StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Flat Income Tax in the United States - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Flat Income Tax in the United States" describes that one of the biggest complaints about the current system of taxation is its overwhelming complexity. The myriad forms, schedules, and attachments required to even file the most basic income and expenditures…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
The Flat Income Tax in the United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Flat Income Tax in the United States"

The Flat Income Tax: A Policy Whose Time Has Come The income tax in the United s has evolved from a simple system designed to generate revenue to a complex process of economic engineering and politicized monetary management. In an effort to implement the complicated maze of US tax laws, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has grown to become one of the largest bureaucratic institutions in the world. To eliminate this burden from the individual taxpayer as well as businesses, tax reform advocates have suggested that we move to a flat income tax system. Under the proposed system would be taxed at an identical rate, which some legislators have proposed to be 17 percent (Armey 24). In addition, all taxpayers would be given a liberal personal deduction These changes in our tax code would simplify the administration of taxation, be more fair, generate greater revenue, and stimulate the economy. One of the biggest complaints about the current system of taxation is its overwhelming complexity. The myriad forms, schedules, and attachments required to even file the most basic income and expenditures is beyond the capability of the average taxpayer. The Internal Revenue tax code contains more than 9.4 million words, thousands of provisions for business and individuals, and an instruction booklet that is over 100 pages in length (Graetz 49). The flat rate income tax form would have only the demographic information and lines for income, personal deduction, tax rate (17 percent), and total taxes. By eliminating the tables, worksheets, and schedules, anyone could calculate their taxes in a matter of minutes. Steve Forbes, former presidential candidate and president of Forbes Inc. argues that, "The flat tax is the only way to bring back sanity and put an end to the clutter, confusion, and distortions of the current system" (58). The flat tax would not only save the taxpayer countless hours of organizing and calculating their yearly taxes, the IRS would save a significant portion of its budget by reducing the time it takes to collect, examine, and audit the returns. The simplified system of the flat tax would also be more fair to all taxpayers. All taxpayers would pay an equal percentage of their income toward taxes, without regards to income bracket or economic class. This would eliminate the ongoing criticism of tax breaks for the wealthy and eliminate the public's distaste for the upper income people who currently pay no taxes. This debate has sparked class resentment among the voters, and Fuest, Peichl, and Schaefer contend that, "Tax simplification concerning the determination of income for tax purposes [. . .] reduces inequality and polarisation" (88). In addition to an equal tax rate, the system's fairness would also benefit from the elimination of the special provisions and loopholes that are afforded some specific industries and individuals. Tax credits and exemptions for special interests such as oil exploration would no longer exist and would eliminate the inappropriate economic engineering that the tax laws do to the free market system. The revenue system is designed to generate revenue and not construct the economy. Loopholes are awarded to special interests and have more to do with social and political concerns than they do with raising revenue. The progressive tax system, and its high marginal tax rate, is often seen as an acceptable method for the redistribution of wealth from the upper classes to the lower classes. Not only are high marginal taxes unfair, Zolt and Bird contend that this concept is outdated and "'most analysts and policymakers had come to believe that high tax rates not only discouraged and distorted economic activity but also were largely ineffective in redistributing income and wealth" (8). Tax credits further disrupt the intentions of the free market by subsidizing activities that would otherwise be unprofitable. This may be in the form of social programs, such as a deduction for charity, or a tax incentive to develop a new technology. Either way, the flat tax would eliminate the improper and artificial market forces produced by tax credits, tax incentives, and deductions. While the tax system can be made fair and balanced, it must also generate the revenue necessary to run the government. In fact, a flat tax would result in an increase in total revenue for several reasons. The simplification of the tax forms would increase taxpayer participation and the number of filers. There are many people who fail to pay taxes simply because they do not understand the tax code. In addition, the high marginal tax rates discourage upper income people from accurately claiming income that can be reasonably, and legally, shielded. Ivanova, Keen, and Klemm state, "It seems to be widely