Nobody downloaded yet

The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
On June 8, 1967 during the Six Day War between Israel and Egypt an American intelligence ship, the USS Liberty, suffered an unprovoked attack at the hands of the Israeli Air Force. A subsequent attack by Israeli torpedoes resulted in over 30 killed and nearly 100 wounded…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty"

Download file to see previous pages There were many questions that remained unanswered during the last 40 years, but recently declassified documents and newly uncovered testimony has shed new light on the events surrounding this tragic event. Examining what we know about the reports from the time, and the information that has been made public since, makes a convincing case that the attack was a deliberate action by the Israeli government and resulted in a massive cover-up by the Navy inquiry.

The official explanation at the time was that in the heat of battle the Israeli Air Force had misidentified the USS Liberty as an Egyptian vessel. Yet, according to a CIA memo of June 13, 1967, 5 days after the attack, the agency reported that two Israeli Mirage fighters had orbited the Liberty on a reconnaissance flight just six hours before the attack (Central Intelligence Agency, 469). The CIA further reported that the weather was clear, the ship was plainly marked, and had a US flag flying. (Central Intelligence Agency, 470). In addition the Liberty was 200 feet longer than the Egyptian ship and had an Ensign that was clearly visible and appropriately marked.

To examine the case of mistaken identity requires that we evaluate what the Israelis knew and when they knew it. The initial air assault took place at 13:58 hours and a second wave occurred at 14:04 (Bregman, 89). These flights consisted of machine gun strafing and napalm, which damaged the deck, antennas, and some communications capability. Israeli tape recordings from that day verify that Colonel Shmuel Kislev, the Commander of Israeli Air Control, knew that it was an American ship by 14:14 hours (Bregman, 89). At 14:26, 12 minutes after they had confirmed it was a US ship, Israeli torpedo boats arrived at the scene. By 14:31, 17 minutes after verifying identification, the Israeli boats had fired 5 torpedoes (Bregman, 89). One of the torpedoes hit the Liberty, killed 25 crewmen, and put the USS Liberty out of commission.
Motives for the attack are difficult to ascertain in the aftermath of war. Military and governments sometimes act as organisms with no clearly definable goal. A plausible explanation has been offered that contends Israel feared that the Liberty would intercept sensitive communications regarding their plans to attack Syria's Golan Heights. If the US were alerted to the plan, they might have tried to prevent what Israel perceived as a vital operation. A CIA report identified Defense Minister Moshe Dyan as the Israeli leader that ordered the attack (Brands, 211). Dyan had gambled that Johnson would not fully investigate the incident.
According to Brands, Johnson made a minimal effort to investigate the area, but was concerned about alarming the Egyptians or the Russians (212). After Johnson was unable to gather any information from the scene, the Israelis apologized. Not wanting to destroy the fragile alliance with Israel, Johnson accepted the apology and ordered the incident to be kept quiet (Brands, 212). The following day, Israel launched an attack against Syria, which wrapped up the final phase of the Six Day War.
There could be little believability that the Israelis were unaware of a major US intelligence ship just off their coast in international waters. It had been in the Mediterranean since June 5 (Joint Chiefs of Staff). The cover story of mistaken identity was so weak, that according ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1526272-the-massive-government-cover-up-of-the-attack-on-the-uss-liberty
(The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty Essay)
https://studentshare.org/politics/1526272-the-massive-government-cover-up-of-the-attack-on-the-uss-liberty.
“The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1526272-the-massive-government-cover-up-of-the-attack-on-the-uss-liberty.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty

Monetary and Fiscal Policy: Government Reactions During a Massive Recession

...?Monetary and Fiscal Policy: Government Reactions during a Massive Recession In the present time, the word recession is being widely used by almost every body to describe the ongoing global economic scenario, which has been experiencing a huge down turn since 2008. All the media across the world is talking about recession every day. Whether it is a news paper, on a news channel on television, or some news bulletin on radio, everywhere people are talking about recession, the methods to recover from the recessionary situation and so on. At present, most of the economies throughout the world are going through a critical phase of recession and among all the economies. The situation has been so critical that the most power economies... as in...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

Liberty

...in which an individual is not under limitations due to the possibility of intimidation or suppression. From both ethical and political perspectives, liberty is expressed as the condition by which people are able to govern themselves, behave on their free will without suppression and have full responsibility for their deeds. Liberty can be both unconstructive and helpful. Negative liberty is characterized by nonexistence of impediment or interferences; whereas, positive liberty is an act of taking charge of personal life and appreciating the basic reason of existence. Varying ideologies of liberty entail the association or connection...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Attack

