Free

Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The airing of ‘’Blackfish’’, a documentary about killer whales in captivity, by CNN has generated an intense debate about the captivity of orcas. The documentary shows the death of a trainer, Dawn Brancheau by an orca in captivity called Tilikum. The death is a reminder…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned"

Animal Captivity of Orcas Should be banned Animal Captivity of Orcas Should be banned The airing of ‘’Blackfish’’, a documentary about killer whales in captivity, by CNN has generated an intense debate about the captivity of orcas. The documentary shows the death of a trainer, Dawn Brancheau by an orca in captivity called Tilikum. The death is a reminder of the danger that orcas in captivity pose to their trainers. The documentary has prompted the state of California to introduce laws banning orca shows at SeaWorld (Martinez, 2014). In as much as several benefits arise from capturing orcas, the act is wrong.
Corporate greed and interests primarily drive keeping killer whales for amusement (Martinez, 2014). The need to maximize profits and minimize costs means that the welfare of the animals is neglected (Clemmit, 2010). Unlike the use of animals for medical research, this practice is merely for the amusement of the public.It serves no greater good besides giving people momentary pleasure. The death of Dawn Brancheau in a deadly encounter with the orca responsible for two other deaths shows the consequences of vested economic interests. It would have been prudent to ensure that such an animal does not encounter another human being.
The lives of trainers are endangered (Martinez, 2014). The documentary explores the death of Dawn Brancheau who was killed by a captive orca. The same orca had killed two other trainers. Although there are generally accepted occupational hazards, the death of three people by one animal is unacceptable. The animals are destabilized when they are away from their indigenous habitats making them violent.
The practice has a negative effect on the mental health of the animals. The film suggests that Tilikum had been driven to madness by his captivity (Martinez, 2014). Captured animals live in a restrictive environment causing them to undergo pain, distress and in extreme cases death. Many marine biologists believe that orcas are designed to travel millions of miles in a single day. The restricted environment makes them irritated and a danger to people (Martinez, 2014).
It is morally wrong to use animals for human amusement. The People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) has equated the practice to slavery (Martinez, 2014). It is morally wrong to inflict pain on one creature for the benefit of another. The animals have the ability to feel and should not be tortured (Clemmit, 2010).
Modern science is increasingly showing that animals are more complex creatures than expected (Clemmit, 2010). A good example is chickens which do not even qualify for Animal protection under the U.S Humane Slaughter Act. They have been found to have complex brains, perceptions and emotions (Clemmit, 2014).
Proponents of the practice argue that keeping of orcas in zoos is important for the growth of science and education. The industry enables people to have a personal and fulfilling experience with animals they would otherwise have never come across. Eleven million people visit SeaWorld annually to see killer whales (CNN, 2014). The experience is expected to create a better understanding of killer whales.
Conclusion
The Blackfish documentary has brought an interesting topic that is often ignored during environmental debates. While a case can be made for the use of animals in medical research, it would be difficult to argue their use in entertainment purposes. The danger they pose to their trainers and the resultant moral questions make the practice not worthwhile. In as much as their captivity contributes to the development of science and education, it is not reason enough to remove the animals from their environment. The government and authorities involved should take appropriate measures to ensure the practice is outlawed.
References
Clemmit, M. (2010, January 8) Animal Rights: Is the treatment of Animals improving? CQ
Researcher 20(1)1-24
CNN. (2013). ‘SeaWorld responds to questions about ‘orcas’ Captive film’.
Retrieved from http://edition.cnn.com/2013/10/21/us/seaworld-blackfish-qa/
Martinez, M. (2014). California Bill will ban orca shows at SeaWorld.
Retrieved from http://edition.cnn.com/2014/03/07/us/california-bill-orca-killer-whale-seaworld/ Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/biology/1643765-animal-captivity-of-orcas-should-be-banned
(Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned Essay)
https://studentshare.org/biology/1643765-animal-captivity-of-orcas-should-be-banned.
“Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/biology/1643765-animal-captivity-of-orcas-should-be-banned.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned

Banned Books

... enjoys freedom of the press and freedom of thought, the United States itself has experienced a long and sordid past with relation to censorship. This censorship has primarily been concentric around education in that certain individuals, teachers, parents and/or government officials have actively sought to ban certain “morally devious” material. Of course this action in and of itself opens Pandora’s box due to the fact that the first question that one must ask when posited such a statement is on whose interpretation of morality is “morally devious” based. Finally, it should be noted that although censorship can be implemented successfully for a period of time, as indicated by the reference to the Soviet Union, it inherently fails... to be...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Animal testing should not be banned

...being and indeed, animal testing should not be forbidden considering that animal testing is beneficial for science field. One of the primary reasons of performing animal experiment is that animal testing is beneficial for science field. Scientists and doctors argue that every achievement in medical field in 20th century has relied on the use of animals in some way. Thus, scientists have prior knowledge and experience of using animal testing in carrying out experiments for many years (“National Academics Press” 12.) First, animal testing plays an essential role in developing the surgical field. According...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper

