Nobody downloaded yet

Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates - Assignment Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
In almost all the criminal justice systems, there are two opposing schools of thought: Those who believe that sentencing of similar cases should be uniform and those who believe that sentencing should take an individualized approach. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.7% of users find it useful
Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates"

Download file to see previous pages The first group argue that it is logical for “punishment to fit the crime that constitute the interesting penological questions” while the second group counters by arguing that “justice should be served by an individualized approach to sentencing” (Jacobson & Hough, 2007). The fact is that in creating laws, we have imagined a situation whereby a robber is handed the same sentence by all magistrates as any other robber. However, even these legislative pieces have given the judges and magistrates some discretion to decide on the exact sentence that the different robbers should be handed. This principle has been opposed by factions of the society. They have perceived such sentences as being based on personal whims rather than the law (Jacobson & Hough, 2007). This is a long-standing debate in the criminological circles in Hong Kong as in any where else. This approach has made some people to argue that the magistrates are sending the wrong message to the public (Jacobson & Hough, 2007). This is more so when such sensitive issues as socio-economic status come to play. The public will not understand why the judge let go of a first-time offender, who happened to be the niece of a judge; and took to jail another boy who has been a habitual offender, and who comes from a poor family, for the same offense. However, different magistrates will give different sentences for similar cases. This is not a default of Hong Kong’s criminal justice system. This is a principle that is carried out for the sake of justice; it is a principle that promotes rehabilitation of an offender rather than retribution. However, not many people agree to that principle. Some people believe that this principle has been misused. Yes, Hong Kong needs a criminal justice system that is thorough, impartial and fair: A justice system that will look at a robber and hand him or her the same penalty as any other robber. Human beings have tried to create a justice system that is blind to people’s social, academic, health or family backgrounds. But as much as we have wanted this to work, it has not been possible. A juvenile who steals from a shop can not be handed the same sentence as a grown man who steals from the same shop. If someone has committed a crime for the first time, you do not punish him as a habitual offender. But still people have reasoned that it is only when the justice process is free, fair and impartial that justice is truly served. Some people have gone as far as suggesting that certain juveniles should be subjected to the same justice system as the adults. These people have gone ahead and described delinquent acts crime: That murder is murder is murder, whether committed by an adult or a minor. These people argue that the children who engage in delinquent acts break the law just as any other criminal. They should thus face the full force of the law just any other person. Unfortunately, this has not always been the case. The same crimes, when subjected to different magistrates, the world over, have invited different sentences. This phenomenon has been more pronounced in Hong Kong. This has left some key stake holders in the Hong Kong’s criminal justice system wondering: Is there different sentences for similar cases in different magistrates? If yes, why have these similar cases received different sentences by different magistrates? There are numerous statistics which show that, indeed, there are different sentences for similar cases by different magistrates. This might have cast aspersions on the integrity and credibility of Hong Kong’s Judiciary. Some people have interpreted this to mean that the Courts are compromised in their judgments (and ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates Assignment”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates Assignment)
“Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates Assignment”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
wlangosh added comment 1 year ago
Student rated this paper as
The topic of "Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates." was tough to find. I spent hours to find it. Here at StudentShare, I got the best example. Many thanks!

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates

Malaysia and Hong kong

...?Malaysia and Hong Kong Table of Contents 0.A Case Study Analysis: Hong Kong 3 1.Government’s Role in Enhancing Economic Competitiveness 3 2.Role of Human Capital in Developing Economic Competitiveness 4 1.3.SWOT Analysis of Hong Kong’s Human Capital 7 1.4.Key Characteristics of a Knowledge-Based Economy According to APEC 9 1.5.Recommendations 10 2.0.A Case Study Analysis: Malaysia 11 2.1.Causes of the Financial Crisis in Malaysian Economy: 1998 and 2008 11 2.2 Governmental Measures Undertaken 12 2.3 Pros & Cons of the Measures Adapted 13 2.4 The Present Scenario: Economic and Social Context 14 References 15 Bibliography 17 1.0. A Case...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Hong Kong Courts Sentences

...just for the purposes of criticizing the court’s rulings which he or she will not be sure of winning, many will regard this as a waste of time and effort. If all these are considered, many people will opt to give the judges the final say when it comes to sentencing criminals and their word becomes final, it thus becomes very hard to question it on the basis of leniency. It can be agreed that the Hong Kong courts are faced with major injustice practices including that of sentencing. Sentencing has been done in the recent past with a lot of lenience without regard to societies’ morals. Even with this, there is a big gap and knowledge...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

