Ethical Attributions for and against the Milgram Experiment - Essay Example

Add to wishlist

Summary

This document “Ethical Attributions for and against the Milgram Experiment” will look at the ethical attributions of the Milgram experiment and argue for and against the experiments according to the ethical principles of psychologists and code of conduct set out by the American Psychological Association…

Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing

GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.2% of users find it useful

Ethical Attributions for and against the Milgram Experiment

Read Text Preview

Subject: Sociology
Type: Essay
Level: High School
Pages: 1 (250 words)
Downloads: 4

Extract of sample "Ethical Attributions for and against the Milgram Experiment"

However it should be commended that when offering payment of $4.50 an hour, the participants were told that they would receive the payment whether or not they completed the experiment, this was the most ethical thing to do as then payment wouldn't be the motivator of the participant's actions. Looking at all the facts given above, it can be argued that the researchers should have been honest with the participants about the nature of the experiment being a study in obedience and not that of memory and learning and that the experimenter should have reminded the participant/teacher that they are free to leave at any time, instead of using verbal prods to ensure they continue with the experiment.

While this is correct we should keep in mind that the experiment results would not have been accurate if the above suggestions were followed even though it may have made the experiment more ethical.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Attributions for and against the Milgram Experiment

Can Individual Virtue Survive Corporate Pressure

The researcher of this essay “Can Individual Virtue Survive Corporate Pressure?... rdquo; aims to compare two opposing points of view presented by Robert C.... Solomon and Gilbert Harman on the question of 'Can Individual Virtue Survive Corporate Pressure?... … The author explains that Robert Solomon objects to the deterministic standpoint, by noting how there is an evasion of 'responsibility' by both corporations and its managers for their actions....

5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Importance of Power Relations

In real-world settings, examples of such overlooked instances can be seen in racial discrimination against colored people and discrimination against women (Hollway et al.... This paper explains the notion of power relations and shows how and why it is a central component of the critical evaluation....

8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Causes of Evil and Their Nature

The second example is the milgram's experiment where subjects were under the instructor's instruction to obey the evil actions by pressing the button with the high or extreme voltage in order to kill the learner (Foldager, Schultz, St?... Causes of Evil Name Instructor Course Date Abstract Over the years, it is has always been said that conception of evil is controversial....

10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Power of Situation

” Jerry M Burger explains the findings of an experiment that replicated Stanley Milgram's obedience studies.... In his book, “Replicating milgram: Would People still Obey Today?... The environment in which a child is born and brought up has more potential to shape his identity than his internal humanistic conscience and other internal forces....

8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

A Lot of Questions

aking sure that group leaders remain impartialfinding holes in all arguments that go against the groups desiresseeking opinions of people outside of the groupvoting for a choice by secret ballot rather than with a show of handsmaking sure that group members know they will be responsible for the groups decisionQuestion 14 (Multiple Choice Worth 1 points)An individual who exerts less effort when working on a group task if individual contributions will not be evaluated is engaging in what is called _____....

21 Pages (5250 words) Assignment

Comparative Methods of Explaining Social Behaviour

The paper "Comparative Methods of Explaining Social Behaviour" describes that different theories have been developed to explain social behaviour.... The pillars of each of them have been evolving since the early 1900s when the focus shifted to and introduced science in the field.... nbsp;… The theory posits that social behaviour is dependent on three factors: internal or social locus; controllability; and stability or the likelihood of a behaviour retaining or altering the status quo (Elster, 2007)....

6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

How Authorities Come to Have so Much Power That, They Can Convince to Kill People

The influence of the authority over the subjects in demanding loyalty is a factor in crimes against humanity.... he term describing the violent crimes committed against a given group with the intent to eliminate their existence did not exist until 1944.... This report "How Authorities Come to Have so Much Power That, They Can Convince to Kill People" discusses the case of the Holocaust and Rwanda Genocide in the minds of generations....

9 Pages (2250 words) Report

Obedience in Psychology

Heath (1999), a major critic of the milgram experiment argued that it lacked experimental pragmatism since the participants did not necessarily comprehend the experimental setup.... Obedience refers to a form of social impact where a person's actions are driven by the orders of another person (milgram, 1978).... He further argues that state officials are the major perpetrators of crimes against humanity as they incite the masses to kill each other....

6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework