Free

A Violation of Title IX Law - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In the paper “A Violation of Title IX Law” the author focuses on a violation of Title IX law. Title IX law requires that no one shall be excluded from participation, denied benefits, or be subjected to any form of discrimination…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
A Violation of Title IX Law
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A Violation of Title IX Law"

A Violation of Title IX Law
The reason for my writing to you is that it has come to my attention that the budgetary constraints necessitating the cutting or demotion of women’s swimming team will be a violation of Title IX law. Title IX law requires that no one shall be excluded from participation, denied benefits, or be subjected to any form of discrimination in any activity/education program that receives Federal financial assistance on the basis of sex. Cutting or demoting the women’s swimming team will result in a lawsuit under Title IX that we will fail on the basis of three points that are discussed as major points in this memo.
The first compliance test of Title IX is that enrolment of women should be proportional to sports participation for example if enrolment is at 49%, sports participation ought to be 49%. In the first test, we will fail because the women enrolment rate is 52% with sports participation rate at 42% depicting a huge difference (10%) in participation. The courts have previously decided on cases using this test in Cohen v. Brown University (13%) and Roberts vs. Colorado State University (10.6%), since the case is substantially similar the decision of the court will stand and we will fail the first test.
The second test requires that the school depict recent expansion of women sports offering through offering a new sport in the past 3 to 5 years. A new sport has not been offered for over 10 years and following a substantially similar case decided by the court in Favia v. Indian University of Pennsylvania; we will fail the second test based on history of expansion.
The third test requires that there is full and effective accommodation of interest of women through documenting emerging interests of women in sports regularly through surveys. Since there is no documentation of recent interests of women in surveys and instead the growing interest in swimming by women is intended for demotion or cutting we will fail this test on full accommodation of interest as exemplified by court decisions in Cohen v. Brown University and Favia v. Indian University of Pennsylvania.
Component 3 of Title IX requires the equivalence of benefits and opportunities including access to rights by women teams, competent officials, quality equipment and facility, among other factors. Turning the team into a club cannot be an option as it will result in the reduction of budget allocated for the women team in terms of a reduction in coaching costs, recruitment and travel budgets, and elimination of scholarships breaking component 3 requirements. The courts have previously decided in the Favia vs. Indiana University of Pennsylvania case where women scholarships were to be reduced showing that we will fail on this front.
Adding a women soccer team will be made mandatory by the court owing to the lack of commitment to providing new opportunities for women in over ten years. Compliance with Title IX requires the provision of new opportunities for women in the past 3 to 5 years as was decided in Favia vs. Indiana University of Pennsylvania requiring the women soccer team to be introduced to ensure compliance.
The recommendations for this case are to increase the amount of dollars through other measures instead of cutting or demoting the women’s swimming team, which will result in a lawsuit that we are going to fail. Plans have to be set for the introduction of a women soccer team to ensure compliance to test two of the Title IX law. Boosting dollars can be done through reducing other expenditures that may not result in violation of Title IX. Cutting the men swimming team is possible to allow the University to have access to more funds.
References
Women’s Sports Foundation. Standard Language of Title IX. Retrieved on February 17, 2015 from http://www.womenssportsfoundation.org/home/advocate/title-ix-and-issues/what-is-title-ix/standard-language-of-title-ix Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Violation of Title IX Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 61”, n.d.)
A Violation of Title IX Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words - 61. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1678745-case-study
(A Violation of Title IX Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 61)
A Violation of Title IX Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 61. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1678745-case-study.
“A Violation of Title IX Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words - 61”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1678745-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Violation of Title IX Law

How Title IX has Affected Public Policies in the U.S

..., limitations, and flaws. Although the first guideline about the execution of Title IX was not made public until 1975 and colleges and high schools were granted until 1978 to meet the terms, its enactment conveyed a direct notice to athletic courses all over the nation (Carpenter & Acosta 2005). The law at this time clearly declared that women cannot be singled out or unfairly treated in any school activity or program where the school obtained federal support. Soon after, participation of women in athletic programs skyrocketed (Zimbalist 1999, 58): In 1971, 294,015 girls participated in high school sports; that number increased 2.8 times to 817,073 in 1973, and to 2.08 million in 1978. At...
15 Pages(3750 words)Research Paper

Norm Violation Assignment

...not shop. This grocery store is not near where I live, work, or go to school. I did this so I wouldn’t encounter anyone I knew. This served both as protection for me socially as well as protection for the assignment. I didn’t want to see someone I knew and be tempted to chicken out of breaking the norm. The store I chose was a large, comprehensive, chain grocery store. It is the same chain I typically do my shopping in near my home. Thus, the store layout was the same. I knew how the typical procedures and peculiarities of the store. The clientele were similar in demographics to the store in my neighborhood: diverse both in racial and socioeconomic breakdown. I chose to violate my norm during a busy shopping time, but...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Educational Amendments: Should we do away with Title IX

