Free

Legitimate authority - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The author of this essay "Legitimate authority" comments on the types of authority, legitimate and illegitimate. According to the text, one of the problems with this article is that the author insists that choice is an important part of legitimate authority…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Legitimate authority
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Legitimate authority"

 While the author of “Power Politics” does a good job examining the types of authority, legitimate and illegitimate, that exist, it works under a series of assumptions that can be problematic when put into practice in a school environment.
One of the problems with this article is that the author insists that choice is an important part of legitimate authority. He says that part of legitimate authority is voluntary compliance with commands, rather than people obeying commands for some other reason (172). The problem with this is that it leaves the subordinate in the superior-subordinate relationship to determine whether or not to obey a command. For instance, everyone can agree that a teacher has the ability to assign students work and grade them on the said work. But, sometimes a teacher assigns work that a student considers inappropriate – the student believes that it is too hard or not to grade level, is too long and so on. Should the student have the right to challenge this assignment? And if the student challenges it, and the teacher insists upon their command, does the teacher have the right to force the student to finish the assignment, or punish them for not doing so by failing them? In the practice of authority relationships in school, the answer is no, the student does not have the right to challenge a command, and yes, the teacher has the right to essentially coerce the student into following it through the threat of a failing grade. This does not mean that the system itself is wrong – the ability to fail students who do not behave or follow instructions is important to run a school or class room, but only that school systems fail to meet the requirement for legitimate authority functionally, meaning that other systems need to be in place to make authority legitimate in the way the author says.
This problem of choice also extends to other areas of the article. The author talks about principles and students and so on “accepting” the rules of schools, and entering an “agreement” with schools and other institutions (173). The words “accept” and “agreement” both work under mean the person, such as the student or the principle, has a choice whether they want to be part of the school or not, and that by choosing to do so they agree that all authority above them is legitimate. But students are often forced without their choice by law to attend schools until a certain age, and the school they attend is decided by the where they live or what their parents tell them to do rather than their own choice. So legitimate authority, as the author talks about it involving choice, cannot function for the students; if they need to “accept” and “agree” for authority to be legitimate, as the author says, they should be able to say that none of the authority above them is legitimate, because they did not accept or agree to it.
This essay does not intend to say that the organization of teachers, administrators and so on are not legitimate forms of authority, but rather that choice to be part of an organization cannot be part of forming legitimate authority in school environments. This means that other structures have to stand to take their place, for instance the ability to appeal decisions a student or parent questions questions, because coercive forces work on subordinates in school relationships without them having a choice. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legitimate authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1578080-critical-thinking-essay
(Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/politics/1578080-critical-thinking-essay.
“Legitimate Authority Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1578080-critical-thinking-essay.
  • Cited: 1 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legitimate authority

Legitimate Authority

...? While the of “Power Politics” does a good job examining the types ity, legitimate and illegitimate, that exist, it works under a series of assumptions that can be problematic when put into practice in a school environment. One of the problems with this article is that the author insists that choice is an important part of legitimate authority. He says that part of legitimate authority is voluntary compliance with commands, rather than people obeying commands for some other reason (172). The problem with this is that it leaves the subordinate in the superior-subordinate relationship to determine whether or not to obey a command. For instance, everyone can agree that a teacher has the ability to assign students work and grade them... is...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Public Authority

... Table of Contents Introduction 3 What Steps the Local Authority Can and Should Take 5 Short-Term Measures That Can be Taken By the Local Authority 6 Long-Term Measures That Can Be Taken By the Local Authority 8 Conclusion 9 References 10 Introduction The provided case study reveals about the two prime protagonists i.e. Barrett family and their neighbour Mrs. Smith. It depicts that the Barrett family had shifted to a rented house in St. Albans. The family comprises 5 members which include a lady named Shirley and her 3 children along with her boyfriend Donald. Shirley’s three young children named Danni, Charlie and Emily aged 5, 7 and 14 years respectively. The adjacent neighbour...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Authority

