StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper discusses the pro-life versus pro-choice argument. In essence, it is the argument on the religious ethos that life is a God-given gift, which is not for humankind to destroy and the right of a woman to do what she desires with her body…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life"

Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Introduction: The Pro-life versus Pro-choice argument has been going on for a long time. There appears to be no end to the argument, with public opinion swaying depending on events that occur. On one side is the Church with its conservative supporters and on the other side are the women’s right protagonists with their liberal supporters. In April this year the Supreme Court upheld the Federal Abortion Ban case, virtually reversing the judicial stand on abortion, which was seen in the Roe v Wade case. (1). In essence it is argument on the religious ethos that life is a God given gift, which is not for humankind to destroy and the right of a woman to do what she desires with her body. There is no end in sight to the pro-life versus pro-choice argument. The Pro-Life Argument: The pro-life argument is against the practice of abortion, and the legalizing of abortion. In the pro-life argument the main point of view is surprisingly supported both by religion and by science. The religious perspective is that life begins at conception. It is a gift of God and human beings do not have the right to deny this life from seeing the light of day. This makes abortion tantamount to murder. Science supports this argument through its findings that the fetus starts to display several determinants of life at a very early stage. Thus the main basis of the argument against abortion is based on the fetus as an individual life separated from that of the mother, and that it is wrong to destroy such life. It also goes on to argue that abortion is denial of the right to live of the fetus, and by abetting abortion, society would be guilty of denial of the rights of the fetus The other perspectives against abortion include the harm that abortions cause the mother, and the impact of abortions on society. Abortions are unsafe, and can lead to severe complications for the woman immediately after the abortion, or in terms of long term complications, including the dreaded breast cancer. Other complications could be demonstrated at the time of delivery of a child, should the woman choose to have a baby later. The impact on society lies in two arguments. The first is the economic costs to society as a result of abortion. The second argument is that if the fetus is morally expendable, child abuse is bound to arise. Instead of abortion, avoidance of unnecessary pregnancies could be brought about through use of contraceptives or abstinence from sexual activity. (2) The Pro-Choice Argument: The fundamental arguments of those that support abortion or are pro-choice is that delivering a baby is the decision of a woman, as it is her body that goes through the whole process. Having an abortion or not is thus the right of a woman. In the United States of America, where the rights of an individual are considered as sacred, denying this right to a woman would be ignoring the basis of the founding of the state. Opposition to abortion is based on religious and moral beliefs, and religious and moral beliefs should not be imposed on a woman. This is more so, when there is doubt on these beliefs, as there is no clarity still, as to when life really begins. The pro-choice argument points out that if abortion is made illegal, it would lead to many illegal abortions that would cause more complications for the women, and even cause death. The economic cost to society would mount, as it would become necessary to provide for the pre-natal care of women do not want to have the child. Teenage pregnant girls find themselves at times thrown out of their parent’s home, and society would have top cater to the needs of mother and child. Forcing women to have children would lead to many unwanted children being delivered. Many of these children are likely to end up abused. It would be better for these children not to have been born, than to face the torment of child abuse. The final issue is the case of rape victims falling pregnant. If pregnancy is denied, the victim carries the torment of the event throughout the period of pregnancy (3) Conclusion: There is no end in sight to the pro-life versus pro-choice argument. The arguments in favor of abortion and against abortion do not counter the main basis of the arguments of either side. Neither side looks at themselves as ant-life or anti-choice. Through the use of different frames of argument the two sides try to make the position taken by the other side irrelevant, and their position the one of importance. The pro-choice proponents do not state that the killing of the fetus is appropriate, and do not address the issue of the rights of the fetus. Instead the position that they take is that there is no killing involved in abortion, and therefore no denial of rights. In a similar vein the pro-life argument does not address the rights of a woman, and the issue of rape victims. They counter to the rights of women issue, by bringing into play the rights of the fetus and try making the debate an issue on the life of the fetus, and not an issue on the rights of women. They remain silent on the issue of abortion for rape victims, so that they do not continue to be tormented by an event for which they were not responsible. Both sides thus operate within a framework of comfort avoiding stepping into the framework of the other side. Stepping into the framework of the other side would be asking for trouble, as it would be an awkward defense that could be offered, when operating in the framework of the opponent. It is for this reason that the pro-life and pro-choice protagonists skirmish with one another, and seldom do battle. This makes the arguments in favor of abortion and those against abortion to continue without any end in sight. (4) Works Cited 1. “ROBERTS COURT SHOWS ITS CARDS: IN A STUNING REVERSAL, SUPREM COURT RULES AGAINST WOMEN’S HEALTH IN FAVOR OF ABORTION RESTRICTIONS. REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS. 2007. 30 July 2007. http://www.reproductiverights.org/pr_07_0418FAB.html 2. “PROLIFE: 10 Arguments Against Abortion”. CHRISTIAN ACTION FOR REFORMATION & REVIVAL. 2003. AFRICA CHRISTIAN ACTION. 30 July 2007. . 3. Johansen, Jay. “A Summary of Pro-Choice Arguments”. 2000. Pregnant Pause 30 July 2007. . 4. Burns, G. “The Moral Veto: Framing Contraception, Abortion, and Cultural Pluralism in the United States”. 2005. Cambridge University Press. 22 March 2007. http://www.cambridge.org/catalogue/catalogue.asp?isbn=9780511114175&ss=exc Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1541662-procon-essay
(Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1541662-procon-essay.
“Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1541662-procon-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life