History of Hong Kong

...of culture, but with a dense western influence too. Majority of people in Hong Kong contemplate themselves as "Hong Konger" or "Hong Kongese" instead of "Chinese" for they feel like if they say they are Chinese, people would deliberate they are from central China, which, for many explanations, they do not like being reflected as "Mainland Chinese" (Carroll, 2007). On different social characteristics, the bottom - line Chinese principles of "family solidarity", "saving face" and "courtesy" carry significant weight on the culture (Carroll, 2007). Heavy influence gets derived from Cantonese culture of the neighboring Chinese Guangdong province. There are...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Disneyland Hong Kong

...? Disneyland Hong Kong Table of Contents Disneyland Hong Kong Table of Contents 2 Executive summary 3 Introduction 3 Disney on international forum 4 Company background 4 Development of Disneyland in other international destinations 5 Hong Kong Disneyland 6 Disneyland in Japan 7 Disneyland in France 8 Conclusion and Recommendations 9 References 10 Executive summary The Disneyland is a fascinating name in the entertainment industry that is a multi-million dollar lavish and prolific theme park. It is present in different countries and is rated as one of the best elements in the global entertainment industry. Since 1955, The...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Hong kong disney land

...? Disneyland in Paris and Hong Kong: What’s Next? 13 October Disney is aware of the importance of global expansion to its brand equity and financial growth; however, it has experienced varying degrees of success in different parts of the globe. Disneyland theme parks are flourishing in the United States and Tokyo, but they have struggled in Hong Kong and Paris (Needle, 2004, p.522). This essay explores several issues regarding Disney’s challenges in Hong Kong and Paris, and it also determines the best country and city for the next Disneyland. One of the most essential entry approaches for Disney is to work with foreign...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Hong Kong film

...Kong; the claim of Hong Kong construction methods to film series like the Matrix and Lord of the Rings trilogies), and will like tentative Hong Kong's advance to reinventing traditional accepted film genres. In this research I have argue a well-known question: what do we make of film as industrial product and film as cultural body For the purposes of this research on hong kong film culture I use 'film culture' in a limited sense to submit to film expenditure, or the globe of movement of the cinema between different audience groups. At the very beginning I hope to spot out that I create a number of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Company law (hong kong)

...Company Law Order #135643 (words 3020) Business corporations exist for the sole purpose of making profits for their stockholders". (A A Berle, "For Whom Corporate Managers Are Trustees "A corporation is an abstraction. It has no mind of it's own any more than it has a body of its own; its active and directive will must consequently be sought in the person or somebody who for some purposes may be called an agent, but who is really the directing mind and will as the corporation, the very ego and centre of the personality of the corporation1" The main objective of any business corporation is to make profit for both shareholders and stock holders of the company. Therefore managers are trustees of the organization... Law Order #135643...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Hong Kong Hotel Industry

...Dissertation Proposal "Do environment friendly practices can create competitive advantage in Hong Kong Hotel Industries" We all know that Hong Kong is one of the major tourist spots not only in Asia but also in the world. Since it was colonized by Britain, this place somehow showed a remarkable growth in industrialization in which investments from different countries came. It also distinguished itself as more ahead from China with the way their trade and commerce goes. Upon seeing these things, Hong Kong has a big potential in attracting tourists and more likely uplift the Hotel industries within its vicinity. However,...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Hong Kong Cinema

...that everyone can find something to re-realize and learn. Cantonese language, as Abbas (1997) writes, is the thid noticeable characteristic of Hong Kong cinema. In fact, under this superfluous assumption lies the bitter truth about Hong Kong residents - they are being forced to mimicry in order to have their products consumed. Cantonese language, however, serves as the background of the plot, or, more precisely, creates the impression of authenticity - and 'City of Glass' is not an exception. English language is used by the protagonists, but arriving at different settings, they begin to match English words with Cantonese ones in order to facilitate...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Criminal Sanctions and Criminal Remedies Deterrence The notion of penal sanction as deterrent to future crimes has been found to be objectionable by some. The first opposition to this is that it violates the idea of the justice principle that there must be no other consideration in imposing punishment but the crime itself and that it must therefore correspond or be proportionate to the crime. Giving consideration to future criminals and crimes in imposing punishment for a crime committed specifically by a certain offender will tend to make the punishment disproportionate to the crime. The notion of deterrence will also open the possibility of subjecting a crime to different gradations of penalty and hence, a wide disparity in sentencing...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Difference in Sentencing by Different Hong Kong Magistrates for FREE!

Contact Us