StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparing David by Donatello and David by Michelangelo - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The artworks discussed in the paper "Comparing David by Donatello and David by Michelangelo" are two sculptures of David from the Renaissance period. Michelangelo’s David dates back to the 16th century. It was finished around 1504. Donatello’s David had been created a century earlier…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Comparing David by Donatello and David by Michelangelo
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparing David by Donatello and David by Michelangelo"

? Analysis Paper Analysis Paper Two works of art that have been chosen for analysis in this paper are two sculptures of David from the Renaissance period. Michelangelo’s David dates back to the beginning of the 16th century. It was finished around 1504. Donatello’s David had been created a century earlier. Presumably, the bronze sculpture of David was finished in the 1440s. While these sculptures belong to two different periods within the Renaissance period, portray the biblical hero king David in different light, are made of different material, and have many other differences, they are both sculptures of nude males, gave the same subject matter (David’s victory over Goliath), and display the features of the Renaissance art. My goal in this paper is to critically examine these two sculptures and find how each of them represents its style, time period, and the talent of its creator. Also, the paper will focus on similarities and differences between these two sculptures visually as well as in terms of their meaning. First, let us focus on the sculpture of David by Donatello. This is a bronze sculpture which represents a standing man who poses one of his feet on his enemy’s head presumably after a victorious fight. The man is a portrayal of a biblical character – King David, while the head under David’s foot is that of giant Goliath. David is depicted with a mysteriously smile. He is nude but wears a hat with evergreen laurel on top of it. He also wears boots and has a sword in his hand. If to refer to the Scriptures, the sword is that of Goliath. Interestingly, the helmet of Goliath’s head features a feather. It looks as though it was attached to the victor’s foot. David, Donatello, bronze, circa 1440s Just as its predecessor – Donatello’s marble sculpture of David completed at the very beginning of the 15th century – bronze David appeared to be among the first free-standing sculptures of nude men since the time of Graeco-Roman civilization. Moreover, David within Donatello’s authorship was remarkably natural. This was possible to achieve due to the recently developed technique of schiacciato. The latter was about carving in a rather low relief with the help of the mathematical perspective trick taught by Brunelleschi, a famous architect of that time. That technique helped create illusion of bigger depth (Moretti, 2010, p.32). David by Michelangelo portrays King David in nude. David is presented in a pose which is clearly serene and confident. It seems he is contemplating something important. Perhaps this is the fight that he is about to have with Goliath, a giant warrior of enormous physical strength. This is the most widespread version of the statue’s background. Other critics also say David may be portrayed thinking about his victory after he defeated Goliath. The meaning behind this statue is “aspiration toward freedom, justice, and good government” (Bussagli, 2000, p.48). David, Michelangelo, marble, 1501-1504. The differences between these two sculptures of David stem from the fact that they were created within different periods. Donatello (1386-1466) lived and worked in Early Renaissance whose borders with late Middle Ages with its Gothic sculpture and architecture were still blurred. In history, this period is known as Quattrocento. Frederick Hartt in his History of Italian Renaissance Art (2006) refers to Quattrocento as to the forefront of Italian Renaissance. It encompassed culture and artistic heritage of both Middle Ages and Early Renaissance and may be called a transition from the medieval period to Renaissance. Revolutionary by its clearly expressed individualism, which was a sign of dramatic changes in all spheres of human life (economic, social, as well as cultural), Quattrocento was characterized by integration of Greek and Roman classic representations into the arts. At the same time, the Quattrocento artworks differed from those of High Renaissance with their highly perfect forms, lines, and representations. As or Donatello, he was a pioneer of classical forms in sculpture. On the contrary, Michelangelo’s David was created more than half a century later. Michelangelo, who died in 1564, was the dominant artist (both sculptor and painter) of the period known as High Renaissance. The latter began at the turn of the 16th century and was marked by a flow of new original solutions. In particular, Michelangelo’s David was lauded for providing a perfect sample of human forms (Bussagli, 2000). This may be explained by the fact that the great sculptor had studies human anatomy before. He was known to study it so thoroughly that he had even dissected human corpses to get to know about human bones and muscles. The two sculptures differ by meaning. Donatello’s David, which portrays a “serenely pastoral boy with his long locks and garlanded shepherd’s neck”, is devoid of heroism and rather appeals to sensuality and homoerotic feelings (“Art in Tuscany”, n.d.). Michelangelo’s David, on the contrary, managed to unite both naturalness and heroic idealism. Paoletti & Radke observe that Michelangelo’s David is “a striking representation of the male human body and (…) idealism that Michelangelo projected onto the body”. They further comment that this sculpture is well understandable as a representation of an ordinary man and at the same time as a hero (Paoletti & Radke, 2005, p.389). In terms of symbolism, both sculptures symbolize Florence, since David had been considered the symbol of the city from early days. David by Donatello, which was commissioned by the Medici, was placed in the centre of their Florentine courtyard. It meant that the family thought they were the owners of the city. Thus, the political symbolism is inherent here, scholars agree. As for Michelangelo’s David, it also symbolized Florence, but this symbolism was different from Donatello’s David. Specifically, Michelangelo managed to depict David before the battle in a confident and victorious light. The symbolism may be that Florence ended up a victor a few times during the periods of great threats in the last decade of the 15th century. The projection for the future is it will continue to do so. Although the overall theme is the same (David’s victory over Goliath), the subjects are a bit different. In Donatello’s sculpture David is depicted after the battle, while in Michelangelo’s David is portrayed before it. Yet, both David were sculpted in cotrapposto pose. In other words, Davids were presented standing naturalistically with the weight of their bodies falling on one hip and the remainder of the body shifting towards that. Below the two Davids are placed for comparison. Despite the fact the sculptures were made of different materials, Michelangelo’s David was made of marble and Donatello’s David from bronze, they were both inspired by statues found in Roman and Greek art. Besides, Michelangelo took inspiration from Donatello’s David since he considered the latter to have been a master of sculpture. Another difference is the size. Donatello’s sculpture is as high as 185 cm, while Michelangelo’s David was twice higher – 411 cm. In addition, the difference in materials suggested different approaches to work. Donatello’s David was constructed through casting in bronze the clay model of David. The process was very complex technically since the sculptor needed to cover the figure in wax after it had been sculpted. The wax would melt out once molten bronze got cast in the mould made from it. Michelangelo carved his David from marble. To conclude, despite many differences found between David by Donatello and David by Michelangelo, these sculptures were revolutionary artworks of their time. They were critical for changing the whole direction of sculpture as an art and inspired many other important creations (one of them the Baroque statue of David by Gian Lorenzo Bernini). Works Cited “Art in Tuscany” (n.d.) Retrieved from http://www.casasantapia.com/art/donatello.htm. Bussagli, M. (2000) The great painters: Michelangelo. Giunti Editore. Hartt, F. (2006) History of Italian Renaissance Art. Person Prentice Hall. Moretti, J. (2010) Frommer's Florence, Tuscany and Umbria. John Wiley & Sons. Paoletti, J. & Radke, G. (2005) Art in Renaissance Italy. Laurence King Publishing. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis Paper Term Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1467123-your-analysis-paper-will-address-two-works-of-art
(Analysis Paper Term Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1467123-your-analysis-paper-will-address-two-works-of-art.
“Analysis Paper Term Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1467123-your-analysis-paper-will-address-two-works-of-art.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparing David by Donatello and David by Michelangelo

