Free

Current Supreme Court Cases - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
California case focused on the nature of invading privacy when co-tenants have dissimilar ideologies relative to police officers accessing their apartment. Police officers traced Fernandez, the petitioner, back to his apartment as a prime suspect to a stabbing…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Current Supreme Court Cases
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Current Supreme Court Cases"

Political Science Essay Fernandez v. California Summary The Fernandez v. California case focused on the nature of invading privacy when co-tenants have dissimilar ideologies relative to police officers accessing their apartment. Police officers traced Fernandez, the petitioner, back to his apartment as a prime suspect to a stabbing in a violent gang robbery (Russell 1). Outside the apartment, the police officers could hear screams and people arguing and after knocking Roxanne Rojas (Fernandez’s in-house girlfriend) opened the door. Roxanne appeared fleshly battered and was bleeding according to the police officer’s description. She had an infant in her hands and with the nature of the situation plus the initial occurrences; the officers asked her if they could conduct a safety search(Russell 1). However, Fernandez was quick to object claiming that he knew his rights. The officers brought Fernandez into custody under the suspicion he was behind Roxanne’s assault. After identification as one of the perpetrators from the gang robbery, the police accompanied him to the police station. Later on, one of the officers returned to the premises and obtained Roxanne’s consent to search the apartment(Russell 1). The search brought out new evidence that linked Fernandez to the violent robbery.
In court, Fernandez’s motion to subdue the proof from the second search did not influence his case. The Georgia v. Randolph case chiefly influenced Fernandez’s motion since the summary judgment held that where there is physical presence of co-tenants and one objects the police’s consent while the other agrees; the police have no option but to respect the objection. Justices Alito, Ginsburg, Kagan, Sotomayors and the Chief Justice were against were against any motions filed with Randolph case as the basis hence agreed with the final decision(Russell 1). However, Fernandez has four votes from Justices Breyer, Kennedy, Scalia and Karlin who supported the Randolph summary judgment with the argument that the police officers went against the law by first taking into custody the objecting party and coming back to obtain consent of other co-tenant. Nonetheless, the California Court of Appeal’s affirmations held that Fernandez was not physically present when Roxanne gave consent of the search. Typically, the application of Georgia v. Randolph as advocated for by Jeffrey Fisher (Fernandez’s lawyer) was not rational enough to make any exceptions particularly because one of the opposing justices invoked that his expression only depicted insightful disrespect towards Roxanne who wanted the police officers to conduct the search in both situations(Russell 1).
Thoughtful Questions
Essentially, the Randolph and Fernandez cases have similar interpretations but different summary judgments. Moreover, after Fernandez v. California, it appears less complex for police officers to evade the Georgia v. Randolph, especially since the lack of the target’s physical presence acts a gate pass for them to ask for the other tenants consent. However, since most of the opinions in this particular reaffirm the contracted clarification of Randolph prior to Fernandez’s conviction, can police officers really get around it?
On the other hand, most of Fernandez’s motion mainly focused on the statement of ‘physical presence’. However, both Fernandez and Randolph cases lack clarity on the definition of presence. Is it inside, nearby, outside or on the premises?
Works Cited
Russell, Kevin. Fernandez v California: Supreme Court of the United States Blog (SCOTUS-blog) 2015, Web, 25 Jun. 15 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Current Supreme Court Cases Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Current Supreme Court Cases Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1699248-current-supreme-court-cases
(Current Supreme Court Cases Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Current Supreme Court Cases Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1699248-current-supreme-court-cases.
“Current Supreme Court Cases Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1699248-current-supreme-court-cases.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Current Supreme Court Cases

Supreme court cases

...? The case at bar has been a very controversial topic in courts. There are lots of concurring and dissenting opinions from different judges. The different states in the United States have given different decisions involving similar or the same set facts. In the case at bar, Mary and Susan were married in the state of Massachusetts where same sex marriage is allowed. Moving to Texas, their marriage was invalidated because it is against the Texas Ordinance. The issues presented in the present case is whether the marriage of Susan and Mary is invalid because it is against Texas Ordinance and whether or not fundamental rights of Susan and Mary are violated by the Texas...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Supreme court cases

...?Supreme Court cases: Roe and Wade The judiciary presides over disputes in order to maintain law and order through implementation of law in a jurisdiction. The constitution is the primary and supreme source of law and therefore overrides other sources of law. Existence of many sources of law however leads to dissent judgments that may be reversed on appeals. While judges and magistrates in lower courts may offer unitary judgments as they may preside over cases as single judges or magistrates, decisions in the Supreme Court are made on majority votes of presiding Supreme...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Supreme Court