believed - indeed taken as obvious - that a reduction in the rate at which a tax is levied will tend to improve compliance with it" (408). In addition, the flat tax's simplicity would make enforcement easier and result in even higher rates of compliance. More people filing and more income claimed can result in higher revenues. The Joint Economic Committee (JEC) of the United States Senate was even more animate when they argued that, "High marginal tax rates discourage work effort, saving, and investment, and promote tax avoidance and tax evasion" (Frenze para.4). The elimination of the high marginal tax rate would continue to contribute to a growing tax revenue stream. While the flat tax system would raise revenues through increased participation, it would also significantly contribute to economic growth. Implementing a flat tax policy would, "'eliminate the tax code's bias against capital formation by ending the double taxation of income that is saved and invested. This means no death tax, no capital gains tax, no double taxation of saving, and no double tax on dividends" (Mitchell). The increased savings and the economic rewards for investments would spur economic growth and "Even if a flat tax boosted long-term growth by only 0.5 percent, the income of the average family of four after 10 years would be as much as $5,000 higher than it would be under current tax laws" (Mitchell). These higher incomes would additionally contribute to the revenue base when they are taxed at the flat rate of 17 percent. The flat tax plan has been criticized for its failure to give a tax deduction for charitable donations and interest on home mortgage loans (Armey 26,41). While there is a valid concern for waning philanthropy under a flat tax system, Armey points out that charitable giving rose after the Reagan tax cuts of the 1980s, even though their value as a tax deduction was slashed by as much as 65 percent (41). The overeall reduction in taxes and increased wealth made it possible for Americans to continue compassionate giving through this period. The loss of the home mortgage interest deduction instills a sense of reluctance for many taxpayers, but has no basis in fact. Since interest income is tax exempt, interest rates on debt instruments would decline by the rate of tax on interest under the current system (Foster 3). There would be a zero sum gain or loss for the homeowner. In fact, for homes under the $200,000 range, the reduction in interest rates would raise property values by 10-25 percentage points (Foster 3). The loss of specific deductions would be more than offset by gains made in other areas. In conclusion, a tax system should be designed to be equitable, practical, and serve the important function of raising the necessary revenue. The flat tax would remove the mountains of paperwork and cumbersome tax laws that accompany the current system. The flat tax system would create equality by eliminating the unfair tax credits that are aimed at special interest groups, industries, and individuals to gain a political advantage. It would also remove the IRS from the role of artificially creating or discouraging markets through tax laws. The higher participation and compliance in a flat tax system would increase revenues, while increased savings and investments would spur economic growth. While citizens are naturally reluctant to surrender their current tax deductions, any advantage lost by the elimination of these deductions would be more than offset by gains in other areas. The IRS has grown to be an out of control federal bureaucracy that is overdue for an overhaul. The flat tax system would greatly benefit individuals and businesses alike, and it is a policy whose time has arrived. Works Cited Armey, Dick. "The Flat Tax in our Future." The Madison Review 1996: 24+ . 27 Apr. 2008 . Forbes, Steve. Flat Tax Revolution: Using a Postcard to Abolish the IRS. Washington, DC: Regnery Publishing, 2005. Foster, J D. "The Flat Tax and Housing Values." Tax Foundation: Special Report 59 (1996): 1-4. 27 Apr. 2008 . Frenze, Christopher . "The Reagan Tax Cuts: Lessons for Tax Reform." JEC Report (1996): 11 pars. 27 Apr. 2008 . Fuest, Clemens, Andreas Peichl, and Thilo Schaefer. "Does a Simpler Income Tax Yield More Equity and Efficiency'" CESifo Economic Studies 54.1 (2008): 73-97. Graetz, Michael J. "A Fair and Balanced Tax System for the 21st Century." President's Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform, Washington, DC. 11 May 2005. Ivanova, Anna, Michael Keen, and Alexander Keen. "The Russian 'Flat Tax' Reform." Economic Policy (2005): 397-444. EBSCO. 27 Apr. 2008. Mitchell, Daniel J. "A Brief Guide to the Flat Tax." The Heritage Foundation. 7 July 2005. The Heritage Foundation. 27 Apr. 2008 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Flat Income Tax Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words”, n.d.)
The Flat Income Tax Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1508664-the-flat-income-tax
(The Flat Income Tax Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
The Flat Income Tax Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1508664-the-flat-income-tax.
“The Flat Income Tax Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1508664-the-flat-income-tax.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Flat Income Tax in the United States

