StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The creation of the ICC has been controversial for both legal and ethical reasons. Explain how the ICC works and why it is controversial - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The International Criminal Court (ICC) functions like any ordinary criminal court, with the only difference being that member states, as opposed to individual claimants, or the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) refer situations of serious crimes to the ICC prosecutor. The…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
The creation of the ICC has been controversial for both legal and ethical reasons. Explain how the ICC works and why it is controversial
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The creation of the ICC has been controversial for both legal and ethical reasons. Explain how the ICC works and why it is controversial"

College: ICC Legal and Ethical Controversy The International Criminal Court (ICC) functions like any ordinary criminal court, with the only difference being that member states, as opposed to individual claimants, or the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) refer situations of serious crimes to the ICC prosecutor. The crimes are usually war offences or crimes against humanity deemed to be of significant magnitude. It is after evaluating available information on the situation that the prosecutor decides whether it is reasonable to investigate further and present the case before the court.
Even though the ICC, which was established in 2003, seems to have genuine interest to seek justice for crime victims, it has not been devoid of legal and ethical controversy. For instance, since its establishment until now the ICC has only opened cases on African member nations. This has prompted many African organizations like the African Union (AU) to question the legitimacy of the ICC as an international platform for justice. The legality of the ICC has also been brought to question, owing to the lack of comprehensive evidence collection and procedural concerns.
In 2004 the then ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo issued an arrest warrant for Sudan’s President, Omar al Bashir, for war crimes, genocide, and crimes against humanity. The prosecutor, however, failed to consider facts such as the commencement of the civil conflict in the country long before the president came into power. The prosecutor also ascribed land grabbing and ethnic cleansing solely to Bashir, failing to account for colonial land allocation disparities among peasant and nomadic communities. It was also not Bashir’s fault that climate change has resulted in expansion of arid areas hence reduction of productive land. In addition to these factual discrepancies that question the court’s ethics and legitimacy, the ICC has not focused on other countries. This has prompted many stakeholders to perceive it as a Western Court that seeks to judge African countries, without accounting for prior political and social concerns in respective societies. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The creation of the ICC has been controversial for both legal and Essay”, n.d.)
The creation of the ICC has been controversial for both legal and Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1658737-the-creation-of-the-icc-has-been-controversial-for-both-legal-and-ethical-reasons-explain-how-the-icc-works-and-why-it-is-controversial
(The Creation of the ICC Has Been Controversial for Both Legal and Essay)
The Creation of the ICC Has Been Controversial for Both Legal and Essay. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1658737-the-creation-of-the-icc-has-been-controversial-for-both-legal-and-ethical-reasons-explain-how-the-icc-works-and-why-it-is-controversial.
“The Creation of the ICC Has Been Controversial for Both Legal and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1658737-the-creation-of-the-icc-has-been-controversial-for-both-legal-and-ethical-reasons-explain-how-the-icc-works-and-why-it-is-controversial.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The creation of the ICC has been controversial for both legal and ethical reasons. Explain how the ICC works and why it is controversial

Controversial legal issue

Major religions of the world favor the continuance of life in practically most instances with a very few exceptions where the taking of life can be justified. Religious laws are quite absolute about the prohibition against taking a life, whether one's own life or that of another person. In the eyes of God, anyone who takes life commits a grave mortal sin. However, great strides and advances in medical science and technology now allow the person to prolong life by artificial methods. This technological achievement is unprecedented in the history of mankind. For the first time ever, Man can now “play God” because he has a power to extend a life whenever he wants to. Regrettably, present laws and jurisprudence has not kept up with t...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Simmel's Stranger and ICC

...? Running Head: SIMMEL’S STRANGER & ICC FUNDAMENTALS OF INTERCULTURAL COMMUNICATION (ICC) Simmel’s ‘The Stranger’ This paper is focused on the different dimensions and evolution of intercultural communication with respect to George Simmel’s’ extraordinary writing, “The Stranger”. The concepts used in this marvelous piece of writing have been the chief source of deriving the complex synthesis and implementation of intercultural communication. The major focus will be on effective communication. Introduction “Intercultural communication” is a diverse topic of in-depth research which gained its significance during 1960s and has been a major subject matter of different fields of study like Philosophy, Sociology, Anthropology, Economics...
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ethical controversial about the abortion

