To What Extent Can Blauner's Operationalization of Alienation Be Regarded as Marxist - Coursework Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
To What Extent Can Blauner’s Operationalization of Alienation Be Regarded As Marxist? Outline Introduction Body Conclusion Introduction Alienation, a term which was first conceptualised by Karl Marx in Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts of 1844 and which literally meant estrangement, was attributed to labour under the capitalist system…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
To What Extent Can Blauners Operationalization of Alienation Be Regarded as Marxist
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "To What Extent Can Blauner's Operationalization of Alienation Be Regarded as Marxist"

Download file to see previous pages For him, this feeling of estrangement was because commodities which have value would control and shape the activities of human beings or a belief which was also known as commodity fetishism (Craib: 1997: 35 – 42; Haralambos, 2004: 621 – 623; Slattery, 2003: 14 – 21). On the one hand, for Blauner, alienation was job dissatisfaction. In 1940s, Robert Blauner had examined alienation through the manual workers in the American modern industry (Grint: 1998: 269 – 272). In his effort to link Melvin Seeman’s psychological dimensions of alienation, his operationalization of the concept alienation was very much resembling to that of Marx’s idea of alienation under the capitalist system even though he was not a Marxist. Because of this, Blauner was criticised for using a non – Marxist concept of alienation. In this regard, this paper would aim at figuring out up to what extent is Blauner’s operationalization of alienation regarded as Marxist. Main Body Marx’s idea of alienation under capitalism was comprised by four (4) characteristics. First, he identified that alienation could result from the worker’s alienation from the product of his own labour. It was the case that in capitalism, the worker who produced the product had no longer control over that certain product. The control was owned by the capitalist system which had not only controlled his workers but also had the control over the product of labour of his workers. Second, a worker could be alienated from the very act of production itself for the reason that this very act of production was something in exchange of profit through wages instead of his social needs. Third, a worker could be alienated from his very own self being the producer of the product, as a human being. He, then, happened to see himself doing meaningless activities because he was reduced to a machine working for survival. Forth, a worker could be alienated from the other workers. In a capitalist society, social relations happened to be displaced for labour was something that was reduced to a commodity needed to be exchanged in the market (Craib: 1997: 35 – 42; Slattery, 2003: 14 – 21). On the one hand, alienation for Blauner was something that was not a result of the capitalist relations but was something that was attributed to job dissatisfaction. For him, this concept comprised four (4) dimensions such as powerlessness, meaninglessness, isolation and self – estrangement. The first sign of alienation, powerlessness, was the degree of control the worker had over his work in which the control was shaped by external factors. Second was meaninglessness or the sense of purpose that the worker had in his job. Third indication was social isolation which was characterised by the extent to which they were integrated at the social level with their co – workers. The last state was self – estrangement which was regarded as how involved a worker was in his work (Fulcher and Scott, 2007: 679 – 682). Moreover, according to Haralambos (2004: 626 – 629) and O’Donnell (1997: 262 – 268), Blauner considered 4 occupational situations through printing industry (craft technology), textile industry (machine minding technology), car industry (assembly line production), and chemical industry (automation) in his examination of alienation. As an illustration of a pre – industrial craft technology, the printing industry ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“To What Extent Can Blauner's Operationalization of Alienation Be Coursework”, n.d.)
To What Extent Can Blauner's Operationalization of Alienation Be Coursework. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1442739-to-what-extent-can-blauner-s-operationalisation-of
(To What Extent Can Blauner'S Operationalization of Alienation Be Coursework)
To What Extent Can Blauner'S Operationalization of Alienation Be Coursework. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1442739-to-what-extent-can-blauner-s-operationalisation-of.
“To What Extent Can Blauner'S Operationalization of Alienation Be Coursework”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1442739-to-what-extent-can-blauner-s-operationalisation-of.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF To What Extent Can Blauner's Operationalization of Alienation Be Regarded as Marxist

Alienation

... spheres of life. Children of immigrants encounter discrimination in schools and colleges. Ethnic speech and other activities of segregation make them feel odd in America. Their parents attempt to Americanize them do not bring the desired consequences. Children of immigrants struggle to manage their lives in two conflicting worlds. Children face a different world when they meet their peers. Hispanic and Asian children who attend metropolitan area schools suffer from various kinds of discrimination. Social workers and immigration professionals can help the children who encounter alienation problems. They must try to understand the difficulties faced by immigrant children. They must learn where these children are coming... assignment is due...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

To What Extent Can Blauner's Operationalisation of Alienation Be Regarded as Marxian

...? To what extent can Blauner’s operationalization of alienation be regarded as Marxian? Introduction Division of labor refers to the breaking down of work into several tasks, each performed by a specialized worker. To Durkheim, division of labor was positive in that it gave an equal chance to all members in the society to participate in its development, which also meant, that there were enough resources to go around. It meant a reduction in the struggle for survival since everyone had a role to play (Woodward 2005). According to Karl Marx, division of labor is negative mainly because it is a product of a capitalistic society. When a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Blauner's Operationalization of Alienation: On What Grounds It Can Be Marxist

