Nobody downloaded yet

The problems with traditional ethnographic filmmaking as exemplified by Nanook of the North - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The film Nanook of the North is a pioneering effort by film-maker Robert Flaherty. Released in 1922 and filmed in the immediately preceding years, the film was a tentative experimentation in two genres – ethnography and documentary. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
The problems with traditional ethnographic filmmaking as exemplified by Nanook of the North
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The problems with traditional ethnographic filmmaking as exemplified by Nanook of the North"

Download file to see previous pages The film Nanook of the North is a pioneering effort by film-maker Robert Flaherty. Released in 1922 and filmed in the immediately preceding years, the film was a tentative experimentation in two genres – ethnography and documentary. At a time when the written word was the primary mode of information dissemination, Nanook of the North attempted to achieve what an ethnographic book on the Eskimo would have done. When motion picture as we know it today was taking its early steps as a medium of popular culture, Flaherty, who called it a non-fiction film, can be credited to have made the first documentary. Looking back at the ninety years since the release of Nanook of the North, one can see vast improvisations in film-making technique and technology. The addition of synchronized sound would be another cornerstone in the history of films. (Ellis & McLane, 2005) As can be expected in this early example/experimentation with narrative film, there are a few obvious problem areas. While nominally adapted to the documentary form, the viewer cannot avoid feeling the enactment of a pre-conceived script. It is as if the film-maker, instead of making himself the invisible observer of unfolding events, seems to have instructed Nanook and his clan to perform specific acts. This is typical of not only early documentaries but also the vast body of ethnographic publishing of the previous century. For example, other post-First World War forays in this genre such as Dziga Vertov's The Man with the Movie Camera, Walter Ruttmann's Berlin: Symphony of a City (1927) and John Grierson's Drifters (1929) all share this common flaw. This is also true of Flaherty's subsequent film Moana (1926). Flaherty portrays Eskimo and Samoan cultures in a revisionist mode by creating imagined characters, bringing back to life lost cultural practices (such as hunting for Walruses using harpoons) and setting the film in an ancient period (conveyed to the audience through use of oil lamps when electricity is easily available). All this goes to show that these early ethnographies were “done less in the name of art than to salvage elements of the past by portraying them in the filmic equivalent of 'the ethnographic present'. As a result, Flaherty's alterations and temporal licenses met considerable disapproval in scholarly circles. He only inflamed passions further by stating, 'Sometimes you have to lie. One often has to distort a thing to catch its true spirit'." (Askew, 2006, p.29) There is also a directorial slant that seeks to iterate well-established stereotypes of the natives. This is not only applicable to Nanook and the Native American stock he comes from, but also to all indigenous people under European imperialist purview. For example, similar stereotyping of the natives is evident in British-authored ethnographies in Indian subcontinent, German experience in African colonies, Belgians in the Congo and the French occupation of Indo-China. What is also evident in early film ethnographies are the fixedness in perspective – these films were made by white men for other white men, with a patronizing attitude toward nativities/communities being explored. Further, the primitives were shown to display Western family ideals: “Like a museum display in which sculpted models of family groups perform "traditional activities," Nanook's family adopts a variety of poses for the camera. These scenes of the picturesque always represent a particular view of family or community, usually with the father as hunter and the mother as nurturer, paralleling Western views of the nuclear family. In the following trading post sequence, Nanook is shown to be ignorant of Western technology....This conceit of the indigenous person who does not understand Western technology allows for voyeuristic pleasure and reassures the viewer of the contrast between the Primitive and the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The problems with traditional ethnographic filmmaking as exemplified Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Problems With Traditional Ethnographic Filmmaking As Exemplified Essay)
“The Problems With Traditional Ethnographic Filmmaking As Exemplified Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The problems with traditional ethnographic filmmaking as exemplified by Nanook of the North

Ethnographic film

...its filming and production. In 1970’s, Judith and MacDougall started to produce ethnographic films with subtitles. Later different production techniques such as reflex ion and experimental montages become introduced in filming of ethnographic films by Minh-Ha. These summarize a brief history of how ethnographic films evolved in the world. There have been conflicts between the filmmakers and the archaeologist. Archaeologists argue that the ethnological films they produce do not satisfy the required criteria. Lack of scientific knowledge among the filmmakers contributes to this problem. They further argue that the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Reflexivity in relation to anthropologicalethnographic filmmaking

...Reflexivity in relation to anthropological/ethnographic filmmaking Emphasizing reflexivity in an anthropological/ethnographical filmmaking is about creating a shared space between the researcher and the researched (Cataln, 2). It chooses to show the participation that goes into filmmaking and the production of knowledge through informant's information. Hence, reflexivity must account for processes that are both methodological as well as autobiographical. Tim Asch and Napoleon Chagnon's The Ax Fight as well as Robert Flaherty's Nanook of the North, helps to analyze the "reciprocity" (Ruby, 121) that follows such presence...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Filmmaking Techniques

