Question 5- Topic Seven: Summarise the chosen reading and include two (correctly referenced) quotations. According to the reading, the writer notes that the beginning of cultural studies experienced some difficulties and most people including scholars experienced some difficulties having to teach it as a discipline or a new part in the development of knowledge. The development of cultural studies began as a united effort among teachers and scholars that was manifested in the pedagogical methods of the Birmingham School for cultural studies.
In his writing, the writer also talks about the importance of knowledge in social and cultural studies as a politically infested atmosphere that joined together with the ‘out there in the dirty world’ (Stuart, The Emergence of Cultural Studies and the Crisis of the Humanities October 1990) According to Stuart, the criteria for the work done in cultural studies is work on the things that matter at the moment, these are the things that emerge from the experience of researchers in order to transform the same type of knowledge into practice.
According to hall, cultural studies found itself in a state that was defined to as ‘a good candidate for (them) at the Center, because it was not someone who had already engaged with and become committed to a field of inquiry which seemed, to that person, to matter. (The Emergence of Cultural Studies and the Crisis of the Humanities October, 1990) However he continues to say that the knowledge in social and cultural studies has been put in place in order to bring the theory of cultural living into practice.
As for the other part of the reading about the crisis of humanities, Stuart tries to talk more on what is known as the standards debate. Here he attacks the concept of free public education system as he looks at what is being taught in institute in terms of the developments in social and cultural studies. He adds that most of the schools and institutions lacked the Basic English skills and knowledge of the history of the English country which is highly blamed for the cultural crisis in the past and modern society.
Throughout the reading the writer continues to argue that there is an effort by scholars to ‘try to bring to light the ideological assumptions underpinning the practice,’ (Stuart, The Emergence of Cultural Studies and the Crisis of the Humanities 1990) and the erosion of the nation-state. In the concept of Thatcherism he attempts to find out who can still be "English", and these "truly English" people are reduced to only a handful of Oxford scholars after Thatcherism excluded virtually everybody, including its own "uneducated" youth.
So in order for the English to fight off this critical situation that might make them lose their identity, there should be a development of a national curriculum. Here a standard system should be imposed the humanities are "invoked as the last bastion of the liberal defensive operation". In the development of social and cultural studies under discussion, these concepts were taken to Falkland’s so that they are able to maintain the past and make it become a possible future. The crisis was come to be known as the identity crisis, for this reason most cultural scholars wanted to figure out when it first began.
However when it is traced well, it can definitely be concluded that the identity crisis that was experienced in the English country by this times was known as that crisis of British inclusion and exclusion from other parts of Europe. In the reading thus, the reader will be able to find out that the studies in cultural studies is to theorize these processes and find ways for the excluded to have their part in the national culture and community. In concluding thus, it can be said from reading Hall, the knowledge in cultural studies are what can be referred to as exploration of academics from what is on the ground, what people on the ground actually do practice and what is actually in theory or what is ought to be practiced by the people themselves.
Read More