These people base their argument with Aristotle point of view that abortion is right since it creates a strong path for people to control the size of their family. Supporters of abortion believe that there is no biblical text that specifically prohibits abortion, despite many citing various biblical verses as a framework for forbidding abortion. This essay seeks to underline the ethical controversial about abortion. In the article entitled, Abortion in Australia: a Legal Misconception 2005 Kerry Petersen presented the opinion polls, which showed that most Australians approved women having their rights to carry out abortions. In Australia, there has been little support and emphasize for introducing restrictive laws that ban aborti...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Controversial Paper

mostly people who migrate illegally to other countries are mostly from third world counties to look for better lives in the developed countries for example the Mexicans migrate from Mexico and sneak their way into the USA statistics shows that more than twelve million immigrants live in the USA , but this can be a tough and a hard journey and it is not guaranteed that everybody will reach their destination some of them always end up dying because of cold weather and others fall in the rap of border patrols. Effects of immigration The effects of immigrants in the USA are: Economic theory states that there could be possible effects on the employment and wages of domestic workers, trade between USA and other countries, growth rate a...
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Controversial Advertising

... in the advertising business for more than 100 years, has been openly challenged. According to this theory, consumers tend to move through some type of measurable mental process on the way to purchasing a product or service. Weilbacher argued that the hierarchy-of-effects models are flawed. He presented four main reasons why these models have not and cannot be validated. He concluded, "These models have never been explicitly validated --hierarchy models are little more than rationally and intuitively sensible."(2) Wielbacher's article was so controversial that a rebuttal (3) and counter rebuttal (4) ensued. Additionally, at least two books critical of the advertising industry were published in 2002. Sergio Zyman argued that 30-second...
30 Pages (7500 words) Coursework

Controversial Artwork

...Making Controversial Artworks Full Ideas expressed through artworks beyond what is normally considered moral probably are the most controversial in the field of Arts. While photographic paintings and other performances that are aesthetically applauded are generally considered acceptable and commendable, those that portray the other side of beauty usually attract the attention of critics. Sometimes, it could be considered that what makes a modern artwork successful is the lunacy expressed in it that generally draws criticisms, consequently making an artwork famous, although not in a positive way. Chris Ofili’s Holy Virgin Mary caught national attention in 1999 when it was exhibited at the Brooklyn Museum of Art because it portrayed a queer...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

International Tribunals and the ICC

... International Tribunals and the ICC To ensure that justice prevails in various situations, there was the formation of various tribunals such as the military tribunal and other kinds of tribunals. The ICC was also formed to ensure that there is justice for war crime victims in various countries in the world. These justice systems have had a number of successes in their practices, however, they also have some weaknesses that can be improved on through amends and this will form the basis of discussion in this paper. One strength of the ICC and other tribunals in bringing war crime suspects to justice has been the fact that it provides a mechanism for international prosecutions where crimes committed that are not catered for within...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Controversial topic

...The Inevitable Future of Genetically Modified Organisms Intro: GMOs refer to plants and animals whose genes have been changed by scientists Claim: Food GMOs appear to be safe to produce and eat, but we should also provide more funding for research and regulation so that we can be more certain of their safety Important concerns exist, but 3 reasons to support GMO research and development: Definite benefits in agriculture; No ill health effects reported; Projected benefit for world hunger Agriculturally, concerns over effects of crops on non-target species and gene-flow Difficult to come to agreement because it’s hard to define “harm” to the environment – i.e., we don’t know how a) dramatic the change needs to be, to be considered...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Controversial topic

...Jordan Medina The Bane of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO) A genetically modified organism is “an organism, with the exception of human beings, in which the genetic material has been altered in a way that does not occur naturally by mating and/or natural recombination (European Parliament and of the Council). Genetically modified organism (GMO) is a product of modern science and agriculture. It is much talked about and here to stay. Public preoccupation and opinion are divided as to whether it is a harmful and helpful, with both listing several arguments to their cause. However, GMOs have been severely untested in the natural living ecosystem for it to be categorized as an advantage to mankind. Several possible negative effects...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

International criminal law (ICC)

... during their rule. Furthermore, the international criminal tribunal for Yugoslavia has also been exercising victors justice. There has been minimal number of prosecutions against the Serbs compared to Croats or members of other groups involved in the conflict. A small number of Serbs were persecuted despite the fact that 86 percent of the civilian killings were perpetrated by the Serbians or those people that they controlled (Sander, 105). Further, such claims again have been experienced in the Rwanda’s international criminal tribunal. The president of Rwanda refused to provide information that was necessary to prosecute Tutsis who were the most affected during the 1994 genocide. On the other hand, the same tribunals for perpetrating...
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The creation of the ICC has been controversial for both legal and ethical reasons. Explain how the ICC works and why it is controversial for FREE!

Contact Us