...and who it has aided. This Title IX is not merely targeting universities and colleges but also is an essential high school as well. In order to be in accordance with this law, the institutemust have equality and an equal number of both the sexes in athletics when a student body is formed. This law is not required to be completely implemented the way it has been published and certain amendments according to the requirements are possible, it is not necessary that female athletes are equal but their rights under any circumstances should not be violated. Females are liable to file a law suit if they feel that there are chances of...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Expectancy Violation theory

...September 17, Theory: Expectation Violations Theory and Interaction Adaptation Theory by Judee Burgoon Word count: 1621 Judee Burgoon proposed the Expectation Violations Theory (EVT), where people’s expectations of other people’s behaviors affect their interactions, impressions and the results of these interactions. This theory can help understand personal space violations in the first episode of The Nanny (1993). During this time, Fran Fine (Fran Drescher) is applying as a nanny for Maxwell Sheffield (Charles Shaughnessy). The scene analyzed is the one where Maxwell interviews her in the living room, as he reads her resume. EVT is used to understand and to evaluate their interactions...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Law and Practice Disciplinary Violation

...Law and Practice – Disciplinary Violation Introduction: This case concerns the issue of employee misconduct and dismissal in the case of Sandra, who obtained unauthorized access to confidential files and passed on the trade secrets contained therein to a competitor. The second concerns the issue of getting one of the directors of the Company to resign. Areas of law in first case: The relevant areas of law that will apply in Sandra’s case are the Employment Act of 2002, with the revised Dispute resolution (Regulations) 2004, which came into effect on October 1, 2004. Also relevant in this case is the Law of Confidence. Definition of...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Undergraduate LAW seen exam questions - module title : Title and security

...) For the Cricket Cub the claim would amount to 1924 (the amount of embezzled funds) Total funds required 31924 There would be a shortfall of 11004 The Law Under common law it is only the property that is noticeably traceable that can be recovered. Equity adopts a wider scope and has developed to an extent where property such as money can be traced even where there is mixed funds. Traced funds can be awarded to the Plaintiff. Common law is capable of tracing the legal ownership of property but is limited to being able to do this only where there have been clean substitutions Smith, The Law of Tracing, (1997) pp 162-174 (1815) 3 M & S 562 One of the main cases...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Responsibility for Violation of the Law

...Responsibility for Violation of the Law Arthur was in a gang. He frequently carried a knife which he said he did to protect himself. He regularly used cannabis which made him paranoid and he frequently had psychotic episodes where he thought he was being attacked by aliens. One morning he woke up and smoked some cannabis and immediately suffered one of his psychotic episodes. He decided he was going to find the members of a local rival gang to beat up and put a knife in his pocket. He put a baseball cap on and pulled it down over his eyes as he did not want to be seen on any CCTV cameras. He went into the centre of town and saw two rival gang members, George and Tony, sitting on a bridge over a river....
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Title ix

...football coach tried to contact the prospective candidates at other institutions (OYEZ). Upon learning about this, TSSAA forced various penalties on Brentwood with the result that Brentwood sued TSSAA (Cornell University Law School). Finally, in the case of Mercer v. Duke University, Heather Sue Mercer, a football player, alleged that she had been discriminated against by her coach. She alleged that her coach who not only passed offensive comments at her but refused to make her the place-kicker on the university’s football team (UNC). This was clearly a violation of Title IX. The woman’s fellow team members also bore witness to the fact that she had demonstrated superior...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Title

... Happy Life I agree with the that the competition has diverted the attention from us to other people. Many organizations care less on different aspects that affect their subordinates. For instance, employees are facing difficult times while negotiating for a better working environment, health and other insurance policies, an effective rewarding system, and better remuneration. However, they are pushing very hard to ensure that the interests of the customers are met. In addition, we are being forced to ensure that the tastes and preferences of the clients are taken into consideration in every aspect of decision making. Therefore, our feelings, living conditions, and other important aspects that contribute to a happy life... Happy Life I agree...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Norm Violation

...NORM VIOLATION s Norm Violation It is patent that norms are generally regarded as some expectations, or certain rules prescribing how one should behave in terms of the society. It is worth noting that such rules of conduct usually develop out of people’s values. For the present project, I was required to violate a social norm. As a norm to violate, I chose to wear my clothes backwards. Thus, throughout the day I was wearing a sweatshirt and jeans turned inside down so that everyone could be able to see the fancy stitches of my clothes. In such a way, I expected to see people’s reactions to it, receive adequate data, collect it, and analyze it. By doing this particular...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A Violation of Title IX Law for FREE!

Contact Us