House of Lords Reform - Essay Example

Summary

One of the most important agendas of this Government has been the reform of the House of Lords. Both the public and the parties that make up the government have called for changes to the powers and composition of the Second Chamber. This memorandum outlines these changes to the House of Lords and discusses their merits and dismerits.
…

Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing

GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful

Read TextPreview

Subject: Politics
Type: Essay
Level: Ph.D.
Pages: 5 (1250 words)
Downloads: 2
Author: delpha00

Extract of sample "House of Lords Reform"

Download file to see previous pages 110). That same year the government took its first significant steps in reforming the House with the Constitutional Reform Act. This act mandated the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom to take over the existing role of the Law Lords, in addition to taking on a role in the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. It also removed the powers of the Speaker of the House of Lords and Head of the Judiciary of England and Wales from the office of Lord Chancellor.
This change has been the most contentious of those proposed. The number of elected representatives that should be allowed has been the subject of considerable debate. It was proposed that 120 members be elected by the public, 120 appointed by a statutory independent commission and the rest would be appointed by political parties in proportion to votes received by a party at the most recent general election. Despite the debate surrounding the number of members a larger issue is at stake. In the report put forward by Clarke, Cook, Tyler, Wright and Young (2005) they claim that it is not so much the number of elected members but rather the powers they will receive that is at issue (p. 8). They state, "Whilst there has been a great deal of support for the introduction of elected members, some in the political world have been concerned that this would make the second chamber more powerful, and therefore result in a challenge to the traditional primacy of the House of Commons" (p. 8).
merits and dismerits: There is little doubt that the introduction of elected members to the House of Lords would allow for a greater degree of democratic representation than is seen today, particularly within the regions. Yet, it could cause an unfavorable change in the balance of power between the two houses if elected members do not take the spirit of the Salisbury Doctrine into consideration, something many doubt would happen. Roger and Walters (2004) state the Salisbury convention is perhaps more a code of behaviour for the Conservative Party when in opposition in the Lords than a convention of the House. Indeed it is a moot point whether, following the passage of the House of Lords Act 1999, the expulsion of the hereditary members and the ending of the overwhelming numerical advantage of the Conservative Party, the Salisbury convention as originally devised can have any continuing validity (p. 19)1. If the House of Commons and the Executive wish for there to be a check on the House of Lord's powers of bill prevention they must look to making such limitations.
2. The reduction of the number of House members
Currently the House of Lords has over 700 members and is one of the largest parliamentary chambers in the world. Although, since members are appointed for life and often reach an age where they cannot sit in on House meetings as often, attendance is considerably lower than the total number of ...Download file to see next pagesRead More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF House of Lords Reform

The House of Lords Lynn

...Introduction In order to successfully appeal to the House of Lords Lynn will need to establish that there is a point of law which their Lordships are required to clarify. We would argue that the High Court and Court of Appeal erred on the first point in their judgement with regard to the status of Lynn's indirect contribution to the acquisition of the property. Further we suggest that the decision in Midland Bank plc v Cooke [1995] does not determine acquisition criteria, but rather quantum of beneficial interest. The Lloyds Bank v Rosset [1994] 1 AC 107 case indicated that failing an express common intention, an intention to share ownership may be inferred from the conduct of the parties. The question then arises what type of conduct...

6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

The House of Lords

THE HOUSE OF LORDS IN PUBLIC LAW Yusuf Belgore The House of Lords The House of Lords is an organ of the British parliament. The origin of the British parliament could be traced to the11th century in the Witans; where council are consulted by Saxon kings and attended by religious leaders, magnates and the king's own ministers. By 13th century, attendance included representatives of counties, cities and boroughs. With time two distinct houses emerged. One, the lower house, was composed of shire and borough representatives which was called the House of Commons: the other, made up of religious leaders (Lords Spiritual) and magnates (Lord Temporal), became known as the upper house, called the House of Lords.
Membership of the Lords...

2 Pages(500 words)Essay

House of Lords

Today, the House's jurisdiction is limited to the hearing of appeals from the lower courts that are technically addressed to the Queen-in-Parliament. By constitutional convention these judges known as Lords of Appeal or Lords of Law hear the appeals. For several years we have heard of the deafening calls for reform and change in the highest court of this land which separates them from the second house of Parliament. The recent calls moved for the removal of the Lords of Appeal from the legislature which received full support and endorsement from the government on March 21, 2005 leading us all to believe that the Constitutional Reform Act, 20052, as a new system will reflect the independence of the judiciary from both the legislat...

5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

The Reform of the House of Lords

...How would you reform the House of Lords (Legislative) and why The call for reforms in the House of Lords (the "Lords has always provoked intense debate and policy initiatives that spans for over 100 years. The paper outlines some of the proposals with a set of principles underlying the process: the primacy of the House of Commons (the "Commons"), complementarity, legitimacy, no dominant party, a non party-political element, diverse representation, and continuity. 1 Primacy In the call for reforms, the primacy of the Commons must be maintained2 because its pre-eminence is anchored on a political reality that it is the majority party that organizes Government, subject to its continuing confidence to implement the programme set out in its...