The Art of the Renaissance and the 20th Century

The results are clearly evident in his sculptures of the Pieta and david, classical masterpieces completed before he was thirty years old.... For many, michelangelo's work on the Sistine Chapel has been his most monumental work.... Contrary to the Pope's original wishes for the twelve apostles, michelangelo persisted in following his ideas and was finally allowed artistic license to do so.... For the purpose of this assignment, I have chosen to compare and contrast the works of michelangelo in the Renaissance Era to that of Salvador Dali in the 20th century....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

David by Donatello, Michelangelo, Bemini

Religious themes had been immensely prevalent in the Renaissance art and david, a prominent biblical figure, became one of the famous subjects which distinguished the style and professional insights of one artist from the other as depicted in the masterpieces of Donatello, Michelangelo, and Bernini.... As the increasing pursuit for artistic excellence vividly reflects in the exquisite creations of donatello and Michelangelo, their contemporaries were equivalently inspired to develop art forms according to the Greek and Roman concepts and this trend of innovative craftsmanship has carried on to influence even the works of Baroque sculptors like Bernini and those of the current modern artists alike....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Michelangelo's Statue of David

Antonio Rossellino continued his ideas, but a final masterpiece was finished and polished by michelangelo (Lieberman 2001, p.... A power of beauty is combined in the works by michelangelo with a power of expressivity, feelings and a proper balancing (Condivi 1999, p.... donatello and Agostino di Duccio were the first ones to work at the statue.... Name Subject Date michelangelo's Statue of David The statue of David is well-known nowadays....
3 Pages (750 words) Personal Statement

The Famous Depictions of David

The paper "The Famous Depictions of David" tells that donatello and Verrochio cast their Davids in bronze, while Michaelangelo and Bernini worked in marble.... Ancient Greek sculptures were the first to do this, and then it was revived during the Renaissance, first by donatello's David Donatello (DONATO DI NICCOLO BARDI) (c.... One of the most famous was the marble David of 1408 in Florence by donatello.... 133) Donatello's Bronze david was rumoured to have been paired with Judith and Holofernes....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Different Portrayals of David by Different Artists

The works of the artists mentioned above will be scrutinized further to expose the similarities and differences of the sculptures which were made a century apart with Donatello making the first artwork in 1408 followed by michelangelo in 1504 and Bernini in 1624.... The essay compares three paintings of david by such artists as Donatello, Michelangelo and Bernini.... Full Different Portrayals of david by Different Artists David is not just a famous Biblical character but is also an interesting subject to well-known artists such as Donatello, Michelangelo and Bernini....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

McHam_Donatello's David & Judith_x

Why was the placement of Donatello's bronze david and Judith and Holofernes in the Medici Palace courtyard and garden significant?... david and Judith and Holofernes sculptures was supposed to conjure republican themes that were well known to Florentine elite which the Medici wanted to adopt and bring on board.... david was raised on a high base at the middle of the courtyard and could be seen when the palace's main entrance was open.... ) What evidence does McHam provide that suggests Donatello's earlier marble version of david was interpreted in political terms?...
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Donatello and Michelangelo Statue of David

'Perhaps one of the most famous statues in the world today is the Statue of david by michelangelo.... The paper "donatello and Michelangelo Statue of David" highlights that Michelangelo did get inspiration from the Greek and Roman sculptures but either he intended not to fully follow the standards of proportion or was limited by the block of marble passed on to him.... Where Donatello's David seems to be contemplating his victory by gazing downwards where his foot rests on Goliath's head, michelangelo's creation looks as if it is disturbed by the presence of his aggressor....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

McHam's Donatello's David & Judith

The placement of Donatello's bronze david and Judith and Holofernes in the Medici Palace courtyard and garden was of critical importance as it served to place emphasis on republican themes.... The author argues that there are existing manuscripts that concerned a god who made the fighters Questions from Donatellos Bronze "david" And "Judith" As Metaphors of Medici Rule in Florence Q1.... The placement of Donatello's bronze david and Judith and Holofernes in the Medici Palace courtyard and garden was of critical importance as it served to place emphasis on republican themes....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us