...How do narrative, screen and space in film influence a viewer's interpretation A discussion of themes and theories. Contents Page Introduction 2 New Digital Cinema: Reinventing the moving image 4 Montage 7 Film versus digital 8 Space in Cinema: The new dimension 9 Spatial Montage vs. Spatial Compositing 10 Narrative 12 Mise-en-scne 16 What are syuzhet, style and fabula 18 Video Art 19 Conclusion 22 References 25 Introduction In this essay, I will explore ideas of film form, and themes of Time Code, Drowning by Numbers, early Soviet cinema and the silent films, and the TV series 24. New and traditional methods in filmmaking,...
24 Pages(6000 words)Coursework

Ethnographic interview

...of the participants in cases where there would be a possibility of the participants being harmed. The researcher must be aware of what he or she needs to report about a culture and what would be ethical to convey to the public. The essential core of the activity aims to understand another way of life from the native point of view. (Spradley, 1979, 3) The presence of abundant information often creates a problem, as the ethnographer needs to sort them out and exclude some parts in order to fit a particular design or pattern of the data structure during analysis. A large variety of materials, which are interrelated, need to be organized properly. Often, an ethnographer needs to translate...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay


...for a shot, but on the spot, that lens proved to be too wrong to select for the shot because the effects it created totally ruined the image. I ended up checking different lenses for the shot, which spoke very badly of my competence in the use of camera in front of the actors and the crew. However, it was indeed, a great learning experience for me as I got to find out how different lenses could affect the shot. I need to practice a lot in order to make my actions consistent with my concepts. In order to enhance my knowledge and skill in the use of different kinds of lenses, I am particularly concentrating upon the literature about them. I believe that photographers develop their unique and individualistic style of...
20 Pages(5000 words)Essay


...films using normal video cameras. An HD video camera with a wider aspect ratio of 16:9(wide screen) is necessary for making films in digital formats. The resolution should be greater than 1090 pixels wide x 1080 pixels high (What Camera To Use For Filmmaking). Canon, Nikon, Pentax, Sony etc are some of the prominent companies which make movie cameras. Digital cameras are used extensively nowadays in film shooting. Digital cameras use video tape, hard disk or flash memory for recording digital data. Digital data can be edited or modified easily compared to other data and that is why modern cinematographers use digital camera for the shooting purposes. “Paranormal Activity” is the movie which got highest bookings in last...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


...Filmmaking Filmmaking is a splendid way to enhance awareness and guide attention to a specificissue or topic. Nevertheless, prior to making a film, there are various ethical issues required to be considered. Most of the individuals not involved in this industry are not completely aware if the camera power and the editing methodologies that may be used to develop structure events in unexpected ways. At the center of documentary production is the association among filmmaker and subjects that usually lacks equal equilibrium. And for the majority portion, all of this is determined by the filmmaker. So one of the most important things to be considered while...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethnographic comparisons

..., a thorough analysis of marriage patterns, family and education brings about the similarities and differences between the two societies, the benefits of such factors as well as the social problems faced by the family members. Mexicans are at liberty to choose their marriage partners (Stack, 2012). Nevertheless, are rule and regulations that constrain choices that are made by individuals which are associated to class and traditions. Marriage usually happens after a period of engagement that can last for many years. The standard age at marriage for the male counterparts is usually twenty four years while that for ladies is twenty two years. Even though it will be a desire for everyone to marry someone...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Ethnographic Comparison

...Ethnographic Comparison An assignment submitted by Winter Ethnographic Comparison Anthropology, the science that deals with the origins and social relations of human beings, helps understand the traditions and cultures of different societies. Ethnography, on the other hand, provides scientific description of individual human societies. Ethnographers focus on the striking realities and practices of societies that can potentially supplant the dominating social theories with better understandings of human life and how it entails cultural changes. Comparing different societies from an ethnographic perspective can bring in some valuable information and...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Nanook of the North (YouTube)

...Nanook of The North (1922) Based on the ic movie, ethnography has been portrayed in a distinct manner. The movie brings about an unknown culture to the modern world. It portrays the life of an Eskimo (Nanook) and his family. Through the life of Nanook, we get to know how the traditional society practiced fishing, hunting, frequent migrations of the group in search of food and trading in the Northern Canada (All Classic Video 1922). Assumptions in culture can also be made based on the Nanook movie. It could be noted that the modern clothing was not present at the time because of how Nanook and his ethnicity used to dress...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The problems with traditional ethnographic filmmaking as exemplified by Nanook of the North for FREE!

Contact Us