StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Influences on Judicial Decision Making - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The decision making process is critical in making any judgment as it can mean that justice can be administered or not. The evaluation of the evidence presented…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.5% of users find it useful
Influences on Judicial Decision Making
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Influences on Judicial Decision Making"

Influences on Judicial Decision Making al Affiliation The decision making process by various judges is influenced by various factors as we shall establish in this activity. The decision making process is critical in making any judgment as it can mean that justice can be administered or not. The evaluation of the evidence presented as well as looking at previous cases in the line with the one at hand facilitates the process of coming up with an advised decision. The factors that influence the judge’s decision include;- (1).

Judicial Precedent-in some cases the decision made in one case acts as a link or binder to later cases that are to be made using the same reasoning and law. A superior judge will often make a decision that binds all the judgments that had been made prior to his judgment. (2). Partisanship-In some cases especially the ones involving a given political affiliation, many judges have been found to make decisions that are favoring one of the sides that they favor. (3). Social Background-though quite negligible in affecting the decision of the judges, the social backgrounds have affected how the final decisions are made.

For instance a judge who was brought up in a family where marital fights and abuse were common will be more vigilant in handling such cases (Dimitri & Lax, 2009; Uddin, n.d).Attorney Joe Smith would have the following advantages if he wants to postpone a case until a further date. First due to his close professional interaction with the judges it is possible that he knows their competence levels a factor that is core in the process of defining a case. Second he knows their schedule and since he has a direct contact with all of them he will be able to make his request easily and his request honored (Dimitri & Lax, 2009).

ReferencesDimitri, L. & Lax, J. R. (2009). Legal Doctrine on Collegial Courts. The Journal of Politics. 71(3). p. 949-963. Uddin, B. (n.d). Judicial Decision Making would be better if Judges were more truthful about their Reasons for Particular Decisions, even if those Reasons are Extra-Legal. The Student Journal of Law. Available at.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Influences on Judicial Decision Making Assignment”, n.d.)
Influences on Judicial Decision Making Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1667335-influences-on-judicial-decision-making
(Influences on Judicial Decision Making Assignment)
Influences on Judicial Decision Making Assignment. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1667335-influences-on-judicial-decision-making.
“Influences on Judicial Decision Making Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1667335-influences-on-judicial-decision-making.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Influences on Judicial Decision Making

Are Decisions Made by Universities Directly Affecting Students Justiciable

ommonwealth System:Dicey's jurisprudential thought is central to the present system of constitutional and administrative law; it deals with the decision-making process and the powers of parliament; the government; executive bodies; and the courts.... The precedents for the Commonwealth decision come via the Privy Council or the English House of Lords.... nbsp;… In order to ensure that there is a system of fairness, there needs to be more than the decision of NEAT....
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Judicial Activism and Constitutional Interpretation

Thus, it is a usurpation of power and it happens when a judge takes a decision that is different from common law, jurisprudence and the constitution of the country.... It may also occur when the decision of judges overrules the prevalent law or legal doctrines in the country that are likely to undermine the country's social policy.... The paper “judicial Activism and Constitutional Interpretation” defines judicial activism, argues about the correct interpretation of the constitution and about the difference in philosophy between strict constructionists and those who believe in a living constitution....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Morbaine Limited v First Secretary of State

Some of the court orders are certiorari, which sets aside a decision; mandamus, which makes it imperative for a duty to be… formed; prohibition, which orders that an action should not be undertaken as it is unauthorized; a declaration, which defines the legal rights or obligations or an injunction.... Judicial review permits people with sufficient interest in a decision or action by a public body to seek judicial review in respect of the legality of an enactment or a decision and action or failure to act in relation to the exercise of a public function2....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

How does the relationship between the three branches of government influence the policy-making process

On the other hand, the judicial branch How does the relationship between the three branches of government influence the policy-making process?... How does the relationship between the three branches of government influence the policy-making process?... Thus, this paper will explain how the relationship between the Executive, the Legislative and Judicial branches of government influence the policy-making process.... However, the executive members do not make policy decisions, but they have a strong influence on the process of policy making....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Chinese Judiciary Independence

Finally, the court makes a judicial decision and results after receiving cases from Procuratorate.... Procuratorate can apply counter appeal if they don't think the court's judicial decision is fair and correct.... making a complete and legitimate judgment has three procedures in China.... The Supreme Peoples Court is the highest judicial organ.... After it makes judicial decisions, people cannot apply counter appeal....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint

Supporters of legal activists are to judicial restraint that supports that the judiciary should leave the policy formulation and decisions making process to the executive and legislative branches (Ringhand & Collins, 2010).... t turns out that the decision-making process or aspect of the Supreme Court is the extent to which judges can be grouped into some divisive block, just as revealed by the judicial activism versus judicial restraint.... It is sometimes considered the opposite of judicial restraint....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

General Verdict of Guilty or Not Guilty

Over the years, there have been many threats to this independence when questions were raised on the reasons that the judiciary is liable to give while making verdicts.... Judicial review is also a power granted by some countries where the judiciary gains the power to check the legislature on certain issues where either the legislature is not performing the constitutional duties or making laws that are unconstitutional (Carey, 2003, p.... The judiciary is responsible to act under the principles to make sure they are translated fully into reality and so they are independent to take the decision over rights, freedom, life, and property of the citizens....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Importance of Having an Impartial and Independent Judiciary

The paper "Importance of Having an Impartial and Independent Judiciary" states that when a state allows the judiciary to act independently, the citizens and institutions respect the judicial institution as it should be and they trust it to deliver just decisions.... What this means is that the legislature, the executive, other institutions as well as private individuals should respect and abide by the decisions made by the judicial bodies even when they tend to feel that they do not agree with the decisions....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us