Rquiem por un campesino espaol

There is a reflection of the old argument of nature versus nurture, in which Senders questions whether we are born with certain characteristics or whether society makes us what we are.... As with many of his other novels Ramn Senders fuses historical facts and figures with fiction in his novel 'Rquiem por un campesino espaol'....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Abortion and personhood

Gibson notes that although these various camps of Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life differ as to their belief systems, both from a moral and theological standpoint, they all base these positions on the notion, directly or indirectly on personhood which, in effect, focuses not on the right of the woman but on the moral status of... At this point, pro-life proponents would argue that the rights of the fetus outweigh those of the host (i....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Abortion and the Rule of Law

In an article titled, “Abortion rights are pro-life,” Dr.... The following paper 'Abortion and the Rule of Law' presents a deeply religious viewpoint that is uncompromisingly anti-abortionists and contends that the embryo is human life, which is sacred, and its destruction would tantamount to willful homicide....
18 Pages (4500 words) Assignment

The debate between pro-choice and pro-life

This essay is an attempt to utilize the Toulmin model of argument to analyze the various arguments submitted to question Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life.... There appears to be a constant twist to the facts and thus different people are pro-life at one period of their life and pro-choice at the other.... Mc Cain, on the other hand, is determined that Obama cannot conquer The author of this paper believes that neither of these two candidates has thus far been able to sway those individuals who were pro-choice or pro-life to change their fundamental belief to a new or different philosophical standpoint....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Reasons of Why Team Working and Working Under Supervision Are Beneficial

In fact, nurses make up the biggest group in the NHS and are an important part of the healthcare team.... Nurses work in different health care… gs ranging from accidents, care centres for the elderly and hospitals with individuals across various age brackets, from different backgrounds and cultures (Denny and Earle, 2005:65)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment

Should embryos be treated as human lives

Over the years, the issue of abortion has remained a contentious one with the primary debate being between the pro-life and pro-choice groups, the former believe in the sanctity of human life and according to them life begins as soon as conception occurs.... Retrospectively, the pro-life option was the most widely However contemporary views on the subject are changing to favor of pro-choice, today more people advocate and are tolerant of abortion than ever before and in majority of states, it is allowed as long as it is carried out safely in a hospital....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Abortion, Argument between Pro-life and Pro-choice

Beyond Pro-Choice Versus Pro-Life.... According to Bushnell (447) the article explains the argument between pro-life and pro-choice whereby the pro-life fight against abortion and the pro-choice say abortion should be legalized.... The pro-life believe that fetus is a life while pro-choice believes that life begins in… Bushnell (448) argues that the main point of this thesis is the importance of human life.... The pro-choice argument is not persuasive because to Gender and Sexual Studies Beyond pro-life and pro-choice: by Smith According to Bushnell (447) the article explains the argument between pro-life and pro-choice whereby the pro-life fight against abortion and the pro-choice say abortion should be legalized....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Infrastructure of The Pro-Choice Movement

This research paper describes the infrastructure of the pro-choice movement.... This paper outlines abortions, activists of pro-choice movement, leading organizations of it, early events, development of it and who can be activist.... nbsp;… For pro-choice activists, the morality of the issue centers on the viability of an unborn baby (at what point does it become a person), and again there are shades of grey regarding days, weeks and months of pregnancy....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us