92). Essentially this argument is in direct contradiction to relativism which suggests that what constitutes right and wrong is dependent upon every culture, person or society. This truly is an appealing take on ethical perspectives because it creates a very wide ground to exonerate wrongful acts as long as they are permitted at any one exception. It qualifiedly extinguishes the distinction between right and wrong whenever relativism is accurately applied. “This approach seems to allow us to avoid having to defend ethical claims that can be difficult to defend; however, others maintain that relativism has certain crippling problems” (Mosser, 2010, p.11). The adherence to relativism would render the argument of Goodman devoid of any merit in the same way that Goodman’s proposition is in direct contradiction to relativism. Goodman did make a direct mention of relativism as the same was inevitable due to the conflict between the concepts. There are cultural and individual distinctions which qualify and fundamentally affect the customs of normal life. But emphasis was divulged in that people can deliberately perplex every given situation to distort the same through the simplistic reasoning that is anchored in relativism. There are objective values that are to be upheld above all others. This is not to say that they are absolutely unjustified but that they are not to be used indiscriminately. The opposition to relativism in the essay was delved into with Goodman’s suggestion that polygamy is among those that are simply wrong. “Relativists will say that romantic love and companionate marriage are recent inventions, culture-bound and fraught with troubles of their own… But to say that an institution has a history or cultural setting does not imply that any alternative to it is equally humane” (2010, p.91). This is among the arguments that I do agree with. Yes, it may be true that divorce does occur and it is virtually available in all countries, but this does not in any way lessen the value given to marriage by any culture. There are different rituals that occur and the celebration of which vary accordingly but this only goes to show that the same is given much import. Polygamy is even perhaps among the reasons which perpetuate the truth in why Goodman states ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs Essay”, n.d.)
The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1431452-assingment
(The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs Essay)
The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs Essay. https://studentshare.org/business/1431452-assingment.
“The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1431452-assingment.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs

Cultural Relativism and Universal Human Rights

...practices like custom with respect to dressing sense depends on some local custom and other practices like torture, slavery may be governed through universal standards and wrongly judged despite of the other differences that exist among the cultures. One of the arguments against ethical relativism is that the universal moral standards which tend to exist even when moral believes and practices vary among the various cultures. Cultural difference can be acknowledging in moral practices and believes and still holds that some of the beliefs and practices tend to be morally wrong (Velasquez, 2010). The theory of ethical relativism is considered to be false as...
15 Pages(3750 words)Essay

The wrongs of Obama Care

...? The Wrongs of Obama Care First and of The Wrongs of Obama Care 0 Introduction In a recent news report by Samuelson, the Internal Revenue Service issued a notice that explained the difference between full and part time workers with reference to the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), or otherwise known as the Obama Care, where such distinction is of particular importance as the Act demands employers to offer health insurance on the employment of their 50 or more full-time workers.1 Most Americans perceive that such act would not benefit both the employees and the companies, but it will only weaken the country’s employment rate and the economy. In addition, increasing the cost of health...
16 Pages(4000 words)Research Paper

Relativism-Religion

...? Relativism-Religion I. Introduction Allan Bloom’s book, Closing of the American Mind, is a powerful mind opener. It provides new dimensions of perception that get formed in the intuitive level of human mind; ideas that are difficult to express in words. This book almost makes a modern university graduate feel the lack of real education. In the modern America, most university students endure a level of intellectual frustration through his academic years. This book provides an understanding of the utility of ancient philosophy and is enriched with true knowledge of mankind’s existence. Bloom’s book portrays a critical view of the modern universities and their education...
21 Pages(5250 words)Term Paper

Cultural Relativism

...What is the definition of cultural relativism? Discuss some of the cultural mores in the memoir and how they affect the ordinary lives of the characters. Is it fair to judge these cultural norms or is it incorrect to compare our civilization to that China in the mid-20th century? Cultural relativism is related to a natural theory of evolution that views the cultural and linguistic diversity of human civilization globally as related to unique aspects of geographical isolation and parallel development. Maria Baghramian traces cultural relativism as back as Herodotus, and cites the woks of Montaigne, Dilthey ("Patterns of Culture"), and Frank Boas as the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Cultural Relativism

...? Cultural Relativism Cultural relativism refers to the individuality of cultures, their customs, ethics and beliefs. All cultures, as defined by cultural relativism, are entitled to their own way of doing things without being judged by others, because cultures have different moral standards. All cultures are also entitled to their own believes, in addition to having equal value. Cultural relativism as a concept also explains why it is right for a particular society to do something while it is morally wrong for another society to do the same thing. For example, it is considered morally wrong for a Muslim to eat pork while for person from another religion, eating pork has no negative impact on his/her morals. Cultural diversity... also...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ethical relativism

...Ethical relativism Ethical relativism is a situation where morals are not absolute, that right and wrong vary from one society to another. It is a situation where ethics are judged, not by the universal norms, but according to the society within which a circumstance calls for ethical clarification (Kim 209). Therefore, it can be stated that the morals are no longer absolute in different societies because of the fact that they have evolved over a long time changing considerably from one society to another. A good number of the proponents of this theory believe that morality was an invention of societies to maintain control over its members, and it is because of this that...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Cultural Relativism

...but is not universally acceptable. If relativism should be insisted through those practices, it will just imply the justification of things that might harm humans or in some extent would mean their death. Every cultures might have their own good sides, but human concern should not be bounded in a relativist point of view that what is good is relative. Good things remains to be good without looking after any cultural background. And if culture exist, then respect and tolerance should always remain on adhering to humane considerations. Respect of one’s belief is a responsibility of the scholar of religion most especially when it comes to fact finding. But it should be noted, that what the scholars...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Relativism

...Relativism It is undeniable that one of the most highly valued virtues is forgiveness. Many societies and cultures across the world consider forgiveness among the virtues that hold the society together. People are expected to forgive and forget the wrong done to them by others. Most of the cultures that are primarily based on Christianity uphold forgiveness as one of the top virtues. This is not surprising considering the fact that Christianity is based on forgiveness of sin. Likewise, Christian societies and cultures built on Christian grounds become a forgiving society. However, this is quite different from cultures based on Islam. Although Islamic religion upholds forgiveness as a virtue, there is an appreciable deviation... from this...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Cultural relativism

...al Affiliation Moral Relativism Introduction Moral relativism described as the view that morally based judgments are correct or right about a given standpoint. For example, two individuals may argue differently on the issue of wife battering in the society. While each of them has concrete reasons to support their arguments, there is no unique judgment made since each person views that they are right and the other one is wrong depending on their moral standpoint. Moral relativism does not support a particular argument but ensures that the judgments made on the basis of an individual’s morality are true according to that person’s moral standpoint (Russ 279). Difference ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Cultural Relativism

...and postmodernisms. In the video summary of James Rachel, he explains the elements of moral philosophy by first defining the meaning of morality. He gives an example of baby Theresa who was born without auxiliary functions of her brain, the baby is left so that her organs can be used to help others, and this creates an argument that life is worthless without better interaction with each other. The other side argues that using other person’s life to fulfil the other is wrong and unethical (Atran and Medin, 98). Rachel also continues to explain that different cultures have unique customs and different ways of thinking. This shows that it would be very hard for a particular individual of one culture to understand these...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Discord of Relativism in Relation to Universal Wrongs for FREE!

Contact Us