Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the Senate filibuster rule. Be certain to include the changes voted by the Senate in 1975 and 2013 - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The ruling meant that merits votes were given power to take over from the supermajority votes. Prior to the 2013 ruling, the cloture rule was dominant that required 60…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the Senate filibuster rule. Be certain to include the changes voted by the Senate in 1975 and 2013
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the Senate filibuster rule. Be certain to include the changes voted by the Senate in 1975 and 2013"

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Filibuster Rule. A Senate ruling in eliminated the rule concerning a supermajority vote that was required to end debates. The ruling meant that merits votes were given power to take over from the supermajority votes. Prior to the 2013 ruling, the cloture rule was dominant that required 60 votes from the Senate to end debates (United States Senate, 23). The cloture rule which has been amended several times most notably 1975, supported filibusters in the Senate. The 1975 ruling made filibusters easier since Senators were not required to hold the floor of the Senate for longer periods. Therefore, some Senators could take advantage of this rule and make long speeches that delayed some serious debates. The 1975 ruling also required a three-fifth vote rather than two-thirds votes that were required by previous legislation (Watts, 6-13).
With the tendency of American politics to have divided views, it will be very hard for any party to get 60 votes that can end a debate. For this reason, debates will not be ended easily using filibuster tactics since the 60 votes is almost unachievable on matters that are not very demanding. The cloture rule of 1975 and other amendments later gave the minority party powerful tools to block actions. One Senator could take advantage of the filibusters to kill very important bills with long speeches. The delaying tactics can be utilized by the opposition party in its attempts to destroy the bills proposed by the ruling party. On the other hand, filibusters can be utilized by the ruling party to kill any attempts by the opposition party to make legislations.
As much as filibuster has been criticized, the idea of unlimited debates in the Senate is not very bad. The debates give the minority party power to make contributions to the Senate. However, the minority party could only benefit from the cloture rule if it had at least 41 seats. It must be commanding significant portion of the country to have such number of seats. The filibusters can force the government to be considerate of its actions by reducing radical actions taken by the government. The filibusters are also important because Senators are sensible and know when and how to use the filibusters. For instance, budget bills cannot be compromised by filibusters. The Senate does not use delaying tactics when passing legislation regarding budget. Contrary to this, filibusters may be used to eliminate non-budgetary items that might be attached to the budgetary bills (Wawro and Eric, 12).
Procedural filibusters are advantageous to the Senate since the Senate can soon change to other business matters when it notes that a debate cannot has been hijacked through a filibuster speech. However, the procedural filibusters can benefit the minority in its attempts to block government’s legislations. It could compromise the activities of the government since very debate that encounters a filibuster is put off. Filibusters are useful in moderating the Senate because the ruling party is forced to make concessions with the minority party. The minority cannot give up everything with the filibuster rule in place. It has the power indirectly question a bill on the floor of the Senate. The rule was in contention in 2005 when the President Bush appointed some judges who encountered a filibuster by the Democratic Party. The filibuster was successful since the two parties came to an agreement to eliminate some nominees (Watts, 43).
Work Cited
The United States Senate. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Senate, 2013. Print.
Watts, Duncan. Dictionary of American Government and Politics. Edinburgh [Scotland: Edinburgh UP, 2010. Print.
Wawro, Gregory J., and Eric Schickler.Filibuster: Obstruction and Lawmaking in the U.S. Senate. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton UP, 2006. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the Senate filibuster Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de
(Discuss the Advantages and Disadvantages of the Senate Filibuster Essay)
“Discuss the Advantages and Disadvantages of the Senate Filibuster Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the Senate filibuster rule. Be certain to include the changes voted by the Senate in 1975 and 2013


...?When comparing and contrasting different levels of the federal government it is important to consider both structural and political factors. This isparticularly important when weighing the similarities and differences between political bodies that might appear to be otherwise roughly equal as, for example, the California State Senate and the United States Senate. Viewed from a point of view that is entirely structural, these bodies have obvious functional and constitutional differences that make them appear at least superficially dissimilar. For example, there are 40 CA senators who are elected on alternating terms of four years each so that half the body is up for reelection every other...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Canadian Senate Reform the importance of applying the strategy in the reformed government. Lastly, this paper will give recommendations regarding this matter of the Canadian reform. It will discuss the importance of the changes to be made in the government body as well as what effects the reform could have to the country. Bill for the Agenda In the year 2006, the Canada’s Prime Minister conformist government had established two bills to change the senate. One was to institute restricted conditions for senators, reinstating the system on hand of appointment until one reaches 75 years. The other bill was to launch consultative voting for the legislature with...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Ohio Senate Race 2012 Sherrod Brown vs. Josh Mandel

