StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism Date Art reflects the true character of any civilization at a certain stage. It is natural to find that the material emblems of architecture and sculpture should give the best example of the ideals which our ancestors held.1 In chapter eight of his book, titled Whose Culture Is It, Anyway?…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.9% of users find it useful
Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism"

Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism Art reflects the true character of any civilization at a certain stage. It is natural to find that the material emblems of architecture and sculpture should give the best example of the ideals which our ancestors held.1 In chapter eight of his book, titled Whose Culture Is It, Anyway? Appiah points out to the fact that some museums in the west parts of the world have massive collections of artifacts which were stoles from poor countries during colonial eras.

For instance, in 1801 Lord Elgin appropriated the classical period sculptures from the Parthenon on the acropolis. They became the property of British 15 years later, and centuries later, the Greek government formally asked their return and opened a museum in Athens to house the sculptures.2 There is a t tag of war on whether to return the sculptures to Greece or let them remain in London. Kwame Appiah has given us an approach to this dilemma and this paper analyzes the case of the Parthenon Sculptures in Britain museum using the two concepts by Kwame; the cultural patrimony and cosmopolitanism.

The point is that these artifacts should be returned to Greece because Greeks have an inalienable right to their cultural heritage. The first problematic case, that faces debate on the repatriation of the Parthenon sculptures to Greece, is based on the ideology of cosmopolitanism. Cosmopolitanism is an ideology that all, human ethnic groups, live as a single community anchored on a common morality. Kwame Appiah has it that cosmopolitanism inheres in a situation where individuals from varying locations establish relationships of mutual respect despite their differences in beliefs.

3 In this case, one would argue that the Parthenon sculptures can still remain in Britain. According to Appiah, cosmopolitanism has two parts; first, we have obligations to other people beyond those who are close to us such as; our kin and compatriots. Secondly, we should take an interest in the lives, beliefs and practices of others. In this respect, Greeks have the obligation to the other parts of the world by relinquishing their effort to reclaim their artistic heritage, but whatever obligation that they might have to the foreigners, that obligation should not supersede the obligations they have to those people most familiar to their land.

It is from this premise that the Greek art should be housed in Greece, and not in a far land where common Greeks cannot access them. The Greek artists had an obligation for the future generation when they sculptured their artifacts, and their first obligation was to give a heritage to their immediate descendants, not the foreigners in the far land. The second point in this case lies in the controversy on who owns the Parthenon sculptures. This is where the case of cultural patronage in the Parthenon sculptures emanates.

Scholars, who are for the Britain museum maintaining the Parthenon sculptures, argue that the modern nation states have unfounded connection with the ancient cultures they claim to represent. Kwame Appiah analyzes that cultural patronage does not reside at the culture and people from whom they were taken, and thus, if the artifacts have potential value to all human beings they should belong to all humanity. Further, Kwame Appiah eludes that if we assume that art belongs to cultures that give it significance it deserves, the most art does not belong to a national culture at all.

4 Kwame Appiah argues that, there is the value when cultural heritage belongs to all human being, as in the Nok sculptures in Nigeria.5 However, this argument is subjective when we consider the case of Greek sculptures, which do not benefit Greeks from the London Museum. Even if these artifacts belong to the bigger world, the people of Greece should not be denied their first-priority right to experience their cultural values. In arguing this point, Kwame Appiah has it that artistic property belongs to the states with its cultural patrimony, and from where outsiders can appreciate it.

6 This way, the sculptures should be returned so that, other people from the rest of the world will appreciate Greece artifacts and culture; when expressed from Greece soil and by Greek’s initiative.7 In conclusion, the fact that globalization should not be allowed to constrict homogeneity defends the point that Britain should release the sculptures and let other people view them from their cultural patrimony. The obligation that Greece has for the foreign countries must not go beyond a disservice to the Greeks.

