Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Is general deterrence likely to reduce crime? Name Class Instructor Date Is general deterrence likely to reduce crime? General deterrence as a mechanism to reduce crime is grounded on the basic premise of intimidating and threatening people to refrain them from committing crime…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime"

Download file to see previous pages Imposing punishment as deterrence to crime is a criminal justice philosophy that was first conceptualized by Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham who provided the philosophical foundation of the deterrence and rational choice theory. Cesare Beccaria formulated the theory out of his disgust of the primitive justice system of his time that he considered as whimsical and excessive. He thought of an alternative justice system that is rational, just and efficient, thus is his general deterrence theory (Paternoster, 2010). Today’s prevailing thought about how crime can be curbed or curtailed can be said to be consistent of the general deterrence theory. It is the idea that criminal acts can be prevented out of fear of sanction and, thus, would-be offenders would be deterred to commit crime. In this theory, law enforcement or policing is necessary to have the perception among would be offenders, a risk or certainty of apprehension that would eventually lead to meting out a punishment. The general deterrence theory is hinged on the premise that a man acts out of self-interest or as Beccaria would put it “the despotic spirit which is present in every man” (Beccaria, 1764, p. 94). ...
Thus, being a rational being, the man will elect a course of action based on what will benefit him the most. Following this line of argument, if the pain of punishment far outweighs the benefit or pleasure of breaking a law, and that apprehension and punishment is certain, the man being a rationale being will avoid crime and deterrence takes effect. This theory, however, was questioned and doubted by several scholars on the field of criminal justice. Among them is Von Hentig, a former editor of the journal who dismissed the validity of general deterrence in reducing crime. According to Von Hentig, general deterrence will not work because the threat of punishment is not immediate and distant to the would-be offender. The danger presented by the punishment to the offender is perceived as remote and, thus, can be readily offset by the immediate advantage of committing to the crime (1938). Von Hentig also critiqued the philosophical foundation of general deterrence that there are individuals who are immune from the threats of legal punishment. He cited those who are motivated by “maternal instincts, the young and women who tend to be impetuous, those motivated by ideology, the “have-nots,” and the feeble-minded” (Paternoster, 2011, p. 773). Von Hentig also dismissed the theory that men are basically motivated by pleasure and discouraged by pain as being naive considering the complicity of life (1938). Andenaes shared Von Hentig’s skepticism and doubted general deterrence’s efficacy in reducing crime. For Andenaes, the use of state sanctioned threat of punishment to deter crime is not a sound empirical basis for the validity of the proposition of general deterrence (Paternoster, 2011). These points of view of Andenaes and Von Hentig are shared ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime Essay”, n.d.)
Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1452492-is-general-deterrence-likely-to-reduce-crime
(Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime Essay)
Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime Essay. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1452492-is-general-deterrence-likely-to-reduce-crime.
“Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1452492-is-general-deterrence-likely-to-reduce-crime.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime

The concept of Deterrence

...as insurgents took advantage of the situation to capitalize on popular support (22). The key elements that Sir Gerald used to coin the name include: increasing political rights of the people, reducing abuse and corruption of government power, providing security to the people against insurgent forces and predations from government. Further this involved enhancing positive aspects while minimizing on the negative (23). This theory was applied in Afghanistan after president Obama took office where he started off by stressing partnership with Pakistan (West 89). The next step by the US in Afghanistan was the coalition strategy of COIN, “to secure and serve the population” according to the 2006 U.S. Army and Marine Corps...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

The General Theory of Crime

...The General Theory of Crime In terms of crime's general theory of action, Gottfredson and Hirschi (1990) argue that all crimes occur because they are chosen. They say that there is significant variation in the extent to which people choose to act offensively or recklessly based on their underlying "criminality". This criminality or impulsiveness is an individual property characterized by several things: the need for immediate gratification of desires, the utilization of simple means ("money without work, sex without courtship, revenge without court delays"), preferences for exciting, thrilling, or risky activities, little interest in long term...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Does Marriage Reduce Crime