10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Options for Lords reform

...Options For House of Lords Reform Introduction: The reform of the House of Lords is not a new initiative it has been hanging in the air for more than a hundred years. In these more than hundred years, the movement of reform initiatives resembles the ‘side-step’ dance: one step forward and two steps sideways. The saving grace has been that movement has not been retrograde. As a result the House of Lords, which started out almost on par with the House of Commons has seen its powers and privileges gradually being eroded with the last act being the removal of most of the hereditary peers in 1999. By this initiative there would be only a mere ninety-two hereditary Peers in the House of Lords and that too by election from within the large...

28 Pages(7000 words)Essay

Mistaken Identity in the House of Lords

...Introduction The House of Lords’ decision in Shogun Finance Ltd v Hudson [2004 A.C. 919 implicitly cautions against the risks associated with to the purchase of second-hand goods. The risk is not mitigated where the contract for sale is induced by virtue of fraudulent misrepresentation. There were two approaches open to the Lords in determining whether in such circumstances the contract for sale is voidable or void altogether. This was significant since it determined the outcome and the consequences for the innocent third party who purchased goods subject to a pre-existing contract induced by fraudulent misrepresentation. Lords Hobhouse, Philips and Walker took the position that the initial contract was void altogether so...

10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Should the House of Lords be Abolished

.... Two-thirds of respondents (66%) support holding a nationwide referendum to decide the future of the House of Lords. A clear majority of Britons (58%) supports the notion of allowing the people to directly elect their lords. Conversely, only three-in-ten (30%) are in favour of abolishing the House of Lords altogether.” (Angus Reid, 2010) Thus, the British people are calling for reforms in which politicians and not royals would be elected to the House of Lords in a manner similar to the way the U.S. Senate functions in American democracy, including elections, term limits, and “checks & balances” between the upper & lower Houses of Parliament, rather than the total abolishment of the House of Lords. The House of Lords in fundamentally...

5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

The Lords of Dogtown

Dog town movie In the 1970s, skateboarding had developed into a clique interest, and like numerous disagreeable games, ithad yet to understand its maximum capacity. Enter the now-fanciful "Z-Boys" (remaining for Zephyr, the skate shop where the young men hang out), a gathering of teen surfers whose way of life was brought on by their harsh childhood in "Dogtown" in Venice, California. These youthful surfers would soon turn into the pioneers of the skateboarding unrest Stacy Peralta, Tony Alva, and Jay Adams doing traps and performing tricks, nobody had ever longed for. Composed by Skip Engblom (Heath Ledger), the Zephyr shop holder, the young men (played by, individually, John Robinson, Victor Rasuk, and Emile Hirsch) would begin...

2 Pages(500 words)Movie Review

The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005

...The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005. On February 24, 2004, a bill was introduced in the House of Lords that sought to redefine the role of the judiciary and after amendments, has finally been approved by both Houses as the Constitutional Reform Act of 2005. The purpose of this reform is directed towards strengthening democracy and enhancing the credibility of public institutions1 while also recognizing the value of judicial independence and the need to preserve it.2 The major provisions of the Constitutional Reform Act include: (a) abolishing of the office of Lord Chancellor (b) creating a new, independent Supreme Court to replace the system of Law Lords (c) creating a new Judicial Appointments Commission. (d) Provisions...

6 Pages(1500 words)Coursework

Tax Reform Situation in American

The tax process has been reformed, changed, developed, organized and is now one of the most complicates codes of law in the world. Some of the reforms underway are still being debated and they must be examined to show how the reform process takes place in America.

Overall, American taxation involves payments from individuals to four levels of government depending on where they reside. Taxes are due to the local government i.e. district or country, to the regional bodies like schools and utility providers, to the state government and finally, to the federal government. Other than general income tax on companies and private persons, the American government collects taxes and contributions for Social Security, Medicare and...

7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

The Reform of the Prohibition of Research into Jury Deliberations

Court cases have also been filed with regards to jury deliberations questioning it whether acts or acts of omission were constitutional, adhering to human rights law, right of information, Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996, among other things.

“Research” in this instance could be wide and varied in meaning as there are other extrapolating questions with regards to jury deliberation itself. Are questions limited to the AC 1118 (protection of free debate in the jury room) only? Are there other contradicting details about the jury process which the public must know and that should be properly acted upon? Does “research” apply to the outsiders, or the jurors themselves?

As Se...

10 Pages(2500 words)Case Study

Company Law Reform Bill

Companies Act 2006 (‘the Act’), which received Royal Assent on the 8th November 2006, codifies directors’ duties including the long-established fiduciary duties as well as the common law duty of care and skill into a statutory statement of seven general duties.

The main proposals in respect of the Directors’ duties include a statutory statement of directors’ general duties; and an extended power for shareholders to sue directors for negligence and other defaults. Presently the general duties that a director owes to the company were invariably established through case law rather than statute making it difficult for such duties to be comprehended and pressed for implementation. The Bill incl...

