Do native peoples today invent their traditions - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Do Native Peoples Today Invent Their Traditions Cultural anthropology is the science of the beliefs, ideas, practices and the history of human settlements, of the peoples of our world. The renowned anthropologist, Roger Keesing describes anthropology as “an exploration, an excavation of the cumulated, embodied symbols, of other peoples, a search for meanings, for hidden connections, for deeper saliences than those presented by the surface evidence of ethnography.” (Keesing, R) A variety of methods are used by anthropologists today, to study in depth, the various cultures of the world…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Do native peoples today invent their traditions
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Do native peoples today invent their traditions"

Download file to see previous pages Almost always there are valid arguments on both sides of the controversy. This, I believe is also the case in the arguments put forth by Keesing and Trask, in their difference of opinions, about whether native peoples today invent their traditions. However, I do think the arguments put forth by Trask more valid. Cultural anthropologist Roger M Keesing maintains, that the traditional culture accepted by the native people of the pacific is an invented version of their past, and that they do not really know what life was really like before the invasion of the white man. On the other hand, Haunani-Kay Trask, a Hawaiian scholar argues that Keesing relies only on western documentation, while the native people have sources like oral traditions and genealogies that western documentation does not take into account. I believe that this is a valid point because I think that there is a difference in perception between people of different cultures, and many native customs and nuances in dialects, may not be correctly understood by someone who is alien to that culture. There are subtle changes in the pronunciations of certain words in some dialects and these could convey a very different meaning. Trask herself is critical of the westerner’s understanding of native culture and the institutions therein, while Keesing too argues that “interpretation itself is fraught with difficulties, some perhaps ultimately intractable.” (Keesing, R) In the present debate, Keesing’s arguments are based on a collection of essays of Hobsbawm and Ranger, that conclude that cultures and traditions change over time due to a variety of factors. Most anthropologists agree that customs and traditions change over time. However to say that these have been invented to cater to the tourism industry, and the native people do not really know what life was like before western invasion; also is difficult to accept. It is a well documented fact, that in many cultures, knowledge and traditions were handed down orally from father to son spanning generations. For example in India the Vedic texts are said to have been orally passed on for generations. Although it may be argued that it may not have been handed down in its purest form, allowing for some changes as a result of verbal communication, to say that these traditions have been invented by native people in the recent past cannot be accepted. It must also be accepted that documentation of these traditions were mostly carried out by the western invaders, as the local people relied on verbal communication and not on the written word that was alien to their culture. As Trask argues, it is perhaps the native scholar rather than the western one who would be the better judge of whether the present traditions are those that have come down the ages or invented in the recent past. Having the advantage of being a native, the local anthropologist would be in a better position to understand the nuances of words, and their various meanings, as they were once used in bygone times, and the sum total of what has been handed down through the ages. Keesing accepts the fact that it is important to question ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Do native peoples today invent their traditions Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Do Native Peoples Today Invent Their Traditions Essay)
“Do Native Peoples Today Invent Their Traditions Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
Educating the Native Americans in Arizona: From 1891 Until Today
...can be described as a means of Anglo-conformity. It was a means by which the Federal government solved the problem of what to do with the Native Americans after the Indian Wars. Native Americans were seen as savages who needed to learn the ways of the pale-face in order to live within their society. The purpose of the boarding schools was to alienate the pupils from their families and forcibly change their cultural patterns. This included religion, language, and cultural practices, which would later be seen as a mistake by the Federal government. Luther Standing Bear notes that if they had only had the insight to see the importance of the traditional cultural, spiritual,...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper
Aboriginal (Native) Peoples of Canada: there Perspectives on Mental Disorders
..., which do not base their plans and policies on the perceptions of the Native people. To improve the Natives’ mental health, the organization recognizes that the communities must be supported to maintain their cultural diversity, traditional values, and beliefs. In addition, the aboriginal community must share social justice and economic opportunities with the non-aboriginal Canadians. Among the core principles upon which an all-inclusive and effective approach to treating mental disorders among the aboriginals of Canada include respect for the inherent worth of the aborigines, honour for their contribution to Canadian diversity and inclusiveness, and a...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper
Do native peoples today invent their tradition
