Nobody downloaded yet

On the debates pertaining to inference of an effect from its cause - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
On the debates pertaining to inference of an effect from its cause David Hume held that there are three conditions for inferring cause: 1) contiguity between the effect and the cause; 2) precedence of the cause in relation with the effect; and 3) constant presence of the cause whenever the effect is obtained (Cook and Campbell 1979, p…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.8% of users find it useful
On the debates pertaining to inference of an effect from its cause
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "On the debates pertaining to inference of an effect from its cause"

Download file to see previous pages 172). Taking off from Hume, John Stuart Mill “held that causal inference depends on three factors: first, the cause has to precede the effects; second, the cause and effect have to be related ; and third, other explanations of the cause-effect relationship have to be eliminated” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 182). In other words, the notion of causation and effect that can be found in the ideas of John Stuart Mill is that causation requires precedence of the cause from the effect, correlation, and that rival hypotheses are ruled out. For Cook and Campbell (1979), however, the most significant contribution of John Stuart Mill to the theory of causality pertains to his notions of the criteria, principles, or “methods” of agreement, differences, and concomitant variation. The principle of agreement “states that an effect will be present when the cause is present” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 182). The principle of difference “states that the effect will be absent when the cause is absent” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 182). Finally, the principle of concomitant variation “implies that when both of the above relationships are observed, causal inferences will be all stronger since certain other interpretations of the co-variation between the cause effects can be ruled out” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 182). According to Cook and Campbell (1979, p. ...
183) pointed out that “the concept of a control group is implicit here and is clearly central in Mill’s thinking about cause.” In 1913, Bertrand Russell “looked to physics and astronomy of his day as the most mature sciences, and he noted their lack of concern with unobservables and explicitness and parsimony of the functional relationships that physicists sought to test” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 172-173).1 However, Russell had asked that asked whether the concept of cause continues to be relevant given that cause “is not implied by functional relationships of mathematical form” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 173). The Russell viewpoint is positivist “rejecting unobservables (like cause), and seeking to establish explicit functional laws between continuously measured variables in a closed system” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 173). Positivists like Russell believe that “causation is unnecessary because it is unobservable” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 175). The essentialist viewpoint “argue that the term cause should only be used to refer to variables that explain a phenomenon in the sense that these variables, when taken together, are both necessary and sufficient for the effect to occur” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 177). The essentialists “equates cause with a constellation of variables that necessarily, inevitably and infallibly results in the effect” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 177). In contrast, those “who restrict cause to observable necessary and sufficient conditions (or sufficient conditions that operate when all the necessary conditions are met) reject as causes those factors which are known to bring about effects sometimes, but not always” (Cook and Campbell 1979, p. 177). ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“On the debates pertaining to inference of an effect from its cause Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(On the Debates Pertaining to Inference of an Effect from Its Cause Essay)
“On the Debates Pertaining to Inference of an Effect from Its Cause Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF On the debates pertaining to inference of an effect from its cause

Cause and effect

...Cause and Effect Technological advancement, especially the invention of the internet, has transformed the lifestyles of people. Technologies have changed almost everything, the way we work, communicate and learn. Today, human beings cannot envisage their lives without technological inventions and innovations. However, internet has negative effects on the modern American families. Technologies have influenced the relationships among parents and their kids, spouses, and other members of the society as demonstrated by Turtle (53). Technology has changed modern family lifestyles whereby both genders have assumed corporate roles. The use of technology has crumbled the elements that were the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Cause - Effect Assignment

..., television sets, computer monitors, refrigerators, and other electronic communication devices. Poor disposal of e-wastes poses several risks to human health and degrades environmental quality as they contain noxious metallic elements known to cause serious health complications. When the wastes are buried in landfills, toxic constituents can infiltrate into water systems and the soil, and finally reach our bodies. Should we sacrifice ourselves for the sake of technology? There has been a growing call for industry players to effect proper disposal of e-wastes, or to find alternative uses of the wastes, such as recycling and separating the components of the electronic devices for use in various industrial...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Cause and effect

...?CAUSE AND EFFECT Should Investment into Space Program be continued? Thesis and Introduction Continual investment into space program is necessary forthe future of the human race and the betterment of it. Research by the Cable News Network (2012) revealed that America is currently a divided country when it comes to the idea of whether or not investment into space program should be banned. Indeed, the survey revealed that 50% of respondents wanted the program banned whiles 50% wanted it continued (Adamu, 2012). But in this paper, a firm stand is taken on the need for the investment into space program to continue. Before specific advantages and merits associated with space program will be outlined, a general...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Economic Sustainability, Changing Labor Market through the EU Policies