Babylonian captivity

...Shavonte Evans Mr. Jackson History 101 of research: The Babylonian Captivity Babylonian captivity according to the history of the Israelites is that period between the fall of Jerusalem to the period of the reconstruction of a new jewish state in Israel, which was after 538B.C (Michael 45). Babylonian Exile, commonly referred to as Babylonian Captivity, is known for causing the forceful detention of the Jews in Babylonians after conquest of the Judah kingdom in 598/7, as well as in 587/6 BC (Michael 24). As history indicates, the exile ended in 538 bc, and it is the period in which the Persian conqueror of the Babylonians (Cyrus Great) allowed the Jews to return back to Palestine. This...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Animal

... Sur Supervisor How the Black Plague Changed Europe The word plague has its origin in Greek vocabulary – in a word plege that means stroke. The word refers to the speed with which disease brings down the infected person. The Plague – more commonly described as the Black Death played havoc in the medieval Europe during 14th century. The paper attempts to explore how the disease affected Europe during the time and then in subsequent years. The bubonic plague is known as a rat disease because it is not found at the places where rats are absent. Rats are hosts of a pathogen – a kind of bacillus known as Yersinia pestis. First time, it was identified in 1894 by a French bacteriologist and the pathogen was named after him... Sur Supervisor How the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Book Report/Review

Orcas in Captivity: Cognition and Behavior

...in cognitive development, but in a forceful and constrained manner. Works Cited Abramson, Jose Z., et al. "Experimental evidence for action imitation in killer whales (Orcinus orca)." Animal cognition (2013): 11-22. Print. Eaton, Randall L. "Orcas and dolphins in captivity." The animal ethics reader (2003): 447-451. Print. Ford, John KB, et al. "Dietary specialization in two sympatric populations of killer whales (Orcinus orca) in coastal British Columbia and adjacent waters." Canadian Journal of Zoology (1998): 1456-1471. Print. Greenwood, A. G. and D. C. Taylor. "Captive killer whales in Europe." Aquatic Mammals...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Why Animal Experimentation Should be Banned

...Why Animal Experimentation Should be Banned Introduction With the help of many different animal species, science has made significant inroads into combating some major diseases. However, it has all been without the animals’ consent, and it has not been without significant cost to human lives as well as millions of animals’ lives. In this report I will discuss scientific and ethical reasons against the use of animals in scientific experiments and will show that in the face of overwhelming evidence, such practices should be discontinued. There are two main categories of animal...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Captivity

.... As it has often been observed that the highly qualified professionals are confined to some specific task or job by the rich entrepreneur in the name of financial stability. Similarly, animals are made captive and confined into cages and snares for the entertainment of humans. But captivity is not restrained to encaging or physical confinement only. Rather, there are multiple forms of imprisonment and captivity. Renowned French philosopher of 18th century Jean Jacques Rousseau once said that man was born free, but everywhere he is in chains. The quote maintains depth of oceans in it due to the fact that man undergoes various kinds of captivities,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Exploration of Nazi captivity

...Exploration of Nazi Captivity Commenting or giving ones views on a historical event is always a challenge as one sees things as they are now and can never imagine the extremity of any past situation. The undertaken topic for discussion has been previously addressed in a brief account on “Slavery - Nazi vs American chattel”. Human history is full of books and records that are painted in bloodshed related to violence of the worst kind in the name of race, ethnicity and religion. Amongst the most brutal of these killing and blood shed was recorded in the time of World War II under the regime of Adolf Hitler. It is undoubtedly true that Adolf Hitler and slave owners exploited the unfortunates, using tragic inhumane...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Banned Books

...Banned Book: Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck Steinbeck’s novel Of Mice and Men is a story of two friends – George and Lennie – who dreamed of becoming rich someday despite the financial challenges of the Great Depression. However, in a series of unfortunate events, where Lennie was innocently involved in the death of the wife of the man for whom they are working as tenants, things changed from bad to worse. However, certain elements of the novel plus the idea that George shot Lennie at the back of his head somehow make people believe that the book should be banned. Of Mice and Men was banned because it demonstrates concerns regarding profanity especially as it mentions...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Captivity Narrative

...Captivity Narrative A loud bang, then heavy sounds of footsteps followed and they became clearer with time, apparently somebody was coming towards my direction. My stomach twisted, mostly due to fear, never minding the hunger pangs. I tried making much of my surroundings, but to no avail. My mouth appeared to freeze owing to the coolness. Everything was new to me. The room was stuffy with just one small tiny opening on the opposite wall where I sat, probably a window. I had never felt this scared, most of my life I was used to the comfort of our living room, and partly my bedroom. My memory has not made me any justice yet, I could not recollect how I had gotten into this mess. The door opened, creakily. My heart beat...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Animal Captivity of Orcas Should Be Banned for FREE!

Contact Us