...? Appreciating Human Diversity Anthropology Do native peoples today invent their tradition? Every society is endowed with a history, either hidden or utterly conspicuous in its norms. At the base of every community, are the native aborigines. These cliques of individuals bear a strong attachment and background to the community in question. Often, these people have a cultural and social affiliation that is either extremely different or in line with the current inhabitants of the state or community. Today, the native influence is gradually facing assimilation due to the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Christian Traditions
...In his article Narrative Wolfgang Kemp initiates a discussion about the panel from the doors of the church if Santa Sabina in Rome. There are severalnarratives intermingled in the panel. Named the "Calling of Moses" there are series of other episodes accompanying the panel, presumably depicting in one of the rows the story of Christ's life. This relief is connected with various oral narratives among which the Book of Exodus. Kemp proposes to see the relief as the beginning of the iconographic tradition which is based on the oral narration. The transmission is further complicated, building on the idea of typology. The life of Moses is the pre-text and the figure of Christ is elevated on a higher level. Kemp concludes that...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review
Western traditions
...Western Traditions (Questions in block letters; answers below each question) Page 31 question How did the introduction of writing alter the practice of religion How does it affect our knowledge of history and of ancient religion Religious literature has contributed much in the beliefs and practices of various religions in the world. For one, scriptures and other religious text help document the occurrences and events and the rituals we continue to practice today. Its historical allusion is towards the beginning of how religion has emerged and developed in which areas of the world as well as its impact on society and culture of the countries where religion is practiced, which therefore contributed to the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Easter traditions
...Easter traditions It was as I was stepping of the Huntington Station that I remembered about the eggs. I hate eggs, unless they are scrambled and well done, but of course there is one time of the year when eggs take on a quixotic appeal, around the time of Easter. Easter makes me think of all those nooks and crannies in the rambling old house Grandpa lived in till the end of his days, that smelt of rich cigars and musty furniture, where we cousins would tirelessly poke for the hidden eggs. Eggs stuffed with goodies, eggs that were goodies in themselves, made of chocolate or caramel, slipped into colorful paper pouches that would rustle under the sheets. The finding of each egg was marked by a high-pitched yelp, carried forward... by the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Religious Traditions
...Religion was originally devised as a way or a path that restrains humans physically, emotionally and morally. However, the belief in supernatural power or the divine had existed as part of human society from time immemorial and has been a strong driving force in the formation of world religions. People differ in their opinion and perception of the form and substance of the supernatural power and they are led by either the doctrines of their respective religions or their individual beliefs. Nevertheless, all the world religions have theories and practices concerning the Divine, Sacred Time, Sacred Place and have followers, devotees or members who are dictated by certain ethics of behaviour with fellow believers. The study...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Invent a religion
...Harris Kamran Sociology Creative Composition 12 November Religion Any religion is basically a means of acknowledging the presence of a higher being, and to live the life in accordance with the code that is laid down by that entity. Most of the world’s religions believe in God in one form or the other, and share many of their basic teachings. This essay is an effort to create a new religion which also subscribes to the existence and presence of God. The fundamental philosophy of this religion would be self purification. It will be targeted more towards spiritual purification than physical, as only a pure soul can aspire to get redemption... Kamran Sociology...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Christian Traditions
...Christian Traditions of Affiliate Introduction The emergence of divergent Christian groups with different traditions can be traced back to the divergent interpretations and the perception of the teachings of Jesus Christ and the Bible in general. According to Woodhead (2005, p.46), the two most important groups to have emerged with differing doctrines can be broadly categorized into Church Christians and Biblical Christians. Woodhead goes on to outline that the Church Christians consist of groups such as the Catholic and Orthodox Christians while the Biblical Christians consist of the protestant Churches that emerged in the "16th century" (Woodhead, 2005. p. 47). The Bible has evidently been a central...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Health Traditions
...careful with what they eat. On a closer scrutiny, it was established that the family members always subscribe to these health tradition by mimicry of the elders. Children who grow up with their parents will always follow the path set by the parents. A few others, especially the youth, copy the traditions and views of their peers. Health maintenance, Protection and Restoration The three families must be given adequate health education on various emerging health problems. They should be kept up to date with the current health problems so that they can be able to maintain good health. Health protection concentrates on an identified health threat. The family from the African American background is at risk of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Do native peoples today invent their traditions for FREE!
Contact Us