...that a region must earn income in order to survive by producing goods or services that the outside world will purchase (Hughes, 2003). It is likewise in synergy with multilateral agreements that member-nations join, basically addressing the context of the input-output construct of the multiplier effect model. It hence arrives to an inference that the Union needs a strong consolidation in order to address the economic activities within its region and its competitiveness in the global level. 3.1. ) Economic Impacts A topic of political debates and legal reforms in European Union during the 1980s and 1990s has been the labor market, leading to the...
15 Pages(3750 words)Literature review

Cause and Effect

...Self-motivated Causes for Body Piercing” John Steinbeck once wrote, “(Doc) wears a beard and his face is half Christ and half Satyr and his face tells the truth" (29). While most people take beards as simply the hair growing on a man’s chin, this also shows that a man must prefer having a beard and there can be two reasons for this: The first possibility is culture, such as in the case of Jesus Christ. The other possibility is that he may have no time or care at all to shave it, such as in the case of a Satyr. In any case, we should not see a beard just as a beard but rather a reflection of a deeper truth about a person. Consequently, we should similarly examine body piercing or any kind of decoration, ornamentation or reshaping... find pain...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Cause and effect essay

...Many causes contribute to an individual talking on a cell phone while driving. The cause comes down to one reason; the individual has to talk or textthe individual calling or texting them. Their call is the most important in the world. A mother has to know what the babysitter wants. An employee has to answer his boss’ call. A child must take the call from the elderly parent. Teenagers have to answer their friends. Some people feel that every call must be taken. All of these are causes for people to talk on the cell phone while driving a car. The effects of driving while talking on the cell phone have been documented. “Cell phone distraction causes 2,600 deaths and 330,000 injuries in the United States every year” (Britt 2005... . A person on...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...Outline Introduction 2. What Is the Collective Bargaining Agreement? 3. The Lost Sports Season 4. The Economic Cost of Labor Strikes in Sports 5. The Need for Salary Caps 6. Conclusion 7. Works Cited The Cause and Effect of Labor Strike in Sports The businesses of the world rely on a constant flurry of activity and exchange of monetary considerations in order to remain effective and beneficial to all the parties concerned. In order to keep the money machine rolling, certain concessions and agreements must be reached by the business managers / owners and its employees / players. Parties agree that there is a need for equal sharing of the profits realized by the enterprises and endeavors that the employees participate in.However... , there are...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay


... Essay Cause/Effect According to a recent research conducted by Pew Research Center’s Internet and American Life Project in America, seventy-three percent of adults prefer to communicate via test message instead of voice call on their mobile phone. Moreover, eighty-three percent of the adults in America possess a mobile phone, though the medium of communication depends with situation. It is intriguing to learn that fifty five percent of people who use text messages can exchange up to fifty messages on a daily basis, thus they prefer texting to voice calls (Gahran, 1). Therefore, the paper will focus on identifying three reasons for the high preference of text messaging services compared to voice calls or sending e-mails. One... Essay...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Cause & Effect

...Causes and Effects Essay. Affiliation: who involve themselves in sports benefit from many opportunities in regards to their personal lives. Participating in physical activities improves performance in school and a student’s self-esteem. Improved academics is attributed to the fact that sports encourages students to work better in teams and gain leadership skills. The involvement and agility inspired by baseball enables Native American teenagers to be more involved in class as well as boost their connection to the school environment. Alexie writes about the life in the mascot school routine activities. Alexie Sherman’s book, "Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian” is based on experiences that relate...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Cause & Effect

...Arab Spring: Cause and Effect How the Arab Spring has failed to liberate the Arab World For many years, the Arab world has been under brutal conflicts with some degenerating into civil war. Although North Africa had had its fair share of revolt, the Middle East is undoubtedly the epicentre of Arab strife that has spilled over to many states that are not Islamic. In Africa, Libya, Egypt, Sudan, Morocco, and Algeria have all had a tethered past marred by civil strife and terrorism. Perhaps the propensity to revolutions and religious extremism that has rocked the Middle East for years has left more damage than the benefits it has brought (The Economist, 2014). In as much the Arab Spring has...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic On the debates pertaining to inference of an effect from its cause for FREE!

Contact Us