Article Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Meta-Discourse Of American Diplomats Glinert, Lewis. 2010 - Literature review Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
This article critically evaluates the importance of negotiations and expansive discourse in framing apologies, especially in a political and diplomatic context. Focusing on two Sino-American issues, viz. the 1999 bombing at Belgrade Chinese and the 2001 airplane collision between a Chinese fighter jet and an American spy plane. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Article Review Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Meta-Discourse Of American Diplomats Glinert, Lewis. 2010
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Article Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Meta-Discourse Of American Diplomats Glinert, Lewis. 2010"

Download file to see previous pages This study was based on off-the-record interviews conducted in late 2001 with four anonymous US State Department officials involved in public negotiations of the US apologies. The author’s aim in carrying out these interviews was threefold. Firstly, he wished to clarify the intricacies of international diplomatic apologies. Secondly, he intended to “probe” the opinions of official diplomats on such apologies. Finally, he aimed that this study would contribute to a greater understanding of diplomatic apologies and pragmatics involved therewith.

Observations
The author argues that most political apologies are framed in such a way that both nations’ real political goals are achieved. To carry out an act of apology, “the stage must be set by a process of negotiation and reconciliation” (Thompson 2005). Mirroring this idea, the author describes the kind of negotiations that take place before an official apology. Based on interviews, the author writes that America apologized to China in an “ambiguous” and careless manner and refrained from publicly accepting the incidents as its own fault. Such an apology was unacceptable to the Chinese. Furthermore, both countries took advantage of the linguistic gap between the two and manipulated the wordings of the apology to suit their own interests. Chinese officials reinterpreted the official US apology during translation to suit their own customs. 3. Critique and Evaluation This article is well written, although the author could have done away with a number of unconventional and difficult words. Though the topic is of a general nature and requires little technical knowledge, it is hard to understand and interpret the author’s ideas at first glance, as the language used is of utmost sophistication. A scientific article is successful only when a “large majority of the reading audience accurately perceives what the author had in mind” (Gopen and Swan 1990). To deal with the objectives at hand, the author builds up a strong background through literature review and by criticizing pragmatic models of apologizing. He successfully describes the elasticity of the official US apologies to China in various perspectives, and includes the US officials’ interpretations of these apologies. The author builds on his argument using the instance when America, in its official apology to China, said “we are sorry” instead of “we apologize”. The author states that in saying, “we are sorry”, there could be different intentions, which do not necessarily mean apologizing. He analyzes the letter from the US ambassador to the Chinese foreign minister in this context apart from criticizing other US discourses of apologies, and therefore, the evidence used by him is valid and relevant to the case in point. One possible limitation of this study is that it is largely based on interviews with four US officials, which may not be representative of the views of the US government. Moreover, the study would have presented a stronger case if interviews from Chinese officials were included, as this could show the Chinese stance on US apologies from their own perspective. The article contributes to the field of political and linguistic analysis and provides a cross-sectional view of the act of ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Article Review Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Literature”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/politics/1390690-article-review-apologizing-to-china-elastic-apologies-and-the-meta-discourse-of-american-diplomats-glinert-lewis-2010
(Article Review Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Literature)
https://studentshare.org/politics/1390690-article-review-apologizing-to-china-elastic-apologies-and-the-meta-discourse-of-american-diplomats-glinert-lewis-2010.
“Article Review Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Literature”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1390690-article-review-apologizing-to-china-elastic-apologies-and-the-meta-discourse-of-american-diplomats-glinert-lewis-2010.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
ce
cecilia24 added comment 6 months ago
Student rated this paper as
I never thought 750 words essay could be written in such a free manner. I loved the idea of this essay. Will definitely use it for my own work!

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Article Review Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Meta-Discourse Of American Diplomats Glinert, Lewis. 2010

Article Review

...? Article Review The essay aims to address a two-fold objective to wit to summarize the article; and(2) to critique the article. Article Review Summary General Information. The article compared the preparation of Allied Health Practitioners for management positions to a box. Employees are unable to reach their maximum potential because institutions enclose them in a box that limits their improvement. Among the examples are allied health professions in physical therapy, occupational therapy, medical technology, nutritional science, diagnostic imaging specialties, and speech-language pathology (Bender, 2005, 364). Job levels limit allied health practitioners to fulfill the staff-level clinical roles....
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Article Review

...?Running head: Summary Summary: The Learning Organization and Strategic Change Summary of the Article Organizations have developed different strategies, over the period of time, towards management change in order to tackle obstacles by planning and adopting appropriate actions. Each organization individually learns to change by experiencing problems and resolving them through planning and taking necessary measures. However, the organizations collectively have also learned the process of change over the passage of time. After the development of three models of strategic change, the fourth model, referred to as the ‘learning organization’, is evolving to assist organizations in developing and implementing organizational change... head: Summary...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