...the work of other writers who focused on a specific discipline. Summary Written during the cold war era, and especially during the Cuban missile crisis, this essay focuses on the beguiling comfort that obedience of any form produces on human beings. In this regard, the essay posits that obedience does not contribute to sweeping changes that disobedience can provide. The essay starts with a historical cliche that has been the rallying call for obedience all through humanity. Fromm identifies the phrase “obedience is a virtue, disobedience is a vice” as a phrase that people have used overtime to assert the importance of people following authority, which the essay highlights as obedience in an irrational form. However,...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Legitimate Abortion

...Part I: Thesis Merely affirmed, abortions must be prohibited for the reason that abortions are the sadistic taking of a being's existence, without authority or even rationalization. Towards the sufferers, abortion is the rejection of every liberty without further ado. Devoid of the privilege towards life, the other privileges are worthless. An administration which will not preserve the existence of those general public who may not be able to look after themselves has surrendered its authenticity. With the purpose of protecting one's self against the cruelty which results when the administration identifies numerous people as undeserving of security, we must adopt the widest reasonable designation of human race. Remaining...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Line Authority

...Introduction: 'Management' can be defined in various terms. In a nutshell management can be defined as the art of getting certain tasks done by individuals. It is deemed as the achievement of objectives through the most efficient utilization of resources. With specific reference to organizations it can be defined as the achievement of organizational goals in an effective and efficient manner, by planning, organizing, leading and controlling of organizational resources. 'Authority' is the ability to exercise and influence objects, individuals and situations. Weber, the German sociologist believed in as a fact that authority was derived from tradition. The modern view of authority is that acceptance is a must if a communication... is to...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Categories of Legitimate Reservation

...Categories of Legitimate Reservation In every field of work, specialized knowledge forms the basic requirement for the person to work efficiently, either individually on in groups. Decision-making and logical thinking are the other factors that are quite important in any business setting. Logical thinking is inherently significant, because it allows an individual to rest assured of the fact that his or her decisions are sound. During any process, a number of people are certain of a few established materials, known as facts. They also make certain hypothesis about a particular thing or a process, and the result of the relationship of facts and hypothesis come together in a conclusion. However, every scientific experiment...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Legitimate Businesses

...Legitimate Businesses It is a reality that organized crime is commonly referred to as the mafia. This organized crime is rampant within the different legitimate and legal businesses which are operating in the time and age of today. It is for this reason that the businesses want to keep away from such domains where organized crime has its roots and wants to manifest its own self in the most heinous manner possible1. The organized crime is being seen as a deterrent towards maintaining sanity within the organizations where business regimes get disrupted and are taken over by elements that have absolutely no say within the proceedings that are taking place2. These are some of the most significant reasons behind the improper role... of the...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Biblical Authority

...Brief Summary The writes ‘How Can the Bible be Authoritative?’ with the thesis that “scripture’s own view of authority focuses on the authority of God himself” (Wright, 1991). In the presentation of the article, which was adopted from a lecture delivered by the author, the writer covers areas of biblical authority spanning across the scripture or bible as an entity of its own, the scripture as a guiding tool for Christian living, the scripture as the representation of God and the scripture as a manipulative device by Christians. Through all of these four contents, the writer tries to be as open in his discussion as possible to accommodate as many different sentiments expressed on the subject of biblical authority as possible... . For...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Authority

...The Importance ity in the Military In any organization there needs to be a certain level of respect, primarily for the leaders. The reason is that without respect there will be little reason to follow anything that the leaders have to say. In this case, the military is no different. As an organization, the military is extremely hierarchical with many different layers, sort of like an onion. It is these pre-determined layers that help the military to remain strong and carry out its objectives in an efficient manner. This essay will offer a definition of authority and how it applies to the military, the importance of authority in the military, and also what may happen if authority is either...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Hobbes and Lockes Legitimate Political Authority

...Hobbes’s and Locke’s legitimate political ity based on the consent Introduction Hobbes and Locke have contributed significantly to the field of political science. Both theorists tend to have similar views with regard to where power emanates in the society. They both support the constitution or popular contract as an avenue where the people give the power to rule. Hobbes and Locke reiterate that the people have the power to grant authority to govern and that authority belongs with the people. However, between the two theorists, it is Locke who is recognized to have a greater influence on the modern political science. Conversely, Hobbes’s influence is evident on what the people can do to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Legitimate authority for FREE!

Contact Us