...The Apocalypse of Adolescence By Yuliya Having read through the article en d "The Apocalypse of Adolescence", several conclusions came to mind. First, juveniles should almost never be given the death penalty, as this provides virtually zero learning in relation to moral guidance and the receipt of understanding as to what is right versus what is wrong. The death penalty takes their young lives and forever changes them, without the opportunity to be rehabilitated by competent sociological or psychological professionals. However, when the case is similar to the one in the article, the juvenile death penalty may be imposed, especially when the children show no regret for their actions. The problem, however, appears to lie in whether...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Supreme Court Cases in Education

...for the overturning of Plessy .v. Ferguson was quickly dismissed. Since the case was being held in Kansas, a southern state, the jury was mostly composed of white male, landowners who still believed that African Americans were inferior humans. This was the reason that the court decided to reject the proposed idea of integrated school districts. Because of appeals, the case kept advancing from court to court, through the Supreme Court of Kansas, and finally to the Supreme Court of the United States. The Supreme Court had become more liberal over the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Critically Acclaimed Supreme Court Cases

... Critically Acclaimed Supreme Court Cases Engel V Vitale This is one of the most critical cases in which the Supreme Court made it clear that voluntary prayer conducted in institutions is against the First Amendment rights. The case can relate back to 1951 in which the New York State Board passed a legislature which would require students to recite a prayer before school. The ideology was to promote spiritually amongst students. However, ten students rejected to follow this tradition and filed a law suit. The question remained; did the school snatch the right to have religious liberty from students by enforcing public...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Supreme court cases

...Supreme Court Cases Currently the Supreme Court of United s of America has accepted to review around forty cases during its period of 2012 to 2013. It is even expected that the court will make a decision related to cases that are about the topic of same sex marriage. This report will focus and briefly summaries six cases that the court has agreed to review during 2012 and 2013. One of the cases is Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum which is expected to be tried during the month of October, in this case it will be decided...
2 Pages(500 words)Case Study

Supreme Court

...Supreme Court Opinions The principle responsibility of the U.S. Supreme Court is to interpret the Constitution. It has thefinal say in settling legal arguments and determining the meaning of laws thereby setting national policy. The Justices write majority and minority opinions following a decision. These fall into four categories, unanimous, divided, very divided and per curium. Unanimous decisions are written when all nine members of the court vote the same way. The Chief Justice (John Roberts) assigns any Justice the task of writing it or may choose himself. Sometimes, if the case has many nuances involved, he may have opinions from...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Supreme Court

...Supreme Court Data of Supreme Court In the United s, the court is considered to be the highest tribunal in the land that is expected to exercise justice to all the citizens. It acts on, and provides fair arbitration to all the controversies and cases that arise under the constitution or the law. It being the final arbiter, the Supreme Court is entrusted with the ability to provide equal justice through the use and interpretation of the law, hence, it also functions and a guardian in interpretation of the constitution (Charles, 2012). It is because of these very important functions that the Supreme Court is expected to carry out constitutional review in order to equalize the constitution with the major changes that have taken place... in the...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Supreme Court

...Supreme Court case of Korematsu v. U.S Complaint The complaint in this case was that Korematsuwho was an American of Japanese descent was wrongfully evicted from his location to an internment camp. He complained that this violated his constitutional rights and hence refused to move as the order requested. This led to his arrest and conviction based on disloyalty and disobedience to the country and its laws. Brief summary of the facts At the peak of World War II, President Roosevelt signed a presidential executive order 9066 which demanded that all American-Japanese people be evacuated and taken into internment camps where they would be closely monitored. The aim of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Supreme Court

... DD Month YYYY ESSAY POLITICAL SCIENCE Introduction The American government is divided into various armswhich perform different functions. The arms include the judiciary, legislature and the executive. Every branch of the government has distinctive functions which they perform independent of the other branches. To achieve this each has their specific roles which they perform as led by their leaders. All branches are guided by the American constitution which details out the rule and regulations governing the Americans. This paper explores the functions of the supreme court, its roles as well as Federalism and its effects to America (R. Dye, Zeigler and Schubert). SUPREME COURT The supreme court carries out various functions... which...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Current Supreme Court Cases for FREE!

Contact Us