StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Peter Singers views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper states that among other theorists, Singer asserts that it is an ethical obligation of all humans to mediate and bring an end to prevailing suffering and pain that poor people go through…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Peter Singers views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Peter Singers views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin"

Among other theorists, Singer asserts that it is an ethical obligation of all humans to mediate and bring an end to prevailing suffering and pain that poor people go through. On the other hand, Garrett Hardin believes that world hunger lacks morals. According to Hardin, a person’s suffering and pain is an outcome of one’s qualities, and the, therefore, the government should take responsibility to accommodate the individual.
Singer attempts to challenge Hardin’s theory by contending that people should be impartial and not waste time on unimportant issues, which also contribute towards people’s suffering. One would say that the theory of rights and responsibility lacks morals, but it may prove realistic regarding sustaining the spaceship. The term spaceship is a metaphor to mean the earth has limited space and resources (Kadeem, 2015). Therefore, Hardin means that continued population increase will directly lead to human suffering through famine and drought.
In my opinion, I would prefer singer’s idea because Hardin is a biologist and his opinion is theoretical and don not apply in the real sense. There are communities or countries, which are known to having a high population, but those countries are doing well. For instance China and India, they are overpopulated but still economically stable. Even those communities are not starving as asserted by Hardin. It takes people to work together and achieve stability and avoid poverty. Hardin also talks about government as the solution to people’s problems, but the government is made up of people, which means it will still take people’s initiative to work together and save the poor from hunger and suffering (Kadeem, 2015). However, I agree that human rights and hunger management should be a priority in a fight against suffering.
References
Kadeem P., (2015) Peter Singer’s utilitarianism views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin Education Ambassador at Hill Family Center for College Access Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Peter Singers views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin Assignment - 112”, n.d.)
Peter Singers views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin Assignment - 112. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1701815-any-topic-writeraposs-choice
(Peter Singers Views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin Assignment - 112)
Peter Singers Views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin Assignment - 112. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1701815-any-topic-writeraposs-choice.
“Peter Singers Views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin Assignment - 112”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1701815-any-topic-writeraposs-choice.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Peter Singers views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin

Peter Enterprises

...?TMA 03 Question Answer a) Peter Enterprises Income ment For the Year Ended 31 December 2009 Income from Sales ?3,003,500 Less: Cost of Goods Sold Opening Stock 246,000 Add: Purchases 1,860,500 Less: Ending Stock 287,000 Cost of Goods Sold 1,819,500 Gross Profit ?1,184,000 Expenses Rent & Rates 94,700 Gas & Electricity 28,600 Wages & Salaries 304,000 Motor Expenses 49,500 Professional Fees 12,500 Bank Charges 11,100 Insurance 2,300 Administrative Expenses 12,800 Depreciation Charge for the Year 179,100 Interest on Long Term Loan 45,000 Total Expenses 739,600 Net Profit ?444,400 (b) An income statement represents a company’s activity or performance over a period of time. The income statement is intended to provide investors an accurate...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Should Euthanasia Be Legalized Responding to Peter Singers Taking Life: Humans

An explosion of research into euthanasia is justified by changes in the global ethical philosophy: more and more countries recognize the need and relevance of euthanasia as an instrument of saving people from physical pains. Peter Singer is one of those who defend the right of individuals for death. More specifically, it is not the right to die but the right to choose between life and death. Utilitarian philosophy justifies the use of euthanasia as the way to achieve collective wellbeing and public happiness. Unfortunately, Singer’s vision of euthanasia asks more questions than it can reasonably answer and, objectively, leaves the issue of euthanasia unresolved.
A convinced utilitarian, in Taking Life: Humans Peter Singer pre...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Peter Singer and Garrett Hardin On Helping the Poor

...?In reading the articles “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” by Peter Singer, and “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor”, by Garrett Hardin, it is impossible not to notice the overwhelming attention to the topic of world poverty and underdeveloped, impoverished nations. Mr. Singer argues that, in no uncertain terms, the world is not doing enough to help those that need it, and in fact those that can help have a moral obligation to do so. Mr. Hardin argues that while help is certainly possible for those that need it, the likelihood of being able to help everyone is a reality that will never be attained due to the limited amount of space and shrinking resources. I find that both articles are very well written, and as previously...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Comparison Peter Singer's and Garrett Hardin's Positions on Helping the Poor