...decisions. Conversely, Mandel projects Brown’s pro-choice image as views of an extremist (Sewell). Through campaign ads, debates, and public rallies, the candidates are able to get their messages out to the voters. In fact, the Ohio Senate race is the most expensive race this election year (Davidson). Hence, various people and groups have spent money on ads in this campaign since the stakes are high. The candidates have tried hard to avoid any gaffes and controversies that might cost them the race due to the thin margin in the opinion polls. However, Mandel’s gaffe of calling Mourdock a “gentleman” and his remarks about abortion a “class act” might influence the voting patterns amongst women (Sewell)....
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

Filibustering Within the Senate

...of duly elected and sworn Senators using cloture, which is under rule XXII of the US Senate. The Supreme Court, in 1892, ruled that Senate rules could be changed through a simple majority, although this could occur only in March or January’s first day session. On this day, rules are determined anew with the rules not automatically continuous to the next session. Proponents refer to this as the constitutional option while opponents call it the nuclear option. Rule changes can be filibustered under rules currently in force...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

My letter to facuty senate

...Address of Person In-charge in the Faculty Senate of the School Address Dear Sir/Madam: I am appealing to your kind committee to cancel from my records the two semesters where my performance is unacceptable and far from satisfactory. These are from place inclusive dates here. I admit my shortcomings in fulfilling the requirements for the courses which I’ve taken during the period. I don’t want to blame this on anyone else but by my immaturity during that period. Being that typical teenager who lacks the passion in learning new things, I have a hard time studying by myself ever since I was in high school. When I get to college, I was overwhelmed by personal problems which further erode my interest to go to school. This...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Senate 968 (PIPA) and HR 3261 (SOPA)

...STOP ONLINE PIRACY ACT (SOPA) BACKGROUND: The use of computers and access to the internet in the United s of America is well over the 80% mark. Most jobs are done online, businesses deals are undertaken online and the aspect of demography being a barrier to trade is well overcome. But with this came the menace of cyber crime. Fraudsters are devising digital ways of carrying out their deals over the internet and hacking into private portals then using the information to black mail others as an easier way of making quick money in the US. In an aim to help protect the American population from cyber crime, a bill named Stop Online Piracy Act was introduced into the House of Representatives by the US representative, Lamar Smith... ONLINE PIRACY...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Letter to senate

...Letter to the Senate A national identity card is quite a useless idea. Simply because we already have tools in place that effectively create national identities based on pieces of identification such as social security cards, driver’s license and state ID cards all of which effectively ensure that most American end up carrying one or more photo IDs. Further, not only would such an idea be useless, it would be dangerous in political terms as comparisons to Nazi Germany and Jews being forced to wear certain identifying marks and carrying identity papers are far too easy to make with such a step. As a senator, if you choose to support the idea it would be very close to committing political...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Canadian Politics - Senate Reform in Canada

.... The Senate Appointment Consultations Act postulates that the Prime Minister no longer holds the authority to appoint Senators rather a voting process should be put into place which allows a democratic placement of Senators (Carbert 1). The proposed elements of the Bill C-20 stand on four crucial tenets which are of a preferential voting system, funding for campaigning, a board of nominations and regional magnitude. A scrutiny of these components of the bill suggest that women in the proposed situation could be at a great disadvantage primarily because the first two clauses of the bill wish to forward the government’s view of presenting...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Advantages & Disadvantages of JavaScript

...and your system remains secured. (Freeman, 2012, p. 290) Conclusion: It can be concluded from the above situations that all in all JavaScript has some advantages asa well as disadvantages. Security issue is the main disadvantage that is offered by JavaScript while its main advantage is the high speed accessibility. Privacy is the burning issue that has to be taken care of therefore JavaScript is disabled. . Although, there are many sites that would restrict their execution if JavaScript is disabled, but your system will become faster with respect to performance but no significant loss in business is observed References Daggett, M. 2013. Expert...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Should the legislature of the state of texas pass senate bill 11 and senate bill 17

...was for a CHL holder. The state registered 63, 272 convictions in that single year and only a 0.1897 was for the holders of CHL (Tanne 24). The misrepresentation that was made by Burke was not in a good position to confuse the senators concerned with the state affairs committee. The author of the SB 11 and SB 17 said it very clearly that most of the CHL holders were most of the law-abiding members of the state. The two bills have already ended to the Senate and the Senators to either pass or fail will do them through the voting process under the new rule (Kovandzic and Marvell 12). There are many expectations from outside that there will be a real...
17 Pages(4250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the Senate filibuster rule. Be certain to include the changes voted by the Senate in 1975 and 2013 for FREE!

Contact Us