American Imperialism and American Democracy

...and changing the way in with democratic institutes are supposed to function. Of course America is not alone when it comes to imperialist tendencies since Russia, Great Britain and even France have had a past where their governments used imperialist tactics to get what they wanted. For instance, during the Cuban missile crisis, both Russia and America were involved in conducting interventions into the internal affairs of several Latin American nations. While America wanted to influence Latin American democracies to curtail their links to Cuba, “Moscow tried to persuade Latin American Governments not to cut their economic and diplomatic ties with Cuba (Mujal-Leon, 1989,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Article

Review

...Article Review The article “Knowledge, Reservations, or Promise A Media Effects Model for Public Perceptions of Science and Technology” by Nisbet, Scheufele, Shanahan, Moy, Brossard and Lewenstein (2002) centers on the effect of media on science and technology. Going by the size of audience the size of audience, television renders greater impact of scientific reservations and influence on such perceptions. After a large-scale review of the works of previous researchers, one might infer that two kinds of relations are already established in different literatures. First, use of media affect the relationship between the demographic variables and variables of scientific knowledge. Second, these knowledge...
2 Pages(500 words)Article

The Life and Influence of Joseph McCarthy on American Politics

...The Life and Influence of Joseph McCarthy on American Politics Joseph McCarthy, one of the most popular American politicians, was elected to the US Senate in 1946 and was known for his crusades against Communism in the USA (“McCarthy, Joseph,” 1991). His anti-Communism crusades affected the American government and society in a way that his accusations against government employees cause job losses. Additionally, due to his efforts against Communism, he established ties with his fellow anti-Communists, thereby, ensuring their support. However, for the reason that most of his accusations are not true, McCarthy faced slander cases, which terminated his term of office and caused other officials to doubt his integrity. His influence... in the...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

American History and Civil Rights Movement

...American History Task: American History “Discuss Lyndon B. Johnson’s background prior to his presidency with the Civil Rights Movement” Sarah Heasman wrote in her article that Johnson started working as an elementary school teacher. It was at this time that he realized how awful the minorities’ education was but did not give up on them. He helped them by use of encouragements and incentives to make them study. Johnson ventured into politics by campaigning for Texas State Senator Welly Hopkins as he pursued Congress (Heasman, 2011). Later on, Johnson headed the Texas National Youth Administration, while, in this position, he used the government to the youth’s advantage by confronting the government to...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Ipad Troubles In China

...IPad Troubles in China Apple activities in China have drawn both praises and curses in equal measure. The company has been a hub of employees who struggle to make their lives better. The company has been successful in its operation in terms of economic viability. It has been able to innovate and provide into the market, the most viable products that responds to the demands of the consumers. However, audits into the company operation system indicate that the company does not portray similar features in treating its workers. Independent bodies have indicated that the company working conditions do not reflect the company’s code of conduct. This paper will respond to issues raised against the operation of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Article

Art of Modern China

...: University of California Press, 2012. Maxwell K. Hearn, Judith G. Smith. Chinese Art: Modern Expressions. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2001. Michael Sullivan, Franklin D. Murphy. Art and Artists of Twentieth-century China. California: University of California Press, 1996. Ward, Caroline F. How has the term "modern" been applied to contemporary East Asian art. 17 January 2010. 10 March 2014 . Ying, Li-Hua. The A to Z of Modern Chinese Literature. New Yok: Rowman & Littlefield, 2010 .... Art of Modern China China occupies a center stage in the 21st century international art world. As the country evolves, so too does it’s sculpture, architecture, and art. The country art is a reflection of a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Article

Google in China

...Google in China affiliation Google in China On numerous occasions, the Chinese government has developed measures aimed atlimiting and controlling internet use. Google being the most significant search engine has been severely affected. Across China, products offered by Googlehave been inaccessible due to the limitations developed by the state. Many users do not have access to mail services, advertisement services, and social networking sites such as Facebook, YouTube or Twitter. The problemhas been made significant since government has politicized internet services with claims that it could be used to upset the current regime. Just recently, the state has developed a firewall system that blocked numerous sites supported by Google... . From...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

China's Dangerous Overvaluation

...Summary of the Article The article is about the appreciation of Yuan against other currencies and starts with the news of recent slide in Yuan valueagainst US Dollar. Author indicates that despite all the signs indicating towards economic trouble for China, it may continue to use its policies to further strengthen the Yuan however; the same may actually backfire given how the different economic factors are indicating. A stronger Yuan and higher interest rates in Chinese economy will continue to put pressure on the currency as capital inflows increase and financial liberalization kicks in. Author highlights the times when appreciating Yuan was a desired proposition for China to help the domestic...
2 Pages(500 words)Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Literature review on topic Article Review Apologizing to China: Elastic Apologies and the Meta-Discourse Of American Diplomats Glinert, Lewis. 2010 for FREE!

Contact Us