...?Moral Journeys Nowadays people turn to ethics to reflect on what is important to them. Modern world faces new challenges and problems, most them areconnected with the rapidly growing gap between poor and rich countries. The paper analyses and compares Peter Singer's and Garrett Hardin's positions on helping the poor. Garrett Hardin’s article “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor” presents solid argument against helping the poor. In author’s view, generosity towards the underprivileged nations is an ethical misconception. The arguments Hardin provides can be grouped in three categories: metaphors, utilitarian, and relativist arguments. In his article Hardin contrasts two metaphors: “spaceship metaphor” and “lifeboat metaphor...
9 Pages(2250 words)Article

Analogy, Marginality and Action. Peter Singers Famine, Affluence, and Morality Analysis

... of Learning: Famine, Affluence, and Morality Key Assumptions Peter Singer’s “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” is another point of view of utilitarianism as a philosophical theory or can be considered a relative of the utilitarian concept. He has numerous assumptions in his essay, which apparently discusses humanity’s duty to help starving people in countries that need help the most. Among his assumptions include our duty to prevent what is bad, and promote what is good. He elaborates this contention by explaining that if we, humans, have the capacity to help other people who are in need without sacrificing some things that are equally important and significant to our lives, then by all means, we are ought to do so. In the fifth paragraph...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Mood and Singers Performance

The amazing process of how the brain controls the capabilities of humans to express themselves shall be examined herein as well as solution to the best possible ideas and results that the researcher could garner from the procedures taken into consideration within this piece of work.
Music is an undeniably fine type of art that has captured the hearts of human individuals around the globe. Ever since the human generation began, the existence of music as a primary source of expression has given a chance for the many human generations passing history to preserve the right kind of mark that they would want to leave as legacies of their civilization. From the different developments of the said entity of the human society, there is...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Peter ducker

...Peter Drucker Introduction to Management: Drucker’s explanation of management is an all-encompassing concept which he proposed many decades ago, and still holds true. His insight and foresight have given ground-breaking principles to the management function which are viable even today, and would continue to be so. According to Drucker (2007), management is the fundamental institution describing the nature of modern industrial system and the needs of business enterprise that plays a major role in producing goods and services through human and material resources together. Management is also the face of Western society, and is based on the belief that man’s livelihood can be earned through systematic organisation of economic resources...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

United States-Centric Views Comparison

...United s-Centric Views Comparison Generally, United s-centric viewpoints on different groups like Muslim and Arab American and Christian American groups are similar in some aspects and dissimilar in some other aspects. So, I filled the table 1 (see appendix-1) and asked my friend to complete another table, i.e. table-2 (see appendix-2). The common United States-centric viewpoints on the foretold groups, based on my opinion and my friend’s opinion are summarized below. Summary: compare and contrast A. Similarities Christian American Almost all of my opinions on Christian Americans are similar to my friend’s (see appendix 1 and 2). For instance, both of us consider that Christian Americans are not oppressive to women. At the same...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor

...Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor In his 1974 essay, Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor, Garrett Hardin argues against any “system of worldwide food sharing” (482). His purpose is to demonstrate the adverse effects of the proposed World Food Bank on population growth and the resulting pressure on resources. Hardin criticizes the ‘spaceship metaphor’ which seeks to assert that every individual on earth has an equal right to an equal share of the available resources. He claims that the ‘lifeboat metaphor,’ with its emphasis on limited capacity, and necessary adherence to the margin of safety, more accurately depicts the situation. He identifies the unchecked population growth in poor nations as the greatest...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Peter Doig

... Maracas The artist of this canvas painting is Peter Doig and it measures 297 by 200mm. The image is hereby showcased at Gavin Browns’ enterprise in New York. The Maracas work seems to be a combination of many paintings. There is a green landscape in the background. In addition, there are two palm trees and a slightly blue sky in the backdrop. A lone man stands on what seems as audio music systems. It is essential to highlight that music systems occur in layers of three. The solitary figure and the magnanimous audio system seem to contrast in meaning because the speakers manifest a party life while the lone figure projects a reflective pose. However, since the lone character places one’s hands in the pockets, it seems he is in a relaxed...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Peter Singers views in Comparison to Garrett Hardin for FREE!

Contact Us