...Does marriage reduce crime A counterfactual approach to within-individual causal effects. Marriage is known to be an association linked with the social and physical norms of an individual. It is known throughout centuries that marriage has a certain effect on the life of an individual and usually it changes the life of one. The paper is designed to confirm the effect of marriages on the life of an individual. Research done by Sampson, Laub and Wimer clearly states that there is a link of the association of marriage with that of the rates of crime. The paper gives enough evidence to one individual through which he can conclude the effect of marriage on the rates of crime...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Strategic Deterrence

...RESEARCH PAPER Communicating with the stake holders may sound somewhat negotiating between the companies or the firms but ideally speaking it really reduces the risk of incurring losses. Not only that it also helps reduce excessive manpower used if deterrence is not abided. The concept of Strategic deterrence all begins with the primary intention of saving the market from multi market competition battle, which can ultimately bring stability among multi markets. Strategic deterrence is not accepted the moment the multi market contact start to encroach the others market but it is just an understanding that too mutually agreed up activity, which after...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Strategic Deterrence

...STRATEGIC DETERRENCE Strategic deterrence in its general form can be described as a pre-planned avoidance of its competitors in thesaid field. They may compete in some other field but try to avoid competing in the respective fields. This deterrence is only to avoid incurring losses unnecessary from his competitor. The competitor may be a weak party but still would be unwilling to compete. This strategy is primarily to avoid losses during industry shake out for any particular product. Some firms compete while others forbear from competing with their 'multipoint' rivals-those faced in more than one markets or market segment. According to the study it is clear that multi...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Deterrence

...mechanisms for deterring criminal activity” (Lynch, 1999). One of the most important tasks of the government of any country should be to create the fear of punishment in the minds of criminals in order to prevent them from carrying out a criminal activity. One of the benefits, which come from the implementation of correctional sanctions, is removal of the fear of crimes and violence from the minds of the peaceful citizens. The basic purpose of deterrence is to make the criminals aware of the consequences of crimes. It is a common fact that people do not want to be punished or sent to jails in any case. Therefore, they opt not to commit any sort of crime as it endangers...
2 Pages(500 words)Term Paper

Does NY stop and frisk reduce crime

...Does NY Stop and Frisk Reduce Crime ID Number & Total Number of Words: 364 Accordingto Raymond Kelly – the New York Police Commissioner; “we are successful in suppressing crime, and we want to get the word out about how we do it” (Gardiner & Saul, 2012). To prove that the “stop and frisk” policy is effective in terms of controlling the number of reported city crimes, Mac Donald (2012) highlighted that the crime rate in New York was relatively low at 2,257 per 100,000 residents as compared to Boston’s 4,107 per 100,000 residents and High Point’s 5,212 per 100,000 residents. Due to the fact that the rate of homicide in New York has significantly decreased by up to “82% from 1990 to 2009” made the members of the N.Y.P.D. believe... that the...
1 Pages(250 words)Term Paper

Crime and Deterrence

...that when a government invests more in building the number of police officers in operation, potential criminals may be deterred from engaging in crime by the perception that it is likely for them to be apprehended while at the same time fearing the mode of police operations through detention (incapacitation). Nevertheless, the literature evaluated through the study fails to offer supportive scientific evidence on the perception of reducing crime by deterrence and incapacitation through police tactics and or increased manpower. In another study, Cullen, Jonson and Nagin (2011), intended to study the role of prison in reducing the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Reduce crime rate

.... The second and the important way to reduce crime rates is the mandatory sentencing for criminals and their copartners. Lombroso, Ferrero, Rafter, & Gibson (2004) mentioned that showing people bad outcomes of committing crimes is a very important factor and deterrent for reducing crime rates in the societies. The mandatory sentencing can impose fear of crime for people, and this can make them avoid getting involved in criminal activity. When a person knows that the murder or another crime can lead him/her to jail or to death, he/she will not make any mistakes and he will comply with laws of the society....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Dynamics Of Crime And Delinquency

...from engaging in the same crime. General deterrence is meant to make people aware of the horrors and sanctions thus scaring them from committing crimes. Since the general deterrence was meant to deter those, who witness the infliction of pain on the criminal, corporal punishments, were traditionally carried out in public so that it could scare off people from repeating such crime (Hugh and Scott, 2010). Specific deterrence on the other side is designed to deter only the individual offender from repeating the same crime. Proponents of specific deterrence hold that severe...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Is General Deterrence Likely to Reduce Crime for FREE!

Contact Us