Nobody downloaded yet

Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Three-Dimensional View of Power according To Lukes - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
Many people have come up with varying definitions of power, with each person having various points of focus. Though they could dwell on the same point, they explain it in different ways. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Three-Dimensional View of Power according To Lukes
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Three-Dimensional View of Power according To Lukes"

Download file to see previous pages This has caused critics in light of their differences, with each person trying to extrapolate on the basis of the explanation. Renowned academicians have had their fair share on critics on each other especially in reflection to power and control of the people that are involved (Gidden, 2010). For instance, Marx Weber states that power is a resource that should be utilized in the world. He defines power as a resource that some people have at the expense of other people that do not have. In such a circumstance, people have to take power from others and control other resources. The other people that do not have power have little or no control as they do not have the discrepancy as such. According to Marx Weber, power is defined by a few people that are in control. Steven Lukes steps in to criticize power in a more radical way. He states that power is a continuous exercise which involves two different parties. While some parties will have power, the other parties do not have power to control the people that have power. According to Lukes, a single party will exercise power and use the power to gain control over some issues. In such a situation, the other party does not have control. There will be a divergence of interests as the party with power will exercise the power contrary to the interests of the other party. At times, the party that does not have power will be aware of this, while at other times, the other party will not have a clue as to the actions of the party that is in power. Steven Lukes criticizes power in stating that it has three faces (Gidden, 2010). In the first face, Lukes states that the parties make a mutual decision as they are participatory. Though they are involved in making the decisions, they are only allowed to participate to a certain extent, as their interests have to be catered for. Since they are both involved in the decision making process, their interests are guaranteed. However, this depends on the bodies that are in power as they have the overall power on the decisions that are made. This creates an all inclusive scenario where all the parties that have interests are engaged in decision making. The second face as stated by Lukes is that, there are instances on non-decision. In such a scenario, the people in power set up an agenda where they have control of the decisions that will be made. Part of their agenda is to create a scenario where decisions will not be reached. Certain decisions will never be reached, despite any effort from the people that have lesser control and power. In such a position, the interests of the people that do not have power are jeopardized. Therefore, the people in power have a leeway of making decisions on behalf of other people (Gidden, 2010). This is absolutely done to ensure the people in power have their interests at hand. The people that do not have power have their interests at stake as they will never reach to a decision that will protect their interests. The third face as explained by Lukes states that decisions are made according to the interests of the masses. People in power make decisions so that they can cater for a whole community of the people. This is a contrary opinion which is a critique against Weber’s definition of power. In such a scenario, the people in power make decisions which are inclusive of the interests of all the other people. The desires of everyone are included in the decision making. Though the people in power make such decisions to please everyone else, their interests are also protected. Therefore, these decisions are not made to please an individual but are ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1471755-steven-lukes-and-webers-definition-of-power-and-the-advantages-of-the-three-dimensional-view-of-power-according-to-lukes
(Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Essay)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1471755-steven-lukes-and-webers-definition-of-power-and-the-advantages-of-the-three-dimensional-view-of-power-according-to-lukes.
“Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1471755-steven-lukes-and-webers-definition-of-power-and-the-advantages-of-the-three-dimensional-view-of-power-according-to-lukes.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
ja
jacobsisaias added comment 5 months ago
Student rated this paper as
This paper saved me today. I liked the structure. It was very useful for my sociology course.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Three-Dimensional View of Power according To Lukes

Describe elements of power and quote work from Weber, Bachrach & Baratz & Lukes

...– and stakeholders, aiming to have an advantage towards their rivals and being capable of using flexible plans in order to support their organization, without being exposed to the risks of the local market rules/ regulator bodies. The theories on power as developed by Weber and Bachrach & Baratz have been often criticized, as of their credibility. Lukes (1974) has been among the theorists arguing that the traditional views on power and control should be updated. He explained that power, as theorists had described the concept up to then, is necessarily related to specific activities. However, in practice, it has been made...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Definition of Power

...of the of the Concerned 7 October Definition of Power Power is not a concept that is necessarily or solely confined to the discipline of politics only. It would certainly not be wrong to say that a sense of power is the necessary and intrinsic need of the human existence. In an individual context, the feeling of not having any power over the social ambience in which one lives, over the people and groups that one comes across in one’s day to day life, over the events that collectively constitute an individual’s life, or over the varied aspects of one’s personal life could indeed turn out to be very disturbing and enervating. When people feel helpless...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