14 Pages(3500 words)Coursework

The Themes of The House of the Seven Gables by Nathanial Hawthorne

“Nathaniel’s passivity and indolence appeared especially unmanly in the presence of Robert Manning’s energetic capabilities, not only to the uncle but to the boy himself. The resulting self-distrust was to be permanently in conflict with Hawthorne’s innate pride” (Erlich, 1984). His family’s Puritan past would weigh heavily upon him throughout his life and would be strongly reflected within his writings. Although he was strongly encouraged to take up the family trade and become a merchant marine, Hawthorne had decided, by age 17, that he wanted to be a writer.

Hawthorne’s official education started at the Samuel H. Archer School as preparation for college at the age of 15 and th...

7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

The Concept of Security Sector Reform

...Topic: What do you understand by the concept of security sector reform? In what ways could it offer a way forward in weak s? Explain with examples Security Sector Reform (SSR) is a concept that emerged in Eastern Europe in the 1990s. It begins where a malfunction security sector is not capable of providing security to the state and its inhabitants efficiently under secular set up. A spoilt and malfunctioning security sector comes in the way of long term development, democracy and peace. SSR is both operational as well as normative in concept. Security Sector Reform, according to Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (SSR) is “another term used to describe the transformation of the ‘security system’--which includes...

10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

A Plan to Reform the US Healthcare System

The regimes need to be proactive in nature which means that the vision of having the related healthcare systems within the US medical departments and hospitals should be an ongoing activity rather a one-step, a reactionary move which usually happens from time to time, usually due to one calamity or a catastrophe that hits the particular region within the United States of America. Thus in this paper, our focus would be set on discussing the healthcare systems that are operational within the US and also pinpoint the gray areas where some particular steps could be taken to ward off the negativities thus attached to them.

A healthy person is not difficult to define. He or she is a person who does his chores regularly...

10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Homicide Law within England and Wales: Is There a Need for a Reform

.... “The report of the House of Lords Nathan Committee and the more recent report of the committee chaired by Lord Lane, formerly Lord Chief Justice, provide a most cogent case against the continuation of the mandatory sentence.10” Many Human Rights organisations at different stages, under different circumstances, had been forcing the government that the homicide laws of these two regions should be reformed and all the killings cannot be put under the same category as the circumstances could be conflicting. Every time, a questionable case that deserves a lesser sentence comes up, there had been public outcry and media insistence for the extensive reform of the homicide bill. Not only in England and Wales, but also in Scotland and Northern...

56 Pages(14000 words)Dissertation

House of Lords Reform

...House of Lords Reform The preamble to the 1911 Parliament Act contains the following statement: "And whereas it is intended to substitute for the House of Lords as it at present exists a Second Chamber constituted on a popular instead of hereditary basis, but such substitution cannot be immediately brought into operation”. Discuss the extent to which reform of House of Lords membership has been achieved in the century since the Parliament Act, and is likely to be further achieved in the near future. The reform of the upper house of the Parliament has been attempted since the establishment of parliamentary democracy in the UK. Some of these attempts have fetched positive results whereas the rest have at best been nominal...

13 Pages(3250 words)Essay

Sentimentality in A Dolls House and Home Is So Sad

...A Dolls House Order No. 502436 Introduction The two primary works chosen for discussion are the play ‘A Dolls House’ by Henrik Ibsen and a poem by Phillip Larkin titled ‘Home is so sad.’ Though both these works have their own unique style of presentation, yet there are some common factors shared by them. “A Doll’s House” which is a scintillating play, was written by Henrik Ibsen during the period of the ‘Naturalism Movement’ and revolved around the women of the 19th century society. The basic premise of the play was the portraying of women in different gender roles and how they looked after their families by staying at home. In sharp contrast to Ibsen’s poem is Larkin’s poem ‘Home is so sad’. In this poem, the poet expresses the dark...

6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Critically assess whether the UK Supreme Court's approach to the use of Practice Statement 1966 should be more racial than that of the House of Lords, in order to achieve reform of the law

...Critically assess whether the UK Supreme Courts approach to the use of Practice ment 1966 should be more racial than that of the House of Lords,in order to achieve reform of the law. The Practice Statement of 1966 was made by Lord Gardiner in the House of Lords. As per this statement, the House of Lords could now have the freedom to move away from a rigid adherence to precedents so that the process of law development happens smoothly and there is no restriction that stands in the way of law development (Loveland, 2004). Thus, the House of Lords can depart from the previous decisions as well as the precedents that have been set previously, if it wishes to in circumstances where the precedents are either out of date or erroneous. This set...

6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

A Doll House by Henrik Ibsen

... Analysis of the Doll House Introduction Henrik Ibsen has written a fabulous play “A Doll House” raising the problems of the woman, and revealing the role of women in a society of that time. The aim of this paper is to explore how individuals come to understand themselves and their place in the world by analyzing one character from Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll House. The analysis will be focused on Nora, the main hero of the play. The paper will attempt to explore the various pressures, influences, and/or stereotypes that shape or attempt to shape a character’s life, perspective, and actions, and also consider if and how the character responds to these factors. Brief overview of the character, Nora Helmer The main hero of the Ibsen’s play...

6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

House of Lords Reform - Essay Example

Extract of sample "House of Lords Reform"

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF House of Lords Reform

Let us find you another Essay on topic House of Lords Reform for FREE!