...? Attack Attack Arab-Israeli quest for peace is a worthy cause that has often been inhibited by both the Palestinians’ interests and the Israelis’ interests. Although both nationalities thirst for stability and security in the region, they are caught up fighting for their individual interests. Palestine fights for its nationalism. On the other hand, Israel maintains an iron fist in its bid to survive in a region where she is surrounded by her enemies. For that cause, Israel is willing to use oppressive and defensive measures to uphold and extend her territorial boundaries. Israel uses all possible means to ensure that the balance of power in the Middle East shifts in her favor. Palestine on the other hand...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Does Government secure or inhibit liberty

...?Justin Cheng Bruce Meyerson Introduction to Economic and Political Thought: C80.0011 Undeniably, the greatest “hot button” issue in the country today is abortion. Debates over the issue are happening all over, with the involvement of politicians, church, schools, and different organizations who want to take opposing stands on the issue. Two opposing points are always raised when it comes to abortion. First, that abortion is murder, and second, that a woman has a right to her own body. Both arguments come down to natural law and individual rights. Taking both sides of the coin into consideration, this paper limits itself to the concept of liberty and utilitarianism in looking at the abortion debate....
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Liberty and Government

...Assignment: PURITAN VIEW Relationship between Liberty and Government Roll number: Introduction Therelationship between liberty and good government is very strapping. Both of them depend on each other in order to get effective result as good government is indispensable to promote liberty and autonomy is the soul of good government. Liberty is basically a concept of political philosophy or in other words we can say that it is a condition where an individual is set free to act according to his or her on will but the definition of liberty is a bit different in the dictionaries of the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Term Paper

Liberty

...In many ways it is easy to interpret the philosophy of positive liberty as a critique of negative liberty - which is as it was formulated. Negative liberty, as it is often characterized by liberalism and those who support this interpretation of freedom, is generally the notion that freedom - which is most commonly recognized as a political ideal to aspire to - is a quality that should be maximized by the individual, and that any system of government is morally obligated to impinge upon this freedom as little as possible or not at all. Positive freedom-based theories point out a very obvious weakness of this position; namely, that one of the activities that most often...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Did Johnson Administration Allow the Attack on the USS Liberty and Why

...Did Johnson administration allow the attack on the USS Liberty and why? The USS Liberty event was a tragic assault on a US Navy ship called USS Liberty at international waters about 23km from the shore of the Sinai Peninsula by Israeli torpedo boats and fighter planes on June 8, 1967. It took place during the ‘Six Day War’, a war between Israel and some Arab states. The attack was one of the deadliest attacks on US navy after the Second World War and killed 34 navy personnel besides injuring at least 173. Both American and Israeli governments had carried out several...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Liberty

...Liberty Liberty is a key political and moral principal in the discipline of history, which aims at identifying theways in which human beings govern and control themselves, so as to behave in accordance to their own will by taking responsibility for their own actions. According to feudal societies, liberty is described as an area of allodial land where the rights of the monarchy or ruler are waved. Socialists in liberal sense and in progressive approach defined liberty as a connection to equal wealth distributon.The concept liberty has been conceptualized differently by different scholars, who articulate the individual relationship to...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Liberty

...The Actual Meaning of Liberty Since long time ago, liberty has been one of the most significant aspects protecting rights and freedom of all citizen of any given citizen across the world. Due to this fact, all governments across the world have been doing all their best to ensure that they protect liberty of their citizens under all costs. Liberty refers to the state of a free person, exemption from subjection to the will of another claiming ownership of an individual or service; it is freedom opposed to slavery, bondage, subjection or serfdom (The Emma Goldman Papers 1). Due to the fact that liberty is a term that started to be used by...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Cover-up Most Important Facts

...should support the company’s objectives. This places Frank in a dilemma because he does not believe in the current objective that the company is pursuing. Another important fact to the case is Frank’s professional reputation. Professional codes expect his moral actions and failure to meet expectations exposes him to risk of losing his designation. Frank notes that his designation could be revoked if things do not work out for the organization. He therefore faces the dilemma of exposing the misrepresentation in the report or risking his reputation and designation. The company’s intention is another important fact to the case. The government has proposed measures for controlling disposal and Frank notes that the company’s...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Massive Government Cover-Up of the Attack on the USS Liberty for FREE!

Contact Us