The Parthenon sculptures’ nationality has been alienated and ignored because they are considered as belonging to another nationality. Therefore, there is no need of a sculpture residing in a country where it is threatened or endangered by the idea that it is not a proper part of their cultural heritage. Notes

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1444975-cultural-patrimony-and-cosmopolitanism
(Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1444975-cultural-patrimony-and-cosmopolitanism.
“Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1444975-cultural-patrimony-and-cosmopolitanism.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Cultural Patrimony and Cosmopolitanism

The Concept of Cosmopolitanism

This paper ''cosmopolitanism'' tells that cosmopolitanism is said to be the concept of where humanity belongs to a single community perhaps based on a shared morality....   The philosophical significance in cosmopolitanism lies in its challenge to generally recognize attachments to fellow-citizens, parochially shared cultures, the local state, and the like.... A truly cosmopolitan answer would imply a permanent interest in difference the recognition that internationals and locals depend on each other in order tone it's beginning, cosmopolitanism has been a category marked by a need to negotiate with “others” and has reflected tensions between local and regional realities, ethnocentric and relativist perceptions, and particularism and universalism....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Discuss the historiography of conmopolitanism in Bombay

The concept of cosmopolitanism in Bombay is commonly associated with communal tension, religious tolerance and violence to point to a post-colonial decline of cosmopolitanism as crystallised by the riots of the 1990s1.... However, MacFarlane posits that “claims that the city has… ndergone a general social transformation since the 1990s need to be tempered by the multiple forms of cosmopolitan imaginations and practices that exist in the city”2. Moreover, MacFarlane suggests that from a historiography perspective, the debate regarding cosmopolitanism Alternatively, another argument put forward is the fact that there are “a wide variety of alternative cosmopolitan formations…....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Cosmopolitanism Emphasizes the Importance of Global Citizenship

cosmopolitanism believes in fallibilism philosophy that state that human knowledge is imperfect, provisional, and subject to revision in the face of the new evidence.... The Shattered Mirror is a traveler's Tale by Kwame Anthony Appiah.... Sir Richard Francis Burton is a Victorian adventure whose story is stranger than fiction....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Understanding of the Intersections of Cosmopolitanism and Diversity

From the paper "Understanding of the Intersections of cosmopolitanism and Diversity" it is clear that the concept is related to the ancient notion practiced by the Greeks and Romans.... A non-political cosmopolitanism, although composed of states and participated by governments, is manifested by the United Nations (UN).... osmopolitanism refers to a political and cultural body that encompasses a territorial jurisdiction, extending to the rest of the world (Ribeiro 19)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Why is Cosmopolitanism Such a Contested Concept

The objective of the following research is to define the concept of cosmopolitanism.... Furthermore, the writer of the paper would discuss the main concepts of cosmopolitanism and take a brief look at its history.... Finally, the paper investigates why cosmopolitanism is such a contested concept.... hellip; cosmopolitanism has been a contested term ever since its coinage.... (2002, 2) have defined cosmopolitanism by evoking nationalism as an opposite paradigm....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Multicultural Regulations in the UK

These ideologies encompass the promotion of equivalent respect to divergent cultures in a nation and advocacy of policies supporting the sustenance of cultural variety.... All these ideologies evade presenting any creed, racial, or cultural societal values as dominant.... Secondly, there are those that focus on multiplicity and cultural exclusivity.... cultural segregation can guard the exclusivity of the local traditions of a country and contribute to international cultural miscellany....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Development of Cosmopolitanism

This essay discusses the concept of cosmopolitanism as well as outlines the benefits its attainment could bring to contemporary society.... The writer suggests that with cosmopolitanism, the social and political challenges threatening to engrave the society will ultimately be contained.... nbsp;… Currently, the world has become globalized, and the idea of cosmopolitanism cannot ignore the impulse to merge, cooperate and progress socially, politically and economically as a single unit....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Urban Identities and Cosmopolitanism

They have captured the various cultural phases through the ages and are still doing so, making them appropriate cultural practices to identify with.... … Urban Identities & CosmopolitanismThis paper will try to show how art, architecture and urban identity are intricately and inexorably linked....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us