Power

...What is the division of power within the EC The division of power within the European community may be seen as a two track system. First of all, there exists a hierarchy of member nations that is often criticized, especially when a member first joins the Union, as too vague. "It is often stressed that today, the division of powers, as organized by the Treaties, is not clear enough" (Pris, 2000, 4). Secondly, and more interesting in scope and under scrutiny for the purposes of this discussion, is the separation of powers between the Council, Commission and the Court of Justice. These three C's in many ways mirror the three branches of...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Managing Innovation at St. Lukes Medical Center

...after and have since then, steered the institution in the course that spells excellence in the delivery of health care. Vision, Mission and Values According to the Official Website of SLMC ( pars. 1 & 2), the vision and mission of the hospital are indicated as follows: “VISION: St. Lukes Medical Center will be one of the Top 5 medical institutions in Asia by Year 2010. MISSION: To deliver excellent healthcare through caring and highly competent professionals, utilizing world-class technology and research. This we shall do in the most financially viable way without losing sight of our primary purpose - to be of service to God and mankind.” Further, SLMC adheres to six corporate values which they...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Power

...certain likable qualities which they would like to emulate (Robbins, 2009). The person is mostly charismatic and has a great following. Griffin and Moorhead (2011) note that such a person is good in inspiring loyalty among workers. For example, employee 3 though has worked for very few months in the company already commands a large following due to his qualities and as a result managed to compel other employees to accept the project and was made a leader of the group. B. Relationship between Dependency and Power Robbins (2009) defines power as “capacity that A has to influence the behavior of B so that B acts in accordance with A’s wishes” (351). From this definition...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Why is Steven Lukes critical of Webers definition of power What are the advantages of the three-dimensional view of power according to Lukes

...power as the probability of individuals realizing their wills despite the resistance of others. Weber insists that the people in authority take advantage of the others due to their power. However, Steven Luke criticizes Weber’s definition because exercise of power may involve the decision-making and control over political agenda. Steven disagrees with the idea that people’s resistance to authority defines power (Luke 1973). Through Luke’s analysis, Weber’s definition of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Why is Steven Lukes critical of Weber's definition of power What are the advantages of the three-dimensional view of power according to Lukes

...What is Steven Luke’s critical of Webers definition of power? What are the advantages of the three-dimensional view of power according to Luke’s? Course Title Instructor Date MAX WEBER’S DEFINITION OF POWERAccording to Max Weber, power can be defined as an actor in the social system which has the authority to carry out his own will despite resistance from external bodies. The concept of power may be further defined as the set of all the qualities, characteristics and circumstances that put an individual in a situation to impose his own will. The concept of power may be précised further by adding that the command given by a person who imposes power should be obeyed by others. Power is to pursue one’s own objectives against... as the control...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Three- dimensional echocardiography

...makes it advantageous over 2D echocardiography. The value, feasibility, and accuracy of three-dimensional echocardiography have been evident in the intraoperative environment. Three-dimensional echocardiography gives accurate and frequently additional anatomic information as compared to two-dimensional echocardiography. Interactive three-dimensional TEE was instrumental in identifying folding, and distortion of the annulus as a cause of worsening mitral regulation and functional mitral stenosis during beating heart surgery. Intraoperative three-dimensional TEE is...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Three-dimensional (3D)

...3D Every individual explores his or her hidden talent at one point of time. In the similar manner, I also found my talent or rather explored by talent i.e. writing. I believe that it is essential to be able to write because that leaves a mark of your existence for others. Great legends have left their written pieces about experiences and phases in life. I also believe that writing has made me understand my goals in life and outlook on different issues. I describe myself as a three-dimensional (3D) writer. It is merely because I am able to look at one issue, conflict or aspect of life from different perspectives. Writing has rather enabled me to appoint such an approach that allows effective...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Power

...Power POWER Introduction Power is the ity given to an individual or a certain body to control over others. It is a phrase used widely in the day to day activities, for instance, power trip, power politics and many more others. However, very few connotations of power have positivity in its sense. According to Max Weber’s definition about power, he insinuates that with power any individual or social group can easily access an opportunity despite resistance from others regardless of where the opportunity lies. Due to this, power has been regarded to have innate features hence people have developed a notion that power is a leeway for privileges, wealth and even considering themselves to be of a superior race. Individuals have got... the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Steven Lukes and Webers Definition of Power, and the Advantages of the Three-Dimensional View of Power according To Lukes for FREE!

Contact Us