The Ethical Debate over Assisted Suicide - Essay Example

On the other hand, VAE is when a physician would normally act directly to end a patient's life and would be the one administering the dosage or lethal injection that would put the patient's life to an end. Brock sees no difference between these two, and I would say I have to agree. Does it really matter who is doing the killing if in fact there is killing taking place Either way the outcome is the same, I don't think it really matters who is holding the needle or who is administering the dosage?

There is plenty of relevance in this debate as well to the other debate over the distinction between killing and letting die. Is there really a difference between killing somebody or simply standing by and watching or letting them die I like to think it depends on the scenario, for if you try to help them out then you are really not letting them die so to speak. But people will often try to use their belief that there is a distinction between them to try to work against the legislation of these types of programs.

People will use the argument that there is a huge difference between them and that killing somebody is ethically wrong compared to letting their natural time come and letting them die. They will try to use this to block any measures to give people the choice of these types of death methods, and there may be some merit in their ideas. On the other side, however, many people have rejected this idea, stating that if somebody is dying does it matter if u let it happen or help it along This side of the debate has its merits too, and is often more in favor of people's rights to make decisions themselves.

They reject the idea of a distinction between them, and that there is no difference between killing somebody and letting them die, which I think it a very sound argument. Both sides make good points, however, I feel that morally you cannot take choices away from people and that you may not agree with it, but you have to let people make this own choice in their life based upon what they believe is the right or wrong thing to do.