The Narrators Location in the Central Part of a Consumerist Society - Research Paper Example

On American Consumerism: An Analysis of John Updike’s A & P A surface reading of John Updike’s A & P reveals a story about a young man’s impulsive decision to quit his job at a supermarket, hoping it would attract the attention of girls who were publicly humiliated by their store manager. Told in the first person narrative, the story allows us to dwell into the mind of Sammy, a teenager clerk who holds sarcastic and opinionated thoughts about the world around him. Notably, the main character’s voice is presented in a colloquial and intimate tone to highlight his individuality and character. Readers see through Sammy’s eyes as he describes the scene around him in details – from referring the workplace as a “pinball machine” to labeling an attractive customer as “chunky”. From Sammy’s narration, a typical analysis of the story would be that it only “contains nothing more significant than a checking clerks interest in three girls in bathing suits” (Peden, 1964). Another more sensible take would be that the story presents “a sudden moment of insight when a young man rebels against a conservative society” (Hatcher, 1996). However, beyond the usual understanding of A & P being a “coming of age narrative” is the analysis that John Updike’s masterpiece tells more about an individual’s struggle in a consumerist society. According to Porter (1972), the story A & P can be aptly interpreted as "the character’s rebellion against a consumer-conditioned society." To understand this idea, it is important to first devote our attention to the context of the story and then understand the symbolism behind the character’s language to reveal the author’s intention in creating an irony about the world around him. Since the story is published in the 1960’s, it gives us a picture of a conservative society where people adhere to traditional values and norms. In those days, conforming to the standard appearance and behavior was necessary, especially to middle class families who aspire for social equality through the American dream of typically owning a house, driving a car, and buying enough goods. Adding to this set-up is the industrial development which allowed grocery store chains like A & P to dominate and offer packaged consumer goods around the country. It is this typical middle-class setting in the 1960s which establishes the internal conflict of a young man against his society. In the story, the ultimate act of Sammy to quit his job represents non-conformity to a social structure that is based on commoditization of goods and perpetuation of conservative values. In Sammy’s words, the setting of the story points to an area “right in the middle of town” where “you can see two banks and the Congregational church and the newspaper store and three real-estate offices ". This description tells us about the narrator’s location in the central part of a consumerist society where a grocery store lies in the middle of the financial, spiritual, informational, and property structures. In the story, A & P is the focal area where packaged goods are made available for the consumption of every Americans. In grocery stores, all products are homogenized in order to meet the material demands of every consumer. As such, Sammy becomes part of this materialistic environment which deals with people purchasing goods and individuals finding meaning on things. Because of this, it is no surprise that the narrator himself is inclined to also objectify the things and people around him. At first, he describes the empty store as a “pinball machine” and searches for the girls show up, as if to find the objects of his attraction. Meanwhile, he labels other customers as “sheep” and describes a girl’s rear as a “can” which means that he compares people to things and animals. In Sammy’s eyes, people lose their humanity once they enter the confines of A & P. He sees the girls inside as mere sex objects, viewing them in the same way as customers choose their products. He judges the girls based solely on their physical features in the same way as customers judge a product by its package. Like a consumer who judges a product based on commercials, Sammy is also fascinated by the typical standards of beauty in media advertisements. For Sammy, old and less attractive customers are worthy of his mockery – labeling them as “a witch about fifty with rouge on her cheekbones and no eyebrows”, classifying them “sheep pushing their carts down the aisle”, and calling them “house slaves in pin curlers”. Apparently, this view women also mirrors to what Hatcher (1997) believes that Sammy’s character reveals his biased thoughts that it is all right for the young girls to walk around the store in their bathing suits, but other women, ‘women with six children and varicose veins’, should put on some clothes before they get out of their cars. On the other hand, it is clear that the nineteen year old Sammy sees attractiveness of a woman based on her physical figure. It can be noted that the sexual connotations he used to describe women often refers to the products sold in the shop. For instance, when one of the girls in bathing suit came to A & P, he describes her as someone who has “a sweet broad soft-looking can” and then, towards the end of the story, he describes Queenie as a woman who has “the nicest two scoops of vanilla breasts”. This commodification of women is clearly a reflection of how Sammy seems to blend people with the products sold inside the grocery store. He is attracted to well-packaged looks, in the same way as customers are encouraged to buy well-advertised products. Ultimately, even Sammy’s momentous decision to quit his job in an attempt to impress Queenie is mainly based on his desire for upward social mobility. Once again, we point to American consumerism here as the factor that affects people like Sammy to desire higher status in life. In a consumerist society where more goods are produced, people tend to define themselves based on their material possessions. For a person like Sammy, who belongs to the bottom of the social ladder, it is only natural to desire someone like Queenie who obviously comes from an upper middle class background. The socio-economic divide in the north of Boston is evident when Sammy described the area as unlike being on Cape because “theres people in this town havent seen the ocean for twenty years”. Being a grocery store clerk, Sammy appears to be an unhappy employee who is simply bored with his work since “there is nothing much to do except lean on the register and wait for the girls to show up again”. Then when finally the girls appeared, Sammy focuses more attention on Queenie because she belongs in a social class which he wishes to fit. With Queenie’s declaration to purchase a jar of herring snacks, Sammy immediately formed an image of his family in a formal party where “her father and the other men were standing around in ice-cream coats and bow ties and the women were in sandals picking up herring snacks on toothpicks off a big plate and they were all holding drinks the color of water with olives and sprigs of mint in them”. With these thoughts, it is clear that Sammy secretly fantasizes to be part of the upper middle class circle and fully reveal his air of superiority among others. For him, defending Queenie is his way of renouncing his poor economic status and aspiring for upward social mobility. Sammy wants to fit in within Queenies circle so that he too could enjoy the freedom exercised by the people in the upper echelon of the society. For Sammy, freedom is only enjoyed by those who are rich and powerful enough to express themselves and challenge the existing conventions. As a mere grocery clerk, he is only allowed to keep his thoughts to himself as he is bound by the conventions of his workplace. And so, when Sammy quits from his job, he makes it clear that he wants to break away from the monotony of his work and break free from his social. Unfortunately, knew that when he uttered “how hard the world was going to be to me hereafter”, his supposed fearless act turned into an empty heroism. Works Cited Hatcher, Nathan. "Sammy’s Motive." Ode to Friendship & Other Essays. Ed. Connie Bellamy. Norfolk, Virginia: 1996. Print. Peden, William. “The American Short Story”. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1964. Print. Porter, Gilbert M. "John Updikes A & P: The Establishment and an Emersonian Cashier" English Journal. 61.8 (1972): pp.1155–1158. Print. Updike, John. "A&P." The Harper Anthology of Fiction. Ed. Sylvan Barnet. New York: HarperCollins, 1989. Print. OUTLINE I. surface reading of John Updike’s A & P: a. young teenager quitting his job to impress girls b. teenage clerks interest in 3 girls in bathing suits (Peden) c. young mans rebellion against his society (Hatcher) II. Thesis: A & P is about an mans struggle in a American consumerist society a. Poter (1972): an act was a rebellion against consumerism b. Context and examination of Sammy’s language III. Context of the story: America in the 1960s a. signify conservative society b. conformity was necessary c. supermarket dominate the US IV. Setting of the story Part 1: North of Boston a. center of urbanity and consumerism b. surrounded by institutions (banks, churches, real estate) V. Setting of the story Part 2: A & P a. where packaged goods are made available for everyone b. materialistic environment VI. Sammys POV a. compares people to products b. objectifies women c. evaluate women as products VII. Plot/ending: Sammy quits his job a. for upward mobility b. to break away from monotonous work c. desire for freedom Read More