...? Blauner’s Operationalization of Alienation: On What Grounds It Can Be Marxist? Outline Introduction Marx and Blauner on Alienation Conclusion Introduction According to Craib (1997: 88 - 91) and Haralambos (2004: 621 – 623), Karl Marx had formulated a theory of alienation which had uncovered that the capitalist mode of production was shaping the human activity. For Marx, alienation was when an individual had felt the estrangement from his society as well as its other aspects for the reason that the individual could not avoid the losing of such control of their lives because under the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Variables operationalization

...? Variable operationalization RES500 Research Methods of Health Sciences ABINA RILEY TRIDENT January 16, Variable operationalization Introduction Research defines an organized investigation with the aim of developing a knowledge base. One of the significant elements of a research is the operationalization of involved variables. In this paper, I discus my proposed approach to operationalization by discussing the components of my identified design, and classifying the design. I also explain the reasons for selecting the design and possible bias to which the design is vulnerable. Components of the design A randomized controlled trial is the proposed design for exploring my research hypothesis. The design defines an approach of using... ...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Alienation

...was an old friend and former suitor of Clarissa. Their meeting reflects a mixture of happiness and tension as Clarissa wonders why she married Richard Dalloway instead of Peter Walsh who was her suitor. The novel also revolves around the story of Septimus Warren Smith, a shell-shocked World War I veteran who suffered from the war and later committed suicide. The novel presents the topic of alienation in many dimensions. Alienation depicts a sense of emotional isolation between individuals or groups within a given community. Indeed, we can sense a feeling of emotional isolation as Peter Walsh feels desperate over his unfulfilling life. This results from the fact that his friends and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Alienation

... Paper Applying Marx's Types of Alienation Introduction The are believed to be suffering from tunnel vision, as the corporate practices are not running according to theoretical perspectives of the classroom. The student loans are on the rise in developed economies of the world and therefore, the pupils have to work in order pay off their debt. The students cannot focus on their studies because their time has been consumed by professional duties and responsibilities. However, the early exposure to work environment helps the students in landing a job in early career but in the long-run perspective, the students who could have an exceptional mark in academics end up doing ordinary jobs in comparison to their talents and competencies... . The...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Marxist Analysis

...Marxist Analysis In the American Dream movie, a large Corporation is making enormous profits, and yet it is demanding pay cut of its factory employees. Clash ensues and workers make a strike threat as a result of the company’s intention to reduce the wages. In the fall of 1983, Hormel announced that it would reduce hourly wages of factory workers from $10.69 to $8.25. This was despite the fact that Hormel reported earnings of approximately $30 million. As the workers through their union decide to strike, the movie introduces the key actors. There is Ray Rogers, a freelance strike planner and publicist; Rogers easy, smiling style makes him seem like an opportunist. There is Lewis Anderson, an experienced negotiator from...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Marxist Analysis

...My Analysis Marxist theory stemmed from the philosophy of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. The theory was based on the economic and political philosophy, in which the class struggle plays a fundamental role of historical change, and the capitalism will eventually be superseded by communisms (classless society). In literature, a Marxist perspective combines the power of literary works to convey the extent and illustrate how capitalism shapes society and divides it between the prevailing bourgeoisie and poor class known as the proletariat (Dobie, p.87). The story “The Destructors “by Graham Greene tells of the exploits of a group of adolescent boys who call themselves the Wormsley common...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Theory, Operationalization, and Observation

...). In the example, the variables may be operationalized in the form of questions such as “have you ever stolen anything?” The respondents who say yes will be categorized as delinquents, while the respondents who answer no will be categorized as non delinquent. Social class can be operationalized by posing the question “what was your family’s income last year?” The answer is measured against a set of provided family income categories. The operationalized hypothesis from the stated example can be expressed as the highest incidences of delinquents manifest among respondents bearing the lowest family income category. Observation denotes looking at the world...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Alienation

...settings contrast each other. The communist society helps to streamline the inter-relation between labor and product through common delegation of resources (Marx 66). Contrary to communism, capitalist uphold the existence of private property, which is the apex of alienation (Marx 79). Private property is an ultimate idea in capitalistic societies. According to Marx, private property advocates the existence of inhuman power (100). Inhuman power concerning alienation involves the exploitation of the work force by the wealthy. Resource delegation in such cases of capitalism favors the wealthy who enjoy other people’s investments. Marx maintains that capitalism causes people to be self-centered making them...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Coursework on topic To What Extent Can Blauner's Operationalization of Alienation Be Regarded as Marxist for FREE!

Contact Us