Inbound Taxation Critical Analysis

is a non resident alien in the united states which means that Joe T.... However, under certain circumstances exceptions may be provided to foreign investors in the united states as per taxation on income.... is a non resident alien of the united states who has invested in 1,000 shares of common stock in IBM Corporation.... IBM is registered in Delaware, United States and does most of its business within the united states.... s income derived from sourced within the united states are liable to taxation....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Nationwide Federal Sales Tax Structure

As might be expected, one of the reasons for why a value added tax/sales tax/”fair tax” has not caught on within the united states is due to the fact that a preponderance of negative trade-offs exist with regards to implementing this.... Many nations around the world currently employ a federally mandated sales tax in lieu of deriving government revenue via other methods; namely import taxes, export tariffs, and/or other alternative methods.... hellip; However, one of these suggestions that simply refuses to go away and has a great many positive and negative aspects is with regards to replacing the current income tax with a federal sales tax....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Implementation Of The Fair Tax In The United States

This essay "Implementation Of The Fair tax in the united states" aims at discussing the main points regarding the implementation of the fair tax in the united states.... It is a tax system that is neutral and for the reasons deeply discussed in detail as above, it is believed that for the united states of America.... Investments and personal savings are discouraged under the current income tax system in the US.... This fair tax will thus act as a replacement on the federal income tax on individuals, tax on capital gains, tax on self-employment, and taxation on gifts and the estates....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Peculiarities of the Flat Tax System

(Sexton 243) Flat tax system's supporters think that it would give an… A progressive-rate tax system was used in united states.... progressive-rate tax system was used in united states.... It is already implemented in many states of U.... Flat tax is applied on all the tax payers without any kind of deduction or exceptions allowed.... In 2010, a tax bracket was defined for tax payers for example, if the earning was up to $8,375 the tax bracket Flat tax Definition: It is a tax system that is used to apply same tax rate to all the tax payers despiteof income bracket....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The US Corporate Income Tax Conundrum

united states corporate tax is the highest among the developed countries, and it is currently pushing to have its resident corporations pay taxes on incomes from their worldwide operations.... Globally there has been a shift towards the flat tax regime, where citizens and business are charged at a harmonized tax rate, with everybody paying an equal amount.... Advocates of the flat system argue that there are many benefits that accrue from using this system, the system itself is very simple, with easy to comprehend tax codes, both the taxation authority and the taxpayer benefit....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Housing Policy in the United States

This study “The Housing Policy in the united states” evaluates the US public housing programs undertaken from 1932 till today.... Demand for housing has gone down in the united states in 2008 and 2009, as a result of the economic crisis.... nbsp; The tax credit is due to expire on November this year, and the realty business is worried about its effect on the housing industry (Margate) The multiplier effect on macroeconomic growth, on job creation and on the State budget, The current financial crisis in the united states had a multiplier effect on macroeconomic growth, on job creation and on the State budget....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Flat Tax, Fair Tax and U.S. Federal (Current) Tax System Comparison

it has been obtained that the country's taxation system has led to several controversies over the years with the system being highly complicated and creating difficulties for the people of the country The tax system in the united states is based upon both the federal and the state levels of taxation.... The income tax involves reduction of certain amounts from the individual incomes that the countrymen earn in a year.... Thus each of the states in the U....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper

What Can Be Done to the Tax System of the USA

The essay "What Can Be Done to the Tax System of the USA" discusses the current complex and ineffective tax system in the united states that needs to be replaced with a flat tax system in order to avoid the country from falling further into an economic collapse.... The current complex and ineffective tax system in the united states needs to be replaced with a flat tax system to avoid the country from falling further into an economic collapse.... nbsp;… Notwithstanding the drawbacks of the flat tax, the overall economic gain that could be experienced is sufficient to warrant the analyst to realize that this particular approach is far superior to the system of taxation that currently exists within the united states....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us